Gatestone Institute
The Gatestone Institute publishes articles by a number of prominent right wing, neoconservative, Zionist and counter-jihad individuals and organisations and promotes them at exclusive speaking events, often in New York City.
History
The Gatestone Institute has been publishing articles on its website since October 2008.[1] It has been hosting events since June 2010.
Activities
The Gatestone Institute describes itself as a think tank ‘dedicated to educating the public about what the mainstream media fails to report in promoting: institutions of democracy and the rule of law; human rights; a free and strong economy; a military capable of ensuring peace at home and in the free world; energy independence; ensuring the public stay informed of threats to our individual liberty, sovereignty and free speech’. [2]
Its website also states that it ‘will be publishing books’ and currently conducts ‘national and international conferences, briefings and events for its members and others, with world leaders, journalists and experts -- analyzing, strategizing, and keeping them informed on current issues, and where possible recommending solutions’.
Themes include ‘military and diplomatic threats to the United States and our allies; events in the Middle East and their possible consequences, and the transparency and accountability of international organizations’. [2]
Promoting anti-Muslim writers
Gatestone publishes a number of prominent writers from the anti-Muslim counterjihad movement. These include Fjordman, a far-right blogger ‘idolised’ by Norwegian mass murderer Anders Breivik,[3] Bat Ye’or whose ‘Eurabia’ conspiracy theory is advocated by Fjordman, Daniel Pipes, Robert Spencer and Dutch politician Geert Wilders. Spencer and his Jihad Watch were cited 116 times by Breivik, Pipes and his Middle East Watch 18 times.[4]
Gatestone has also published a defence of Wilders' call for there to be 'fewer Moroccans' in the Netherlands and articles attempting to demonise Islam by linking it to cannibalism (eg. ‘Islamic cannibalism’ by Ali Salim) and to child abuse (eg. ‘child sex slavery, multiculturalism and Islam’ by Soeren Kern.[4] The relationship with Wilders is a close one, as reporter Max Blumenthal noted in 2012:
- At the April event, Wilders's seamless fusion of anti-Muslim bombast and pro-Israel cant was gratefully received by the Gatestone Institute’s founder and director, Nina Rosenwald, whom he acknowledged at the top of his jeremiad as another of his good friends. An heiress to the Sears Roebuck fortune, Rosenwald spreads her millions through the William Rosenwald Family Fund, a nonprofit foundation named for her father, a famed Jewish philanthropist who created the United Jewish Appeal in 1939. His daughter’s focus is more explicitly political. According to a report by the Center for American Progress titled “Fear Inc.,” Rosenwald and her sister Elizabeth Varet, who also directs the family foundation, have donated more than $2.8 million since 2000 to “organizations that fan the flames of Islamophobia.”
Besides funding a Who’s Who of anti-Muslim outfits, Rosenwald has served on the board of AIPAC, the central arm of America’s Israel lobby, and holds leadership roles in a host of mainstream pro-Israel organizations. As groups like AIPAC lead the charge for a US military strike on the Islamic Republic of Iran, threatening to turn apocalyptic visions of civilizational warfare into catastrophic reality, Rosenwald's wealth has fueled a rapidly emerging alliance between the pro-Israel mainstream and the Islamophobic fringe. (In 2003 alone the Rosenwald Family Fund donated well over half of its $1.6 million in total contributions to pro-Israel and Islamophobic organizations.) This alliance serves to sanitize and legitimize professional anti-Muslim bigots like Wilders, allowing their ideas to mingle easily with those of neoconservative foreign policy heavyweights intent on promoting the appearance of a convergence between US and Israeli interests by invoking the specter of a common “Islamofascist” enemy. With Gatestone—which publicizes the writings of figures ranging from pro-Israel super-lawyer Alan Dershowitz to “counter-jihad” propagandist Robert Spencer, and boasts Harold Rhode, a neoconservative former Pentagon official credited, as a senior fellow, with helping to try to push the Bush administration to invade Iraq—Rosenwald has attempted to shift the alliance into overdrive.[5]
Fees
A UK-based policy analyst, interviewed on condition of anonymity, claimed that a separate UK-based Muslim writer on Gatestone’s books was being paid $65,000 a year in return for producing articles 'on demand'.[6]
Gatestone's tax filings reveal that it paid its 'head writer' Soeren Kern $125,859 in 2015 and $130,000 in 2016. [7]
Promoting Eurabia conspiracy theory
Gatestone serves as a 'a clearing house...for claims about Muslim "no-go zones" (the likes of which "terrorism expert" Steven Emerson was ridiculed for)' and has published articles promoting the idea of 'Islamisation' and in particular the Eurabia conspiracy of an Islamic takeover of Europe. It has published articles with titles like:
- ‘The Islamization of France’
- ‘The Islamization of Germany’
- ‘The Islamization of Belgium and the Netherlands’
- ‘Spain: Soon the Muslims will be Kings of the World’
- ‘Britain’s Islamic Future’
- ‘UK Islamic takeover plot’
- ‘How Islam Conquers Europe’.[4]
Events
Events organised by the ‘Gatestone Institute Briefing Council’ are ‘by invitation only’ and exclusively for members. According to its website, Gatestone events ‘often take place at The Four Seasons Restaurant, The '21' Club, The Knickerbocker Club, The River Club and select private residences in New York City’.
It was previously advertised that a minimum donation of $10,000 is ‘required for participation’.[6]
Previous speakers have included Daniel Pipes, Henry Kissinger, John Bolton, Frank Luntz, Bruce Bawer, Alan Dershowitz, Geert Wilders, Douglas Murray and M. Zuhdi Jasser.
The 2015 accounts show that John Bolton was paid $100,000 as an event speaker, though it is unclear whether this was for a single or multiple events - he only gave one publicised talk in that year. [8]
British speakers have included the Henry Jackson Society's associate director Douglas Murray on his book 'The Strange Death of Europe' in November 2017 and the Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks on 'Identity, Politics and Populism'. [9]
Gatestone Europe
Gatestone has a European 'advisory board' run by journalist Amir Taheri and Elisabeth-Ann Moutet. The Institute declares in its accounts that the majority of its overseas expenditure on 'programme services' occurs in Europe.
In January 2017 Gatestone set up a new Twitter account, 'Gatestone Europe', with the description: Gatestone Europe 'Daily European news from a decent right-wing perspective'. The account remains protected and is therefore only accessible by approved followers. The twitter account also provides a link to gatestone.eu, however this defaults to Gatestone.
British links
Quilliam Foundation
Hilary Aked writes:
- In January 2015, just days after the Paris attacks targeting magazine Charlie Hebdo and a kosher supermarket, Gatestone spent approximately $100,000 taking out a full page advert in the New York Times. To drive home its implicit message that a 'good Muslim' supports US power, two out of the three Muslims pictured in the Gatestone advert were posing next to the American flag. Mentioning violence in Iran, Iraq, Syria, Nigeria, Egypt – and, 'Africa' - the text of the advertisement effortlessly ignored all other violence in the world not involving any of the world’s 1.6 billion Muslims and simultaneously glossed over the context-specific political factors at play in each conflict. The subtext was very clear: Gatestone was advocating a mono-causal explanation for this violence and put the spotlight firmly on Islam.
- Ostensibly a 'counter-extremism' initiative, this advert was typical of how contemporary anti-Muslim racism is articulated: by generalizing specific behaviours and attributing them deterministically to religious ideology. This fundamental problem of collectively imputing blame is not negated by the fact that all 23 signatories were Muslims. Though the statement calls on 'all people of conscience' to sign up, since the word 'duty' is twice used in relation to Muslims it is clear that they, far more than others, are expected to prove they reject violence. Thus the Gatestone declaration serves the same function as the so-called 'Charter of Muslim Understanding', which similarly called for Muslims to be required to make special denunciations. Commissioned by UKIP’s Gerard Batten, that document was called 'frightening' even by pro-Israel Tory MP Robert Halfon, who compared it to a first step towards wearing a yellow star, as Jews were required to do under Nazi rule.[6]
Usama Hasan and Maajid Nawaz of the UK-based Quilliam Foundation were among the signatories to this statement.
Henry Jackson Society
In 2011, the British neoconservative think tank the Henry Jackson Society (HJS) received $10,000 from the Abstraction Fund, the private mega-foundation of Nina Rosenwald who set up the Gatestone Institute. In addition, HJS associate director Douglas Murray writes regularly for Gatestone and at the time was listed as a 'distinguished senior fellow'.
The connection between HJS and Rosenwald also means that Student Rights, the campus-monitoring arm of the HJS, may be receiving funding from the same financial sources as Campus Watch - part of the Middle East Forum also funded by Rosenwald's Abstraction Fund - a group that pioneered the McCarthyist blacklisting tactics it employs.[6]
Grants and Expenditures
2016
Grants/gifts received: $2,190,243
Total programme service expenses: $1,631,025
According to the US Inland Revenue Service (IRS) tax filing for the 2016 financial year, Gatestone 'activities conducted in various regions includes research and writing, hosting conferences, translating and maintaining the organization's website and blog to inform the public and the policy community about issues related to human rights and democracy worldwide.'
Overseas expenditures included:
- Europe(Including Iceland and Greenland): $362,847 (26 employees): cited purpose was Program Services. No offices.
- ME and North Africa: $262,550 (14 employees): cited purpose was Program Services
- North America: $12,258 (5 employees): cited purpose was Program Services
- East Asia and the Pacific: $6260 (2 employees): cited purpose was Program Services
- South America: $12157 (1 employee): cited purpose was Program Services
- South Asia: $7500 (4 employees): cited purpose was Program Services
- Total programme employees = 52
- Total programme employees = 52
Fees
- Consulting fees included writers' total fees:$312,694
- Other fees: $19,628
- Article translation fees: $162,671
- Speakers fees: $255,250
Media consulting fees: [10]
2015
Grants/gifts received: $2,190,242 Total programme service expenses: $1,788,828 Overseas expenditures included:
- Europe: $397,072 (32 employees): cited purpose was Program Services
- ME and North Africa: $193,358 (9 employees): cited purpose was Program Services
- East Asia and the Pacific: $5270 (1 employee): cited purpose was Program Services
- South America: $13,255 (3 employees): cited purpose was Program Services
- South Asia: $2700 (3 employees): cited purpose was Program Services
The Institute's 2015 tax filings state that no overseas grants were made in this period.
Writers' total fees: $240,249 Other fees: $29,313 Article translation fees: $145,282 Speakers fees: $278816 Media consulting fees: 25,250
2014
Grants/gifts received: $2,142,026 Overseas expenditures included:
- Europe: $325,528 (23 employees): cited purpose was Program Services
- ME and North Africa: $121,530 (6 employees): cited purpose was Program Services
- Sub-Saharan Africa: $21,000 (4 employees): cited purpose was Program Services
- North America: $17,977 (1 employee): cited purpose was Program Services
- South America: $1,090 (0 employee): cited purpose was Program Services
- South Asia: $600 (1 employee): cited purpose was Program Services
Gatestone grant expenditures amounted to $20,000, distributed as follows:
- European region: $10,000 (overseas grants do not have to be registered in detail)
- The Humanitarian Aid Relief Fund: $10,000 - purpose cited was 'to support Its charitable aId work In the spheres of education & human rights' [11]
2013
Funding
The Gatestone Institute states that it is funded by ‘private donors and foundations’ but does not appear to publish any further details on its website. [2] Donors gleaned from a range of sources are as outlined below.
2016
Gatestone's revenue was $$2,190,243 in 2016.[12]Donors included:
- Mercer Family Foundation: $100,000 )[13](Rebekah Mercer was listed on Gatestone's website as being a member of its board of governors in March/April 2017).
2015
Gatestone's revenue was $$2,192,189 in 2015 [14] Donors included:
- Mercer Family Foundation: $50,000 [15]
2014
Gatestone's revenue was $2,154,147 in 2014, a significant increase on the previous year. [16]. A review of various affiliated organisations' tax filings revealed grants from:
- Abstraction Fund: $1,015,000[17]
- Chisholm Foundation: $20,000 [18]
- College for National Studies: $50,000 in 2014
- Jewish Communal Fund: $55,136 [19]
- Mercer Family Foundation: $50,000 [20]
- Middle East Forum: $13,500 [21]
2013
Middle East Forum
In its 2013 tax filing Gatestone declared a total of US $1,387,104 in income[22], which appears to have come from one source according to IRS filings for the anti-Muslim Middle East Forum (MEF). In fact MEF has given over USD$2.3 million to Gatestone in recent years. The 2013 filing shows it gave one single grant of USD$1,383,471 to Gatestone, an increase on the previous year's USD $1,098,878 grant.[23][24]
Abstraction Fund
According to IRS filings from 2014, the Abstraction Fund also donated a total of USD $1,015,000 to the Gatestone Institute, in 9 separate donations. [25]
Others
In 2013 the Svetlana and Herbert M Wachtell Foundation gave Gatestone USD$5,000. [26]
2012
Gatestone’s revenue was reportedly $1.1 million in 2012.[6]
People
As well as considerable resources, people associated with Gatestone include a combination of far-right bloggers like Fjordman alongside prestigious names like former U.S. ambassador John Bolton (chairman of Gatestone) and James Woolsey, former director of the CIA (Gatestone advisory board member). The presence of such individuals – who have the ability to lend mainstream respectability to vehemently Islamophobic ideas – is something few counterjihad think tanks can boast.
It has been argued that this combination lends it 'faux respectability' and 'establishment kudos' that translates into the potential for 'an alarming degree of mainstream influence' that should give 'more to fear' than 'the danger posed by lone far-right terrorists like Breivik'.[4]
Chairman
Ambassador John R. Bolton[27]
Directors
Nina Rosenwald - director/ president | Georgette Gelbard - director | Grayson Levy - director | Erik Telford - director | Naomi Perlman - secretary/PR manager| Joel Zbar [28]
Board of governors
2015
Viscountess Bearsted | Baroness Caroline Cox | Alan Dershowitz | Lawrence Kadish | Lord Finkelstein | Jack Fowler | Ingeborg Rennert | Rebecca Sugar | Professor Robert Immerman | Meryl Tisch [29]
2014-15
R. James Woolsey – Chairman | Georgette Gelbard | M. Zuhdi Jasser | Lawrence Kadish | Douglas Murray | Naomi Perlman | Ingeborg Rennert | Rebecca Sugar | Amir Taheri | Professor Elie Wiesel | Christine Williams
Board of Governors Gatestone Europe
Amir Taheri - Chairman | Anne-Elisabeth Moutet
Distinguished scholars and senior advisers
Soeren Kern | Guy Milliere | Harold Rhode | Khaled Abu Toameh | Samuel Westrop
Prominent early role for Fjordman
In the institute's early days, mass murderer Anders Behring Breivik's blogger-idol Fjordman was listed as a 'distinguished scholar' (in January 2013), indicating the importance of his ideas.[4] His name was later removed from this list.
Other former distinguished fellows
- British journalist Robert Ellis
Columnists
Writers listed as columnists include:
Contact
- Website: www.gatestoneinstitute.org
- Email: info@gatestoneinstitute.org
- Twitter:
- Twitter: @GatestoneEurope - a protected account set up January 2017 with 587 followers as of 16 March 2017.
Resources
- Max Blumenthal, The Sugar Mama of Anti-Muslim Hate, The Nation.
- Nafeez Ahmed, White Supremacists at the Heart of Whitehall, Middle East Eye.
- Nafeez Ahmed, David Cameron confidant promotes forced depopulation of Muslims in Europe, Media Diversified.
- Hilary Aked, Is Notorious Islamophobic Think Tanks Inspiring More Far-Right Terrorism?, Alternet.
- Hilary Aked, One of America's Most Dangerous Think Tanks is Spreading Hate Across the Atlantic, Alternet. November 23, 2015.
Notes
- ↑ Archives, Gatestone Institute, accessed 6 February 2013
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 About, Gatestone Institute, accessed 6 February 2013
- ↑ Jerome Taylor, Unmasked: the far right blogger idolised by Breivik, The Independent, 6 August 2011
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 Hilary Aked, Is Notorious Islamophobic Think Tanks Inspiring More Far-Right Terrorism?, Alternet, 26 August 2015.
- ↑ Max Blumenthal, The Sugar Mama of Anti-Muslim Hate, The Nation, 13 June 2012.
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 Hilary Aked, One of America's Most Dangerous Think Tanks is Spreading Hate Across the Atlantic, Alternet, 23 November 2015
- ↑ Gatestone Forms 990, 2015, 2016
- ↑ Gatestone Institute, Form 990, 2015, reviewed by Spinwatch
- ↑ Gatestone briefing council Events, Gatestone Institute, n.d, accessed 16 March 2018
- ↑ Gatestone Institute, IRS Form 990, 2016 and [Raw data which includes Schedule F information https://s3.amazonaws.com/irs-form-990/201711329349305646_public.xml] published at Propublica
- ↑ Gatestone Institute, Form 990, 2014
- ↑ Gatestone Institute, Form 990, 2016
- ↑ Mercer Family Foundation Form 990, 2016, reviewed February 2018
- ↑ Gatestone Institute, Form 990, 2015
- ↑ Mercer Family Foundation Form 990, 2015, reviewed by Spinwatch
- ↑ Gatestone Institute, Form 990, 2014
- ↑ Abstraction Fund, 990 Form, 2014
- ↑ Chisholm Foundation, 990 Form, 2014
- ↑ Jewish Communal Fund, 990 Form, 2014
- ↑ Mercer Family Foundation Form 990, 2014, reviewed by Spinwatch
- ↑ Middle East Forum, Form 990, 2014
- ↑ Gatestone Institute 2013 Tax return, accessed 27 February 2015
- ↑ MEF, Form 990, 2013, reviewed by Spinwatch
- ↑ Gatestone Institute, Conservative Transparency database, accessed 3 March 2015
- ↑ Form 990 2014, Foundation Center, accessed 21 January 2016
- ↑ Svetlana and Herbert M Wachtell Foundation, 990 Form, 2013
- ↑ About, Gatestone Institute, accessed 17 December 2015
- ↑ Gatestone Institute 2013 Tax return, accessed 27 February 2015
- ↑ Gatestone Institute website, accessed 2 December 2015
