Max Nordau

From Powerbase
(Redirected from Max Südfeld)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Hungarian-born physician, writer and co-founder with Theodor Herzl of the Zionist Organization, who launched the idea of "muscular Judaism" (1849–1923)

Max Nordau

Image Max Nordau.jpg
Max Nordau, between 1900 and 1919
Born 29 July 1849 Pest (Budapest), Kingdom of Hungary, Austrian Empire
Died 22 January 1923 Paris, France
Occupation Physician, journalist, writer, social critic, Zionist leader
Known for Die conventionellen Lügen der Kulturmenschheit (1883); Entartung (Degeneration, 1892); co-founder of the Zionist Organization; vice-president of the first six Zionist Congresses; "Muskeljudentum" (1898); the "Nordau plan" (1919–20)
Zionist movement
Overview

Zionism | Zionist Movement | Jerusalem Program | World Zionist Congress | The Duties of the Individual Zionist | Lobbying for Zionism on Both Sides of the Atlantic | Balfour Declaration
Precursors: Die Einheit | Hovevei Zion
Ideas: Muscular Judaism

Leading figures

Theodor Herzl | Max Nordau | David Wolffsohn | Arthur Ruppin | Chaim Weizmann | David Ben-Gurion

National institutions

World Zionist Organization | Jewish National Fund / KKL | Jewish Agency for Israel | Keren Hayesod / UIA
National offices: World Zionist Organization UK | L’Organisation Sioniste Mondiale en France | Jewish Agency for Israel UK and Europe | United Israel Appeal | Jewish Federations of North America
Historical: Jewish Colonial Trust | Anglo-Palestine Bank | Bank Leumi

Zionist federations (43)
National JNF bodies (42)
National Keren Hayesod bodies (35)
World unions and factions

Mizrachi | World Mizrachi | Arzenu | Mercaz Olami | World Confederation of United Zionists | Eretz Hakodesh | World Sephardi Federation | Ameinu | Likud | World Likud
UK: Mizrachi of Great Britain and Ireland | Arzenu UK | Mercaz UK | Likud-Herut UK | Herut UK
Historical: Brit Shalom

Affiliated world organisations

Hadassah | Hadassah International | WIZO | WIZO UK | Emunah | Maccabi World Union | B'nai B'rith International | World Union of Jewish Students

Youth movements

Hashomer Hatzair | Habonim Dror | Bnei Akiva | Betar | BBYO | Young Judaea | LJY-Netzer | Zionist Youth Council (UK) | Taglit Birthright | Federation of Zionist Youth
Historical: Youth Aliyah

Labour Zionism and the kibbutz

Kibbutz Artzi | Histadrut | Mapai | Poale Zion | Jewish Labour Movement

Settlement and land

Nachala | Ateret Cohanim | Daniella Weiss | Greater Israel | Nefesh B'Nefesh
Historical: Jewish Colonization Association | Palestine Jewish Colonization Association | Mikveh Israel | Edmond James de Rothschild | James de Rothschild

Military history

Zion Mule Corps | Jewish Legion | Jewish Brigade

Christian Zionism

Christians United for Israel | International Christian Embassy Jerusalem | Christian Friends of Israel - UK | Christians for Israel International | Christians for Zion | ProZion | Israel Allies Foundation

Israel lobby

Israel Lobby Portal | AIPAC | Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations | BICOM | Board of Deputies of British Jews | Conservative Friends of Israel | Labour Friends of Israel | European Friends of Israel | ELNET | Friends of Israel Initiative | StandWithUs | European Jewish Congress

Data and sources

British Zionist charities | 'Zionist' non profits in the US | US Big Israel data | US lobbying and election spending data | US FARA data | Zionist family foundations in the UK - a ranking | The Zionist Year Book | Zionist Review | Herzl Zionist Institute

Europe (45)
North America and the Caribbean (12)
West Asia (17)
North Africa (6)
Sub-Saharan Africa (48)
Latin America and the Caribbean (23)
South Asia (8)
Central Asia (5)
East Asia (6)
Southeast Asia (11)
Oceania and the Pacific (14)

Max Nordau (born Simon Maximilian Südfeld, 29 July 1849 – 22 January 1923) was a Hungarian-born physician, journalist and social critic who became, with Theodor Herzl, a co-founder of the Zionist Organization. The Encyclopaedia Judaica entry by Meir Ben-Horin describes him as "co-founder of the World Zionist Organization, philosopher, writer, orator, and physician".[1] He made his name with Die conventionellen Lügen der Kulturmenschheit (1883) and Entartung (Degeneration, 1892), which applied the psychiatric category of "degeneracy" to modern art and literature. He served as vice-president of the First to the Sixth Zionist Congresses (1897–1903) and president of the Seventh to the Tenth (1905–11), and his congress addresses, the Encyclopaedia Judaica says, "became classics of Zionist literature".[1][2] At the Second Zionist Congress in 1898 he called for the creation of a "Muskeljudentum" ("muscular Judaism"), an idea that historian Etan Bloom calls Nordau's "most important influence" on Arthur Ruppin, "and indeed on the Zionist movement as a whole".[3] In 1919–20 he called for the transfer of 600,000 Jews to Palestine within months to create a Jewish majority, a proposal the Zionist leadership rejected as unrealistic.[1]

Early life and career

Nordau was born in Pest, the son of Rabbi Gabriel Südfeld. He received a traditional Jewish education and, according to the Encyclopaedia Judaica, "remained an observant Jew until his eighteenth year, when he became a militant naturalist and evolutionist".[1] The Neue Deutsche Biographie records that he bore the name Simon Maximilian Südfeld until 1873.[2] He joined the staff of the Pester Lloyd in 1867 and later wrote for the Vossische Zeitung in Berlin, the Neue Freie Presse in Vienna and La Nación in Buenos Aires. He qualified as a doctor of medicine at the University of Pest in 1875 and moved to Paris as a practising physician in 1880.[1] In 1896 he married Anna Dons; their daughter, the painter Maxa Nordau, was born in 1897, and mother and daughter later wrote his biography (Max Nordau: A Biography, 1943).[2][1]

Conventional Lies and Degeneration

Die conventionellen Lügen der Kulturmenschheit (1883; in English as The Conventional Lies of Our Civilization, 1884) attacked "the religious lie", monarchy and aristocracy, and conventional sexual morality. It was translated into fifteen languages and banned in Austria and Russia.[1][2]

Entartung (1892; in English as Degeneration, 1895) applied the criminologist Cesare Lombroso's concept of "degeneracy" to figures such as Nietzsche, Tolstoy, Wagner, Zola and Ibsen, and to symbolism, spiritualism and mysticism, and predicted, in the words of the Encyclopaedia Judaica, "the coming of a human catastrophe of unprecedented proportions". George Bernard Shaw published a book-length rebuttal.[1] Nordau dedicated the book to Lombroso, writing: "Degenerates are not always criminals, prostitutes, anarchists, and pronounced lunatics; they are often authors and artists. These, however, manifest the same mental characteristics, and for the most part the same somatic features, as the members of the above-mentioned anthropological family, who satisfy their unhealthy impulses with the knife of the assassin or the bomb of the dynamiter, instead of with pen and pencil."[4] Historian Todd Samuel Presner places Nordau's later call for "muscular Judaism" in the same fin-de-siècle setting, "marked by both a raging political uncertainty and a paradoxical condensation of intellectual currents ranging from decadence to Social Darwinism".[5]

Herzl and the Zionist Organization

Nordau met Theodor Herzl in 1892, when both were Paris correspondents for German-language newspapers. In November 1895 Herzl set out his idea of a Jewish state to him. According to the Encyclopaedia Judaica, a friend worried about Herzl's mental state had advised him to see a psychiatrist; Nordau ended the consultation by saying: "If you are insane, we are insane together. Count on me!"[1] The Neue Deutsche Biographie says Nordau understood the Jewish state as the realisation of his utopia of "solidarity" among Jews in a state of their own.[2]

At the First Zionist Congress in Basel (1897) Nordau drafted the Basel Program.[1] His congress addresses surveyed the condition of the Jews worldwide: the physical and material plight of the Jews of Eastern Europe, and the "moral plight of the emancipated and assimilated Western Jew".[1] The Neue Deutsche Biographie says it was from this analysis that his call for so-called "Muskeljudentum" followed.[2] The collected edition of his Zionist writings dates the first eight speeches as follows: Basel, 29 August 1897; Basel, 28 August 1898; Basel, 15 August 1899; London, 13 August 1900; Basel, 27 December 1901; Basel, 24 August 1903; Basel, 27 July 1905; and The Hague, 14 August 1907.[6]

1898: "Muskeljudentum"

In his speech to the Second Zionist Congress on 28 August 1898 Nordau said: "Zionism awakens Judaism to new life. … It achieves this morally through the rejuvenation of the ideals of the Volk and corporeally through the physical rearing of one's offspring, in order to create a lost muscular Judaism once again."[7] Presner writes that with this speech Nordau "invented one of Zionism's most famous, most fraught, and most challenging ideals: the muscle Jew".[7] Nordau developed the idea in an essay, "Muskeljudentum", for the Jüdische Turnzeitung, the journal of the Berlin Jewish gymnastics club Bar Kochba, in June 1900. See Muscular Judaism.[8]

1901: "Volksmaterial" and statistics

At the Fifth Congress in December 1901, according to Bloom's translation, Nordau said: "We must know more. We must possess reliable knowledge of the constitution of our Volksmaterial; for it is with this that we must create [our state]. We need a complete anthropological, biological, economic and intellectual statistic of the Jewish people." Bloom writes that Ruppin "embraced Nordau's call and became one of Zionism's leading professional statisticians and demographers".[9]

1903: Uganda, "Nachtasyl" and the Paris shooting

At the Sixth Congress (1903) Nordau defended Herzl's political Zionism against Ahad Ha'am's cultural Zionism, telling the delegates: "'Judaism without Jews' – we know you, beautiful mask! Go with this phrase and join a meeting of spiritualists!"[1] Out of loyalty to Herzl he supported the British offer of territory in East Africa, the so-called Uganda scheme, and coined the term Nachtasyl ("night shelter") to stress that it would be temporary, although, according to the Encyclopaedia Judaica, he himself thought a charter for Uganda "a grave error".[1] In the speech he said that, before the Jews could be given a permanent home, "we must, as it were, open a night shelter" for the hundreds of thousands already on the move, and that he regarded the colony offered by the British government as such a Nachtasyl.[10]

On the evening of 19 December 1903, at a Hanukkah ball in Paris, Chaim Selig Luban (also spelt Louban), a 27-year-old student of Russian origin who opposed the Uganda plan and held Nordau responsible for it, fired at him, reportedly shouting "Death to Nordau, the East African". Nordau was not hit; a bystander was grazed.[1][2][11] According to the Encyclopaedia Judaica, Nordau himself defended Luban before the investigating judge.[1] Herzl telegraphed Nordau the next day that he was "profondément indigné par l'ignoble attentat" ("deeply indignant at the vile attack").[12]

After Herzl

In his last conversation with Nissan Katzenelson, according to the Encyclopaedia Judaica, Herzl named Nordau as his preferred successor. Nordau declined the presidency of the Zionist Organization after Herzl's death in 1904 and instead, according to the Jewish Virtual Library, served as adviser to David Wolffsohn.[1][13] He opposed the "practical Zionists" led by Chaim Weizmann, and the Encyclopaedia Judaica says he "believed in political action rather than in small-scale, gradual agricultural colonization".[1] At the 1911 Congress, according to the same entry, he warned that if current political trends persisted, six million Jews in the Russian Empire and other East European countries "were doomed to perish".[1][2]

He spent the First World War in Spain. According to the Encyclopaedia Judaica, he favoured Vladimir Jabotinsky's idea of a Jewish Legion but thought the Zionist movement should remain neutral.[1]

The "Nordau plan"

In 1919, as a wave of pogroms swept Ukraine, Nordau "began advocating the speedy transfer of 600,000 Jews to Palestine within a matter of months". In his 1920 address at the Albert Hall in London, according to the Encyclopaedia Judaica, he told British statesmen and Zionist leaders that if the Balfour Declaration was to have meaning, "that meaning must be made manifest by the swift creation of a Jewish majority and ensuing Jewish political independence in Palestine". The Zionist leadership rejected the plan as unrealistic, and in 1921 he withdrew from active Zionist work.[1][2] In the late 1930s Ze'ev Jabotinsky named his own programme for the rapid creation of a Jewish majority in Palestine through mass transfer of Jews from the Diaspora "The Max Nordau Plan".[1][2]

Influence on Arthur Ruppin

Bloom writes that the only Zionist, "and the only Jew", who affected Arthur Ruppin in the same meaningful way as the German thinkers who shaped him was Nordau, "whom Ruppin had admired since his youth and with whom he had a warm personal relationship". Martin Buber dated their first meeting to 1901.[14] Ruppin, who in his diaries criticised almost every other Zionist leader, "saw Nordau as his mentor; perhaps the only Jew and certainly the only Zionist who could claim this title". Bloom notes that after reading The Conventional Lies the young Ruppin wrote that he wanted to be someone like Nordau, a "dramatist, world improver, and social reformer". He also sees links in their rejection of the Sephardi Jew as the original Jewish type and in their views of religion as a pathology.[3] Ruppin took up Nordau's image of the Muskeljude, and from the 1920s replaced it with his own ideal of "the Maccabean type". See Arthur Ruppin and Muscular Judaism.[15]

Jabotinsky and the Revisionists

Besides naming his late-1930s mass-immigration programme after Nordau, Jabotinsky, according to historian Simon Levis Sullam, "highly praised" Nordau in his book The War and the Jew (1942).[16] The University of California Press describes Michael Stanislawski's study of Nordau and Jabotinsky as arguing "against the common conception of Nordau and Jabotinsky as nineteenth-century liberals", insisting that they "must be understood against the backdrop of Social Darwinism in the West and the Positivism of Russian radicalism in the fin de siècle".[17]

Death and burial

Nordau died in Paris in January 1923. His remains were moved to Palestine and buried in the Old Cemetery in Tel Aviv in 1926.[1][2] The Neue Deutsche Biographie gives his date of death as 22 January 1923; the Jewish Virtual Library gives 23 January.[2][13]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 1.16 1.17 1.18 1.19 1.20 1.21 Meir Ben-Horin, Nordau, Max Encyclopaedia Judaica (via Encyclopedia.com), accessed 19 November 2026.
  2. ↑ 2.00 2.01 2.02 2.03 2.04 2.05 2.06 2.07 2.08 2.09 2.10 2.11 Martha Keil, Nordau, Max (bis 1873 Simon Maximilian Südfeld) Neue Deutsche Biographie 19 (1999), pp. 339–340, accessed 19 November 2026.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 Etan Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, Leiden: Brill, 2011, pp. 111–112. See also the publisher's page.
  4. ↑ Max Nordau, Degeneration, translated from the second German edition, New York: D. Appleton and Company, 1895, dedication to Cesare Lombroso, p. vii (Internet Archive copy), accessed 19 November 2026.
  5. ↑ Todd Samuel Presner, Muscular Judaism: The Jewish Body and the Politics of Regeneration, London and New York: Routledge, 2007, p. 2. Publisher's preview (PDF), accessed 19 November 2026.
  6. ↑ Max Nordau, Max Nordau's Zionistische Schriften, edited by the Zionistisches Aktionskomitee, Cologne and Leipzig: Jüdischer Verlag, 1909, table of contents (Internet Archive copy), accessed 19 November 2026.
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 Presner, Muscular Judaism, p. 1, translating Nordau's speech to the Second Zionist Congress. The German text is in Zionistische Schriften (1909), p. 72: "Der Zionismus erweckt das Judentum zu neuem Leben. … Er bewirkt dies sittlich durch Auffrischung der Volksideale, körperlich durch die physische Erziehung des Nachwuchses, der uns wieder das verloren gegangene Muskeljudentum schaffen soll."
  8. ↑ Max Nordau, "Muskeljudentum" (Jüdische Turnzeitung, June 1900), in Zionistische Schriften (1909), pp. 379–381.
  9. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, pp. 72–73, quoting Nordau's speech to the Fifth Zionist Congress (Basel, December 1901) from Mitchell Hart, Moses the Microbiologist, p. 89, and Alex Bein, The Man and his Work, p. 124.
  10. ↑ Nordau, speech to the Sixth Zionist Congress (Basel, 24 August 1903), in Zionistische Schriften (1909), p. 153: "Für diese Hunderttausende müssen wir, ehe wir ihnen eine ständige Dauerwohnung anweisen können, gleichsam ein Nachtasyl eröffnen. Als solches Nachtasyl würde ich die Kolonie ansehen, zu der die britische Regierung unter gewissen Bedingungen uns Land zu gewähren bereit ist." Translation by Powerbase.
  11. ↑ David B. Green, 1903: 'Uganda Plan' Prompts Shooting of Zionist Leader Haaretz, 19 December 2013, accessed 19 November 2026.
  12. ↑ FHJU (fhju.fr), Herzl à Nordau, "Profondément indigné par l'ignoble attentat…", 20 décembre 1903 (telegram, collection Nicolas Philippe), accessed 19 November 2026.
  13. ↑ 13.0 13.1 Max Nordau (1849–1923) Jewish Virtual Library, accessed 19 November 2026.
  14. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 43 and note 10, citing Buber's 1943 eulogy for Ruppin (Central Zionist Archives S25/1203) and their 1913–14 correspondence (CZA A107/549).
  15. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, pp. 112–113.
  16. ↑ Simon Levis Sullam, Uncovering the Italian Muscle Jew: from Zionist Gymnastics to Fascist Boxing Quest. Issues in Contemporary Jewish History, no. 11, October 2017, p. 37, accessed 19 November 2026.
  17. ↑ Michael Stanislawski, Zionism and the Fin de Siècle: Cosmopolitanism and Nationalism from Nordau to Jabotinsky, Berkeley: University of California Press, 2001, publisher's description, accessed 19 November 2026.