Arthur Ruppin

From Powerbase
Jump to navigation Jump to search

German Zionist official who headed the Palestine Office from 1908 and was later called the "father of Zionist settlement" (1876–1943)

Arthur Ruppin

Image Arthur Ruppin.jpg
Arthur Ruppin, 1915
Born 1 March 1876 Rawitsch (Rawicz), Posen province, Prussia
Died 1 January 1943
Occupation Zionist official, sociologist, economist
Known for Head of the Zionist Organization's Palestine Office from 1908; land purchase and colonisation; racial sociology of the Jews; founder and first chairman of Brit Shalom
Zionist movement
Overview

Zionism | Zionist Movement | Jerusalem Program | World Zionist Congress | The Duties of the Individual Zionist | Lobbying for Zionism on Both Sides of the Atlantic | Balfour Declaration
Precursors: Die Einheit | Hovevei Zion

Leading figures

Theodor Herzl | David Wolffsohn | Arthur Ruppin | Chaim Weizmann | David Ben-Gurion

National institutions

World Zionist Organization | Jewish National Fund / KKL | Jewish Agency for Israel | Keren Hayesod / UIA
National offices: World Zionist Organization UK | L’Organisation Sioniste Mondiale en France | Jewish Agency for Israel UK and Europe | United Israel Appeal | Jewish Federations of North America
Historical: Jewish Colonial Trust | Anglo-Palestine Bank | Bank Leumi

Zionist federations (43)
National JNF bodies (42)
National Keren Hayesod bodies (35)
World unions and factions

Mizrachi | World Mizrachi | Arzenu | Mercaz Olami | World Confederation of United Zionists | Eretz Hakodesh | World Sephardi Federation | Ameinu | Likud | World Likud
UK: Mizrachi of Great Britain and Ireland | Arzenu UK | Mercaz UK | Likud-Herut UK | Herut UK
Historical: Brit Shalom

Affiliated world organisations

Hadassah | Hadassah International | WIZO | WIZO UK | Emunah | Maccabi World Union | B'nai B'rith International | World Union of Jewish Students

Youth movements

Hashomer Hatzair | Habonim Dror | Bnei Akiva | Betar | BBYO | Young Judaea | LJY-Netzer | Zionist Youth Council (UK) | Taglit Birthright | Federation of Zionist Youth
Historical: Youth Aliyah

Labour Zionism and the kibbutz

Kibbutz Artzi | Histadrut | Mapai | Poale Zion | Jewish Labour Movement

Settlement and land

Nachala | Ateret Cohanim | Daniella Weiss | Greater Israel | Nefesh B'Nefesh
Historical: Jewish Colonization Association | Palestine Jewish Colonization Association | Mikveh Israel | Edmond James de Rothschild | James de Rothschild

Military history

Zion Mule Corps | Jewish Legion | Jewish Brigade

Christian Zionism

Christians United for Israel | International Christian Embassy Jerusalem | Christian Friends of Israel - UK | Christians for Israel International | Christians for Zion | ProZion | Israel Allies Foundation

Israel lobby

Israel Lobby Portal | AIPAC | Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations | BICOM | Board of Deputies of British Jews | Conservative Friends of Israel | Labour Friends of Israel | European Friends of Israel | ELNET | Friends of Israel Initiative | StandWithUs | European Jewish Congress

Data and sources

British Zionist charities | 'Zionist' non profits in the US | US Big Israel data | US lobbying and election spending data | US FARA data | Zionist family foundations in the UK - a ranking | The Zionist Year Book | Zionist Review | Herzl Zionist Institute

Europe (45)
North America and the Caribbean (12)
West Asia (17)
North Africa (6)
Sub-Saharan Africa (48)
Latin America and the Caribbean (23)
South Asia (8)
Central Asia (5)
East Asia (6)
Southeast Asia (11)
Oceania and the Pacific (14)

Arthur Ruppin (1 March 1876 – 1 January 1943) was a German Zionist official, economist and sociologist who, from 1908, headed the Palestine Office of the Zionist Organization in Jaffa and directed Zionist land purchase and colonisation in Palestine. The Encyclopaedia Judaica, in an entry written by Alexander Bein, calls him the originator of the sociology of the Jews and the "father of Zionist settlement". Bein used the same phrase in his introduction to Ruppin's English memoirs.[1][2] Etan Bloom writes that Zionist historiography, from school textbooks to the Encyclopaedia Judaica, gave him the title "The Father of Jewish/Zionist settlement in Palestine."[3] Tom Segev, writing in Haaretz, similarly calls him "the father of the Zionist national settlement in the Land of Israel, beginning in 1908".[4]

Ruppin initiated and chaired the society Brit Shalom, founded in Jerusalem in 1925 to promote a binational arrangement in Palestine. He remained chairman until 1929.[5] His books Die Juden der Gegenwart (1904; English as The Jews of To-day, 1913) and Soziologie der Juden (1930–31; recast in English as The Jews in the Modern World, 1934) treated the Jews as a race and argued against intermarriage. In a 1919 essay, "The Selection of the Fittest", he called the "choice of the human material" one of the most important problems of Zionist colonisation in Palestine.[6] In August 1933 he met the National Socialist race theorist Hans F. K. Günther in Jena.[7] In November 1934, according to Bloom's translation of a Zionist Executive protocol, he opposed increasing the number of Ethiopian Jews in Palestine on racial grounds.[8]

Early life and writings

Ruppin was born on 1 March 1876 in Rawitsch (Rawicz), in the Posen province of Prussia, the first child of Albert Ruppin and Cäcilie Borck.[9][10] His family, once affluent, had become impoverished and moved in 1887 to Magdeburg in Prussian Saxony. He left high school at 15, worked in the grain trade from 1891 to 1899, and later passed the high-school diploma as an external student. From 1899 he studied law and economics at the University of Berlin and the University of Halle, and also spent time on the natural sciences, especially biology. He served in a court from 1902 to 1907 and, in the same period (1903–07), directed the Bureau for Jewish Statistics and Demography in Berlin, founded by Alfred Nossig. Bloom writes that Ruppin entered a competition later known as the Krupp Prize, formulated and supervised by the biologist Ernst Haeckel, on the application of Darwinism to society and the state, and took second place; the work was published as Darwinismus und Sozialwissenschaft.[11] In 1904 he published Die Juden der Gegenwart, which he later expanded into the two-volume Soziologie der Juden (Berlin, 1930–31; issued in Hebrew in several parts, 1931–33). English versions appeared as The Jews of To-day (1913), The Jews in the Modern World (1934) and Jewish Fate and Future (1940).[1][12]

When the first edition of Die Juden der Gegenwart was published, the Encyclopaedia Judaica says, Ruppin "was not yet a Zionist (although he supported the Zionist idea)", but the book "brought him closer to the Zionist movement".[1] In the 1913 English edition he wrote that "The structure of Judaism, once so solid, is crumbling before our very eyes. Conversion and intermarriage are thinning the ranks of Jews in every direction", and concluded that "Zionism is not a mere nationalistic or chauvinistic caprice, but the last desperate stand of the Jews against annihilation".[13]

Palestine Office and colonisation

In 1907 the Zionist Organization sent Ruppin to Palestine to study the situation and the prospects for its work there. The Zionist Executive, then headed by David Wolffsohn, appointed him head of its Palestine Office, which he established in Jaffa in 1908. From then until his death, with intervals for scientific work, travel, and a wartime exile, he was responsible for Zionist colonisation work in Palestine.[1] In 1916 Jamal Pasha forced him to leave for Constantinople, where he organised aid and the transfer of capital to the Yishuv. He returned to Jerusalem in 1920. He was a member of the Zionist Commission in 1920–21, of the Zionist Executive in 1921–27 and again in 1929–31, and of the Jewish Agency Executive in 1933–35. From 1933 he headed the Jewish Agency Department for the Settlement of German Immigrants, and from 1935 he directed the Institute for Economic Research in Palestine, which he founded.[1]

The Encyclopaedia Judaica divides his colonisation work into four periods: laying foundations in 1908–14, including cooperation with the pioneers of the Second Aliyah and the creation of new forms of settlement (the kevutzah and the kibbutz, the moshav ovdim and the moshav shitufi); the wartime effort to sustain the Yishuv in 1914–18; the expansion of urban and rural settlement and of the economy in 1920–33; and, from 1933, a central role in absorbing the Fifth Aliyah from Germany and Nazi-occupied Europe.[1] Segev notes his involvement in the establishment of Kibbutz Degania and in the early development of Tel Aviv, and that he was among the founders of Bank Hapoalim.[4] The Encyclopaedia Judaica also says he was instrumental in the establishment of Tel Aviv and in the purchase of land on Mount Carmel in Haifa and from the Greek Patriarch in Jerusalem (on which Rehavia and other quarters were built).[1] Bloom identifies the training farm established at Kinneret in 1908 as Ruppin's first successful project and a turning point in the emergence of the Palestinian-Zionist labour movement.[14]

Land purchase and tenants

Ruppin established the Palestine Land Development Company (also called the Palestine Land Development Corporation) in 1908, and used it, with the Jewish National Fund, to acquire land, including large tracts in the Jezreel Valley.[1] In a letter to Hans Kohn of 30 May 1928 he stated the consequence of those purchases as he saw it:

Land is the essential condition for putting down economic roots in Palestine […] wherever we purchase land and settle people on it – its current workers [the Arabs] must of necessity be removed, whether they be owners or tenants […] in future it will be much harder to purchase land, because sparsely settled land is no longer available – what is left is land settled with considerable density.

The letter is quoted by Bloom from Bein's Hebrew edition of Ruppin's diaries and letters. This passage does not appear in the abridged English text of the same letter printed in the 1971 selection Memoirs, Diaries, Letters.[15]

Kenneth W. Stein, in a study of cultivators' rights under the Mandate, writes that official purchasing organisations such as the Palestine Land Development Company were, after the First World War, "on the verge of consummating the transfer of some 65,000 dunams of land in the Jezreel Valley owned by the Sursocks of Beirut", and that "the Colonial Office took careful note of the likely removal of these tenants and suggested that due safeguards be maintained for their protection". Stein also tabulates Arab tenant farmers on tracts acquired by Jews in the plains of Esdraelon (the Jezreel Valley) and Acre, and the compensation paid.[16]

Race theory, eugenics and selection

Ruppin treated the Jews as a race and drew on German racial anthropology and eugenics, including writers who were themselves antisemitic. Segev, reporting Bloom's doctoral thesis, writes that Ruppin "believed that the realization of Zionism demanded 'racial purity' among the Jews" and that "in part, his views were inspired by the works of anti-Semitic thinkers, including some of the original Nazi ideologists".[4]

The Jews of To-day and later books

In The Jews of To-day Ruppin wrote that "Intermarriage being clearly detrimental to the preservation of the high qualities of the race, it follows that it is necessary to try and prevent it and preserve Jewish separatism". He set four conditions for Jewish preservation: "1) Jewish schools 2) A self-contained Jewish life 3) A common language 4) Local segregation". He argued that Jews "could best withstand assimilation by being concentrated in great numbers in one area".[17] Bloom also quotes a Hebrew edition of the book: it was important "to preserve this selected human type in the future as well, without mixing it with others, because only in such a way would a full restoration of its racial characteristics be possible".[18]

In Soziologie der Juden he cited, among others, Eugen Fischer and Hans F. K. Günther, and treated Ashkenazi Jews as largely of non-Semitic, "Indo-Germanic" stock, while presenting Sephardi and "Oriental" Jews as inferior in the qualities he prized.[19] Segev summarises Bloom as saying that Ruppin wanted the Zionist enterprise to identify remnants of an "original" or "authentic" Jewish type, which he placed among the Ashkenazi Jews of Eastern Europe, and that he authorised the bringing of Jewish labourers from Yemen only "after long hesitation".[4] The phrase "after long hesitation" is Segev's, not a wording found in Bloom's 2011 book.

In the 1934 English recasting, The Jews in the Modern World, Ruppin still described the Jews as a mixture of the Alpine and Mediterranean races and distinguished three principal types: Oriental, Sephardic and Ashkenazic. He now wrote that "Nor can the Jews be described as of pure race" and that "unity of type" was a better term than "racial purity"; all civilised nations, he said, were mixed. On mental differences he concluded that they were "neither fundamental nor constant" and that "it is very doubtful whether even these mental differences are sufficient to constitute a Jewish race."[20] He nevertheless continued to argue against intermarriage in racial terms. In the closing pages he wrote: "While they marry within their own race, there is the probability that parents of a similar mentality will hand on their qualities to their children; intermarriage with other races reduces those chances. There may be high qualities on both sides, but they have not the same tendency, and the result will probably be not a summing-up but a weakening of the parental qualities."[21]

The Selection of the Fittest

In "The Selection of the Fittest", published in Der Jude in 1919 and collected in English in Building Israel (1949), Ruppin wrote that "One of the most important problems connected with our Palestinian colonization work of the future is the choice of the human material, for it is on the proper solution of this problem that the entire structure of the Jewish community in Palestine will essentially depend." Past practice, he said, had been a "cult of numbers, which overrode all considerations relating to the physical, occupational and moral equipment of the immigrants." He asked whether "we [shall] pay more attention to quality than to quantity, and seek at the beginning of the process to bring into Palestine only such immigrants as, from the point of view of occupation, health and character are most desirable for the Jewish community", and answered that "for the future we shall have to abandon the policy of 'laisser aller' which we have followed till now."[6][22]

Under "Physical Selection" he wrote that it would be "very fine if only strong and healthy persons would come to settle in Palestine", but that in practice selection should be limited to rejecting those with certain infectious diseases or likely to become public charges. He then asked "whether it is possible to work for the keeping pure of the Jewish racial stock":

Since it is our desire to develop in Palestine our Jewish side, it would naturally be desirable to have only "race" Jews come to Palestine. But a direct influence on the process, via the selection of such immigrants as most closely approach the racial type, is not practically possible.

He added that the general type in Palestine was likely to be "more strongly Jewish than the general type in Europe", because "the more strongly Jewish types will be the ones which are most generally discriminated against in Europe."[23] Bloom, translating the same 1919 German essay (Die Auslese des Menschenmaterials für Palaestina), gives the racial sentence as: "Since we want to develop in Eretz Yisrael specifically what is Jewish, it will obviously be desirable that only the racially pure come to the land."[24] Bloom describes this "selection of human material" as the first stage of Ruppin's eugenic plan, to be carried out through agricultural training and the formation of groups from those who proved suitable.[25]

Meeting with Hans F. K. Günther, 1933

A few months after the Nazis came to power, Ruppin met Günther, a leading disseminator of National Socialist racial theory, in Jena. Segev reports the meeting and notes that it took place in 1933.[4] The meeting is not mentioned in the 16 August 1933 diary entry printed in the 1971 English selection, which records Ruppin's negotiations in Berlin on the transfer of capital and goods by emigrants to Palestine and his plan for the emigration of 250,000 German Jews.[26] Bloom, quoting the diary from Bein's Hebrew edition and from Krolik's German edition, gives this English rendering of Ruppin's record of the meeting:

Günther was very kind, rejected the authorship for the concept of Aryans, he agreed with me that the Jews are not inferior [minderwertig], but just different [anderswertig] and that the Jewish question had to be settled in a decent fashion.

Bloom dates the meeting to August 1933 and cites the diary entry of 16 August 1933.[7] Bloom also writes that in January 1930 Ruppin had noted Günther's Rassenkunde des jüdischen Volkes and wanted to insert "many ideas and photographs of ancient reliefs" from it into his own work, and that in Soziologie der Juden he treated Günther as an important authority.[7]

Brit Shalom

Ruppin initiated Brit Shalom in 1925 and chaired it until 1929. The Encyclopaedia Judaica says he wanted the society to be a research group that would present its findings to the Zionist leadership, while others wanted a political programme of their own.[5] On 31 December 1924 he wrote in his diary:

What continually worries me is the relationship between the Jews and the Arabs in Palestine. Superficially, it has improved, inasmuch as there is no danger of pogroms, but the two peoples have become more estranged in their thinking. Neither has any understanding of the other, and yet I have no doubt whatsoever that Zionism will end in a catastrophe if we do not succeed in finding a common platform. Next year, I want to see if it is possible to bring together a small circle of eminent Jews and Arabs who are willing to work towards such an understanding.

[27] At the Fourteenth Zionist Congress in 1925, according to Bloom, he said that part of the population would always be Arab and that "we must live with them in conditions of coexistence", and that "the announcement of the establishment of such a committee must have a propagandist character, and not only for us."[28] Bloom, citing Hagit Lavsky's conclusion that Brit Shalom "assisted Zionist historiography in its desire to promote an image of the Zionist movement as seeking peace", argues that Ruppin's part in founding the society "was meant, or at least served, to promote an image of the Zionist movement as humanistic".[28]

In the 30 May 1928 letter to Kohn, as printed in the 1971 English selection, Ruppin wrote that he had founded Brit Shalom because "there is no parallel in history to the aim of Zionism — to settle the Jews peaceably in a country which is already inhabited." Such an entry, he said, was "known in history only by means of conquest", and "The Brit Shalom was to become the forum to consider and discuss the problem." A constitution that really gave the Arab majority a say would, he wrote, be used "to prevent any economic progress of the Jewish minority. That would quite simply mean the end of the Zionist movement." He had "doubts whether one can immediately apply to Palestine the principles of democracy", and he wondered "whether it would not be breaking faith with the yishuv to address a statement above its head directly to the Arabs."[29] Bloom's translation of the same letter from the Hebrew edition includes passages omitted from the 1971 selection: that Brit Shalom must be a "club for studying and research and not for quarrels"; the land-and-tenants passage quoted above; and that it was not appropriate "to take such a declaration to the Arabs and to bypass organized Zionism."[30]

Bloom, citing a letter to Kohn of 24 November 1928 in Bein's Hebrew edition, says Ruppin resigned as head before the 1929 riots, writing that "This is not the time for peace preaching […] the appeasing tone […] might be interpreted by the Arabs as weakness."[31] The 1971 English diaries do not include a letter of that date. They do include an entry of 24 November 1929, after the August 1929 riots, in which Ruppin wrote that "our conciliatory tone is interpreted by the Arabs as weakness" and that he had "resigned as chairman four weeks ago in favour of Dr Lurie."[32] The Encyclopaedia Judaica says he was chairman until 1929, when Joseph Lurie succeeded him.[5] Bloom says he remained a member and continued to take part in meetings.[31] Bloom, citing Bein's Hebrew edition, also quotes an entry of 31 December 1929: "the propaganda of Brit Shalom might do more harm than good."[33]

On 3 December 1931, in a letter to Victor Jacobson, Ruppin wrote: "The situation is paradoxical: what we can get (from the Arabs) is of no use to us, and what we need we cannot get from them."[34] The Encyclopaedia Judaica says that after the "Arab riots and uprisings in 1929, 1936, and thereafter" he "came to the conclusion that the time was not yet ripe for fruitful Arab-Jewish negotiations" and "believed it necessary to strengthen the Jewish position in the country economically and politically".[1]

On 18 March 1936, after Brit Shalom had virtually ceased to exist, Ruppin wrote to Robert Weltsch a letter that Bloom calls a "farewell letter" to "the intellectuals from Mount Scopus". In the 1971 English text he wrote that "no sort of negotiations with the Arabs can get us anywhere at the moment, because the Arabs are still hoping to deal with us above our heads. Not negotiations, but the development of Palestine towards a larger percentage of Jews in the population and a strengthening of our economic position can and will bring about an easing of the tension."[35] Bloom's translation of the same letter from the Hebrew edition, which includes passages omitted from the 1971 selection, has him describe the Zionist Executive's delay of the Legislative Council as Verschiebungstaktik (a tactic of postponement, or of displacement, or both): "if the Legislative Council had been set up in 1931, it would have been based on a Jewish population of 17 per cent, whereas today it is based on 28 per cent." He wrote that the movement's existence depended on increasing Jewish numbers "over the next five or ten years, until we will be, more or less, on an even keel with the Arabs", and he accepted that postponement could lead to "bloody unrest or even into a general upheaval."[36] Bloom's commentary is that the tactic "enabled the Zionist movement to seem to accept democratic principles, to present itself as willing to achieve agreement through compromise, and, simultaneously, to postpone all practical steps towards achieving such an end" until Jews in Palestine were a majority.[37]

On 25 April 1936, after violence in Jaffa, Ruppin wrote in his diary: "I have adopted the theory that under the circumstances it is natural that the antagonism of the Arabs to Jewish immigration should find release in periodic outbreaks; that we are living in a sort of latent state of war with the Arabs which makes loss of life inevitable. This may be unacceptable, but it is a fact; and if we want to continue our work in Palestine in spite of the Arabs, we will have to expect such losses."[38] A fuller account of the letters and of Ruppin's role in the society is on the page Brit Shalom.

Ethiopian Jews, 1934

In 1934, following a request by Jacob (Yaakov) Feitlovich to bring Ethiopian Jews to Palestine, Ruppin opposed an increase in their number. Bloom, citing the protocol of the Zionist Executive meeting of 14 November 1934 in the Ben-Gurion Archive (N. 20210), and pointing also to Aviva Halamish, A Dual Race Against Time (2006), p. 311, gives this English rendering of Ruppin's words:

Niggers, who came to Judaism by force of the sword in the sixth century B.C. They have no blood connection to the Jews. […] [Therefore] their number in Palestine should not be increased.

The wording, including the slur, is Bloom's English translation. The original language of the protocol (German or Hebrew) has not been independently checked here, so the exact original word is not given.[8] Bloom adds that, for Ruppin, rabbinic recognition of Ethiopian Jews was "not at all important because he perceived the Jews as belonging to the white Indo-Germanic races". Feitlovich's initiative failed. Bloom notes that "the Ethiopian Jews were recognized as Jews by the State of Israel only in 1979."[8] Segev, summarising Bloom, writes that Ruppin "declared that there were no black Jews".[4] In November 1942, about a month before he died, Ruppin was still classifying Jewish "racial types" by nose form; Bloom reproduces a note headed "Jüd. Rasse 29/XI 42" (CZA A 107/347) in which he listed types and placed Feitlovich under "Aschkenasisch-Negroider".[8]

Hebrew University

From 1926 Ruppin served as lecturer and later professor of the sociology of the Jews at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem.[1] Bloom describes him as the founder, in 1926, of the university's first department for Jewish sociology, and says that in 1928 he lectured there on "the race history of the Jews", lectures that became the basis of Soziologie der Juden (1930).[39] Already on 22 December 1924, at the opening of the Institute for Judaica, he had written that he might lecture "on the social and economic conditions of the Jews, on the anthropology of the Jews or on the economic geography of Palestine."[40]

Later years

From 1933 Ruppin headed the Jewish Agency department that dealt with the settlement of immigrants from Germany. From 1935 he directed the Institute for Economic Research in Palestine.[1] A collection of his essays, Three Decades of Palestine, was published in English in 1936; a further selection, Building Israel, appeared in 1949. He died on 1 January 1943 while working in his garden.[41] Bloom writes that he "died of a sudden heart attack while working in his garden, in January 1943".[3] His autobiography, Pirkei Hayyai, edited by Bein, was published in Hebrew in three volumes (1968); Arthur Ruppin: Memoirs, Diaries, Letters appeared in English in 1971. Kefar Ruppin in the Beth-Shean Valley, an agricultural school in Emek Hefer, and a botanical garden at Degania Alef are named after him.[1] Bloom writes that Ruppin asked in his will to be buried at the training farm at Kinneret, and elsewhere that Degania was "the burial place also of Ruppin". The 1971 English memoirs do not mention the burial.[42]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 1.11 Alexander Bein, Ruppin, Arthur Encyclopaedia Judaica (via Encyclopedia.com), accessed 17 November 2026.
  2. ↑ Alex Bein, introduction, in Arthur Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, ed. Alex Bein, trans. Karen Gershon, New York: Herzl Press / London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1971, p. xvii.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 Etan Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, Leiden: Brill, 2011, p. 8.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 Tom Segev, The Makings of History / Revisiting Arthur Ruppin Haaretz, 8 October 2009, accessed 17 November 2026 (Internet Archive copy).
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 Susan Hattis Rolef, Berit Shalom Encyclopaedia Judaica (via Encyclopedia.com), accessed 13 November 2026.
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 Arthur Ruppin, "The Selection of the Fittest", in Building Israel: Selected Essays 1907-1935, New York: Schocken, 1949, pp. 66–67. The essay was first published in Der Jude, 1919.
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 341, quoting Ruppin's diary, 16 August 1933, in Alex Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai (Tel Aviv, 1968), vol. 3, p. 223, and in Schlomo Krolik (ed.), Arthur Ruppin: Briefe, Tagebücher, Erinnerungen (1985), p. 422. The meeting is not recorded in the 16 August 1933 entry printed in the 1971 English selection of the diaries.
  8. ↑ 8.0 8.1 8.2 8.3 Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 104, citing the protocol of the Zionist Executive meeting of 14 November 1934, Ben-Gurion Archive, N. 20210, and Aviva Halamish, A Dual Race Against Time: Zionist Immigration Policy in the 1930s (Jerusalem: Yad Izhak Ben-Zvi, 2006), p. 311. The English wording is Bloom's translation; the original wording of the protocol has not been independently checked here.
  9. ↑ Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, p. 7.
  10. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 19.
  11. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, pp. 47 and 51.
  12. ↑ L. B. Namier, prefatory note, in Arthur Ruppin, The Jews in the Modern World, London: Macmillan, 1934, p. xxxi. Namier dates the Hebrew edition of the sociology to 1931–1933.
  13. ↑ Arthur Ruppin, The Jews of To-day, London: G. Bell and Sons, 1913, p. 300; quoted in Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 75.
  14. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 179.
  15. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 317, quoting Ruppin to Hans Kohn, 30 May 1928, in Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai, vol. 3, pp. 149–150. The abridged English text of the letter is in Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, pp. 237–238.
  16. ↑ Kenneth W. Stein, Legal Protection and Circumvention of Rights for Cultivators in Mandatory Palestine, accessed 17 November 2026.
  17. ↑ Arthur Ruppin, The Jews of To-day, London: G. Bell and Sons, 1913, pp. 227–228, 265, 273; quoted in Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, pp. 84–85.
  18. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 85, quoting Ruppin, HaYehudim BaZman HaZe, p. 162.
  19. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, pp. 85–96 and 103–104, citing Ruppin, Soziologie der Juden, vol. 1 (Berlin, 1930).
  20. ↑ Ruppin, The Jews in the Modern World, pp. 8–10 and 14–18.
  21. ↑ Ruppin, The Jews in the Modern World, p. 400.
  22. ↑ Ruppin, "The Selection of the Fittest", in Building Israel, pp. 69–70.
  23. ↑ Ruppin, "The Selection of the Fittest", in Building Israel, pp. 78–79.
  24. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 174, quoting Ruppin, "Die Auslese des Menschenmaterials für Palaestina".
  25. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, pp. 172–174. Bloom's account of the eugenic logic of "enthusiasm" and "pure race Jews" is his interpretation of Ruppin's vocabulary and practice.
  26. ↑ Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, p. 264, entry dated Prague, 16 August 1933.
  27. ↑ Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, pp. 215–216, entry for 31 December 1924. Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, pp. 313–314, quoting the same entry from Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai, vol. 3, p. 92, renders the key sentences as "The alienation is greater than it was" and "I don't have any doubt that Zionism will have to face a catastrophe if it cannot find a common platform [with the Arabs]."
  28. ↑ 28.0 28.1 Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 314, quoting the protocol of the Fourteenth Zionist Congress, pp. 438–439, as cited in Elchanan Friedlander. The 1971 English memoirs do not include this speech.
  29. ↑ Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, pp. 237–238, letter to Hans Kohn, 30 May 1928.
  30. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, pp. 316–317, quoting Ruppin to Kohn, 30 May 1928, in Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai, vol. 3, pp. 149–150.
  31. ↑ 31.0 31.1 Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 318, quoting Ruppin to Hans Kohn, 24 November 1928, in Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai, vol. 3, p. 179.
  32. ↑ Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, pp. 248–249, entry for 24 November 1929.
  33. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 318, quoting Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai, vol. 3, p. 181, entry for 31 December 1929. The 31 December 1929 entry printed in the 1971 English selection does not include this sentence; it records Ruppin's evidence to the Shaw Commission, in which he said the legal relationship "should be based upon the principle of a bi-national Palestine, that is, the complete equality of both peoples" (Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, p. 249).
  34. ↑ Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, p. 258, letter to Victor Jacobson, 3 December 1931. In a letter to Robert Weltsch of 18 March 1936 he later quoted the sentence and dated the Jacobson letter to 31 December 1931 (ibid., p. 276). Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 318, quoting Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai, vol. 3, p. 203, gives the wording as "What we can get from the Arabs we don't need, and what we need we can't get," and dates it December 1931.
  35. ↑ Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, pp. 276–277, letter to Robert Weltsch, 18 March 1936.
  36. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, pp. 322–323, quoting Ruppin to Robert Weltsch, 18 March 1936, in Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai, vol. 3, pp. 255–258. Bloom gives the English of the Legislative Council passage as his translation of the German.
  37. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 323.
  38. ↑ Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, p. 277, entry for 25 April 1936. The entry says the Jaffa disturbances "claimed sixteen Jews and three Arabs as victims." Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 323, quoting a closely related formulation from Bein's Hebrew edition, reverses those figures ("sixteen Arabs and three Jews") and renders the conclusion as "we are destined to live in a state of constant warfare with the Arabs, and there is no escape from blood sacrifices."
  39. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, pp. 5 and 103.
  40. ↑ Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, p. 215, entry for 22 December 1924.
  41. ↑ Bein, introduction, in Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, p. xix.
  42. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, pp. 137 and 179. The Degania statement appears in a passage on the burial of Otto Warburg, citing Warburg, Warburg, p. 9.