Difference between revisions of "Hovevei Zion"
(New page: Hovevei Zion) |
(Add Collins, Second City Jewry (1990), ch. 8 material checked against the Jewish Chronicle) |
||
| Line 20: | Line 20: | ||
== Relations with Herzl == | == Relations with Herzl == | ||
After Herzl published ''Der Judenstaat'' in 1896 and the [[World Zionist Organization]] was founded, most branches of Hovevei Zion joined the new movement.<ref name="JVLHovevei" /> The ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' says Herzl at first called the small-scale settlement work "infiltration". The Western European groups reacted to him with reserve, while most of the Eastern European groups joined him but kept supporting practical settlement. This was the root of the split between "political" and "practical" Zionists, which lasted until "synthetic Zionism" took hold after [[David Wolffsohn]] resigned as president of the World Zionist Organization in 1911.<ref name="EJHibbat" /> Hovevei Zion in Russia also clashed with Rothschild over his system of patronage in the colonies.<ref name="EJEdmond">[https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/rothschild-baron-edmond-james-de "Rothschild, Baron Edmond James de"], ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'', via Encyclopedia.com, accessed 25 October 2026.</ref> | After Herzl published ''Der Judenstaat'' in 1896 and the [[World Zionist Organization]] was founded, most branches of Hovevei Zion joined the new movement.<ref name="JVLHovevei" /> The ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' says Herzl at first called the small-scale settlement work "infiltration". The Western European groups reacted to him with reserve, while most of the Eastern European groups joined him but kept supporting practical settlement. This was the root of the split between "political" and "practical" Zionists, which lasted until "synthetic Zionism" took hold after [[David Wolffsohn]] resigned as president of the World Zionist Organization in 1911.<ref name="EJHibbat" /> Hovevei Zion in Russia also clashed with Rothschild over his system of patronage in the colonies.<ref name="EJEdmond">[https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/rothschild-baron-edmond-james-de "Rothschild, Baron Edmond James de"], ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'', via Encyclopedia.com, accessed 25 October 2026.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==Glasgow and Edinburgh== | ||
| + | Collins records that a branch of Chovevei Zion was formed in Edinburgh in August 1890, following a visit by [[Chaim Zundel Maccoby|Rev. Chaim Zundel Maccoby]]. During Maccoby's return visit to Edinburgh in April 1891 he was invited by [[Garnethill Synagogue]], in a letter from the President, [[Julius Frankenburgh]], to give two lectures in Glasgow and was granted permission to form a local branch of Chovevei Zion, “the Society for Colonising Palestine by Jewish Emigrants.” After addresses at Garnethill and in Main Street it was agreed that a Glasgow branch should be formed. Support came from both Garnethill and the Gorbals. Collins describes the society, seen in simple terms as a philanthropic organisation in favour of settling poor Jews in Palestine, as attracting no political controversy about its ideals at this stage.<ref name="Collins1990p74">Kenneth E. Collins, ''Second City Jewry: The Jews of Glasgow in the Age of Expansion, 1790–1919'' (Glasgow: Scottish Jewish Archives Committee, 1990), p. 74.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | In June 1891 [[E. P. Phillips|Rev. E.P. Phillips]] preached a sermon in favour of Chovevei Zion. In October of that year 400 people heard [[Abraham Shyne|Rabbi Shyne]] give a lecture in Yiddish encouraging people to join the Glasgow branch. The following year [[Isaac Levine|Rev. Isaac Levine]] of Garnethill declared his support, at a meeting in the Lesser Hall of the Main Street Synagogue, as “the means to an end, namely the final restoration of Palestine.” Two prominent Garnethill members, [[David Wolffe]], a wholesale jeweller, and [[Benjamin Wohlgemuth]], who had a photographic and art business, “were elected to office as Commander and Treasurer.” When Wolffe's business took him more often to London he was appointed delegate to the national headquarters and Wohlgemuth was appointed Commander. The branch quickly collected £75, of which £60 was remitted to London. The committee was dominated by Garnethill members, though public meetings were usually held at the Breadalbane Halls in Kirk Street or the Standard Halls in the Gorbals, especially if the address was in Yiddish.<ref name="Collins1990p74" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | By January 1895 the branch was known as the Glasgow Tent of the Chovevei Zion. [[Michael Simons]] and Rev. I. Levine proposed, at a meeting in which 54 new members were enrolled, a resolution supporting the Paris Central Committee's plan for workmen's co-operatives in Rehovot and Castinie. A few weeks later a junior branch, or Cadet Tent, was founded at Garnethill, organised by [[Jacob Goodman]], whose father [[Abraham Goodman|Abraham]] was the ''shochet'', assistant secretary and ''mohel'' at Garnethill Synagogue as well as Secretary of the Glasgow Tent, until his death in 1897.<ref name="Collins1990p74" /> By 1896 Gorbals Jews formed the majority of the committee, although the four executive posts remained in Garnethill hands.<ref name="Collins1990p75">Collins, ''Second City Jewry'', p. 75.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | In May 1898 [[Adolph Shoenfeld]], a prominent Garnethill member, replaced Wohlgemuth as Commander of the Glasgow Tent.<ref name="Collins1990p117n1">Collins, ''Second City Jewry'', p. 117, n. 1, citing ''Jewish Chronicle'', 6 September 1898 (cited in Collins).</ref> At a public meeting reported in the ''Jewish Chronicle'' of 9 December 1898, Mr. I. Schoenfeld advised the Chovevei Zion to amalgamate with political Zionism, “since both had the same aims.” The meeting established the [[Glasgow Zionist Association]] on the programme of the Basle Congress, with Mr. E. Schoenfeld as Hon. President.<ref name="JC1898Dec9">''Jewish Chronicle'', 9 December 1898, p. 27, “The Provinces” (Glasgow), [https://www.thejc.com/archive/MjM2NTMxZDUtNGExMy00 archive page].</ref> Collins identifies him as [[Adolph Shoenfeld]] and records that the parent Chovevei Zion body merged into the Association, while younger members, still organised as Cadet tents no. 2 and 3, continued separately at Garnethill.<ref name="Collins1990p117n2">Collins, ''Second City Jewry'', p. 117, n. 2.</ref> The Cadet Tent's final general meeting, in January 1903, withdrew from Zionist affiliation and reformed as the Junior Branch of the Glasgow Jewish Board of Guardians.<ref name="Collins1990p119n17">Collins, ''Second City Jewry'', p. 119, n. 17, citing ''Jewish Chronicle'', 23 January 1903 (cited in Collins).</ref> | ||
== See also == | == See also == | ||
Latest revision as of 08:43, 13 November 2026
Movement of the 1880s and 1890s, strongest in Russia and Romania, that promoted Jewish settlement in Palestine before Herzl's political Zionism
| Hovevei Zion
| |
|---|---|
| Type | Movement for Jewish settlement in Palestine (Ḥibbat Zion) |
| Founded | 1881–82 |
| Location | Russia, Romania, Western Europe, the United States |
| Key people | Leon Pinsker; Samuel Mohilewer; Moshe Leib Lilienblum |
Hovevei Zion (also Chovevei Zion, "Lovers of Zion") were the groups of the Ḥibbat Zion ("Love of Zion") movement, which promoted Jewish settlement in Palestine, especially agricultural settlement, from the early 1880s.[1] The Encyclopaedia Judaica describes Ḥibbat Zion as "the intermediate link" between the forerunners of Zionism and the political Zionism of Theodor Herzl and the First Zionist Congress in 1897, and as "the first mass movement to provide Herzl with wide popular support".[2]
Aims and activity
The first Hovevei Zion groups were set up in 1881–82. Some concentrated on philanthropy and others on emigration to Palestine.[1] The Encyclopaedia Judaica says the movement's declared aim was "to solve the problem of the abnormal Jewish life in the dispersion by a return of the Jewish people to Ereẓ Israel, settlement on the land on a large scale, and attaining the recognition of the major powers for this purpose". In practice, after the Russian pogroms of the early 1880s, the groups concentrated on encouraging emigration and settlement rather than politics, since conditions in Russia did not allow open political activity.[2]
The encyclopaedia says the groups' efforts "turned de facto into philanthropic activity of limited scope", and that without the help of Baron Edmond de Rothschild it is doubtful they could have kept the first settlements going.[2] Hovevei Zion also asked Baron Maurice de Hirsch to support the movement, but he refused.[3]
The Odessa Committee
In Russia the groups sought a legally recognised national framework. The authorities insisted that it be a charitable body, and early in 1890 it was approved as the Society for the Support of Jewish Farmers and Artisans in Syria and Eretz-Israel, known as the Odessa Committee. The Jewish Virtual Library says it had about 14,000 sympathisers in Russia in 1892, and that its leaders included Rabbi Samuel Mohilewer, Moshe Leib Lilienblum and Leon Pinsker.[1]
Relations with Herzl
After Herzl published Der Judenstaat in 1896 and the World Zionist Organization was founded, most branches of Hovevei Zion joined the new movement.[1] The Encyclopaedia Judaica says Herzl at first called the small-scale settlement work "infiltration". The Western European groups reacted to him with reserve, while most of the Eastern European groups joined him but kept supporting practical settlement. This was the root of the split between "political" and "practical" Zionists, which lasted until "synthetic Zionism" took hold after David Wolffsohn resigned as president of the World Zionist Organization in 1911.[2] Hovevei Zion in Russia also clashed with Rothschild over his system of patronage in the colonies.[4]
Glasgow and Edinburgh
Collins records that a branch of Chovevei Zion was formed in Edinburgh in August 1890, following a visit by Rev. Chaim Zundel Maccoby. During Maccoby's return visit to Edinburgh in April 1891 he was invited by Garnethill Synagogue, in a letter from the President, Julius Frankenburgh, to give two lectures in Glasgow and was granted permission to form a local branch of Chovevei Zion, “the Society for Colonising Palestine by Jewish Emigrants.” After addresses at Garnethill and in Main Street it was agreed that a Glasgow branch should be formed. Support came from both Garnethill and the Gorbals. Collins describes the society, seen in simple terms as a philanthropic organisation in favour of settling poor Jews in Palestine, as attracting no political controversy about its ideals at this stage.[5]
In June 1891 Rev. E.P. Phillips preached a sermon in favour of Chovevei Zion. In October of that year 400 people heard Rabbi Shyne give a lecture in Yiddish encouraging people to join the Glasgow branch. The following year Rev. Isaac Levine of Garnethill declared his support, at a meeting in the Lesser Hall of the Main Street Synagogue, as “the means to an end, namely the final restoration of Palestine.” Two prominent Garnethill members, David Wolffe, a wholesale jeweller, and Benjamin Wohlgemuth, who had a photographic and art business, “were elected to office as Commander and Treasurer.” When Wolffe's business took him more often to London he was appointed delegate to the national headquarters and Wohlgemuth was appointed Commander. The branch quickly collected £75, of which £60 was remitted to London. The committee was dominated by Garnethill members, though public meetings were usually held at the Breadalbane Halls in Kirk Street or the Standard Halls in the Gorbals, especially if the address was in Yiddish.[5]
By January 1895 the branch was known as the Glasgow Tent of the Chovevei Zion. Michael Simons and Rev. I. Levine proposed, at a meeting in which 54 new members were enrolled, a resolution supporting the Paris Central Committee's plan for workmen's co-operatives in Rehovot and Castinie. A few weeks later a junior branch, or Cadet Tent, was founded at Garnethill, organised by Jacob Goodman, whose father Abraham was the shochet, assistant secretary and mohel at Garnethill Synagogue as well as Secretary of the Glasgow Tent, until his death in 1897.[5] By 1896 Gorbals Jews formed the majority of the committee, although the four executive posts remained in Garnethill hands.[6]
In May 1898 Adolph Shoenfeld, a prominent Garnethill member, replaced Wohlgemuth as Commander of the Glasgow Tent.[7] At a public meeting reported in the Jewish Chronicle of 9 December 1898, Mr. I. Schoenfeld advised the Chovevei Zion to amalgamate with political Zionism, “since both had the same aims.” The meeting established the Glasgow Zionist Association on the programme of the Basle Congress, with Mr. E. Schoenfeld as Hon. President.[8] Collins identifies him as Adolph Shoenfeld and records that the parent Chovevei Zion body merged into the Association, while younger members, still organised as Cadet tents no. 2 and 3, continued separately at Garnethill.[9] The Cadet Tent's final general meeting, in January 1903, withdrew from Zionist affiliation and reformed as the Junior Branch of the Glasgow Jewish Board of Guardians.[10]
See also
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 Jewish Virtual Library, "Zionism: Hovevei Zion", accessed 25 October 2026.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 Getzel Kressel, "Ḥibbat Zion", Encyclopaedia Judaica, via Encyclopedia.com, accessed 25 October 2026.
- ↑ Jewish Virtual Library, "Baron Maurice de Hirsch (1831–1896)" (source: Gates to Jewish Heritage), accessed 25 October 2026.
- ↑ "Rothschild, Baron Edmond James de", Encyclopaedia Judaica, via Encyclopedia.com, accessed 25 October 2026.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 Kenneth E. Collins, Second City Jewry: The Jews of Glasgow in the Age of Expansion, 1790–1919 (Glasgow: Scottish Jewish Archives Committee, 1990), p. 74.
- ↑ Collins, Second City Jewry, p. 75.
- ↑ Collins, Second City Jewry, p. 117, n. 1, citing Jewish Chronicle, 6 September 1898 (cited in Collins).
- ↑ Jewish Chronicle, 9 December 1898, p. 27, “The Provinces” (Glasgow), archive page.
- ↑ Collins, Second City Jewry, p. 117, n. 2.
- ↑ Collins, Second City Jewry, p. 119, n. 17, citing Jewish Chronicle, 23 January 1903 (cited in Collins).