Difference between revisions of "Brit Shalom"

From Powerbase
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Create page (Moser Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History batch))
 
(Ruppin's role, letters and Verschiebungstaktik, sourced to Bloom 2011 and Ruppin's published writings)
 
Line 10: Line 10:
 
| remarks      = Never numbered more than 200 members; attacked by most Zionist parties<ref name="EJBrit" />
 
| remarks      = Never numbered more than 200 members; attacked by most Zionist parties<ref name="EJBrit" />
 
}}
 
}}
−
'''Brit Shalom''' (also transliterated '''Berit Shalom'''; Hebrew for "Covenant of Peace") was a society founded in Jerusalem in 1925 "to foster relations of rapprochement between Jews and Arabs in Palestine, on the basis of a bi-national solution to the conflict between them, with Jews and Arabs having an equal share in the administration regardless of the size of their respective populations", according to the ''Encyclopaedia Judaica''.<ref name="EJBrit" /> It never numbered more than 200 members and had virtually ceased to exist by 1933.<ref name="EJBrit" />
+
{{Zionist movement sidebar}}
 +
'''Brit Shalom''' (also transliterated '''Berit Shalom'''; Hebrew for "Covenant of Peace") was a society founded in Jerusalem in 1925 "to foster relations of rapprochement between Jews and Arabs in Palestine, on the basis of a bi-national solution to the conflict between them, with Jews and Arabs having an equal share in the administration regardless of the size of their respective populations", according to the ''Encyclopaedia Judaica''.<ref name="EJBrit" /> It never numbered more than 200 members and had virtually ceased to exist by 1933.<ref name="EJBrit" /> Its initiator and first chairman was [[Arthur Ruppin]], head of the [[World Zionist Organization|Zionist Organization]]'s Palestine Office from 1908 and a central figure in Zionist land purchase and settlement, later called the "father of Zionist settlement".<ref name="EJBrit" /><ref name="EJRuppin">Alexander Bein, [https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/ruppin-arthur Ruppin, Arthur] ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' (via Encyclopedia.com), accessed 17 November 2026.</ref>
  
 
Benjamin Moser, in ''Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History'', places Brit Shalom within "cultural" or "spiritual center" Zionism, and says that "many members of Brit Shalom opposed the partition of Palestine and advocated for a binational or one-state solution".<ref name="Moser205">Benjamin Moser, ''Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History'' (New York: Doubleday, 2026), p. 205.</ref>
 
Benjamin Moser, in ''Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History'', places Brit Shalom within "cultural" or "spiritual center" Zionism, and says that "many members of Brit Shalom opposed the partition of Palestine and advocated for a binational or one-state solution".<ref name="Moser205">Benjamin Moser, ''Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History'' (New York: Doubleday, 2026), p. 205.</ref>
  
 
== History ==
 
== History ==
−
The immediate trigger for the society's founding, the ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' says, was a lecture at the opening of the Hebrew University by the Orientalist Joseph Horowitz of Frankfurt, and the initiative came from [[Arthur Ruppin]].<ref name="EJBrit" /> It identifies three groups among the active members: East European immigrants who arrived before the First World War, were academically trained and "shared a practical political approach to Zionism" (including Ruppin, Jacob Thon, Joseph Lurie, Yitzhak Epstein, Haim Margolis-Kalvaryski and Rabbi Binyamin); from about 1929, a more ideological group of Central European intellectuals strongly influenced by [[Martin Buber]] (Hugo Bergmann, Hans Kohn, Gershom Scholem, Ernst Simon and Robert Weltsch); and a group of so-called "Anglo-Saxons", mostly men employed by the Palestine Administration, including Edwin Samuel, son of the first High Commissioner [[Herbert Samuel]], and the attorney general [[Norman Bentwich]].<ref name="EJBrit" />
+
The immediate trigger for the society's founding, the ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' says, was a lecture at the opening of the [[Hebrew University of Jerusalem|Hebrew University]] by the Orientalist Joseph Horowitz of Frankfurt, and the initiative came from Arthur Ruppin.<ref name="EJBrit" /> It identifies three groups among the active members: East European immigrants who arrived before the First World War, were academically trained and "shared a practical political approach to Zionism" (including Ruppin, Jacob Thon, Joseph Lurie, Yitzhak Epstein, Haim Margolis-Kalvaryski and Rabbi Binyamin); from about 1929, a more ideological group of Central European intellectuals strongly influenced by [[Martin Buber]] (Hugo Bergmann, Hans Kohn, Gershom Scholem, Ernst Simon and Robert Weltsch); and a group of so-called "Anglo-Saxons", mostly men employed by the Palestine Administration, including Edwin Samuel, son of the first High Commissioner [[Herbert Samuel]], and the attorney general [[Norman Bentwich]].<ref name="EJBrit" />
  
 
The entry says that from the start members differed over purpose: Ruppin wanted a research group that would present its findings to the Zionist leadership, while others wanted a political programme of their own. Ruppin chaired the society until 1929, and the more activist line was carried out by his successor, Joseph Lurie.<ref name="EJBrit" /> In 1930 senior members published four memoranda, the first of which, ''Memorandum by the Brit Shalom Society on an Arab Policy for the Jewish Agency'', was submitted to the Zionist Executive in London in February; the last was a "Judeao-Arab Covenant" prepared by Kalvaryski and given to a member of the Arab Executive.<ref name="EJBrit" /> The monthly ''She'ifoteinu'' ("Our Aspirations") was its journal.<ref name="EJBrit" />
 
The entry says that from the start members differed over purpose: Ruppin wanted a research group that would present its findings to the Zionist leadership, while others wanted a political programme of their own. Ruppin chaired the society until 1929, and the more activist line was carried out by his successor, Joseph Lurie.<ref name="EJBrit" /> In 1930 senior members published four memoranda, the first of which, ''Memorandum by the Brit Shalom Society on an Arab Policy for the Jewish Agency'', was submitted to the Zionist Executive in London in February; the last was a "Judeao-Arab Covenant" prepared by Kalvaryski and given to a member of the Arab Executive.<ref name="EJBrit" /> The monthly ''She'ifoteinu'' ("Our Aspirations") was its journal.<ref name="EJBrit" />
  
 
The ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' says that the society "was attacked by most of the Zionist parties, who viewed its members as defeatists at best and traitors and worst", and that many members deserted it and it ran out of funds.<ref name="EJBrit" />
 
The ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' says that the society "was attacked by most of the Zionist parties, who viewed its members as defeatists at best and traitors and worst", and that many members deserted it and it ran out of funds.<ref name="EJBrit" />
 +
 +
=== Ruppin's purpose and later position ===
 +
On 31 December 1924 Ruppin wrote in his diary:
 +
 +
<blockquote>What continually worries me is the relationship between the Jews and the Arabs in Palestine. Superficially, it has improved, inasmuch as there is no danger of pogroms, but the two peoples have become more estranged in their thinking. Neither has any understanding of the other, and yet I have no doubt whatsoever that Zionism will end in a catastrophe if we do not succeed in finding a common platform. Next year, I want to see if it is possible to bring together a small circle of eminent Jews and Arabs who are willing to work towards such an understanding.</blockquote>
 +
 +
<ref name="Memoirs1971p215">Arthur Ruppin, ''Memoirs, Diaries, Letters'', ed. Alex Bein, trans. Karen Gershon, New York: Herzl Press / London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1971, pp. 215–216, entry for 31 December 1924. Etan Bloom, ''Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture'', Leiden: Brill, 2011, pp. 313–314, quoting the same entry from Alex Bein (ed.), ''Pirkei Hayyai'' (Tel Aviv, 1968), vol. 3, p. 92, renders the key sentences as "The alienation is greater than it was" and "I don't have any doubt that Zionism will have to face a catastrophe if it cannot find a common platform [with the Arabs]."</ref> Bloom writes that the core members met for the first time in April 1925, after Ruppin's official retirement from the Zionist Executive, and that Ruppin was chosen to write the association's regulations.<ref name="Bloom2011p315">Bloom, ''Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture'', p. 315, citing Bein (ed.), ''Pirkei Hayyai'', vol. 3, p. 97 (10 June 1925).</ref> At the Fourteenth Zionist Congress in 1925, according to Bloom, he said that part of the population of the country would always be Arab and that "we must live with them in conditions of coexistence". He called for a committee on the Arab problem and said that "the announcement of the establishment of such a committee must have a propagandist character, and not only for us".<ref name="Bloom2011p314">Bloom, ''Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture'', p. 314, quoting the protocol of the Fourteenth Zionist Congress, pp. 438–439, as cited in Elchanan Friedlander. The 1971 English memoirs do not include this speech.</ref> Bloom, citing Hagit Lavsky's conclusion that Brit Shalom "assisted Zionist historiography in its desire to promote an image of the Zionist movement as seeking peace", argues that Ruppin's part in founding the society "was meant, or at least served, to promote an image of the Zionist movement as humanistic".<ref name="Bloom2011p314" />
 +
 +
In a letter to Hans Kohn of 30 May 1928, as printed in the 1971 English selection, Ruppin rejected the demand that Brit Shalom support a constitution and take a public political stand. He wrote:
 +
 +
<blockquote>In founding the Brit Shalom, I was guided by the consideration that there is no parallel in history to the aim of Zionism — to settle the Jews peaceably in a country which is already inhabited. Such an entry by one nation into the country of another is known in history only by means of conquest; so far, no nation has ever been willing to tolerate another nation settling beside it and claiming complete equality and national autonomy. In my opinion, the uniqueness of this case made it impossible to tackle the problem according to the usual constitutional ideas. It demanded a very special approach. The Brit Shalom was to become the forum to consider and discuss the problem.</blockquote>
 +
 +
A constitution that really gave the Arab majority a say would, he wrote, be used "to prevent any economic progress of the Jewish minority. That would quite simply mean the end of the Zionist movement." He had "doubts whether one can immediately apply to Palestine the principles of democracy", and he wondered "whether it would not be breaking faith with the yishuv to address a statement above its head directly to the Arabs."<ref name="Memoirs1971p237">Ruppin, ''Memoirs, Diaries, Letters'', pp. 237–238, letter to Hans Kohn, 30 May 1928.</ref> Bloom's translation of the same letter from Bein's Hebrew edition includes passages omitted from the 1971 selection. In Bloom's wording, the society must be a "club for studying and research and not for quarrels"; "Land is the essential condition for putting down economic roots in Palestine" and "wherever we purchase land and settle people on it – its current workers [the Arabs] must of necessity be removed, whether they be owners or tenants"; and it was not appropriate "to take such a declaration to the Arabs and to bypass organized Zionism."<ref name="Bloom2011p317">Bloom, ''Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture'', pp. 316–317, quoting Ruppin to Hans Kohn, 30 May 1928, in Bein (ed.), ''Pirkei Hayyai'', vol. 3, pp. 149–150.</ref>
 +
 +
Bloom, citing a letter from Ruppin to Kohn of 24 November 1928 in Bein's Hebrew edition, says that Ruppin resigned as head of Brit Shalom before the 1929 riots, writing that "This is not the time for peace preaching […] the appeasing tone […] might be interpreted by the Arabs as weakness."<ref name="Bloom2011p318">Bloom, ''Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture'', p. 318, quoting Ruppin to Hans Kohn, 24 November 1928, in Bein (ed.), ''Pirkei Hayyai'', vol. 3, p. 179.</ref> The 1971 English diaries do not include a letter of that date. They do include an entry of 24 November 1929, after the August 1929 riots, in which Ruppin wrote that "The Brit Shalom has become the scapegoat on which the Jews vent their displeasure at the present circumstances", that "our conciliatory tone is interpreted by the Arabs as weakness", and that he had "resigned as chairman four weeks ago in favour of Dr Lurie."<ref name="Memoirs1971p248">Ruppin, ''Memoirs, Diaries, Letters'', pp. 248–249, entry for 24 November 1929.</ref> The ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' says he was chairman until 1929, when Joseph Lurie succeeded him.<ref name="EJBrit" /> Bloom says he remained a member and continued to take part in meetings.<ref name="Bloom2011p318" /> Bloom, citing Bein's Hebrew edition, also quotes an entry of 31 December 1929: "the propaganda of Brit Shalom might do more harm than good."<ref name="Bloom2011p318b">Bloom, ''Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture'', p. 318, quoting Bein (ed.), ''Pirkei Hayyai'', vol. 3, p. 181, entry for 31 December 1929. The 31 December 1929 entry printed in the 1971 English selection does not include this sentence; it records Ruppin's evidence to the Shaw Commission (Ruppin, ''Memoirs, Diaries, Letters'', p. 249).</ref> On 3 December 1931, in a letter to Victor Jacobson, he wrote: "The situation is paradoxical: what we can get (from the Arabs) is of no use to us, and what we need we cannot get from them."<ref name="Memoirs1971p258">Ruppin, ''Memoirs, Diaries, Letters'', p. 258, letter to Victor Jacobson, 3 December 1931. In his letter to Robert Weltsch of 18 March 1936 he later quoted the sentence and dated the Jacobson letter to 31 December 1931 (ibid., p. 276). Bloom, ''Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture'', p. 318, quoting Bein (ed.), ''Pirkei Hayyai'', vol. 3, p. 203, gives the wording as "What we can get from the Arabs we don't need, and what we need we can't get," and dates it December 1931.</ref>
 +
 +
=== The 1936 letter on ''Verschiebungstaktik'' ===
 +
On 18 March 1936, after Brit Shalom had virtually ceased to exist, Ruppin wrote to Robert Weltsch, the former editor of the ''Jüdische Rundschau'' and a member of the society's Central European circle. Bloom calls this a "farewell letter" to "the intellectuals from Mount Scopus". In the 1971 English text Ruppin wrote that he had been "obliged to withdraw" from the society after members publicised suggestions for an understanding with the Arabs which, in his view, the Jewish public was not prepared to accept. He also wrote:
 +
 +
<blockquote>It is my opinion that no sort of negotiations with the Arabs can get us anywhere at the moment, because the Arabs are still hoping to deal with us above our heads. Not negotiations, but the development of Palestine towards a larger percentage of Jews in the population and a strengthening of our economic position can and will bring about an easing of the tension. When coming to an understanding with us will no longer mean that the Arabs will have to make concessions to us, but only be a question of coming to terms with reality, the weight of the facts will bring about an easing of the tension.</blockquote>
 +
 +
<ref name="Memoirs1971p276">Ruppin, ''Memoirs, Diaries, Letters'', pp. 276–277, letter to Robert Weltsch, 18 March 1936.</ref> Bloom's translation of the same letter from the Hebrew edition includes passages omitted from the 1971 selection. In it Ruppin used the German term ''Verschiebungstaktik'' (a tactic of postponement, or of displacement, or both) for the Zionist Executive's handling of the proposed Legislative Council:
 +
 +
<blockquote>It is right that a government [will] develop step by step […] but since no specific time has been defined for the establishment of these self-governing bodies, we absolutely have the right to demand a postponement [''Verschiebung''] of their establishment to a later moment. That was the tactic that the Zionist executive pursued for five years, i.e., since the question of the Legislative Council was raised anew. I see one proof of the rightness of that decision in the fact that, if the Legislative Council had been set up in 1931, it would have been based on a Jewish population of 17 per cent, whereas today it is based on 28 per cent.</blockquote>
 +
 +
He wrote that the Zionist movement's existence depended on increasing "our numbers and strength here, over the next five or ten years, until we will be, more or less, on an even keel with the Arabs", and he accepted that postponement could lead to "bloody unrest or even into a general upheaval."<ref name="Bloom2011p322">Bloom, ''Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture'', pp. 322–323, quoting Ruppin to Robert Weltsch, 18 March 1936, in Bein (ed.), ''Pirkei Hayyai'', vol. 3, pp. 255–258. Bloom gives the English of the Legislative Council passage as his translation of the German.</ref> Bloom's commentary is that the tactic "enabled the Zionist movement to seem to accept democratic principles, to present itself as willing to achieve agreement through compromise, and, simultaneously, to postpone all practical steps towards achieving such an end" until Jews in Palestine were a majority.<ref name="Bloom2011p323">Bloom, ''Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture'', p. 323.</ref>
 +
 +
On 25 April 1936, after violence in Jaffa, Ruppin wrote in his diary that "we are living in a sort of latent state of war with the Arabs which makes loss of life inevitable" and that "if we want to continue our work in Palestine in spite of the Arabs, we will have to expect such losses."<ref name="Memoirs1971p277">Ruppin, ''Memoirs, Diaries, Letters'', p. 277, entry for 25 April 1936. The entry says the Jaffa disturbances "claimed sixteen Jews and three Arabs as victims." Bloom, p. 323, quoting a closely related formulation from Bein's Hebrew edition, reverses those figures and renders the conclusion as "we are destined to live in a state of constant warfare with the Arabs, and there is no escape from blood sacrifices."</ref>
 +
 +
The ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' entry on Ruppin, written by Alexander Bein, puts the same change of view in shorter form: after the "Arab riots and uprisings in 1929, 1936, and thereafter", Ruppin "came to the conclusion that the time was not yet ripe for fruitful Arab-Jewish negotiations", and "believed it necessary to strengthen the Jewish position in the country economically and politically".<ref name="EJRuppin" />
  
 
=== Judah Magnes ===
 
=== Judah Magnes ===
−
Moser lists [[Judah Magnes]], with Martin Buber and [[Henrietta Szold]], among Brit Shalom's "most prominent spokespeople".<ref name="Moser205" /> The ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' says Magnes, who also advocated bi-nationalism, "was never a member of the society, even though his name was frequently identified with it".<ref name="EJBrit" />
+
Moser lists [[Judah Magnes]], with Martin Buber and [[Henrietta Szold]], among Brit Shalom's "most prominent spokespeople".<ref name="Moser205" /> The ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' says Magnes, who also advocated bi-nationalism, "was never a member of the society, even though his name was frequently identified with it".<ref name="EJBrit" /> Bloom likewise notes that Magnes "was not a member but had important influence on some of its members".<ref name="Bloom2011p315" />
  
 
== Anti-Zionism? ==
 
== Anti-Zionism? ==
−
'''The Zionist state.''' According to the ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'', "bi-nationalism for Berit Shalom was not an ideal but a function of reality", and the first of its 1930 memoranda was addressed to the Zionist Executive as a proposal for an "Arab policy" for the Jewish Agency.<ref name="EJBrit" /> Moser says many of its members opposed the partition of Palestine into separate Jewish and Arab states.<ref name="Moser205" />
+
'''The Zionist state.''' According to the ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'', "bi-nationalism for Berit Shalom was not an ideal but a function of reality", and the first of its 1930 memoranda was addressed to the Zionist Executive as a proposal for an "Arab policy" for the Jewish Agency.<ref name="EJBrit" /> Moser says many of its members opposed the partition of Palestine into separate Jewish and Arab states.<ref name="Moser205" /> Ruppin's 1928 letter to Kohn described the society's purpose as study of how "to settle the Jews peaceably in a country which is already inhabited", and he wondered whether it would be "breaking faith with the yishuv to address a statement above its head directly to the Arabs".<ref name="Memoirs1971p237" /> After 1929 he treated an agreement with the Arabs as something to postpone until Jewish numbers and economic power had grown.<ref name="Memoirs1971p276" /><ref name="EJRuppin" />
  
 
'''A replacement state.''' It proposed a binational arrangement in Palestine, with Jews and Arabs having an equal share in the administration irrespective of population size.<ref name="EJBrit" /> Moser describes the hope of its members as an "independent, democratic Palestine" in which "a new kind of Jewish culture could develop, including the Hebrew language".<ref name="Moser205" /> Rabbi Binyamin, the first editor of its monthly, who demanded an agreement with the Arabs on the basis of unlimited Jewish immigration, was replaced when a majority of members declared themselves ready to accept a temporary limitation of immigration to facilitate an agreement.<ref name="EJBrit" />
 
'''A replacement state.''' It proposed a binational arrangement in Palestine, with Jews and Arabs having an equal share in the administration irrespective of population size.<ref name="EJBrit" /> Moser describes the hope of its members as an "independent, democratic Palestine" in which "a new kind of Jewish culture could develop, including the Hebrew language".<ref name="Moser205" /> Rabbi Binyamin, the first editor of its monthly, who demanded an agreement with the Arabs on the basis of unlimited Jewish immigration, was replaced when a majority of members declared themselves ready to accept a temporary limitation of immigration to facilitate an agreement.<ref name="EJBrit" />
  
−
'''The Zionist movement.''' Neither source reports a call to dissolve the Zionist movement. The ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' says that Ruppin wanted the society to be a research group that would present its results to the Zionist leadership.<ref name="EJBrit" />
+
'''The Zionist movement.''' Neither Moser nor the ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' reports a call to dissolve the Zionist movement. The ''Encyclopaedia Judaica'' says that Ruppin wanted the society to be a research group that would present its results to the Zionist leadership.<ref name="EJBrit" /> His 1928 letter, in Bloom's translation from the Hebrew edition, said it would not be appropriate "to take such a declaration to the Arabs and to bypass organized Zionism"; the 1971 English selection of the same letter puts the same objection as "breaking faith with the yishuv".<ref name="Bloom2011p317" /><ref name="Memoirs1971p237" />
 +
 
 +
Ruppin's own racial writings and his later record as a Zionist official, including a 1934 statement to the Zionist Executive opposing an increase in the number of Ethiopian Jews in Palestine, are set out on the page [[Arthur Ruppin]].
  
 
== See also ==
 
== See also ==
 +
* [[Arthur Ruppin]]
 
* [[Zionism]]
 
* [[Zionism]]
 
* [[Hannah Arendt]]
 
* [[Hannah Arendt]]
Line 41: Line 75:
  
 
[[Category:Defunct Jewish organisations]]
 
[[Category:Defunct Jewish organisations]]
 +
[[Category:Zionist movement]]

Latest revision as of 09:31, 17 November 2026

Society founded in Jerusalem in 1925 to promote Jewish–Arab rapprochement through a binational state in Palestine; inactive by 1933

Brit Shalom

Type Society promoting Jewish–Arab rapprochement
Founded 1925
Founder(s) Arthur Ruppin (initiator)[1]
Status Virtually ceased to exist by 1933[1]
Location Jerusalem, Mandatory Palestine
Key people Arthur Ruppin (chairman to 1929); Joseph Lurie (chairman from 1929); Hugo Bergmann; Hans Kohn; Gershom Scholem; Ernst Simon; Robert Weltsch
Remarks Never numbered more than 200 members; attacked by most Zionist parties[1]
Zionist movement
Overview

Zionism | Zionist Movement | Jerusalem Program | World Zionist Congress | The Duties of the Individual Zionist | Lobbying for Zionism on Both Sides of the Atlantic | Balfour Declaration
Precursors: Die Einheit | Hovevei Zion

Leading figures

Theodor Herzl | David Wolffsohn | Arthur Ruppin | Chaim Weizmann | David Ben-Gurion

National institutions

World Zionist Organization | Jewish National Fund / KKL | Jewish Agency for Israel | Keren Hayesod / UIA
National offices: World Zionist Organization UK | L’Organisation Sioniste Mondiale en France | Jewish Agency for Israel UK and Europe | United Israel Appeal | Jewish Federations of North America
Historical: Jewish Colonial Trust | Anglo-Palestine Bank | Bank Leumi

Zionist federations (43)
National JNF bodies (42)
National Keren Hayesod bodies (35)
World unions and factions

Mizrachi | World Mizrachi | Arzenu | Mercaz Olami | World Confederation of United Zionists | Eretz Hakodesh | World Sephardi Federation | Ameinu | Likud | World Likud
UK: Mizrachi of Great Britain and Ireland | Arzenu UK | Mercaz UK | Likud-Herut UK | Herut UK
Historical: Brit Shalom

Affiliated world organisations

Hadassah | Hadassah International | WIZO | WIZO UK | Emunah | Maccabi World Union | B'nai B'rith International | World Union of Jewish Students

Youth movements

Hashomer Hatzair | Habonim Dror | Bnei Akiva | Betar | BBYO | Young Judaea | LJY-Netzer | Zionist Youth Council (UK) | Taglit Birthright | Federation of Zionist Youth
Historical: Youth Aliyah

Labour Zionism and the kibbutz

Kibbutz Artzi | Histadrut | Mapai | Poale Zion | Jewish Labour Movement

Settlement and land

Nachala | Ateret Cohanim | Daniella Weiss | Greater Israel | Nefesh B'Nefesh
Historical: Jewish Colonization Association | Palestine Jewish Colonization Association | Mikveh Israel | Edmond James de Rothschild | James de Rothschild

Military history

Zion Mule Corps | Jewish Legion | Jewish Brigade

Christian Zionism

Christians United for Israel | International Christian Embassy Jerusalem | Christian Friends of Israel - UK | Christians for Israel International | Christians for Zion | ProZion | Israel Allies Foundation

Israel lobby

Israel Lobby Portal | AIPAC | Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations | BICOM | Board of Deputies of British Jews | Conservative Friends of Israel | Labour Friends of Israel | European Friends of Israel | ELNET | Friends of Israel Initiative | StandWithUs | European Jewish Congress

Data and sources

British Zionist charities | 'Zionist' non profits in the US | US Big Israel data | US lobbying and election spending data | US FARA data | Zionist family foundations in the UK - a ranking | The Zionist Year Book | Zionist Review | Herzl Zionist Institute

Europe (45)
North America and the Caribbean (12)
West Asia (17)
North Africa (6)
Sub-Saharan Africa (48)
Latin America and the Caribbean (23)
South Asia (8)
Central Asia (5)
East Asia (6)
Southeast Asia (11)
Oceania and the Pacific (14)

Brit Shalom (also transliterated Berit Shalom; Hebrew for "Covenant of Peace") was a society founded in Jerusalem in 1925 "to foster relations of rapprochement between Jews and Arabs in Palestine, on the basis of a bi-national solution to the conflict between them, with Jews and Arabs having an equal share in the administration regardless of the size of their respective populations", according to the Encyclopaedia Judaica.[1] It never numbered more than 200 members and had virtually ceased to exist by 1933.[1] Its initiator and first chairman was Arthur Ruppin, head of the Zionist Organization's Palestine Office from 1908 and a central figure in Zionist land purchase and settlement, later called the "father of Zionist settlement".[1][2]

Benjamin Moser, in Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History, places Brit Shalom within "cultural" or "spiritual center" Zionism, and says that "many members of Brit Shalom opposed the partition of Palestine and advocated for a binational or one-state solution".[3]

History

The immediate trigger for the society's founding, the Encyclopaedia Judaica says, was a lecture at the opening of the Hebrew University by the Orientalist Joseph Horowitz of Frankfurt, and the initiative came from Arthur Ruppin.[1] It identifies three groups among the active members: East European immigrants who arrived before the First World War, were academically trained and "shared a practical political approach to Zionism" (including Ruppin, Jacob Thon, Joseph Lurie, Yitzhak Epstein, Haim Margolis-Kalvaryski and Rabbi Binyamin); from about 1929, a more ideological group of Central European intellectuals strongly influenced by Martin Buber (Hugo Bergmann, Hans Kohn, Gershom Scholem, Ernst Simon and Robert Weltsch); and a group of so-called "Anglo-Saxons", mostly men employed by the Palestine Administration, including Edwin Samuel, son of the first High Commissioner Herbert Samuel, and the attorney general Norman Bentwich.[1]

The entry says that from the start members differed over purpose: Ruppin wanted a research group that would present its findings to the Zionist leadership, while others wanted a political programme of their own. Ruppin chaired the society until 1929, and the more activist line was carried out by his successor, Joseph Lurie.[1] In 1930 senior members published four memoranda, the first of which, Memorandum by the Brit Shalom Society on an Arab Policy for the Jewish Agency, was submitted to the Zionist Executive in London in February; the last was a "Judeao-Arab Covenant" prepared by Kalvaryski and given to a member of the Arab Executive.[1] The monthly She'ifoteinu ("Our Aspirations") was its journal.[1]

The Encyclopaedia Judaica says that the society "was attacked by most of the Zionist parties, who viewed its members as defeatists at best and traitors and worst", and that many members deserted it and it ran out of funds.[1]

Ruppin's purpose and later position

On 31 December 1924 Ruppin wrote in his diary:

What continually worries me is the relationship between the Jews and the Arabs in Palestine. Superficially, it has improved, inasmuch as there is no danger of pogroms, but the two peoples have become more estranged in their thinking. Neither has any understanding of the other, and yet I have no doubt whatsoever that Zionism will end in a catastrophe if we do not succeed in finding a common platform. Next year, I want to see if it is possible to bring together a small circle of eminent Jews and Arabs who are willing to work towards such an understanding.

[4] Bloom writes that the core members met for the first time in April 1925, after Ruppin's official retirement from the Zionist Executive, and that Ruppin was chosen to write the association's regulations.[5] At the Fourteenth Zionist Congress in 1925, according to Bloom, he said that part of the population of the country would always be Arab and that "we must live with them in conditions of coexistence". He called for a committee on the Arab problem and said that "the announcement of the establishment of such a committee must have a propagandist character, and not only for us".[6] Bloom, citing Hagit Lavsky's conclusion that Brit Shalom "assisted Zionist historiography in its desire to promote an image of the Zionist movement as seeking peace", argues that Ruppin's part in founding the society "was meant, or at least served, to promote an image of the Zionist movement as humanistic".[6]

In a letter to Hans Kohn of 30 May 1928, as printed in the 1971 English selection, Ruppin rejected the demand that Brit Shalom support a constitution and take a public political stand. He wrote:

In founding the Brit Shalom, I was guided by the consideration that there is no parallel in history to the aim of Zionism — to settle the Jews peaceably in a country which is already inhabited. Such an entry by one nation into the country of another is known in history only by means of conquest; so far, no nation has ever been willing to tolerate another nation settling beside it and claiming complete equality and national autonomy. In my opinion, the uniqueness of this case made it impossible to tackle the problem according to the usual constitutional ideas. It demanded a very special approach. The Brit Shalom was to become the forum to consider and discuss the problem.

A constitution that really gave the Arab majority a say would, he wrote, be used "to prevent any economic progress of the Jewish minority. That would quite simply mean the end of the Zionist movement." He had "doubts whether one can immediately apply to Palestine the principles of democracy", and he wondered "whether it would not be breaking faith with the yishuv to address a statement above its head directly to the Arabs."[7] Bloom's translation of the same letter from Bein's Hebrew edition includes passages omitted from the 1971 selection. In Bloom's wording, the society must be a "club for studying and research and not for quarrels"; "Land is the essential condition for putting down economic roots in Palestine" and "wherever we purchase land and settle people on it – its current workers [the Arabs] must of necessity be removed, whether they be owners or tenants"; and it was not appropriate "to take such a declaration to the Arabs and to bypass organized Zionism."[8]

Bloom, citing a letter from Ruppin to Kohn of 24 November 1928 in Bein's Hebrew edition, says that Ruppin resigned as head of Brit Shalom before the 1929 riots, writing that "This is not the time for peace preaching […] the appeasing tone […] might be interpreted by the Arabs as weakness."[9] The 1971 English diaries do not include a letter of that date. They do include an entry of 24 November 1929, after the August 1929 riots, in which Ruppin wrote that "The Brit Shalom has become the scapegoat on which the Jews vent their displeasure at the present circumstances", that "our conciliatory tone is interpreted by the Arabs as weakness", and that he had "resigned as chairman four weeks ago in favour of Dr Lurie."[10] The Encyclopaedia Judaica says he was chairman until 1929, when Joseph Lurie succeeded him.[1] Bloom says he remained a member and continued to take part in meetings.[9] Bloom, citing Bein's Hebrew edition, also quotes an entry of 31 December 1929: "the propaganda of Brit Shalom might do more harm than good."[11] On 3 December 1931, in a letter to Victor Jacobson, he wrote: "The situation is paradoxical: what we can get (from the Arabs) is of no use to us, and what we need we cannot get from them."[12]

The 1936 letter on Verschiebungstaktik

On 18 March 1936, after Brit Shalom had virtually ceased to exist, Ruppin wrote to Robert Weltsch, the former editor of the Jüdische Rundschau and a member of the society's Central European circle. Bloom calls this a "farewell letter" to "the intellectuals from Mount Scopus". In the 1971 English text Ruppin wrote that he had been "obliged to withdraw" from the society after members publicised suggestions for an understanding with the Arabs which, in his view, the Jewish public was not prepared to accept. He also wrote:

It is my opinion that no sort of negotiations with the Arabs can get us anywhere at the moment, because the Arabs are still hoping to deal with us above our heads. Not negotiations, but the development of Palestine towards a larger percentage of Jews in the population and a strengthening of our economic position can and will bring about an easing of the tension. When coming to an understanding with us will no longer mean that the Arabs will have to make concessions to us, but only be a question of coming to terms with reality, the weight of the facts will bring about an easing of the tension.

[13] Bloom's translation of the same letter from the Hebrew edition includes passages omitted from the 1971 selection. In it Ruppin used the German term Verschiebungstaktik (a tactic of postponement, or of displacement, or both) for the Zionist Executive's handling of the proposed Legislative Council:

It is right that a government [will] develop step by step […] but since no specific time has been defined for the establishment of these self-governing bodies, we absolutely have the right to demand a postponement [Verschiebung] of their establishment to a later moment. That was the tactic that the Zionist executive pursued for five years, i.e., since the question of the Legislative Council was raised anew. I see one proof of the rightness of that decision in the fact that, if the Legislative Council had been set up in 1931, it would have been based on a Jewish population of 17 per cent, whereas today it is based on 28 per cent.

He wrote that the Zionist movement's existence depended on increasing "our numbers and strength here, over the next five or ten years, until we will be, more or less, on an even keel with the Arabs", and he accepted that postponement could lead to "bloody unrest or even into a general upheaval."[14] Bloom's commentary is that the tactic "enabled the Zionist movement to seem to accept democratic principles, to present itself as willing to achieve agreement through compromise, and, simultaneously, to postpone all practical steps towards achieving such an end" until Jews in Palestine were a majority.[15]

On 25 April 1936, after violence in Jaffa, Ruppin wrote in his diary that "we are living in a sort of latent state of war with the Arabs which makes loss of life inevitable" and that "if we want to continue our work in Palestine in spite of the Arabs, we will have to expect such losses."[16]

The Encyclopaedia Judaica entry on Ruppin, written by Alexander Bein, puts the same change of view in shorter form: after the "Arab riots and uprisings in 1929, 1936, and thereafter", Ruppin "came to the conclusion that the time was not yet ripe for fruitful Arab-Jewish negotiations", and "believed it necessary to strengthen the Jewish position in the country economically and politically".[2]

Judah Magnes

Moser lists Judah Magnes, with Martin Buber and Henrietta Szold, among Brit Shalom's "most prominent spokespeople".[3] The Encyclopaedia Judaica says Magnes, who also advocated bi-nationalism, "was never a member of the society, even though his name was frequently identified with it".[1] Bloom likewise notes that Magnes "was not a member but had important influence on some of its members".[5]

Anti-Zionism?

The Zionist state. According to the Encyclopaedia Judaica, "bi-nationalism for Berit Shalom was not an ideal but a function of reality", and the first of its 1930 memoranda was addressed to the Zionist Executive as a proposal for an "Arab policy" for the Jewish Agency.[1] Moser says many of its members opposed the partition of Palestine into separate Jewish and Arab states.[3] Ruppin's 1928 letter to Kohn described the society's purpose as study of how "to settle the Jews peaceably in a country which is already inhabited", and he wondered whether it would be "breaking faith with the yishuv to address a statement above its head directly to the Arabs".[7] After 1929 he treated an agreement with the Arabs as something to postpone until Jewish numbers and economic power had grown.[13][2]

A replacement state. It proposed a binational arrangement in Palestine, with Jews and Arabs having an equal share in the administration irrespective of population size.[1] Moser describes the hope of its members as an "independent, democratic Palestine" in which "a new kind of Jewish culture could develop, including the Hebrew language".[3] Rabbi Binyamin, the first editor of its monthly, who demanded an agreement with the Arabs on the basis of unlimited Jewish immigration, was replaced when a majority of members declared themselves ready to accept a temporary limitation of immigration to facilitate an agreement.[1]

The Zionist movement. Neither Moser nor the Encyclopaedia Judaica reports a call to dissolve the Zionist movement. The Encyclopaedia Judaica says that Ruppin wanted the society to be a research group that would present its results to the Zionist leadership.[1] His 1928 letter, in Bloom's translation from the Hebrew edition, said it would not be appropriate "to take such a declaration to the Arabs and to bypass organized Zionism"; the 1971 English selection of the same letter puts the same objection as "breaking faith with the yishuv".[8][7]

Ruppin's own racial writings and his later record as a Zionist official, including a 1934 statement to the Zionist Executive opposing an increase in the number of Ethiopian Jews in Palestine, are set out on the page Arthur Ruppin.

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 1.16 1.17 Susan Hattis Rolef, Berit Shalom Encyclopaedia Judaica (via Encyclopedia.com), accessed 13 November 2026.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 Alexander Bein, Ruppin, Arthur Encyclopaedia Judaica (via Encyclopedia.com), accessed 17 November 2026.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 Benjamin Moser, Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History (New York: Doubleday, 2026), p. 205.
  4. ↑ Arthur Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, ed. Alex Bein, trans. Karen Gershon, New York: Herzl Press / London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1971, pp. 215–216, entry for 31 December 1924. Etan Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, Leiden: Brill, 2011, pp. 313–314, quoting the same entry from Alex Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai (Tel Aviv, 1968), vol. 3, p. 92, renders the key sentences as "The alienation is greater than it was" and "I don't have any doubt that Zionism will have to face a catastrophe if it cannot find a common platform [with the Arabs]."
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 315, citing Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai, vol. 3, p. 97 (10 June 1925).
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 314, quoting the protocol of the Fourteenth Zionist Congress, pp. 438–439, as cited in Elchanan Friedlander. The 1971 English memoirs do not include this speech.
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, pp. 237–238, letter to Hans Kohn, 30 May 1928.
  8. ↑ 8.0 8.1 Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, pp. 316–317, quoting Ruppin to Hans Kohn, 30 May 1928, in Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai, vol. 3, pp. 149–150.
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 318, quoting Ruppin to Hans Kohn, 24 November 1928, in Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai, vol. 3, p. 179.
  10. ↑ Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, pp. 248–249, entry for 24 November 1929.
  11. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 318, quoting Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai, vol. 3, p. 181, entry for 31 December 1929. The 31 December 1929 entry printed in the 1971 English selection does not include this sentence; it records Ruppin's evidence to the Shaw Commission (Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, p. 249).
  12. ↑ Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, p. 258, letter to Victor Jacobson, 3 December 1931. In his letter to Robert Weltsch of 18 March 1936 he later quoted the sentence and dated the Jacobson letter to 31 December 1931 (ibid., p. 276). Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 318, quoting Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai, vol. 3, p. 203, gives the wording as "What we can get from the Arabs we don't need, and what we need we can't get," and dates it December 1931.
  13. ↑ 13.0 13.1 Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, pp. 276–277, letter to Robert Weltsch, 18 March 1936.
  14. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, pp. 322–323, quoting Ruppin to Robert Weltsch, 18 March 1936, in Bein (ed.), Pirkei Hayyai, vol. 3, pp. 255–258. Bloom gives the English of the Legislative Council passage as his translation of the German.
  15. ↑ Bloom, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture, p. 323.
  16. ↑ Ruppin, Memoirs, Diaries, Letters, p. 277, entry for 25 April 1936. The entry says the Jaffa disturbances "claimed sixteen Jews and three Arabs as victims." Bloom, p. 323, quoting a closely related formulation from Bein's Hebrew edition, reverses those figures and renders the conclusion as "we are destined to live in a state of constant warfare with the Arabs, and there is no escape from blood sacrifices."