Difference between revisions of "Terrorexpertise:Major World Newspapers - Affiliations Analysis"

From Powerbase
Jump to: navigation, search
(Analysis: stats updated)
(Undo revision 94548 by Tom Mills (Talk))
 
(5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 84: Line 84:
 
<td>6</td>
 
<td>6</td>
 
<td>[[Daniel Pipes]]</td>
 
<td>[[Daniel Pipes]]</td>
<td align="center">&times;</td>
+
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
Line 479: Line 479:
 
<td>42</td>
 
<td>42</td>
 
<td>[[Boaz Ganor]]</td>
 
<td>[[Boaz Ganor]]</td>
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
+
<td align="center">&times;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
Line 765: Line 765:
 
<td>68</td>
 
<td>68</td>
 
<td>[[Jonathan Stevenson]]</td>
 
<td>[[Jonathan Stevenson]]</td>
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
+
<td align="center">&times;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
Line 831: Line 831:
 
<td>74</td>
 
<td>74</td>
 
<td>[[Daniel Byman]]</td>
 
<td>[[Daniel Byman]]</td>
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
+
<td align="center">&times;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
 
<td align="center">&nbsp;</td>
 
<td align="center">&times;</td>
 
<td align="center">&times;</td>
Line 1,129: Line 1,129:
 
A significant number of the experts (42 out of 100) are currently or have previously been a member of state institutions such as government, security or intelligence services, policing or the military.
 
A significant number of the experts (42 out of 100) are currently or have previously been a member of state institutions such as government, security or intelligence services, policing or the military.
  
The majority of the experts (67 of the 100) are currently or have previously been members of private think-tanks or research institutes. Of the remaining experts (16 out of 33) are currently or have previously worked in private security or intelligence firms, or alternatively state institutions such as government, security or intelligence, policing or military service.
+
The majority of the experts (67 of the 100) are currently or have previously been members of private think-tanks or research institutes. Of the remaining experts 16 out of 33 are currently or have previously worked in private security or intelligence firms, or alternatively state institutions such as government, security or intelligence, policing or military service.
  
 
Of the remaining 17 ‘independent’ experts, four are British journalists <ref>namely Simon Reeve, Jason Burke, Kevin Toolis and Neil Doyle</ref> and 13 are current or former academics with no such affiliation.<ref>The 13 ‘independent’ academics are listed below:
 
Of the remaining 17 ‘independent’ experts, four are British journalists <ref>namely Simon Reeve, Jason Burke, Kevin Toolis and Neil Doyle</ref> and 13 are current or former academics with no such affiliation.<ref>The 13 ‘independent’ academics are listed below:
Line 1,147: Line 1,147:
 
</ref> The 13 academics include the prominent critic of Western foreign policy [[Noam Chomsky]], as well as supporters of state and corporate power such as [[Francis Fukuyama]] and [[Alan Dershowitz]].
 
</ref> The 13 academics include the prominent critic of Western foreign policy [[Noam Chomsky]], as well as supporters of state and corporate power such as [[Francis Fukuyama]] and [[Alan Dershowitz]].
  
Half of the experts are currently or have previously held tenure at an institution of higher education. Of those 50, 35 are known to be members of Private Think-Tanks or Research Institutes.
+
53 of the experts are currently or have previously held tenure at an institution of higher education. Of those 53, 35 are known to be members of Private Think-Tanks or Research Institutes.
  
 
16 experts are current or former journalists. Of those 16, three have been employed in private security or intelligence firms, seven have worked for a government, intelligence or law enforcement agency, and seven are known to be members of Private Think-Tanks or Research Institutes. The four journalists with no such affiliations are [[Jason Burke]], [[Simon Reeve]], [[Kevin Toolis]] and [[Neil Doyle]].
 
16 experts are current or former journalists. Of those 16, three have been employed in private security or intelligence firms, seven have worked for a government, intelligence or law enforcement agency, and seven are known to be members of Private Think-Tanks or Research Institutes. The four journalists with no such affiliations are [[Jason Burke]], [[Simon Reeve]], [[Kevin Toolis]] and [[Neil Doyle]].

Latest revision as of 07:33, 26 August 2009

Below is a table detailing the known affiliations of the 100 experts from the Major World Newspapers List. The table is followed by analysis of this data.

Past and Present Affiliations of Experts from the Major World Newspapers List

Terror Experts
Column A: Tenure at academic institution
Column B: Employee of Private Security/Intelligence firm
Column C: Member of government or law enforcement agency
Column D: Member of military or intelligence services
Column E: Member of private think-tanks or research institute
Column F: Media employee or independent journalist (not including contract work)
No. Name of Expert A B C D E F
1 Rohan Gunaratna ×   ×   ×  
2Noam Chomsky ×          
3 Sidney Jones         ×  
4 Clive Williams ×     × ×  
5 Francis Fukuyama ×          
6 Daniel Pipes         ×  
7 Paul Wilkinson ×     × ×  
8 Jason Burke           ×
9 Avi Dichter     × × ×  
10 Anthony Cordesman ×   ×   ×  
11 Alan Dershowitz ×          
12 Bruce Hoffman ×       ×  
13 Peter Bergen         × ×
14 Robert Baer       ×    
15 Arnaud de Borchgrave       × × ×
16 Michael Clarke ×       ×  
17 Jonathan Evans       ×    
18 Magnus Ranstorp   ×     ×  
19 Irwin Cotler ×   ×   ×  
20 Daniel Benjamin     ×   × ×
21Michael Scheuer       × ×  
22 Zachary Abuza ×       ×  
23 David Capitanchik ×          
24 John Thompson       × ×  
25 Simon Reeve           ×
26 Wesley Wark ×          
27 Frances Townsend     ×      
28 David Charters ×          
29 Kevin Toolis           ×
30 Tariq Ramadan ×       ×  
31 Steve Emerson         × ×
32 Steve Simon ×       ×  
33 Paul Beaver   ×   × × ×
34 Larry Johnson   × × ×    
35 Brian Jenkins   ×   ×    
36 Rita Katz       × ×  
37 David Wright-Neville ×   × ×    
38 Olivier Roy ×       ×  
39 Michael Ledeen       × ×  
40 Robert Pape ×          
41 Lawrence Eagleburger     ×   ×  
42 Boaz Ganor ×     × ×  
43 Paul Rogers ×       ×  
44 Mike Yardley       ×   ×
45 Fouad Ajami ×       ×  
46 Paul Pillar ×     × ×  
47 Conor Cruise O'Brien     ×     ×
48 Jessica Stern ×       ×  
49 Patrick Clawson         ×  
50 Graham Allison ×   ×      
51 Michael Osterholm     ×   ×  
52 Peter Power   × ×      
53 John O'Connor     ×      
54 Matthew Levitt ×   ×   ×  
55 Michael McKinley ×          
56 Mustafa Alani         ×  
57 Stephen Schwartz         × ×
58 Louise Richardson ×          
59 Evan Kohlmann         ×  
60 Anthony Glees ×          
61 Laurie Mylroie ×       ×  
62 Bruce Riedel       × ×  
63 Nick Kaldas     ×      
64 John Sifton         ×  
65 Jeane Kirkpatrick ×   ×   ×  
66 Neil Doyle           ×
67 Donald Henderson ×          
68 Jonathan Stevenson ×       × ×
69 Irwin Redlener ×       ×  
70 Charles Pena         ×  
71 Dan Plesch × ×     ×  
72 Tara O'Toole ×   ×   ×  
73 Michael Walzer ×       ×  
74 Daniel Byman ×   ×   ×  
75 Walter Laqueur ×       ×  
76 Adam Roberts ×       ×  
77 Marc Sageman ×     × ×  
78 Jusuf Wanandi ×       ×  
79 Athol Yates         ×  
80 Crispin Black   ×   ×    
81 Rachel Ehrenfeld         ×  
82Andrew Lynch ×          
83 Rolf Tophoven         × ×
84 Alan Krueger ×       ×  
85 Roger Cressey   × ×   ×  
86 Jack Goldsmith ×   ×   ×  
87 Alex Standish   ×       ×
88 Cass Sunstein ×   ×   ×  
89 Charles Shoebridge   × × ×    
90 Scott Atran ×       ×  
91 Seth Jones         ×  
92 Yonah Alexander ×       ×  
93 David Claridge   ×     ×  
94 Fred Halliday ×       ×  
95 David Kilcullen       × ×  
96 Kevin Rosser   ×        
97 Ariel Merari ×       ×  
98 Carl Ungerer ×       ×  
99 Bruce Ackerman ×          
100 Michael Chandler       × ×  

Analysis

A significant number of the experts (42 out of 100) are currently or have previously been a member of state institutions such as government, security or intelligence services, policing or the military.

The majority of the experts (67 of the 100) are currently or have previously been members of private think-tanks or research institutes. Of the remaining experts 16 out of 33 are currently or have previously worked in private security or intelligence firms, or alternatively state institutions such as government, security or intelligence, policing or military service.

Of the remaining 17 ‘independent’ experts, four are British journalists [1] and 13 are current or former academics with no such affiliation.[2] The 13 academics include the prominent critic of Western foreign policy Noam Chomsky, as well as supporters of state and corporate power such as Francis Fukuyama and Alan Dershowitz.

53 of the experts are currently or have previously held tenure at an institution of higher education. Of those 53, 35 are known to be members of Private Think-Tanks or Research Institutes.

16 experts are current or former journalists. Of those 16, three have been employed in private security or intelligence firms, seven have worked for a government, intelligence or law enforcement agency, and seven are known to be members of Private Think-Tanks or Research Institutes. The four journalists with no such affiliations are Jason Burke, Simon Reeve, Kevin Toolis and Neil Doyle.

Notes

  1. namely Simon Reeve, Jason Burke, Kevin Toolis and Neil Doyle
  2. The 13 ‘independent’ academics are listed below:
    Noam Chomsky
    Francis Fukuyama
    Alan Dershowitz
    David Capitanchik
    Wesley Wark
    David Charters
    Robert Pape
    Michael McKinley
    Louise Richardson
    Anthony Glees
    Donald Henderson
    Andrew Lynch
    Bruce Ackerman