Difference between revisions of "Patriotic Europeans Against Islamisation of the West"
Hilary Aked (talk | contribs) m (→Affiliations) |
(→2016) |
||
(96 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
===Leadership=== | ===Leadership=== | ||
According to Der Spiegel, PEGIDA has a ‘middle class leadership’ and at least three key organisers, including founder and leader [[Lutz Bachmann]] have prior criminal convictions, including burglary, drug crimes and fraud charges<ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. A translation of a German press agency article on the counterjihad website [[Gates of Vienna]] states that Lutz has a 'twelve-person organizational team'.<ref name="findingpegida"/> According to some sources, it key organisers were not political active prior to the emergence of the movement.<ref name="expandsinGer"/> | According to Der Spiegel, PEGIDA has a ‘middle class leadership’ and at least three key organisers, including founder and leader [[Lutz Bachmann]] have prior criminal convictions, including burglary, drug crimes and fraud charges<ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. A translation of a German press agency article on the counterjihad website [[Gates of Vienna]] states that Lutz has a 'twelve-person organizational team'.<ref name="findingpegida"/> According to some sources, it key organisers were not political active prior to the emergence of the movement.<ref name="expandsinGer"/> | ||
+ | |||
+ | It lost two leaders in one week after [[Lutz Bachmann]] resigned over photographs of him posing as Adolf Hitler and the announcement that he was being invetogated by the authorities, and then his replacement [[Kathrin Oertel]] quit days later.<ref>[http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jan/28/pegida-loses-second-leader-kathrin-oertel-week Pegida loses second leader in a week], Reuters/''The Guardian'', 28 January 2015</ref> | ||
==Ideology== | ==Ideology== | ||
+ | |||
+ | ===Slogans=== | ||
According to ''The Independent'' newspaper, PEGIDA’s slogan 'wir sind das Volk' (we are the people), harks back to protests before the fall of the Berlin Wall but ‘Volk’ and ‘Vaterland’ also retain connotations of the Nazi-era. <ref name="17000march"/><ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. But the group has made efforts to distance itself from the far right, stating that it is against ‘preachers of hate, regardless of what religion’ and ‘radicalism, regardless of whether religiously or politically motivated’<ref name="thousandsagainst">[http://www.dailymail.co.uk/wires/ap/article-2897177/Protests-4-German-cities-against-anti-Islam-rallies.html Thousands of Germans protest against anti-Islam rallies], Daily Mail, 5 January 2015, accessed 5 January 2015</ref>. | According to ''The Independent'' newspaper, PEGIDA’s slogan 'wir sind das Volk' (we are the people), harks back to protests before the fall of the Berlin Wall but ‘Volk’ and ‘Vaterland’ also retain connotations of the Nazi-era. <ref name="17000march"/><ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. But the group has made efforts to distance itself from the far right, stating that it is against ‘preachers of hate, regardless of what religion’ and ‘radicalism, regardless of whether religiously or politically motivated’<ref name="thousandsagainst">[http://www.dailymail.co.uk/wires/ap/article-2897177/Protests-4-German-cities-against-anti-Islam-rallies.html Thousands of Germans protest against anti-Islam rallies], Daily Mail, 5 January 2015, accessed 5 January 2015</ref>. | ||
+ | |||
+ | Another PEGIDA slogan, '''Lügenpresse''' (lying press), used to articulate a mistrust of the media and deflect allegations of racism, is reportedly 'seen as harking back to the Nazi era' because it was used by Adolf Hitler in 1922 and later by his propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels.<ref name="Hill"/> | ||
+ | |||
+ | According to an article in the ''Guardian'', one speaker at PEGIDA rally spoke 'about fear of Überfremdung – a word that had its heyday under the Nazis and suggests a native culture becoming tainted by too many foreign influences'.<ref>Ingo Shulze, [http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/feb/01/pegida-germanys-useful-idiots Pegida: Germany’s useful idiots], The Guardian, 1 february 2015</ref> | ||
===Counterjihad rhetoric=== | ===Counterjihad rhetoric=== | ||
Line 31: | Line 39: | ||
Its manifesto also lists policies including integration, 'sexual self-determination' and stopping the 'almost obsessive' movement against gendered German language. It reportedly also calls for the immediate deportation of asylum seekers with criminal convictions<ref name="17000march"/><ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. Many people on demonstrations waved German flags. Some PEGIDA banners bore the slogan ‘Non-violent and United Against Faith Wars on German Soil’ (‘Gewaltfrei & Vereint Gegen Glaubenskriege auf Deutschem Boden'). Der Spiegel reported that many of those involved in the PEGIDA protests don't believe the official statistics regarding the numbers of Muslims or immigrants but ‘are convinced that a cartel of politicians and "main-stream media" are audaciously misleading the public over the true state of affairs’<ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. | Its manifesto also lists policies including integration, 'sexual self-determination' and stopping the 'almost obsessive' movement against gendered German language. It reportedly also calls for the immediate deportation of asylum seekers with criminal convictions<ref name="17000march"/><ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. Many people on demonstrations waved German flags. Some PEGIDA banners bore the slogan ‘Non-violent and United Against Faith Wars on German Soil’ (‘Gewaltfrei & Vereint Gegen Glaubenskriege auf Deutschem Boden'). Der Spiegel reported that many of those involved in the PEGIDA protests don't believe the official statistics regarding the numbers of Muslims or immigrants but ‘are convinced that a cartel of politicians and "main-stream media" are audaciously misleading the public over the true state of affairs’<ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. | ||
+ | |||
+ | ===Participants' voting preferences=== | ||
+ | An ''Economist'' straw poll suggested that 9 out of 10 PEGIDA supporters would back the euro-skeptic [[Alternative for Germany]] party.<ref name="Econ">[http://www.economist.com/news/europe/21640386-how-anti-foreigner-anti-establishment-group-changing-german-politics-gone-boy-right Gone boy on the right], The Economist, 24 January 2015</ref> | ||
==Activities== | ==Activities== | ||
Line 36: | Line 47: | ||
PEGIDA began holding weekly demonstrations in Dresden on Mondays in October 2014. | PEGIDA began holding weekly demonstrations in Dresden on Mondays in October 2014. | ||
− | *A | + | ===Weekly demonstrations=== |
+ | |||
+ | *A protest in Dresden on 8 December attracted approximately 10,000 people. An anonymous PEGIDA speaker reportedly invoked Martin Luther King Jr., beginning his speech with the words ‘I have a dream’, saying he hoped for ‘peaceful coexistence’ but calling for acceptance of what he described as ‘the hard reality that we are in a state of war’<ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. | ||
+ | |||
+ | *A protest in Dresden on 1 December 2014 attracted approximately 7,500 people.<ref name="tiderises">Alison Smale, [http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/08/world/in-german-city-rich-with-history-and-tragedy-tide-rises-against-immigration.html?_r=1 In German City Rich With History and Tragedy, Tide Rises Against Immigration], New York Times, 7 December 2014, accessed 6 January 2015</ref> | ||
+ | |||
+ | *A protest in Dresden on 15 December 2014 attracted between 10,000 and 15,000 people. Around 5,700 attended a counter-demonstration<ref name="pinstripeNazis"/>. | ||
+ | |||
+ | *A protest in Dresden on 22 December 2014 attracted more than 17,000 people<ref name="17000march"/>; some estimates put the number at as many as 20,000. | ||
+ | |||
+ | *A protest on 5 January 2015 attracted about 18,000 people.<ref>[http://www.dw.de/charlie-hebdo-attack-german-lawmakers-warn-against-xenophobia/a-18180826 Charlie Hebdo attack: German lawmakers warn against xenophobia], Deutsche Welle, 8 January 2015, accessed 3 February 2015</ref> | ||
+ | |||
+ | *A protest in Dresden on 12 January 2015 is thought to have attracted a record 25,000, perhaps due to the reaction to the 7 January 2015 murders in Paris including at the offices of the magazine [[Charlie Hebdo]].<ref name="CBC">[http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/pegida-leader-kathrin-oertel-resigns-one-week-after-founder-quits-1.2934993 PEGIDA leader Kathrin Oertel resigns one week after founder quits], CBC, 28 January 2015</ref> | ||
+ | |||
+ | *What would have been the group's 13th demonstration on 19 January 2015 was cancelled, after German intelligence services reportedly identified founder [[Lutz Bachmann]] as a target for potential assassination<ref name="Hitlerpic"/> | ||
+ | |||
+ | *A protest on 26 January 2015 saw numbers drop to 17,000, perhaps due to revelations about founder [[Lutz Bachmann]] posing as Hitler which led to his resignation.<ref name="CBC"/> | ||
+ | |||
+ | *Following the resignation of two leaders ([[Lutz Bachmann]] and [[Kathrin Oertel]]) in a week, no demonstration was held on 2 February 2015<ref name="local2">[http://www.thelocal.de/20150128/pegida-spokeswoman-reported-to-be-leaving-group Pegida spokeswoman quits group: report]], The Local.de, 28 January 2015</ref> | ||
+ | |||
+ | *Just 'a few thousand people' attended the 9 February demo according to a video produced by Erik Olsen for the New York Times but significantly [[Lutz Bachmann]] returned despite his 'tarnished image'<ref name="NYT"/> | ||
+ | |||
+ | *Support for Pegida's weekly marches later dipped 'to only several hundred' following its leadership crisis but according to the ''New York Times'', by Monday 9 March the group's Dresden demonstration 'again mobilized several thousand people'.<ref name="NYT">Melissa Eddy, [http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/12/world/europe/citing-fear-of-neo-nazi-group-a-german-mayor-quits.html?_r=0 Citing Fear of Neo-Nazi Group, a German Mayor Quits], New York Times, 11 March 2015</ref> | ||
− | + | ===Press conference=== | |
+ | At reportedly the movement's 'first ever press conference' on 19 January 2015, then leaders [[Lutz Bachmann]] and [[Kathrin Oertel]] are said to have 'insisted that the group was not racist and later in a heated television discussion distanced themselves from footage showing Pegida demonstrators delivering racist remarks'.<ref name="Hitlerpic"/> | ||
− | + | ===Scandals and resignations=== | |
+ | ====2015==== | ||
+ | PEGIDA founder [[Lutz Bachmann]] stepped down as leader of the group on 21 January 2015, after a photograph of him posing as Adolf Hitler was published by in German newspapers and it was announced he was being investigated for describing immigrants as 'cattle, 'scumbags' and 'trash' in Facebook posts from September 2014.<ref name="Hitlerpic">[http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jan/21/germany-pegida-adolf-hitler-lutz-bachmann Germany’s Pegida leader steps down over Adolf Hitler photo], Guardian, 21 January 2015</ref><ref name="CBC">[http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/pegida-leader-kathrin-oertel-resigns-one-week-after-founder-quits-1.2934993 PEGIDA leader Kathrin Oertel resigns one week after founder quits], CBC, 28 January 2015</ref> The ''New York Times'' noted that despite claiming to have quit the group, Bachman soon reappeared and spoke at Pegida's 9 March demonstration.<ref name="NYT"/> | ||
− | + | He was replaced as leader by [[Kathrin Oertel]], who reportedly told a German newspaper that Bachmann’s resignation was the 'only possibilty' and said: | |
+ | |||
+ | ::We reject the Facebook postings made by Lutz Bachmann in September which have now come to light in the strongest possible terms. They do nothing to nurture trust in Pegida’s goals or its protagonists. | ||
+ | |||
+ | But within a week she had also resigned, citing 'hostility' and 'threats'.<ref>[http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jan/28/pegida-loses-second-leader-kathrin-oertel-week Pegida loses second leader in a week], Reuters/''The Guardian'', 28 January 2015</ref> Four other PEGIDA leaders reigned at the same time: they were [[Alternative for Germany]] member [[Achim Exner]], [[Thomas Tallacker]], a municipal politician from the city of Meißen,<ref name="local2"/> [[Bernd-Volker Lincke]] and [[René Jahn]]. One of these four others reportedly told the newspaper ''Bild'' that 'Bachmann's continuing influence and the role of a separate, sister movement in Leipzig known as [[LEGIDA]]' had contributed to their decision.<ref name="Hill">Jenny Hill, [http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-31018097 Germany Pegida: Leader Kathrin Oertel quits protest group], BBC News, 28 January 2015</ref> ''The Independent'' also noted that prior to the departure of Oertel and the other four, PEGIDA’s leadership committee had been 'immersed in a bitter dispute over whether to join forces with [[LEGIDA]]'.<ref name="Patt">Tony Patterson, [http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/pegida-movement-on-verge-of-total-implosion-as-five-of-its-leading-members-resign-in-disgust-due-to-fears-of-being-taken-over-by-germanys-far-right-10011943.html Pegida movement on verge of implosion as five of its leading members resign in disgust due to fears of being taken over by Germany's far right], The Independent, 29 January 2015</ref> | ||
+ | |||
+ | The group of five announced they were founding a new movement called [[Direct Democracy for Europe]], expected to 'move away from the anti-Islam stance' of [[PEGIDA]].<ref name="local">[http://www.thelocal.de/20150202/pegida-off-shoot-set-to-demo-next-week Pegida offshoot set to demo next week]], The Local.de, 2 Feb 2015, accessed 2 Feb 2015</ref> | ||
+ | |||
+ | ====2016==== | ||
+ | In was alleged in October 2016 that [[Lutz Bachmann]] had used money from the group's coffers to pay off €5,000 court costs of two cases brought against him as an individual. On his private Facebook page last year, Bachmann had insulted two mayors who were photographed helping refugees with their suitcases. He argued on Facebook that 'if a Pegida member posts something on a site belonging to the group' - including on his own personal page - 'then it is the most normal thing in the world that the association would pay for the court case.' <ref>[https://www.thelocal.de/20161026/pegida-leader-paid-court-costs-with-groups-money-reports Pegida leader 'paid court costs with group's money'], ''The Local'', 26 October 2016. Accessed 03 November 2016. </ref> | ||
+ | |||
+ | After appealing a court decision in May 2016, the Dresden state court confirmed on November 30th 2016 that Bachmann would have to pay the fine of 9,600 euros for 'inciting hatred against foreigners'. According to reports, Bachmann called the refugees 'cattle,' 'garbage' and a 'dirty bunch' in his Facebook in 2014. <ref> [https://sputniknews.com/europe/201612011048032807-german-court-pegida-fine-sentence/ German Court Upholds Fine Against PEGIDA Anti-Islamist Movement Leader], ''Sputnik News'', December 1 2016. Accessed 21 December 2016. </ref> | ||
+ | |||
+ | ==Copycat movements== | ||
+ | |||
+ | [[File:Draft 4.png||500px|thumb|right|How the PEGIDA movement spread across Europe (click on image to enlarge)]] | ||
===Copycat movements in Germany=== | ===Copycat movements in Germany=== | ||
Line 57: | Line 108: | ||
In Kassel, a Faecbook group with the name [[KAGIDA]] and similar variants appeared in Bonn, Darmstadt and elsewhere.<ref name="expandsinGer"/> | In Kassel, a Faecbook group with the name [[KAGIDA]] and similar variants appeared in Bonn, Darmstadt and elsewhere.<ref name="expandsinGer"/> | ||
− | In Leipzig a first protest was planned for 12 January 2015 under the name [[LEGIDA]]<ref>[http://gatesofvienna.net/2014/12/finding-pegida/ Finding PEGIDA], Gates of Vienna, 27 December 2014, accessed 5 January 2015</ref> | + | In Leipzig a first protest was planned for 12 January 2015 under the name [[LEGIDA]]<ref>[http://gatesofvienna.net/2014/12/finding-pegida/ Finding PEGIDA], Gates of Vienna, 27 December 2014, accessed 5 January 2015</ref>. When five PEGIDA leaders including [[Kathrin Oertell]] resigned, they distance themselves from [[LEGIDA]], regarded as 'a militant far-right grouping'<ref>Tony Patterson, [http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/pegida-movement-on-verge-of-total-implosion-as-five-of-its-leading-members-resign-in-disgust-due-to-fears-of-being-taken-over-by-germanys-far-right-10011943.html Pegida movement on verge of implosion as five of its leading members resign in disgust due to fears of being taken over by Germany's far right], The Independent, 29 January 2015</ref> |
+ | |||
+ | In Duisburg, a PEGIDA-offshoot calling itself [[DÜGIDA]] has organised at least one demonstration.<ref name="Hitlerpic"/> | ||
===Copycat movement in France=== | ===Copycat movement in France=== | ||
Line 64: | Line 117: | ||
===Copycat movement in the UK=== | ===Copycat movement in the UK=== | ||
− | On 1 January 2015 a [[Pegida UK]] facebook page was set up. It had over 3,000 'likes' one week later. The page claimed to be for Europeans who 'dislike radical Islam' but the tag given to the page was 'Patriots of Europe against Islam'. A post on 6 January 2015 stated that 'ultimately the aim is to organize (sic) peaceful protests' but no date or located had been announced.<ref>[http://powerbase.info/index.php/File:Pegida_UK_facebook_page.png Screengrab of Pegida UK's facebook page on 7 January 2015], Powerbase, 7 January 2015</ref> | + | On 1 January 2015 a [[Pegida UK]] facebook page was set up. It had over 3,000 'likes' one week later. The page claimed to be for Europeans who 'dislike radical Islam' but the tag given to the page was 'Patriots of Europe against Islam'. A post on 6 January 2015 stated that 'ultimately the aim is to organize (sic) peaceful protests' but no date or located had been announced.<ref>[http://powerbase.info/index.php/File:Pegida_UK_facebook_page.png Screengrab of Pegida UK's facebook page on 7 January 2015], Powerbase, 7 January 2015</ref> Following a poorly attended gathering in Manchester on 11 January 2015<ref name="Hastings">Gary Hastings, [http://edlnews.co.uk/2015/01/10/pegida-uk-a-middle-class-protest-group-or-a-front-for-the-far-right/ PEGIDA UK – A MIDDLE CLASS PROTEST GROUP OR A FRONT FOR THE FAR RIGHT?], EDL News, 10 January 2015, accessed 12 January 2015</ref>, [[Pegida UK]] held what it described as its 'first' demonstration in Newcastle on 28 February 2015. It attracted up to 400 people and far-right groups were clearly present<ref>Ian Hughes, [http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/newcastle-pegida-rally-recap-first-5246852 Newcastle Pegida rally: RECAP on first UK protest by anti-Islam movement], The Mirror, 28 February 1015</ref> but they were outnumbered by up to 3,000 counter-protesters.<ref name="Smith">Dominic Smith, [http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/feb/28/newcastle-pegida-unites-far-right-march-islam-protest Far-right Pegida eclipsed by its opponents at first UK demo], The guardian, 28 February 2015, accessed 27 March 2015</ref> |
+ | |||
+ | ===Copycat movement in Norway=== | ||
+ | A [https://www.facebook.com/pegidanorge?ref=profile facebook group for Norway] called [[Pegida Norge]] was set up on 27 December 2014. It's tag line reads: 'PEGIDA is a protest movement with a humanistic basis demonstrating against Muslim immigration and the influence of Islam' ('PEGIDA er en protestbevegelse som på humanistisk grunnlag demonstrerer mot muslimsk innvandring og påvirkningen fra islam'). A rally in Oslo on 12 January 2015 attracted just under 200 people<ref name="Local1"/> but the following week, 19 January 2015, only 70 people attended.<ref name="Local2">[http://www.thelocal.no/20150120/anti-islam-group-loses-support-in-norway Anti-Islam group loses support in Norway], The Local, 20 January, accessed 13 February 2015</ref> | ||
− | ===Copycat | + | ===Copycat movement in Sweden=== |
− | A [https://www.facebook.com/ | + | A [https://www.facebook.com/pegidasverige?ref=profile facebook group for Sweden] called [[Pegida Swerige]] was set up in December 2014 and had over 5,000 'likes' by 7 January 2015. [[Henrik Rönnquist]] was reportedly a key organiser. |
− | + | The administrators of the page also promoted a [https://www.facebook.com/pegidascandinavia Scandinavia-wide Pegida page]. | |
− | + | ===Copycat movement in Denmark=== | |
+ | There is also a [[Pegida Denmark]], and at least three associated social media accounts (a [https://www.facebook.com/pegidadanmark?ref=profile Pegida Danmark] facebook page and a [https://www.facebook.com/pegidadk PegidaDK] facebook page and [https://twitter.com/pegidadk PegidaDK] twitter accounts. A protest take place on 19 January 2015, led by [[Nicolai Sennels]].<ref name="Pershing">Linda Pershing, [http://www.truth-out.org/news/item/28800-first-anti-islam-march-by-pegida-movement-fizzles-in-denmark First Anti-Islam March by Pegida Movement Fizzles in Denmark], TruthOut, 29 January 2015</ref> | ||
− | + | ===Copycat movement in Austria=== | |
+ | In the Austrian capital Vienna, [[Pegida Österreich]] held a demonstration on 2 February 2015 that drew just 200 people and reportedly 5,000 counter-protesters.<ref>[http://www.dw.de/pegida-and-counter-demonstrations-come-to-austria/a-18231026 PEGIDA and counter-demonstrations come to Austria], Deutsche Welle, 2 February 2015, accessed 3 February 2015</ref> Similarly, an 8 February 2015 protest in Linz, northern Austria, attracted only 150 people and was dwarfed by a counter-protest of around 2,000 anti-racism demonstrators.<ref>Rosie Waites[http://www.thelocal.at/20150208/pegida-in-linz-meets-fierce-resistance Pegida in Linz meets fierce resistance], The Local, 8 February 2015</ref> | ||
===Copycat movements elsewhere=== | ===Copycat movements elsewhere=== | ||
− | Right wing media outlet [[Breitbart]] reported on 6 January 2015 that | + | Right wing media outlet [[Breitbart]] reported on 6 January 2015 that groups in Italy and Spain had also vowed to launch the movement there.<ref name="breitbartpeg"/> |
==Responses== | ==Responses== | ||
Line 83: | Line 141: | ||
According to ''The Independent'' newspaper, the leaders of PEGIDA have reportedly been labelled ‘Nazis in pinstripes’ by opponents (this quote has variously been attributed to [[Thomas Opperman]] of Germany’s [[Social Democrat]] SPD party [3] and [[Ralf Jäger]] of the same party) <ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. | According to ''The Independent'' newspaper, the leaders of PEGIDA have reportedly been labelled ‘Nazis in pinstripes’ by opponents (this quote has variously been attributed to [[Thomas Opperman]] of Germany’s [[Social Democrat]] SPD party [3] and [[Ralf Jäger]] of the same party) <ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. | ||
− | Meanwhile [[Angela Merkel]]’s [[Christian Democrats]] (CDU) were said to have offered ‘mixed’ responses with some urging understanding for the march’s motivations <ref name="visiblerise"/>. Saxony Interior Minister [[Markus Ulbig]] of the CDU said: ‘We cannot label 10,000 people as right-wing extremists. That creates more problems than it solves’, adding that there were many "middle-class citizens" among the demonstrators, ‘and you can't toss them all into the same Neo-Nazi pot’<ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. However Merkel herself strongly criticised the movement in her New Year's speech, saying 'their hearts are cold and often full of prejudice, and even hate'.<ref>[http://www.dw.de/merkel-criticizes-anti-islam-pegida-movement-in-new-years-speech/a-18164445 Merkel criticizes anti-Islam PEGIDA movement in New Year's speech], DW.de, 31 December 2014, accessed 6 January 2015</ref>. | + | Meanwhile [[Angela Merkel]]’s [[Christian Democrats]] (CDU) were said to have offered ‘mixed’ responses with some urging understanding for the march’s motivations <ref name="visiblerise"/>. Saxony Interior Minister [[Markus Ulbig]] of the CDU said: ‘We cannot label 10,000 people as right-wing extremists. That creates more problems than it solves’, adding that there were many "middle-class citizens" among the demonstrators, ‘and you can't toss them all into the same Neo-Nazi pot’<ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. However Merkel herself strongly criticised the movement in her New Year's speech, saying 'their hearts are cold and often full of prejudice, and even hate'.<ref>[http://www.dw.de/merkel-criticizes-anti-islam-pegida-movement-in-new-years-speech/a-18164445 Merkel criticizes anti-Islam PEGIDA movement in New Year's speech], DW.de, 31 December 2014, accessed 6 January 2015</ref>. However her Vice-Chancellor, the Social Democrat leader [[Sigmar Gabriel]] in late January 'admittted he had attended a Dresden forum and talked with Pegida supporters'.<ref>Tony Patterson, [http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/pegida-movement-on-verge-of-total-implosion-as-five-of-its-leading-members-resign-in-disgust-due-to-fears-of-being-taken-over-by-germanys-far-right-10011943.html Pegida movement on verge of implosion as five of its leading members resign in disgust due to fears of being taken over by Germany's far right], The Independent, 29 January 2015</ref> |
− | However, [[Alexander Gauland]], one of the leaders of the ‘fast-growing’ Eurosceptic party [[Alternative for Germany]] (AfD) however, declared his party ‘the natural allies of this movement’ and announced his intention to attend a Dresden protest on 15 December 2014.<ref name="visiblerise"/> | + | However, [[Alexander Gauland]], one of the leaders of the ‘fast-growing’ Eurosceptic party [[Alternative for Germany]] (AfD) however, declared his party ‘the natural allies of this movement’ and announced his intention to attend a Dresden protest on 15 December 2014.<ref name="visiblerise"/> Another MP, [[Hans-Thomas Tillschneider]], spoke at a rally in May 2016, and in November 2016 [[Lutz Bachmann]] even invited [[AfD]] co-leader [[Frauke Petry]] to do the same, adding 'these are your voters, Frauke, and you have to be here'. <ref> Chris Tomlinson, [http://www.breitbart.com/london/2016/11/16/pegidas-bachmann-salutes-america-invites-afd-leader-petry-speak/ PEGIDA’s Bachmann Salutes America, Invites AfD Leader Petry To Speak], ''Breitbart'', 16 November 2016. accessed November 28 2016. </ref> |
The far-right [[National Democratic Party]] (NPD) also appeared to welcome the protests which, according to ''Der Spiegel'', it saw as ‘a chance to take their worldview directly to the middle class’<ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. | The far-right [[National Democratic Party]] (NPD) also appeared to welcome the protests which, according to ''Der Spiegel'', it saw as ‘a chance to take their worldview directly to the middle class’<ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. | ||
Line 91: | Line 149: | ||
===Security establishment response in Germany=== | ===Security establishment response in Germany=== | ||
One the eve of one PEGIDA march, Germany’s most senior policeman is reported to have noted 'a visible rise in xenophobic crime countrywide', including growing number of anti-Muslim and anti-Jewish incidents.<ref name="visiblerise"/> Germany’s domestic security agencies were said to be monitoring a number of groups including [[Hooligans Against Salafists]] (HoGeSa)<ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. | One the eve of one PEGIDA march, Germany’s most senior policeman is reported to have noted 'a visible rise in xenophobic crime countrywide', including growing number of anti-Muslim and anti-Jewish incidents.<ref name="visiblerise"/> Germany’s domestic security agencies were said to be monitoring a number of groups including [[Hooligans Against Salafists]] (HoGeSa)<ref name="rattlesGermany"/>. | ||
+ | ====Bans==== | ||
+ | On November 8 2016 it was announced that [[Lutz Bachmann]] and his deputy leader, [[Siegfried Däbritz]], had been banned from leading weekly PEGIDA rallies until 2021. Bachmann still expressed his intention to attend them despite the ban. <ref> Tom Porter, [http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/founder-far-right-pegida-group-banned-leading-rallies-1590534 Founder of far right Pegida group banned from leading rallies], ''International Business Times'', November 8, 2016. Accessed November 28 2016. </ref> | ||
===Grassroots responses: anti-PEGIDA protests=== | ===Grassroots responses: anti-PEGIDA protests=== | ||
Anti-PEGIDA protests have taken place or been planned in Würzberg, Nuremberg, Leipzig, Düsseldorf, Frankfurt,<ref name="rattlesGermany"/> Dresden,<ref name="pinstripeNazis"/> Munich and Cologne. Thousands of anti-fascist protesters on the counter-demonstrations have used the anti-Nazi slogan “nie wieda” - never again <ref name="17000march"/>. When on 5 January 2015 the PEGIDA protests spread to Berlin and Cologne (drawing only a few hundred supporters in these cities) they were opposed by much larger anti-PEGIDA protests which also took place in Stuttgart and Dresden<ref name="thousandsagainst"/>. In Cologne the famous cathedral turned off its lights to show it did not support the 'anti-Islamisation' protest. | Anti-PEGIDA protests have taken place or been planned in Würzberg, Nuremberg, Leipzig, Düsseldorf, Frankfurt,<ref name="rattlesGermany"/> Dresden,<ref name="pinstripeNazis"/> Munich and Cologne. Thousands of anti-fascist protesters on the counter-demonstrations have used the anti-Nazi slogan “nie wieda” - never again <ref name="17000march"/>. When on 5 January 2015 the PEGIDA protests spread to Berlin and Cologne (drawing only a few hundred supporters in these cities) they were opposed by much larger anti-PEGIDA protests which also took place in Stuttgart and Dresden<ref name="thousandsagainst"/>. In Cologne the famous cathedral turned off its lights to show it did not support the 'anti-Islamisation' protest. | ||
+ | |||
+ | On 12 January, when [[PEGIDA]] drew its biggest number yet (25,000) following the [[Charlie Hebdo]] and other killings in Paris, around 100,000 people took part in counter-demonstrations 'for tolerance and openness', across Germany.<ref name="local"/> | ||
+ | |||
+ | ==Divisions== | ||
+ | On September 27 2016, ''Deutsche Welle'' reports that Germany's PEGIDA is 'descending into chaos as internal divisions have resulted in conflicting demonstrations' and as founder [[Lutz Bachmann]] has moved to a Spanish island. The former leader, [[Tatjana Festerling]], staged her own counter-demonstration of 60-100 participants, against the regular event led by the current leader [[Lutz Bachmann]]. Both sides reportedly jeered the other during the demo, as insults, threats, and mutual accusations of splitting the movement were heard among demonstrators. | ||
+ | |||
+ | These scenes are allegedly 'the latest episode in what has become a meandering saga for PEGIDA'. the Facebook pages of the two leaders are full of accusations and counter-accusations towards one another, with Festerling repeatedly claiming that Bachmann stole 100,000 euros from the group's coffers and hoarded cash in his private home. Bachmann has claimed that she deliberately publicised his home address, where there were 'four break-in attempts' subsequently, and a manipulation of his car that resulted in its engine 'blowing up' on a highway.<ref> Ben Knight, [http://www.dw.com/en/pegida-splintered-as-conflicting-demos-staged-in-dresden/a-35903672 PEGIDA splintered as conflicting demos staged in Dresden], ''Deutsche Welle'', 27 September 2016. Accessed 07 October 2016. </ref> | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | |||
==People== | ==People== | ||
− | *[[Lutz Bachmann]] – founder and leader | + | ===Germany=== |
+ | *[[Lutz Bachmann]] – founder and leader, quit 21 January 2015 but reportedly retained influence and reappeared the 9 March demonstration.<ref name="NYT"/> | ||
+ | *[[Kathrin Oertel]] - co-founder, quit 28 January 2015 | ||
*Dr [[Karl Schmitt]], a former CDU activist, reportedly organised the copycat 'BAERGIDA' demonstration in Berlin<ref>[http://www.thelocal.de/20150105/anti-islam-demos-spread-to-berlin Anti-Islam demos spread to Berlin], The Local, 5 January 2015, accessed 6 January 2015.</ref> | *Dr [[Karl Schmitt]], a former CDU activist, reportedly organised the copycat 'BAERGIDA' demonstration in Berlin<ref>[http://www.thelocal.de/20150105/anti-islam-demos-spread-to-berlin Anti-Islam demos spread to Berlin], The Local, 5 January 2015, accessed 6 January 2015.</ref> | ||
− | * [[Udo Ulfkotte]] - spoke at Bonn demonstration | + | *[[Udo Ulfkotte]] - spoke at Bonn demonstration |
+ | *[[Heidi Mund]] - addressed 26 January 2015 demonstration<ref name="Gov">Baron Bodissey, [http://gatesofvienna.net/2015/01/an-israeli-addresses-pegida/ An Israeli Addresses PEGIDA]], Gates of Vienna, 28 January 2015</ref> | ||
+ | *[[Rotem Avitu]] - an 'Israeli psychologist' who also addressed the 26 January demo<ref name="Gov"/> | ||
+ | *[[Bernd-Volker Lincke]] - former organiser, quit with Oertel 28 January 2015<ref name="local"/> | ||
+ | *[[René Jahn]] - former organiser, quit with Oertel 28 January 2015<ref name="local"/> | ||
+ | *[[Achim Exner]] - former organiser, quit with Oertel 28 January 2015<ref name="local2"/> | ||
+ | *[[Thomas Tallacker]] - former organiser, quit with Oertel 28 January 2015<ref name="local2"/> | ||
===Sweden=== | ===Sweden=== | ||
− | *[[Henrik | + | *[[Henrik Rönnquist]] - founder and leader of the Swedish branch<ref name="DW">Malcolm Brabant, [http://www.dw.de/sweden-doesnt-need-groups-like-pegida/a-18246884 Sweden 'doesn't need groups like PEGIDA'], Deutsche Welle, 10 February 2015, accessed 12 February 2015</ref> who denies the organisation is racist and says he wants thousands upon thousands of Swedes to vocally oppose the 'Islamisation' of the country. <ref> Baron Bod [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s-_x_J70IIc Sweden: "We want thousands against the Islamisation of Sweden," says Swedish PEGIDA founder], YouTube, published 5 January 2015, accessed 7 January 2015 </ref> |
+ | *[[Dan Park]] - organiser<ref name="SwRad">[http://sverigesradio.se/sida/artikel.aspx?programid=2054&artikel=6089362 Thousands gather to oppose Pegida demo], Radio Sweden, 9 February 2015</ref> | ||
+ | |||
+ | ===Norway=== | ||
+ | *[[Max Hermansen]] - organiser<ref name="Local1">[http://www.thelocal.no/20150119/anti-islam-march-to-go-ahead-in-oslo Anti-Islam march to go ahead in Oslo], The Local, 19 January 2015</ref> | ||
+ | |||
+ | ===Denmark=== | ||
+ | *[[Nicolai Sennels]] - leader<ref name="Pershing"/> | ||
+ | |||
+ | ===Austria=== | ||
+ | *[[Immanuel Nagel]] - former spokesperson<ref name="Local">[http://www.thelocal.at/20150204/vienna-pegida-spokesman-steps-down Vienna's Pegida spokesman steps down], The Local, 4 February 2015</ref> | ||
+ | |||
+ | ===United Kingdom=== | ||
+ | *[[Donna Treanor]] - a veteran former member of the fascist [[British National Party]] and subsequently a member of ex-leader [[Nick Griffin]]'s new party, [[British Voice]] | ||
+ | *[[Ronnie Alte]] - until recently the leader of the [[Norwegian Defence League]], a street movement modelled on the EDL said to have influenced mass murdered [[Anders Behring Breivik]] | ||
+ | *[[Craig Farnsworth]] - a member of several far right groups in the Bolton area including the [[English Defence League]], the [[Infidels]] (a [[National Front]] spin off), the [[British National Party]] and its splinter group the [[British Voice]]. | ||
+ | *[[Steven Barker]] - member of the [[English Volunteer Force]], a splinter group of the English Defence League who model themselves on paramilitaries in Northern Ireland. | ||
+ | *[[Billy Charlton]] - a long term member of the [[English Defence League]]’s Sunderland Division.<ref name="Hastings">Gary Hastings, [http://edlnews.co.uk/2015/01/10/pegida-uk-a-middle-class-protest-group-or-a-front-for-the-far-right/ PEGIDA UK – A MIDDLE CLASS PROTEST GROUP OR A FRONT FOR THE FAR RIGHT?], EDL News, 10 January 2015, accessed 12 January 2015</ref> | ||
+ | *[[Matthew Pope]] - reportedly a devout Christian, a fan of the [[British national Party]], the [[English Defence League]] and [[Britain First]] on facebook and formerly the administrator of a page called 'Ban Islam'. Described as official spokesperson for 28 February 2015 demonstration<ref>Shane Croucher, [http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/pegida-uk-leader-matthew-pope-wants-islam-banned-has-far-right-links-1487742 Pegida UK promoter Matthew Pope wants Islam banned and has far-right links], IBTimes, 12 February 2015</ref> | ||
+ | *[[Marion Rogers]] - reportedly 'Proprietor of JR Flat Roofing in Redruth'<ref>Derek Fender, [http://edlnews.co.uk/2015/03/22/pegida-uk-manage-to-attract-four-demonstrators-to-their-scotland-demo/ PEGIDA UK MANAGE TO ATTRACT FOUR DEMONSTRATORS TO THEIR SCOTLAND DEMO], EDLNews, 22 March 2015</ref>. Described as a spokesperson for 28 February 2015 demonstration<ref>[http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-tyne-31657167 'Anti-Islamisation' group Pegida UK holds Newcastle march], BBC News Online, 28 February 2015, accessed 27 March 2015</ref> | ||
+ | |||
+ | ==Resources== | ||
+ | *Ingo Shulze, [http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/feb/01/pegida-germanys-useful-idiots Pegida: Germany’s useful idiots], ''The Guardian'', 1 February 2015. | ||
+ | *[http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-30776182 Who goes to German Pegida 'anti-Islamisation' rallies?], BBC News, 13 January 2015, accessed 3 February 2015. | ||
+ | *[http://www.menschen-in-dresden.de/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/pegida-positionspapier.pdf POSITIONSPAPIER der PEGIDA], PEGIDA position paper [in German]. | ||
==Affiliations== | ==Affiliations== | ||
Line 111: | Line 213: | ||
*[[Skinheads Sächsische Schweiz]] | *[[Skinheads Sächsische Schweiz]] | ||
*[[BAEGIDA]] | [[KOEGIDA]] | [[DÜGIDA]] | [[KAGIDA]] | [[LEGIDA]] | *[[BAEGIDA]] | [[KOEGIDA]] | [[DÜGIDA]] | [[KAGIDA]] | [[LEGIDA]] | ||
− | *[[Pegida UK]] | [[Pegida Norge]] | [[Pegida Swerige]] | [[Pegida Danmark]] | [[PEGIDA France]] | + | *[[Pegida UK]] | [[Pegida Norge]] | [[Pegida Swerige]] | [[Pegida Danmark]] | [[PEGIDA France]] | [[Pegida Österreich]] |
− | |||
− | |||
==Notes== | ==Notes== | ||
Line 119: | Line 219: | ||
<references/> | <references/> | ||
+ | [[Category:PEGIDA]] | ||
[[Category:Counterjihad]] | [[Category:Counterjihad]] | ||
+ | [[Category:Islam Critics]] | ||
+ | [[Category:Germany]] |
Latest revision as of 14:40, 21 December 2016
Patriotic Europeans Against Islamisation of the Occident (PEGIDA) is a far-right populist movement in Germany which emerged in late 2014 in Dresden. It opposes what it calls ‘the Islamisation of the West’ and calls for tough immigration policy.
The name is an acronym derived from the German name Patriotische Europäer Gegen die Islamisierung des Abendlandes ('Patriotic Europeans Against Islamisation of the West').
Its name and message bears a strong resemblance to the 'alliance of European patriots against Islamisation' called for by Geert Wilders in a speech at the Four Seasons Hotel in New York on 25 September 2008, prior to the Facing Jihad conference in Jerusalem.[1]
Contents
[hide]History
Emergence
PEGIDA began holding weekly demonstrations on Mondays at Schlossplatz square in Dresden[2] in October 2014. Initially attendance figures were in the dozens or hundreds but by December 2014 its rallies were attracting over 10,000 people. The movement’s Facebook page had 44,000 ‘likes’ at the end of 2014[2]. By 7 January 2015 it had over 113,000 'likes'.
Germany takes in more asylum seekers than any other EU country[3] but PEGIDA’s protests have centred around the east German city of Dresden, the capitol of Saxony, home to neither a large proportion of immigrants (about 2.5%, or 100,000) or a significant Muslim minority (just 0.1%)[3][2]. Der Spiegel linked the emergence of PEGIDA to a general rise in far right protests in Germany in 2014, including 86 attacks on asylum seekers’ hostels between January and September[2].
Writing in mainstream newspaper Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, German journalist Peter Carstens drew attention to Dresden's unique historical symbolism, noting that at the end of World War II an Allied air attack killed up to 100,000 people in February 1945.[4] One German scholar noted that neo-Nazi demonstrations had for years taken place on the anniversary of the bombing in the city and argues it is no coincidence that the new movement emerged in Dresden.[5] Other observers say the movement's emergence in Dresden may also be connected to its Communist past and the rapid transformations of recent decades.[6]
Attendees
Attendees at PEGIDA demos appear to include far right activists and football hooligans[7] but reportedly also include members of the public concerned about immigration[8]. Most media outlets called the PEGIDA marches ‘anti-Muslim’, others as ‘anti-immigrant’. The organiser claim to only be against ‘extremism’ but demonstrations have been supported by neo-Nazi groups[3]. Far-right elements identified as having links with PEGIDA include Fist of the East a far right Dresden hooligan group, Hooligans Elbflorenz (Florence on the Elbe, a nickname for Dresden), Skinheads Sächsische Schweiz, a banned far-right organisation[2] and Hooligans Against Salafists (HoGeSa)[2].
One German journalist characterised the attendees as reminiscent of 'a gathering of Saxon craftsmen' and wrote that they were 'Mostly middle-aged men, sturdy types, dressed in outdoor jackets and solid shoes — dressed for all the tasks in construction. Here and there a few older men, all kinds of women, few young people.'[4] A different journalist writing in the same paper suggested the movement was 'deeply middle-class' and the protests themselves 'took a middle-class form (a walk)'[4], also referred to as a 'stroll'.[9]
Leadership
According to Der Spiegel, PEGIDA has a ‘middle class leadership’ and at least three key organisers, including founder and leader Lutz Bachmann have prior criminal convictions, including burglary, drug crimes and fraud charges[2]. A translation of a German press agency article on the counterjihad website Gates of Vienna states that Lutz has a 'twelve-person organizational team'.[4] According to some sources, it key organisers were not political active prior to the emergence of the movement.[5]
It lost two leaders in one week after Lutz Bachmann resigned over photographs of him posing as Adolf Hitler and the announcement that he was being invetogated by the authorities, and then his replacement Kathrin Oertel quit days later.[10]
Ideology
Slogans
According to The Independent newspaper, PEGIDA’s slogan 'wir sind das Volk' (we are the people), harks back to protests before the fall of the Berlin Wall but ‘Volk’ and ‘Vaterland’ also retain connotations of the Nazi-era. [3][2]. But the group has made efforts to distance itself from the far right, stating that it is against ‘preachers of hate, regardless of what religion’ and ‘radicalism, regardless of whether religiously or politically motivated’[11].
Another PEGIDA slogan, Lügenpresse (lying press), used to articulate a mistrust of the media and deflect allegations of racism, is reportedly 'seen as harking back to the Nazi era' because it was used by Adolf Hitler in 1922 and later by his propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels.[12]
According to an article in the Guardian, one speaker at PEGIDA rally spoke 'about fear of Überfremdung – a word that had its heyday under the Nazis and suggests a native culture becoming tainted by too many foreign influences'.[13]
Counterjihad rhetoric
PEGIDA seems to exhibit a counterjihad ideology since organisers reportedly played on fear of Isis and al-Qaedas [7] and it emphasises the preservation of what it calls 'Judeo-Christian Western culture' instead of 'Islamisation' and 'parallel societies with Sharia police'.
Its manifesto also lists policies including integration, 'sexual self-determination' and stopping the 'almost obsessive' movement against gendered German language. It reportedly also calls for the immediate deportation of asylum seekers with criminal convictions[3][2]. Many people on demonstrations waved German flags. Some PEGIDA banners bore the slogan ‘Non-violent and United Against Faith Wars on German Soil’ (‘Gewaltfrei & Vereint Gegen Glaubenskriege auf Deutschem Boden'). Der Spiegel reported that many of those involved in the PEGIDA protests don't believe the official statistics regarding the numbers of Muslims or immigrants but ‘are convinced that a cartel of politicians and "main-stream media" are audaciously misleading the public over the true state of affairs’[2].
Participants' voting preferences
An Economist straw poll suggested that 9 out of 10 PEGIDA supporters would back the euro-skeptic Alternative for Germany party.[14]
Activities
<youtube size="medium" align="right" caption="German protests against growing 'Islamisation'">tz_SfJz-ztM</youtube> PEGIDA began holding weekly demonstrations in Dresden on Mondays in October 2014.
Weekly demonstrations
- A protest in Dresden on 8 December attracted approximately 10,000 people. An anonymous PEGIDA speaker reportedly invoked Martin Luther King Jr., beginning his speech with the words ‘I have a dream’, saying he hoped for ‘peaceful coexistence’ but calling for acceptance of what he described as ‘the hard reality that we are in a state of war’[2].
- A protest in Dresden on 1 December 2014 attracted approximately 7,500 people.[6]
- A protest in Dresden on 15 December 2014 attracted between 10,000 and 15,000 people. Around 5,700 attended a counter-demonstration[8].
- A protest in Dresden on 22 December 2014 attracted more than 17,000 people[3]; some estimates put the number at as many as 20,000.
- A protest on 5 January 2015 attracted about 18,000 people.[15]
- A protest in Dresden on 12 January 2015 is thought to have attracted a record 25,000, perhaps due to the reaction to the 7 January 2015 murders in Paris including at the offices of the magazine Charlie Hebdo.[16]
- What would have been the group's 13th demonstration on 19 January 2015 was cancelled, after German intelligence services reportedly identified founder Lutz Bachmann as a target for potential assassination[17]
- A protest on 26 January 2015 saw numbers drop to 17,000, perhaps due to revelations about founder Lutz Bachmann posing as Hitler which led to his resignation.[16]
- Following the resignation of two leaders (Lutz Bachmann and Kathrin Oertel) in a week, no demonstration was held on 2 February 2015[18]
- Just 'a few thousand people' attended the 9 February demo according to a video produced by Erik Olsen for the New York Times but significantly Lutz Bachmann returned despite his 'tarnished image'[19]
- Support for Pegida's weekly marches later dipped 'to only several hundred' following its leadership crisis but according to the New York Times, by Monday 9 March the group's Dresden demonstration 'again mobilized several thousand people'.[19]
Press conference
At reportedly the movement's 'first ever press conference' on 19 January 2015, then leaders Lutz Bachmann and Kathrin Oertel are said to have 'insisted that the group was not racist and later in a heated television discussion distanced themselves from footage showing Pegida demonstrators delivering racist remarks'.[17]
Scandals and resignations
2015
PEGIDA founder Lutz Bachmann stepped down as leader of the group on 21 January 2015, after a photograph of him posing as Adolf Hitler was published by in German newspapers and it was announced he was being investigated for describing immigrants as 'cattle, 'scumbags' and 'trash' in Facebook posts from September 2014.[17][16] The New York Times noted that despite claiming to have quit the group, Bachman soon reappeared and spoke at Pegida's 9 March demonstration.[19]
He was replaced as leader by Kathrin Oertel, who reportedly told a German newspaper that Bachmann’s resignation was the 'only possibilty' and said:
- We reject the Facebook postings made by Lutz Bachmann in September which have now come to light in the strongest possible terms. They do nothing to nurture trust in Pegida’s goals or its protagonists.
But within a week she had also resigned, citing 'hostility' and 'threats'.[20] Four other PEGIDA leaders reigned at the same time: they were Alternative for Germany member Achim Exner, Thomas Tallacker, a municipal politician from the city of Meißen,[18] Bernd-Volker Lincke and René Jahn. One of these four others reportedly told the newspaper Bild that 'Bachmann's continuing influence and the role of a separate, sister movement in Leipzig known as LEGIDA' had contributed to their decision.[12] The Independent also noted that prior to the departure of Oertel and the other four, PEGIDA’s leadership committee had been 'immersed in a bitter dispute over whether to join forces with LEGIDA'.[21]
The group of five announced they were founding a new movement called Direct Democracy for Europe, expected to 'move away from the anti-Islam stance' of PEGIDA.[22]
2016
In was alleged in October 2016 that Lutz Bachmann had used money from the group's coffers to pay off €5,000 court costs of two cases brought against him as an individual. On his private Facebook page last year, Bachmann had insulted two mayors who were photographed helping refugees with their suitcases. He argued on Facebook that 'if a Pegida member posts something on a site belonging to the group' - including on his own personal page - 'then it is the most normal thing in the world that the association would pay for the court case.' [23]
After appealing a court decision in May 2016, the Dresden state court confirmed on November 30th 2016 that Bachmann would have to pay the fine of 9,600 euros for 'inciting hatred against foreigners'. According to reports, Bachmann called the refugees 'cattle,' 'garbage' and a 'dirty bunch' in his Facebook in 2014. [24]
Copycat movements
Copycat movements in Germany
Der Spiegel reported that the PEGIDA movement spawned ‘many clones’.[2] Small copycat protests took place in 2014 other German cities such as West Dusseldorf[7], Chemnitz[5] Kassel and Würzburg but these only had a few hundred supporters[2].
In December 2014 the newspaper that PEGIDA protests were planned Cologne, Düsseldorf and Unna in 2015[2]. On 5 January 2015 there were protests in Dresden, Berlin and Cologne. The protests in Berlin and Cologne drew only a few hundred supporters.
The Berlin variant called itself BAERGIDA (also spelled BÄRGIDA or BERGIDA)
The Cologne demonstration using the name KOEGIDA (or KÖGIDA).
A Düsseldorf demonstration and Facebook group used the name DÜGIDA.[5]
In Kassel, a Faecbook group with the name KAGIDA and similar variants appeared in Bonn, Darmstadt and elsewhere.[5]
In Leipzig a first protest was planned for 12 January 2015 under the name LEGIDA[25]. When five PEGIDA leaders including Kathrin Oertell resigned, they distance themselves from LEGIDA, regarded as 'a militant far-right grouping'[26]
In Duisburg, a PEGIDA-offshoot calling itself DÜGIDA has organised at least one demonstration.[17]
Copycat movement in France
The PEGIDA protest also inspired French anti-Islam activists to take to the streets. On 1 January 2015 the Gates of Vienna blog reported that 18 January 2015 was the date organisers in France has chosen to call for ‘anti-Islamisation’ rallies across the country.[4] A PEGIDA France facebook page which may or may not be connected was set up in December 2014 and had over 6,000 'likes' by 7 January 2015.
Copycat movement in the UK
On 1 January 2015 a Pegida UK facebook page was set up. It had over 3,000 'likes' one week later. The page claimed to be for Europeans who 'dislike radical Islam' but the tag given to the page was 'Patriots of Europe against Islam'. A post on 6 January 2015 stated that 'ultimately the aim is to organize (sic) peaceful protests' but no date or located had been announced.[27] Following a poorly attended gathering in Manchester on 11 January 2015[28], Pegida UK held what it described as its 'first' demonstration in Newcastle on 28 February 2015. It attracted up to 400 people and far-right groups were clearly present[29] but they were outnumbered by up to 3,000 counter-protesters.[30]
Copycat movement in Norway
A facebook group for Norway called Pegida Norge was set up on 27 December 2014. It's tag line reads: 'PEGIDA is a protest movement with a humanistic basis demonstrating against Muslim immigration and the influence of Islam' ('PEGIDA er en protestbevegelse som på humanistisk grunnlag demonstrerer mot muslimsk innvandring og påvirkningen fra islam'). A rally in Oslo on 12 January 2015 attracted just under 200 people[31] but the following week, 19 January 2015, only 70 people attended.[32]
Copycat movement in Sweden
A facebook group for Sweden called Pegida Swerige was set up in December 2014 and had over 5,000 'likes' by 7 January 2015. Henrik Rönnquist was reportedly a key organiser.
The administrators of the page also promoted a Scandinavia-wide Pegida page.
Copycat movement in Denmark
There is also a Pegida Denmark, and at least three associated social media accounts (a Pegida Danmark facebook page and a PegidaDK facebook page and PegidaDK twitter accounts. A protest take place on 19 January 2015, led by Nicolai Sennels.[33]
Copycat movement in Austria
In the Austrian capital Vienna, Pegida Österreich held a demonstration on 2 February 2015 that drew just 200 people and reportedly 5,000 counter-protesters.[34] Similarly, an 8 February 2015 protest in Linz, northern Austria, attracted only 150 people and was dwarfed by a counter-protest of around 2,000 anti-racism demonstrators.[35]
Copycat movements elsewhere
Right wing media outlet Breitbart reported on 6 January 2015 that groups in Italy and Spain had also vowed to launch the movement there.[9]
Responses
Political responses in Germany
According to The Independent newspaper, the leaders of PEGIDA have reportedly been labelled ‘Nazis in pinstripes’ by opponents (this quote has variously been attributed to Thomas Opperman of Germany’s Social Democrat SPD party [3] and Ralf Jäger of the same party) [2].
Meanwhile Angela Merkel’s Christian Democrats (CDU) were said to have offered ‘mixed’ responses with some urging understanding for the march’s motivations [7]. Saxony Interior Minister Markus Ulbig of the CDU said: ‘We cannot label 10,000 people as right-wing extremists. That creates more problems than it solves’, adding that there were many "middle-class citizens" among the demonstrators, ‘and you can't toss them all into the same Neo-Nazi pot’[2]. However Merkel herself strongly criticised the movement in her New Year's speech, saying 'their hearts are cold and often full of prejudice, and even hate'.[36]. However her Vice-Chancellor, the Social Democrat leader Sigmar Gabriel in late January 'admittted he had attended a Dresden forum and talked with Pegida supporters'.[37]
However, Alexander Gauland, one of the leaders of the ‘fast-growing’ Eurosceptic party Alternative for Germany (AfD) however, declared his party ‘the natural allies of this movement’ and announced his intention to attend a Dresden protest on 15 December 2014.[7] Another MP, Hans-Thomas Tillschneider, spoke at a rally in May 2016, and in November 2016 Lutz Bachmann even invited AfD co-leader Frauke Petry to do the same, adding 'these are your voters, Frauke, and you have to be here'. [38]
The far-right National Democratic Party (NPD) also appeared to welcome the protests which, according to Der Spiegel, it saw as ‘a chance to take their worldview directly to the middle class’[2].
Security establishment response in Germany
One the eve of one PEGIDA march, Germany’s most senior policeman is reported to have noted 'a visible rise in xenophobic crime countrywide', including growing number of anti-Muslim and anti-Jewish incidents.[7] Germany’s domestic security agencies were said to be monitoring a number of groups including Hooligans Against Salafists (HoGeSa)[2].
Bans
On November 8 2016 it was announced that Lutz Bachmann and his deputy leader, Siegfried Däbritz, had been banned from leading weekly PEGIDA rallies until 2021. Bachmann still expressed his intention to attend them despite the ban. [39]
Grassroots responses: anti-PEGIDA protests
Anti-PEGIDA protests have taken place or been planned in Würzberg, Nuremberg, Leipzig, Düsseldorf, Frankfurt,[2] Dresden,[8] Munich and Cologne. Thousands of anti-fascist protesters on the counter-demonstrations have used the anti-Nazi slogan “nie wieda” - never again [3]. When on 5 January 2015 the PEGIDA protests spread to Berlin and Cologne (drawing only a few hundred supporters in these cities) they were opposed by much larger anti-PEGIDA protests which also took place in Stuttgart and Dresden[11]. In Cologne the famous cathedral turned off its lights to show it did not support the 'anti-Islamisation' protest.
On 12 January, when PEGIDA drew its biggest number yet (25,000) following the Charlie Hebdo and other killings in Paris, around 100,000 people took part in counter-demonstrations 'for tolerance and openness', across Germany.[22]
Divisions
On September 27 2016, Deutsche Welle reports that Germany's PEGIDA is 'descending into chaos as internal divisions have resulted in conflicting demonstrations' and as founder Lutz Bachmann has moved to a Spanish island. The former leader, Tatjana Festerling, staged her own counter-demonstration of 60-100 participants, against the regular event led by the current leader Lutz Bachmann. Both sides reportedly jeered the other during the demo, as insults, threats, and mutual accusations of splitting the movement were heard among demonstrators.
These scenes are allegedly 'the latest episode in what has become a meandering saga for PEGIDA'. the Facebook pages of the two leaders are full of accusations and counter-accusations towards one another, with Festerling repeatedly claiming that Bachmann stole 100,000 euros from the group's coffers and hoarded cash in his private home. Bachmann has claimed that she deliberately publicised his home address, where there were 'four break-in attempts' subsequently, and a manipulation of his car that resulted in its engine 'blowing up' on a highway.[40]
People
Germany
- Lutz Bachmann – founder and leader, quit 21 January 2015 but reportedly retained influence and reappeared the 9 March demonstration.[19]
- Kathrin Oertel - co-founder, quit 28 January 2015
- Dr Karl Schmitt, a former CDU activist, reportedly organised the copycat 'BAERGIDA' demonstration in Berlin[41]
- Udo Ulfkotte - spoke at Bonn demonstration
- Heidi Mund - addressed 26 January 2015 demonstration[42]
- Rotem Avitu - an 'Israeli psychologist' who also addressed the 26 January demo[42]
- Bernd-Volker Lincke - former organiser, quit with Oertel 28 January 2015[22]
- René Jahn - former organiser, quit with Oertel 28 January 2015[22]
- Achim Exner - former organiser, quit with Oertel 28 January 2015[18]
- Thomas Tallacker - former organiser, quit with Oertel 28 January 2015[18]
Sweden
- Henrik Rönnquist - founder and leader of the Swedish branch[43] who denies the organisation is racist and says he wants thousands upon thousands of Swedes to vocally oppose the 'Islamisation' of the country. [44]
- Dan Park - organiser[45]
Norway
- Max Hermansen - organiser[31]
Denmark
- Nicolai Sennels - leader[33]
Austria
- Immanuel Nagel - former spokesperson[46]
United Kingdom
- Donna Treanor - a veteran former member of the fascist British National Party and subsequently a member of ex-leader Nick Griffin's new party, British Voice
- Ronnie Alte - until recently the leader of the Norwegian Defence League, a street movement modelled on the EDL said to have influenced mass murdered Anders Behring Breivik
- Craig Farnsworth - a member of several far right groups in the Bolton area including the English Defence League, the Infidels (a National Front spin off), the British National Party and its splinter group the British Voice.
- Steven Barker - member of the English Volunteer Force, a splinter group of the English Defence League who model themselves on paramilitaries in Northern Ireland.
- Billy Charlton - a long term member of the English Defence League’s Sunderland Division.[28]
- Matthew Pope - reportedly a devout Christian, a fan of the British national Party, the English Defence League and Britain First on facebook and formerly the administrator of a page called 'Ban Islam'. Described as official spokesperson for 28 February 2015 demonstration[47]
- Marion Rogers - reportedly 'Proprietor of JR Flat Roofing in Redruth'[48]. Described as a spokesperson for 28 February 2015 demonstration[49]
Resources
- Ingo Shulze, Pegida: Germany’s useful idiots, The Guardian, 1 February 2015.
- Who goes to German Pegida 'anti-Islamisation' rallies?, BBC News, 13 January 2015, accessed 3 February 2015.
- POSITIONSPAPIER der PEGIDA, PEGIDA position paper [in German].
Affiliations
- Alternative for Germany (AfD)
- National Democratic Party (NPD)
- Hooligans Against Salafists (HoGeSa)
- Fist of the East
- Hooligans Elbflorenz
- Skinheads Sächsische Schweiz
- BAEGIDA | KOEGIDA | DÜGIDA | KAGIDA | LEGIDA
- Pegida UK | Pegida Norge | Pegida Swerige | Pegida Danmark | PEGIDA France | Pegida Österreich
Notes
- Jump up ↑ MP Geert Wilders, Chairman, Netherlands Party for Freedom, Facing Jihad, accessed 25 February 2008.
- ↑ Jump up to: 2.00 2.01 2.02 2.03 2.04 2.05 2.06 2.07 2.08 2.09 2.10 2.11 2.12 2.13 2.14 2.15 2.16 2.17 2.18 The End of Tolerance? Anti-Muslim Movement Rattles Germany, Spiegel Online International, 21 December 2014, accessed 5 January 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 Lizzie Dearden, Germany anti-Islam protests: 17,000 march on Dresden against 'Islamification of the West', The Independent, 23 December 2014, accessed 5 Jan 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 Baron Bodissey,Refusing the Islamization of France, Gates of Vienna, 1 January 2015, accessed 5 January 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 Anti-Islamization protests expand in Germany, DW.de, 7 December 2014, accessed 6 January 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 6.0 6.1 Alison Smale, In German City Rich With History and Tragedy, Tide Rises Against Immigration, New York Times, 7 December 2014, accessed 6 January 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 Adam Withnall, Germany sees 'visible rise' in support for far-right extremism in response to perceived 'Islamisation' of the West, The Independent, 15 December 2014, accessed 5 Jan 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 8.0 8.1 8.2 Adam Withnall, Dresden march: Germans warned not to heed 'Nazis in pinstripes' as 10,000 turn out for 'anti-Islam' protest, The Independent, 16 December 2014, accessed 5 Jan 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 9.0 9.1 Oliver Lane, Up to 20,000 walk in largest anti-Islamisation march yet in Germany Breitbart News, 6 January 2015, accessed 7 January 2015
- Jump up ↑ Pegida loses second leader in a week, Reuters/The Guardian, 28 January 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 11.0 11.1 Thousands of Germans protest against anti-Islam rallies, Daily Mail, 5 January 2015, accessed 5 January 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 12.0 12.1 Jenny Hill, Germany Pegida: Leader Kathrin Oertel quits protest group, BBC News, 28 January 2015
- Jump up ↑ Ingo Shulze, Pegida: Germany’s useful idiots, The Guardian, 1 february 2015
- Jump up ↑ Gone boy on the right, The Economist, 24 January 2015
- Jump up ↑ Charlie Hebdo attack: German lawmakers warn against xenophobia, Deutsche Welle, 8 January 2015, accessed 3 February 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 16.0 16.1 16.2 PEGIDA leader Kathrin Oertel resigns one week after founder quits, CBC, 28 January 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 17.0 17.1 17.2 17.3 Germany’s Pegida leader steps down over Adolf Hitler photo, Guardian, 21 January 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 18.0 18.1 18.2 18.3 Pegida spokeswoman quits group: report], The Local.de, 28 January 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 19.0 19.1 19.2 19.3 Melissa Eddy, Citing Fear of Neo-Nazi Group, a German Mayor Quits, New York Times, 11 March 2015
- Jump up ↑ Pegida loses second leader in a week, Reuters/The Guardian, 28 January 2015
- Jump up ↑ Tony Patterson, Pegida movement on verge of implosion as five of its leading members resign in disgust due to fears of being taken over by Germany's far right, The Independent, 29 January 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 22.0 22.1 22.2 22.3 Pegida offshoot set to demo next week], The Local.de, 2 Feb 2015, accessed 2 Feb 2015
- Jump up ↑ Pegida leader 'paid court costs with group's money', The Local, 26 October 2016. Accessed 03 November 2016.
- Jump up ↑ German Court Upholds Fine Against PEGIDA Anti-Islamist Movement Leader, Sputnik News, December 1 2016. Accessed 21 December 2016.
- Jump up ↑ Finding PEGIDA, Gates of Vienna, 27 December 2014, accessed 5 January 2015
- Jump up ↑ Tony Patterson, Pegida movement on verge of implosion as five of its leading members resign in disgust due to fears of being taken over by Germany's far right, The Independent, 29 January 2015
- Jump up ↑ Screengrab of Pegida UK's facebook page on 7 January 2015, Powerbase, 7 January 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 28.0 28.1 Gary Hastings, PEGIDA UK – A MIDDLE CLASS PROTEST GROUP OR A FRONT FOR THE FAR RIGHT?, EDL News, 10 January 2015, accessed 12 January 2015
- Jump up ↑ Ian Hughes, Newcastle Pegida rally: RECAP on first UK protest by anti-Islam movement, The Mirror, 28 February 1015
- Jump up ↑ Dominic Smith, Far-right Pegida eclipsed by its opponents at first UK demo, The guardian, 28 February 2015, accessed 27 March 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 31.0 31.1 Anti-Islam march to go ahead in Oslo, The Local, 19 January 2015
- Jump up ↑ Anti-Islam group loses support in Norway, The Local, 20 January, accessed 13 February 2015
- ↑ Jump up to: 33.0 33.1 Linda Pershing, First Anti-Islam March by Pegida Movement Fizzles in Denmark, TruthOut, 29 January 2015
- Jump up ↑ PEGIDA and counter-demonstrations come to Austria, Deutsche Welle, 2 February 2015, accessed 3 February 2015
- Jump up ↑ Rosie WaitesPegida in Linz meets fierce resistance, The Local, 8 February 2015
- Jump up ↑ Merkel criticizes anti-Islam PEGIDA movement in New Year's speech, DW.de, 31 December 2014, accessed 6 January 2015
- Jump up ↑ Tony Patterson, Pegida movement on verge of implosion as five of its leading members resign in disgust due to fears of being taken over by Germany's far right, The Independent, 29 January 2015
- Jump up ↑ Chris Tomlinson, PEGIDA’s Bachmann Salutes America, Invites AfD Leader Petry To Speak, Breitbart, 16 November 2016. accessed November 28 2016.
- Jump up ↑ Tom Porter, Founder of far right Pegida group banned from leading rallies, International Business Times, November 8, 2016. Accessed November 28 2016.
- Jump up ↑ Ben Knight, PEGIDA splintered as conflicting demos staged in Dresden, Deutsche Welle, 27 September 2016. Accessed 07 October 2016.
- Jump up ↑ Anti-Islam demos spread to Berlin, The Local, 5 January 2015, accessed 6 January 2015.
- ↑ Jump up to: 42.0 42.1 Baron Bodissey, An Israeli Addresses PEGIDA], Gates of Vienna, 28 January 2015
- Jump up ↑ Malcolm Brabant, Sweden 'doesn't need groups like PEGIDA', Deutsche Welle, 10 February 2015, accessed 12 February 2015
- Jump up ↑ Baron Bod Sweden: "We want thousands against the Islamisation of Sweden," says Swedish PEGIDA founder, YouTube, published 5 January 2015, accessed 7 January 2015
- Jump up ↑ Thousands gather to oppose Pegida demo, Radio Sweden, 9 February 2015
- Jump up ↑ Vienna's Pegida spokesman steps down, The Local, 4 February 2015
- Jump up ↑ Shane Croucher, Pegida UK promoter Matthew Pope wants Islam banned and has far-right links, IBTimes, 12 February 2015
- Jump up ↑ Derek Fender, PEGIDA UK MANAGE TO ATTRACT FOUR DEMONSTRATORS TO THEIR SCOTLAND DEMO, EDLNews, 22 March 2015
- Jump up ↑ 'Anti-Islamisation' group Pegida UK holds Newcastle march, BBC News Online, 28 February 2015, accessed 27 March 2015