Hilltop Youth
Loosely organised young Israeli settlers on unauthorised West Bank outposts, linked to price-tag attacks; not a Chabad movement
The Hilltop Youth (Hebrew: No'ar HaGvaot) are loosely organised young Israeli settlers who set up unauthorised outposts in the West Bank and are linked to "price tag" attacks on Palestinians and, at times, on Israeli security forces.[1][2] They are a phenomenon of the settler movement, not an organisation and not a branch of Chabad-Lubavitch. Tessa Satherley writes that, unlike Gush Emunim, "no formal organizational structure coordinates or directs the hilltop movement".[2]
Yitzhak Ginsburgh, a self-identified Chabad Hasid and the spiritual leader of the Od Yosef Chai Yeshiva in the settlement of Yitzhar, has had a substantial influence on the worldview of some of these youths.[3][4][5][6]
Character and origins
Satherley, in her 2015 University of Melbourne doctoral thesis, describes the outposts as generally independent of the settler establishment (the Yesha Council and Amana) and without permits. The lifestyle is "frugal, seeking authenticity and spiritual connection to the land", with the "guiding hope" that the outposts will become permanent settlements that "can never be handed over to a future Palestinian state". Hilltop Youth "often see their activities as a revival of the tradition of Gush Emunim in its heyday of pioneering chutzpah (the late 1960s and 1970s)". Outpost communities "seem to have begun crystallizing in the early 1990s, perhaps in response to the First Intifada and the Oslo process, and the phenomenon expanded tremendously after the 2005 Hitnatkut".[2]
She reports socio-psychological findings that many of the youths show a "perpetual sense of friction and insecurity" formed during the Second Intifada; a wish to implement what they see as the core norms of the settler movement, which they believe "the 'grown-ups'" have failed to do; "not infrequently, histories of social and family problems"; and individualism, "with most making the decision to move to the hills without encouragement from--and sometimes in opposition to--their parents". Many come "seeking belonging after failing to 'fit in' at formal educational institutions". The milieu can "at least partly be characterized as anti-intellectual".[2][7] Trust in Israeli law-enforcement institutions was already low in the early 2000s and was further eroded by the disengagement. In the outposts, she quotes Moti Feige, "Israeli law is considered little more than a courteous recommendation, and respect for state institutions is practically nonexistent."[7]
Motti Inbari writes that Yitzhak Ginzburg (his spelling) "is considered an important spiritual and ideological authority among the so-called hill dwellers, who are also sometimes known, due to their relative youth, as the Youth of the Hills". He describes "a group of people aged nineteen to thirty who live on temporary, often unlawful, outposts established on hilltops around Judea and Samaria", estimated at "a few hundred activists", forming "the fringe of the settler movement" and "perceived as a radical ideological faction that is willing to accept a hard and ascetic lifestyle."[8]
Colin Shindler traces one source of inspiration to the Kahane camp: after Meir Kahane's assassination, "Kahane's son and a younger group of followers established Kahane Hai, which in turn inspired the Hilltop Youth of the twenty-first century to erect makeshift unauthorised outposts on the West Bank."[9] That is a statement about the Kahane legacy, not about Chabad.
Two streams after 2005
Satherley writes that many of the youths rejected the mainstream religious-Zionist rabbis who had called for calm during the 2005 disengagement. "Two religio-ideological streams began to fill the void opened by this crumbling of traditional religious Zionist rabbinical authority: i) the Od Yosef Chai yeshiva and Ginsburgh's brand of Hasidism, and ii) the community dedicated to the legacy of the late Rabbi Meir Kahane (leader of the Kach movement and Jewish Defense League, both of which are officially terrorist organizations)." Rabbis, yeshiva students and activists attached to these two spheres have been, in her account, "the outposts' most constant sources of solidarity, religious legitimation, and practical assistance (e.g., arranging legal aid when youths are apprehended for attacking Arabs or damaging IDF property)".[10]
She stresses the limit of that connection: "Od Yosef Chai and the Hilltop Youth around Yitzhar are meaningfully connected; however, it is not clear that this connection is one of authority and direction." The former head of the junior yeshiva attached to Od Yosef Chai and rabbi of Yitzhar, David Dudkovitz, told her that some of the local Hilltop Youth accepted his halakhic authority and others did not, and that it was "not a formal arrangement of supervision and authority. The youth choose their own path--and whom they'll listen to." The yeshiva nonetheless "confers practical and ideological support (if not authority)" to militant youth.[3]
Her conclusion is that "Ginsburgh and Od Yosef Chai have a substantial influence in shaping the worldview of some Hilltop Youth, although the youths do not necessarily accept them as halakhic authorities". She adds that this distinction matters because Ginsburgh's teachings, as she reads them, "praise unreflective, impulsive violence" in a milieu that already has "weak halakhic restraints" because of its rejection of rabbinical authority.[4]
Ginsburgh, Od Yosef Chai and Chabad
Ginsburgh is a self-identified adherent of Chabad-Lubavitch and lives in Kfar Chabad. Biale and his co-authors describe him as loosely affiliated with Chabad, still considering himself a Chabad Hasid, but as having "carved out a partially autonomous niche for himself as a kind of rebbe". The Forward reports that "to this day he considers himself part of Chabad even though, to a significant extent, he has diverged from the Chabad doctrine and created one of his own."[5][6]
David Biale and his co-authors, in Hasidism: A New History, write that there are "Hasidim or quasi-Hasidim, especially associated with Chabad and Bratslav, in some of the illegal 'hilltop' settlements in the West Bank. These youngsters are for the most part of religious Zionist background and are not recognized as Hasidim by the mainstream Hasidic communities." They describe Ginsburgh as "loosely affiliated with Chabad but [serving] as a quasi-rebbe to certain elements in the settlement community."[11] In their later discussion they call him "another quasi-Hasidic figure with ties to Chabad" who "still considers himself a Chabad Hasid and lives in Kfar Chabad" but has "carved out a partially autonomous niche for himself as a kind of rebbe". "These followers include the so-called hilltop youth, young Orthodox and ultra-Orthodox Jews who have built themselves residences in sites in the West Bank (or Judaea and Samaria), often in opposition to government policy. They are a highly volatile and at times violent group, which follows its own eclectic and even antinomian version of halakhah. Ginsburgh has had a major influence on this group in part through the Od Yosef Hai yeshivah."[5] They add that although "many individual Hasidim, especially those connected with Chabad, may share these kind of extreme views", "no Hasidic group as such embraces such politics or the violence that at times accompanies it."[5]
The Forward (Natan Odenheimer, 2016) writes that "Ginsburgh's students include the so-called Hilltop Youth". It describes Meir Ettinger, a grandson of Meir Kahane, as "a prize student of Ginsburgh" who "remain[s] a close associate". Ettinger's wife told an interviewer that he "gets all of his ideas from him [Ginsburgh]". In a 2014 letter Ginsburgh called Jewish terror attacks "uncontrolled reactions of youngsters who care about Israel", arguing that the remedy was for the state to accept that the whole land "belongs solely to the Nation of Israel". The Forward added that in recent years he "has somewhat toned down his violent rhetoric, even decrying the use of violence".[6]
In May 2014 Haaretz, citing Israeli security officials, estimated that close to 100 activists, mostly from Yitzhar and the hilltop outposts, were behind a wave of "price tag" hate crimes, and that they based their acts on Ginsburgh's ideas.[12]
"Price tag" attacks
BBC News (17 September 2012) described "price-tag" tactics as attacks by West Bank Jewish settlers, often after Israeli authorities dismantled unauthorised outposts, aimed at exacting a "price" from Palestinians or from the state.[1] The 2014 Haaretz report cited above concerns a wave of such attacks and the security officials' estimate of the number of activists involved.[12] Satherley also reviews clashes around Yitzhar and the 2014-15 Border Police occupation of the Od Yosef Chai building, which the army, according to Haaretz, chose because it was described by an "army source" as a "front base for violent operations against the nearby Palestinian villages and the security services."[13]
See also
- Yitzhak Ginsburgh
- Od Yosef Chai Yeshiva
- Yitzhak Shapira
- Torat Hamelekh
- Yeshivat Shavei Hevron
- Chabad in occupied Palestine
- Meir Ettinger
- Meir Kahane
- Gush Emunim
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 "'Price-tag' tactics of West Bank Jewish settlers", BBC News, 17 September 2012, accessed 16 November 2026.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 Tessa Dawn Satherley, Unity and opposites in Israel's settler movement: Rabbi Tzvi Yisrael Tau & Rabbi Yitzchak Ginsburgh, PhD thesis, School of Historical and Philosophical Studies, University of Melbourne, August 2015, p. 180.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 Satherley (2015), p. 184.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 Satherley (2015), p. 195.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 Biale et al., Hasidism: A New History, 2018, pp. 797-798.
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 Natan Odenheimer, "The Kabbalist Who Would Be King of a New Jewish Monarchy in Israel", Forward, 14 October 2016, accessed 16 November 2026.
- ↑ 7.0 7.1 Satherley (2015), p. 181, quoting Moti Feige, Settling in the Hearts (2009), p. 237.
- ↑ Motti Inbari, Jewish Fundamentalism and the Temple Mount, Albany: State University of New York Press, 2009, p. 132. Inbari spells the name Ginzburg.
- ↑ Colin Shindler, The Rise of the Israeli Right: From Odessa to Hebron, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015, p. 336.
- ↑ Satherley (2015), p. 183.
- ↑ David Biale, David Assaf, Benjamin Brown, Uriel Gellman, Samuel Heilman, Moshe Rosman, Gadi Sagiv and Marcin Wodzinski, Hasidism: A New History, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2018, p. 710.
- ↑ 12.0 12.1 Amos Harel, Revital Hovel and Jack Khoury, "Security Sources: 100 Followers of Racist Rabbi Are Behind Hate Crimes", Haaretz, 8 May 2014, accessed 16 November 2026.
- ↑ Satherley (2015), p. 194, quoting Gili Cohen and Chaim Levinson, "Israeli army deploys Border Police company in Yitzhar", Haaretz, 11 April 2014.