Crown Heights riot
Three days of violence in Crown Heights, Brooklyn, in August 1991, after a car in the Lubavitcher Rebbe's motorcade killed Gavin Cato and a mob killed Yankel Rosenbaum; called a "riot", a "rebellion" or a "pogrom" depending on the speaker
| Crown Heights riot (1991) | |
| Date | 19–22 August 1991 (violence largely ended by 23 August) |
|---|---|
| Place | Crown Heights, Brooklyn, New York City |
| Trigger | Death of Gavin Cato (7), struck by a car in the motorcade of Menachem Mendel Schneerson |
| Deaths | Gavin Cato; Yankel Rosenbaum (stabbed); see also Bracha Estrin |
| Injuries | "Over 150 police officers and at least thirty-eight civilians" (Girgenti Report) |
| Official inquiry | Girgenti Report (July 1993), 2 vols |
| Other names | Crown Heights riots; Crown Heights disturbances; Crown Heights pogrom; Crown Heights rebellion/uprising |
The Crown Heights riot (also called the Crown Heights riots, disturbances, pogrom or rebellion) was three days and nights of violence in the Crown Heights neighbourhood of Brooklyn, New York, in August 1991. On the evening of 19 August a station wagon in the motorcade of the Lubavitcher Rebbe, Menachem Mendel Schneerson, went through the intersection of Utica Avenue and President Street, was struck by another car and mounted the pavement, killing seven-year-old Gavin Cato, the son of Guyanese immigrants, and badly injuring his cousin Angela.[1] Rumours that the Hatzolah ambulance had taken away the Hasidic driver while leaving the Black children to die "fueled the disturbance for three days", according to the New York State inquiry.[1] About three hours later Yankel Rosenbaum, a 29-year-old Australian Jewish scholar, was stabbed by a group of young Black men and died. Over the following days roving groups attacked Jewish homes, people and cars, threw rocks and bottles at police, and looted shops; the state's Girgenti Report counted "over 150 police officers and at least thirty-eight civilians" injured and found that the city's response was "inadequate" until the fourth day.[2][3]
What to call the events remains contested. Lubavitch Hasidim and many Jewish commentators call them a pogrom; many Black residents and activists speak of a "riot" or "rebellion" against what they saw as police and state favouritism towards the Hasidim. The anthropologist Henry Goldschmidt argues that the two framings rest on different understandings of "race" and "religion" in the neighbourhood.[4] The events damaged Mayor David Dinkins, New York's first Black mayor, who lost the 1993 election to Rudy Giuliani, and the role of the Rev. Al Sharpton, who gave the eulogy at Gavin Cato's funeral, has been argued over ever since.
Background
Lubavitch and its neighbours
Crown Heights became the world headquarters of Chabad-Lubavitch after Yosef Yitzchak Schneersohn settled at 770 Eastern Parkway in 1940. In the 1960s, as most white Jewish residents left for the suburbs and the neighbourhood became predominantly Black and Afro-Caribbean, the Lubavitchers stayed. Goldschmidt writes that "the Lubavitch Hasidim, a tight-knit community of orthodox Jews, chose to stay in Crown Heights in the late 1960s when nearly all of their White Jewish neighbors chose to leave", and dates the decisive moment to "the spring of 1969, when the Lubavitcher Rebbe declared that his community would stay in Crown Heights as it became a predominantly Black neighborhood".[5][6]
In the Chabad-side account published by Chabad.org for the 30th anniversary, the Rebbe told a gathering on the last day of Passover, 10 April 1969: "A phenomenon has recently spread among the Jewish people, like a plague, G‑d forbid, of abandoning Jewish neighborhoods".[7] The same piece describes a meeting between the Rebbe and Mayor John Lindsay on 26 November 1968 at which Lindsay pledged support "for the Rebbe's stabilization efforts, including security and policing", and records that "during the 15 years preceding the 1991 riot, at least 10 members of the Crown Heights Jewish community were murdered".[7] The historian Edward S. Shapiro gives the same figure: "In the decade and a half prior to the 1991 riot, at least ten Lubavitchers were murdered in Crown Heights".[8] He describes the Rebbe's 1969 address, given "during the 1969 Passover holiday" before three thousand followers, as "an unequivocal statement ... on the necessity of remaining in Crown Heights".[9] Goldschmidt notes that, following the Rebbe's 1969 call, the Crown Heights Jewish Community Council in the 1970s worked with Hasidic developers to form Chevra Machazikei Hashchuna, the Coalition to Strengthen the Neighborhood.[10]
In his 1981 doctoral history of the Jewish Defense League (JDL), written from close to the League, Shlomo Russ traces an earlier conflict over the anti-poverty Crown Heights Community Corporation. He writes that "Only the Hasidim remained, most of them followers of the Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Menachem Schneerson", and that "Rabbi Schneerson had long fought for Jews to remain in Crown Heights". The Jewish Community Council challenged the October 1967 corporation elections, alleging intimidation of Jewish voters, and the challenge was upheld in April 1968.[11] Russ records that "JDL was called to protect the Jewish poll watchers" at the February 1969 elections. In March 1970 armed JDL members went to the corporation's office after it was taken over by a group led by Robert (Sonny) Carson.[12] In 1970 JDL members also planned a bombing in Crown Heights in retaliation for the burning of a Jewish communal office. The plan was dropped after the Palestinian hijackings of September 1970.[13] Russ describes these events largely from the JDL's side; the Black accounts are not represented in his narrative.
Grievances and policing
The Girgenti Report summarised the background as "charges and counter charges of preferential treatment and inequity in City services, a 'double standard' in law enforcement, and an intense fear of crime and resentment of defensive actions against it". It added that "the conscious decision of the Lubavitchers to stay increased the competition for government-funded resources, especially for housing", sharpened by the creation of Community Board 9.[14]
Shapiro calls housing the most important of these issues. The high Lubavitch birth rate pushed up prices and rents. Black residents accused Lubavitch landlords of refusing to rent to Black tenants and of forcing them out, and the Rev. Clarence Norman, Sr., of the First Baptist Church said: "The Hasidim are discriminatory." Shapiro answers that the Lubavitchers "lacked the financial resources to monopolize the housing market", but concedes: "Norman was not entirely wrong. Jewish real estate entrepreneurs did seek, when possible, to reserve Crown Heights rental units to Lubavitch families."[15] Lubavitchers knocking on Black neighbours' doors to ask whether houses were for sale caused particular resentment. In August 1987 Mayor Koch wrote to Rabbi Joseph Spielman that "This type of persistent and unwelcome solicitation of homeowners ... constitutes a form of harassment that can only lead to increased tension". The Lubavitch saw it as "simply the way a free market is supposed to operate", and Spielman said "no malice" was intended.[15][16] In 1977 the Lubavitch area was separated from Community Planning Board 8 and placed in Board 9. That board was "initially controlled by the Lubavitch", with Rabbi Jacob Goldstein as chairman. Shapiro writes that Black residents "charged, not without justification", that a disproportionate share of anti-poverty funds went to Lubavitch institutions, although that influence had "dissipated" by 1991.[16] When Daughtry alleged collusion between the Lubavitch and city hall after the riot, Shapiro judged it "highly unlikely" because "both the mayor and his first deputy were black".[16]
Black residents pointed to the 1978 death of Arthur Miller, "a prominent businessman and Crown Heights civic leader", who died "while struggling with police", and to the Hasidic anti-crime patrols, which "they maintain, are little more than a vigilante group set up to harass black men". In June 1978 "members of a Hasidic anti-crime patrol beat a sixteen-year old black youth and he fell into a coma", leading to a march of two thousand Black residents. Lubavitchers, for their part, said their appearance made them "inviting targets for robbery, bias crimes and other forms of anti-semitic harassment"; in January 1988 about 200 of them "'stormed' the 71st Precinct" to demand more protection.[17] Shapiro records that in 1978 "a group of young Lubavitchers beat Victor Rhodes for allegedly knocking the skullcap off the head of a Hasid", and that Rhodes "lay in a partial coma for two months"; in 1986 "a black teenager was beaten with a bat, hammer, and hose by three members of a Lubavitch anticrime patrol".[18][8] He writes that the patrols, begun in the 1960s, "had ignored the guidelines for patrols laid down by the police", and that Rabbi Yehuda Krinsky, a Lubavitch spokesman, "denied that those manning the patrols were a vigilante group".[19]
The Black pastor and activist Herbert Daughtry, in a first-hand account written as an activist participant in the events, describes the police car stationed outside the Rebbe's home: "We complained bitterly that this was preferential treatment."[20] He attributes the explosion of August 1991 to "years of built up rage derived from a double standard and preferential treatment accorded the Hasidim — which includes everything from immigration laws and services to special treatment by law enforcement".[21] A BlackPast.org entry states that "black residents had voiced resentment that Jews had received special protections from law enforcement due to a police redistricting decision in 1976".[22]
Shapiro traces the escort to threats from the rival Satmar Hasidim. In the 1970s, after clashes that included "the burning of effigies of Schneerson in Williamsburg", the police "began protecting Schneerson and Lubavitch headquarters around the clock". Mayor Ed Koch removed the police presence in front of 770 Eastern Parkway after taking office in 1978, but "when death threats were made against Schneerson in 1981 by Satmar zealots, Koch assigned a patrol car to accompany the Rebbe to the Lubavitch cemetery in Queens". In Shapiro's view, "had blacks been aware of the history of Lubavitch-Satmar relations, they would not have so readily accused the police of favoring the Lubavitch"; for black residents, he writes, the police car nonetheless "symbolized the special privileges accorded the Lubavitchers by city hall", as Schneerson was "the only religious figure in the city with such an entitlement".[23] On 17 October 1991 Police Commissioner Lee Brown announced a "strategic deployment" that "eliminated the heavy concentration of police around 770 Eastern Parkway".[24]
The Village Voice's Michael Kamber, writing in 2002, cited a 1984 Carnegie Corporation report describing the neighbourhood as "awash in a sea of ethnocentrism, prejudice, and violent conflict", and listed "the Jewish Defense League patrols accused of randomly harassing Black residents, the struggles over housing, the fight for control of federal poverty grants, and an epidemic of street crime".[25] The Chabad.org account, by contrast, stresses blockbusting and violent crime against Jews, including the 1975 murder of Holocaust survivor Israel Turner, at whose funeral there were shouts of "Heil Hitler".[7]
The summer of 1991
In the weeks before the riot the City College professor Leonard Jeffries had been widely criticised for remarks about Jews. In July 1991, according to a reference biography, "he gave a speech in Albany, New York, that many considered antiwhite and, especially, anti-Semitic"; CUNY later cut his term as department chairman, and a federal jury in 1993 found this had violated his First Amendment rights.[26] The Anti-Defamation League (ADL), in a 1992 advocacy report, quoted an Amsterdam News editorial of 17 August 1991, two days before the accident, warning of "the conflagration that will surely come should any kind of incident occur, by accident or design, that threatens the well-being of Professor Jeffries".[27] Philip Gourevitch, writing in the neoconservative Commentary in 1993, argued that "anti-Semitism was in the ether" and that Black newspapers including the Amsterdam News and the City Sun had defended Jeffries.[28] The New York Times reported that in his Albany lecture of 20 July Jeffries spoke of "a conspiracy, planned and plotted and programmed out of Hollywood," by "people called Greenberg and Weisberg and Trigliani".[29] Among those Gourevitch lists as having defended Jeffries that August was Sharpton.[28]
19 August 1991
The death of Gavin Cato
According to the Girgenti Report, at about 8.20 pm "an Hasidic driver, part of a procession escorting the Lubavitcher Grand Rebbe, struck and killed seven-year-old Gavin Cato at President Street and Utica Avenue. Gavin's cousin Angela Cato was seriously injured. People on the street reacted by attacking the car's occupants."[1] The Rebbe was returning from the Old Montefiore Cemetery in Queens, where he had visited the graves of his wife, Chaya Mushka, and of his father-in-law and predecessor, Yosef Yitzchak Schneersohn. A police car from the 71st Precinct accompanied him; Shapiro writes that the police had provided this protection "for about a decade" and that it "resulted from the political influence of the Lubavitch community". The third car, a station wagon "containing four young members of the Lubavitch community", followed his car "to provide security".[30][31] The police escort to the Lubavitch cemetery in Queens "was eliminated after the 1991 riot".[32] Goldschmidt describes the sequence: "The police car and the Rebbe's car passed through the intersection of Utica and President without incident ... But the station-wagon entered the intersection through a red or yellow traffic light—depending who you ask—and was struck by a car heading north on Utica."[33] The driver was Yosef Lifsh (also spelled Lifsch), a 22-year-old Israeli Lubavitcher.[34]
Black and Jewish accounts dispute almost every detail. Goldschmidt records that "a number of witnesses claimed the car ... was hurtling down President Street at speeds up to 65 miles per hour", and some claimed Lifsh was drunk, whereas an accident reconstruction expert hired by his lawyers "estimated his speed at 30 to 35 miles per hour" and he and the police "vehemently denied the charge that he had been drinking".[35][36] Shapiro sets out the range: spectators' estimates ran "from twenty-five miles to sixty-five miles per hour"; Lifsh's expert put the speed at "no more than thirty to thirty-five miles per hour"; and an expert hired by the Kings County District Attorney's office "calculated the speed at between forty-five to fifty miles per hour". He adds that "most reports agreed that it exceeded the speed limit of thirty miles per hour".[37] Lifsh was given a breath-alcohol test "seventy minutes after the accident"; "the test results were negative".[38] Of the rumours that followed (that the car had deliberately run the children down, that Lifsh was drunk or unlicensed, and that Hatzolah had refused to help Gavin), Shapiro writes: "None of these were correct, but all fueled the growing fury in Crown Heights."[39] He is equally sceptical of Lubavitch claims that Lifsh had been commended by the fire department for rescuing two black children: "Investigators, however, could find no record of this".[40] At the time, Deputy Mayor Milton Mollen said the driver "was tested and found not to be intoxicated".[41] For many Black residents, Goldschmidt writes, "the Rebbe's police escort—the patrol car leading the motorcade—[was] a clear sign of the 'preferential treatment' Lubavitchers have long been thought to receive from local police and other state agencies".[42]
Hatzolah and the ambulance dispute
What Hatzolah is
Hatzolah (Hatzoloh, Hatzalah) is a Jewish volunteer emergency medical service. The Girgenti Report describes it as "a privately funded, all-volunteer service started by the Hasidic community in New York City", adding that "some leaders in the black community maintain that the ambulance service caters exclusively to the Jewish community".[17][14] A 2015 trade-press profile records that "Hatzalah started in Williamsburg in 1965, after a prominent member of the Hasidic Jewish community had a heart attack and died while waiting for an ambulance to arrive", and that "Hasidic communities in other neighborhoods — like Crown Heights and Borough Park — frustrated by slow responses to 911 calls, began to copy the model". The service is free, and states that its mission is to "treat all in need, regardless of race, religion, or ethnicity", a claim some Black residents doubt: "I've never seen them pick up nobody of color," a resident of 39 years told the reporter. It is regulated like other volunteer ambulances, and in 2010 it received "a $445,000 grant from the New York State Assembly" for its dispatch system.[43] Its all-male membership has also drawn criticism: in 2019 a regional council refused an ambulance to Ezras Nashim, an all-women Hasidic group in Borough Park, whose members said the board was "packed with sympathizers of Hatzolah", which had "forcefully opposed its female counterpart's right to exist"; a board member who voted against replied: "This has nothing to do with Hatzolah."[44] The Chabad.org account traces the Crown Heights branch to the 1976 death of the community activist Samuel Schrage, after which his widow "spearheaded a campaign to purchase the first-ever ambulance for Crown Heights' nascent Hatzalah volunteer emergency medi[cal service]", following city paramedics who "came late and apparently under the influence of drugs or alcohol".[7] Daughtry, a critic, records that Black residents objected to "the ambulance and the police car parked in front of the Lubavitcher headquarters and the home of the Grand Rebbe, respectively", and disputes that the ambulance was wholly privately funded: "part of the money came from the public".[20]
The ambulances that night
According to the Girgenti Report, Chaim (spelled "Chiam") Blachman, "an emergency medical technician for Hatzoloh, a voluntary Hasidic-run ambulance service", heard the call, and "within minutes of the accident, the Hatzoloh ambulance arrived". One of the first police officers on the scene said an unidentified Black man "was already giving Gavin Cato cardiopulmonary resuscitation" and that "the Hatzoloh ambulance was on the scene when he got there. It left moments late[r]".[45] The report's summary states: "The police ordered the Hasidic ambulance to carry away the car's Jewish occupants. This spurred a rumor that the Hasidic ambulance helped the Jews, and left the injured black children to die. That rumor, and others, fueled the disturbance for three days."[1] Goldschmidt writes that "the EMS paramedics treated the gravely injured Cato children on the spot, while the Hatzoloh paramedics brought the mildly injured driver and passengers to a nearby hospital", a "division of labor [that] fostered a widely shared, but hotly contested, perception that the Cato children and the Hasidim were given unequal medical care".[46]
The critics' case
For many Black residents the ambulance, more than the accident, was the grievance. A participant in the violence told Goldschmidt in 1998: "It was the disrespect of the Jewish ambulance coming along and totally disregarding two children lying under a car bleeding to death, and attending to the Jewish folks inside the car that had minimal damage. That's what created the whole scenario."[47] The Rev. Heron Sam of St Mark's Episcopal Church told the playwright Anna Deavere Smith: "When the [Hatzoloh] ambulance came, they were more concerned to take care of their own than to worry about some boy—some Black boy—who lay dying on the street."[47] The Girgenti Report found that this "widespread perception gave credence to the violence-inciting rumor".[14] A sign at the accident site, reported by the JTA, asked: "Where is the 'white' Jewish man who was taken away in the 'special' ambulance — unhandcuffed and escorted by the New York Police Department's finest?"[34] In his eulogy for Gavin Cato, as reprinted in the City Sun and quoted by Goldschmidt, Sharpton said: "It's an accident to allow an apartheid ambulance service in the middle of Crown Heights."[48] Goldschmidt notes that Lubavitchers' neighbours "tend to see them as a privileged White minority operating an 'apartheid ambulance service'".[49][50]
The Hatzolah and Jewish response
The JTA reported Jewish residents' account that "the Hatzoloh driver was told by the police to 'take your guys and leave'", while the city ambulance crew treated the children.[34] Goldschmidt summarises the Hasidic position: the volunteers "arrived at the scene of the accident just moments—not minutes—before the EMS ambulances, and were explicitly instructed by the police to remove the injured Hasidim from the scene, out of a justified fear for their safety, and in an attempt to calm the angry crowd".[36] Gourevitch, writing for Commentary, likewise states that Lifsh "was set upon by angry black bystanders who beat and robbed him before the police could reach the scene" and that "police, seeking to remove the object of the crowd's anger, directed the crew to take away Lifsh and his passengers".[28] The Lubavitch view, as Goldschmidt puts it, is that "the death of Gavin Cato was a tragic accident, and nothing more".[36]
The killing of Yankel Rosenbaum
About three hours after the accident, Yankel Rosenbaum, a 29-year-old doctoral student from Melbourne, was attacked a few blocks away. Volume II of the Girgenti Report states that "a group of young black men reportedly shouted, 'There's the Jew. Get the Jew.' Two of the stab wounds punctured Rosenbaum's lungs, causing him to bleed to death. The police apprehended a sixteen-year-old black man named Lemrick Nelson within moments of the crime."[51] Rosenbaum died at Kings County Hospital, where, the defence later argued, negligence had caused his death; the report devotes a section to "The Negligence of Kings County Hospital".[52] The state Health Department's Statement of Deficiencies of 23 September 1991 found that "The patient was not provided care that meets generally acceptable standards of professional practice", agreeing with the hospital's own internal investigation that improper medical care, and not the severity of his wounds, was responsible for his death.[53] One of the three stab wounds in his chest was not detected until 12.30 am, his vital signs were not monitored, and he was pronounced dead at 2.25 am.[54] A city inquiry by the special counsel Stanley H. Lowell, reporting on 1 November 1991, described "administrative disorganization," "lack of accountability," and "departmental fragmentation" at the hospital.[55] In June 2005 the city's Health and Hospitals Corporation settled the family's malpractice suit for $1,250,000 with the statement that "diagnostic and treatment errors made during the emergency room care provided to Yankel Rosenbaum in the hours after his stabbing played a role in his death".[56] The JTA quoted Jewish community representatives stressing "that while both deaths both tragic, one was accidental and the other a deliberate murder".[34]
The three days of violence
The Girgenti Report describes "the most extensive racial unrest New York City has experienced in over twenty years".[57] It records that "members of the Jewish community were harassed and assaulted as roving bands of black youths traveled through the neighborhood, sometimes shouting anti-semitic slurs. Rocks were thrown through windows and passing motorists were attacked. Several stores were looted and numerous cars were damaged."[58] It identified "twenty-seven bias crimes ... in the 71st Precinct, including twenty-one anti-semitic, three anti-black, and three anti-white incidents".[2]
Shapiro gives a day-by-day account. On the Monday night Charles Price began addressing the crowd at Utica Avenue at about 11 pm; witnesses recalled him saying "Do y'all feel what I feel? Do y'all feel the pain?" and "I'm going up to the Jew neighborhood! Who's with me?", after which groups moved west along President Street, attacking police and Lubavitch homes, and "One of the groups encountered Rosenbaum."[59] On Tuesday groups of Black youths and Hasidim "numbering in the hundreds threw rocks and bottles at one another", while marchers chanted "No justice, no peace!", "Whose streets? Our Streets!" and "Death to the Jews!"; after a rally addressed by Sharpton and Lenora Fulani, two hundred police officers "retreated rapidly" down Utica Avenue under bottles, bricks and gunfire, and only twelve arrests were made that day.[60]
At about 6 pm that Tuesday Isaac Bitton, a Moroccan immigrant, and his twelve-year-old son Yechiel were attacked on Schenectady Avenue after police at the corner told Bitton it was safe to walk home; the photograph of Yechiel crouched beside his injured father became "the riot's most famous photograph".[60] According to Shapiro, "The police saw the attack and, instead of coming to the Bittons' rescue, radioed for reinforcements"; the two were rescued by residents and reporters, several of them Black, including Peter Noel of the Village Voice, and "None of the perpetrators were arrested."[61] Isaac Bitton recalled that "a black guy, who was not with the mob, saved Yechiel and me".[62]
On Wednesday Sharpton and Alton Maddox gave the city seventy-two hours to arrest Lifsh, threatening a "citizens' arrest". Eight officers were wounded by shotgun pellets, police cars were overturned and a flag of the Zionist entity was burned, and marchers threw stones and bottles at 770 Eastern Parkway while shouting "Heil Hitler"; "While the Hasidim did not stage counter-demonstrations, they did throw rocks and bottles in response."[61][63] On Thursday 1,800 officers were deployed and order was restored. Shapiro writes that the calm was also helped by "a meeting between the Lubavitchers and representatives of the Cato family held at the office of the National Committee for the Furtherance of Jewish Education, a Lubavitch institution. At the meeting two candles were lit, one for Gavin Cato and the other for Yankel Rosenbaum."[64] Sharpton and Maddox refused the mayor's request to call off a march past Lubavitch headquarters on Saturday 24 August; 1,400 police lined the route, "Only four hundred persons marched, and two hundred and fifty of them had been bused in from Harlem", no member of the Cato family took part, and there were no incidents, although marchers shouted antisemitic slurs.[64][65]
Shapiro puts the toll at 152 police officers and at least 38 civilians injured, 27 police vehicles damaged or destroyed and nearly $7 million in costs.[65] In all, 129 people were arrested and 46 given summonses; more than 90 per cent were Black males under 25, and six were Hasidim. Fifteen were charged with felonies, of whom six were convicted: four received probation and two were jailed for one to three years for burglary.[66]
On Tuesday 20 August Sharpton and others led a march; on the way back, the report says, "there was another confrontation between blacks and Hasidim. Twelve police officers and a civilian were injured."[67] Accounts of who threw first differ. The report quotes an observer that the "crowd of teenagers pelted the Hasidim one more time. This time the Jews retaliated with a fusillade of projectiles", records Sharpton's recollection that "rocks flew, but he was unsure who started it", and notes that the Amsterdam News reported "a barrage of rocks from Hasidic store owners".[68] On Wednesday marchers again went to the Lubavitch headquarters at 770 Eastern Parkway. The report says the police "could not control the marchers, many of whom pelted the building with rocks and bottles and chanted anti-semitic slogans"; the marchers also "burned an Israeli flag".[69][70]
The JTA reported on 22 August that the Crown Heights Jewish Community Council counted, for one night alone, "18 Hasidim injured, 50 Jewish-owned cars vandalized, a Lubavitch 'Mitzvah tank' destroyed and 60 Jewish homes damaged", and quoted Rabbi Shimon Hecht: "It was like Kristallnacht ... People were afraid for their lives."[34] Gourevitch reported signs reading "Hitler didn't do his job" and a rioter who told him: "Write this down. Jews are murderers. The black Hitler is coming this time."[28] On 26 August a 68-year-old Holocaust survivor, Brokha (Bracha) Estrin, died after apparently jumping from her window; Rabbi Shmuel Butman said she "had told neighbors that the recent escalation in neighborhood tension had become too much for her".[41] Butman also said that her death "was a direct result of fear placed on her by strangers outside of the community using Nazi tactics"; Shapiro calls such explanations "mere conjectures".[71] On 5 September 1991 Anthony Graziosi, a 67-year-old salesman with a white beard and dark suit, was shot dead at a red light at Rogers Avenue and Lincoln Place by one of four Black men; his wallet was not taken.[71][72] His family and their lawyer, Robert J. Miller, held that he had been mistaken for a Hasid ("Anthony Graziosi was killed because he looked like a Jew"), while the police treated it as a "bungled robbery attempt".[72][73] The only person charged, Carl Jeffrey Daniels, was acquitted in June 1992; in April 1993 Attorney General Janet Reno ordered the FBI to examine whether it was a bias crime, but "No federal indictments were ever handed down."[72][73]
The columnist Jimmy Breslin, who was beaten during the riot, later dismissed the scale of the events in an interview with the Village Voice: "There was no pogrom, there was no riot ... How many stores looted? Seven, seven stores, that's all."[25]
Police and the mayor
Mayor David Dinkins did not visit Crown Heights on the Tuesday; "Deputy Mayor Lynch told us that the Mayor and his advisors felt his presence might exacerbate the disturbance".[74] On Wednesday, after visiting the Cato family, he was met with bottles and rocks.[69] The Police Department's approach for the first three days, the report found, "was one of restraint, predicated upon the desire not to make things worse. What it failed to do was provide a tactical response for ending the violence. On Thursday, the approach of the first three days was abandoned."[75] About 1,800 officers were deployed on Thursday 22 August and order was restored.[76]
Jewish residents accused the city of deliberately holding the police back. Gourevitch quoted a police captain saying his officers were "flipping out" and that "a lot of them feel that they're paying the price for Rodney King".[28] The Girgenti Report addressed the charge directly: "We found no evidence, direct or implicit, of an order by City Hall to restrain the police."[77] The charge was fuelled by a remark attributed to Dinkins by Governor Mario Cuomo in a Jewish Press interview of 6 September 1991, that the first night had been "a sort of day of grace to the mob"; Dinkins and Cuomo both denied it, and Shapiro writes that "The evidence supported him."[78] Shapiro concludes that "There was never any evidence of a plan by the mayor to gain favor within the black community at the expense of Jews", but that "a good case can be made" that more force was needed from the start: once the police "got serious" on 22 August, making sixty-one arrests, "the riot quickly fizzled out".[79][80]
The Girgenti Report
In July 1993 the state Director of Criminal Justice, Richard H. Girgenti, delivered a two-volume report to Governor Mario Cuomo. Volume I, on the city's response, concluded that Police Commissioner Lee Brown "did not meet these expectations and failed to fulfill his ultimate responsibility for managing the Department's activities to suppress rioting and preserve the public peace".[81] Of the mayor, it found that "the Mayor, as the City's Chief Executive, did not act in a timely and decisive manner in requiring the Police Department to meet his own stated objectives".[82] Volume II, on the Rosenbaum case, concluded that "it is most probable that Lemrick Nelson participated in the attack that resulted in Yankel Rosenbaum's death", but that "deficiencies in the initial investigation created problems with the evidence".[83][84]
The inquiry was a response to the Nelson verdict. Within days of it, the US Attorney General, William P. Barr, announced a federal civil-rights investigation, and Cuomo's Executive Order 160 of 17 November 1992 set up the state review.[85][86] It was not authorised to examine the accident that killed Gavin Cato, and Carmel Cato and others called the result "politically motivated, biased toward the Lubavitch, and anti-black".[87] The report, some six hundred pages in two volumes, was released on 20 July 1993. It cleared Dinkins of ordering a "day of grace" for the rioters but criticised his handling of the riot.[88] Dinkins responded: "This report concludes that my reliance was misplaced. I accept that conclusion."[89] Norman Rosenbaum called on him to resign.[90] Rabbi Joseph Spielman of the Crown Heights Jewish Community Council said: "The report clearly vindicates our position that the mayor had responsibility that he did not exercise, to the detriment of the Jewish community."[91]
The trials
On 29 October 1992 a Brooklyn jury acquitted Lemrick Nelson of all counts; the Girgenti Report records that "the public reaction to the verdict by many, especially in the Jewish community, was immediate and angered disbelief".[52] The jury of six Black, four Hispanic and two white jurors deliberated for four days; it believed Nelson had been part of the group that attacked Rosenbaum but concluded that murder or manslaughter had not been proved "beyond a reasonable doubt".[92][93] After the verdict the jurors attended "a postdecision victory celebration hosted by Nelson's attorneys" at a Brooklyn restaurant.[94] Dinkins told New Yorkers that "ours is a society of laws ... we accept and abide by the decision of the jury system"; Rabbi Shea Hecht replied: "That's not what he said after the Rodney King verdict."[94] Norman Rosenbaum called the mayor an anti-Semite, and a Lubavitch advertisement in the New York Times of 18 November 1992 was headed "In New York City Jewish Civil Rights Just Don't Matter".[95] Spielman and Rabbi Morris Sherer of Agudath Israel of America both objected to calling the mayor an anti-Semite.[85]
The case then moved to the federal courts. After a 97–0 Senate resolution, Attorney General Janet Reno instructed the US attorney in January 1994 to seek an indictment,[96] and on 11 August 1994 a federal grand jury indicted Nelson for violating Rosenbaum's civil rights.[97] On 6 August 1996 Charles Price, whom witnesses identified as having urged the crowd to "get the Jews!", was indicted for the same offence and Nelson was re-indicted.[98] On 10 February 1997 a federal jury convicted both, "Nelson for wielding the knife that killed Rosenbaum and Price for inciting the crowd to attack the victim"; Nelson was sentenced to nineteen and a half years and Price to twenty-one years and ten months.[99] On 7 January 2002 the Second Circuit overturned both convictions because Judge David Trager had manipulated jury selection to obtain a racially and religiously balanced jury, while upholding federal jurisdiction and holding that religious groups are protected under the Fourteenth Amendment.[100][101][102] Price then accepted a reduced sentence of eleven years and eight months; at an April 2002 hearing he apologised, but added: "[O]n that night I felt that black people in Crown Heights were treated unfairly and that Jewish people were treated much better and that revenge was appropriate."[102][103] At Nelson's retrial before Judge Frederic Block in 2003, his lawyer admitted in the opening statement that Nelson had stabbed Rosenbaum, but said he had done so because he was drunk, not because Rosenbaum was Jewish.[103] In May 2003 the jury found that Nelson had violated Rosenbaum's civil rights but that the government had not proved beyond reasonable doubt that he was directly responsible for the death, after a medical examiner testified that "botched medical care and not the stabbing" was directly responsible. On 20 August 2003 Block imposed the maximum sentence of ten years for a "horrendous and pathetic act of racial and religious bigotry".[104] Goldschmidt summarises the reversal as a finding that the judge had "manipulated the jury selection process, in a well-intentioned but unconstitutional effort to ensure a racially balanced jury".[105]
A civil suit filed in November 1992 by Rosenbaum's estate and members of the Crown Heights Jewish community alleged that the city had "discriminatorily and selectively withheld police protective and investigative services from the Crown Heights Jewish community". In August 1997 Judge Block dismissed Dinkins and Brown as defendants on grounds of qualified immunity.[106] In January 1998 the city settled separately with Isaac and Yechiel Bitton for $200,000. On 2 April 1998 Mayor Rudy Giuliani announced a settlement with the remaining plaintiffs and a statement that "the City of New York accepts responsibility for the mistakes that were made in August 1991, and apologizes to the residents of Crown Heights";[107] the city paid $1,100,000 plus $250,000 in legal costs.[108]
A grand jury declined to indict Yosef Lifsh on 5 September 1991, "following two weeks of hearings and one hour of deliberations"; "Lifsch was on a plane hours later, returning home to Israel".[109] The grand jury of ten African Americans, five Latinos and eight Caucasians heard more than thirty witnesses and declined to indict him "either for criminally negligent homicide or assault in the third degree".[110] The District Attorney, Charles J. Hynes, had said on the Black-owned radio station WLIB that tests showed no alcohol in Lifsh's system, and cited twenty-two similar cases, most involving Black and Hispanic drivers, in which there had been no indictment.[111] The Cato family had refused to cooperate with the grand jury.[112] On 17 September 1991 Sharpton and Alton Maddox flew to the Zionist entity to serve Lifsh with notice of a wrongful-death suit but did not find him.[113] Sharpton, Maddox and Colin Moore then announced a $575 million suit on behalf of the Cato families against Rabbi Schneerson, Lifsh, the owner of the station wagon, Hatzolah, Hynes and the police department, and left the papers in the door handle at 770 Eastern Parkway; they did not proceed with it.[114] On 9 January 2002 the city announced a settlement under which it paid the Cato family $400,000 and the family dropped its suit alleging negligence by the city's Emergency Medical Service in treating Gavin.[56] Writing for the Village Voice in 2002, Dasun Allah reported that "members of the Black community find it appalling that laws passed to protect Blacks from legal lynchings from all-White juries in the segregated South were used to convict a young Black man who had been acquitted by a racially diverse state jury", while "no one has been held accountable for the death of Gavin Cato".[115] From the far left, the Socialist Workers Party weekly The Militant called the 2003 verdict a conviction "in frame-up", arguing that "the big-business press trumpeted the incident ... as an anti-Jewish riot" whereas "the outburst ... actually erupted in response to racist treatment of Black residents of that neighborhood by the cops and emergency personnel", and that using civil-rights statutes against Nelson "was a travesty of justice".[116] Goldschmidt observes that the verdicts "included something for everyone in Crown Heights—and something for everyone to be angry about".[105]
Al Sharpton
The Rev. Al Sharpton arrived on the second day, by his own later account at the request of Gavin's father, Carmel Cato.[117] With Daughtry, Alton Maddox, Sonny Carson and Colin Moore he met police at the 71st Precinct, where they "again demanded Lifsch's arrest".[118] The ADL, in its 1992 advocacy report, accused him of "polarizing relations and exacerbating tensions between Blacks and Jews" and quoted him in Newsday on 22 August: "This is no one-person thing. The emphasis is on Black survival in Crown Heights. Our people are under attack."[119]
The eulogy
Sharpton delivered the eulogy at Gavin Cato's funeral at St Anthony's Baptist Church on 26 August 1991. Two contemporary wire reports agree on its core. UPI reported that he said: "They say they want peace. They don't want peace. They just want quiet", that the Black community would allow "no compromise, no sellout ... nothing less than the prosecution of the murderer of this young man", and that he attacked "Jews as 'diamond merchants'".[120] The Associated Press version, printed in the Washington Post, has: "I hear the word 'peace' ... They don't want peace. They want quiet. If they want peace, look at the arrangements in Crown Heights and make it equal."[41] At the same service Sonny Carson said of the rioters, according to the ADL, "You might not like this. But I'm very proud of them."[121]
A fuller text was printed in the Black weekly City Sun a few days later, under the title "Gavin's Death Must Spark a Beginning"; Goldschmidt quotes from that reprint: "The world will tell us [Gavin] was killed by accident. Yes, it was a social accident. It's an accident for one group of people to be treated better than another group of people. It's an accident to allow a minority to impose their will on a majority. It's an accident to allow an apartheid ambulance service in the middle of Crown Heights." He adds that Sharpton "then went on to criticize the Hasidic community in terms many observers considered antisemitic—for example by linking 'diamond merchants' in Crown Heights and Tel Aviv to the apartheid regime in South Africa".[48] A longer version of the eulogy was also printed by Gourevitch in Commentary (1993) and in the same wording by Slate (2003), which quotes Sharpton as saying: "It's an accident to allow an apartheid ambulance service in the middle of Crown Heights. … Talk about how Oppenheimer in South Africa sends diamonds straight to Tel Aviv and deals with the diamond merchants right here in Crown Heights. The issue is not anti-Semitism; the issue is apartheid. … No compromise, no meetings, no kaffe klatsch, no skinnin' and grinnin'. Pay for your deeds."[49][28] Neither of these two gives its source. Shapiro also takes the text from the City Sun reprint and quotes Sharpton telling the mourners, "We must not reprimand our children for outrage when it is the outrage that was put in them by an oppressive system", and asking, "Well, who sowed violence?" He notes that no speaker at the funeral mentioned Rosenbaum.[122]
Later accounts
In a New York Daily News op-ed on 21 August 2011, a self-interested retrospective, Sharpton wrote that he had arrived "late in the evening the day after" and "did not know Yankel Rosenbaum had been killed by a mob on that first night". He said the "diamond merchants" remark referred to "the likes of the Oppenheimer family — which at the time was trading diamonds with apartheid South Africa", and that "Extremists seized upon that to say that I was calling all Jews diamond merchants, and I spent years defending the statement rather than recognizing that in hours of tension, one must be clearer than at any other time." He conceded: "Our language and tone sometimes exacerbated tensions and played to the extremists rather than raising the issue of the value of this young man whom we were so concerned about," and added: "I would still have stood up for Gavin Cato, but I would have also included in my utterances that there was no justification or excuse for violence or for the death of Yankel Rosenbaum."[117]
The New York Jewish Week noted that his statement that he saw "brick-throwing on all sides" was "at odds with the contention of the chasidic community, that the violence was entirely directed at Jews".[123] Rosenbaum's brother Norman said: "I don't hear the words 'I apologize' ... As far as I'm concerned it's just a cynical attempt to appease those who haven't forgotten the truth." Abraham Foxman of the ADL said Sharpton "comes close to doing the right thing" but "still hasn't come far enough to say 'I made a mistake, I acted in a bigoted way and I'm sorry'".[123] Days earlier, withdrawing from a forum at the Hampton Synagogue, Sharpton had written: "I have made mistakes in my career, but the allegations around Crown Heights, which is proven to be patently untrue, was not one of them."[123] In 2024 he told a sympathetic biographer: "Crown Heights happened in August 1991. I would have to be schizophrenic to do what they claim that I did."[124]
Later rapprochement
In October 2001 Sharpton met Israel's consul-general in New York, Alon Pinkas; Haaretz called it "the first time Sharpton will meet an official Israeli representative".[125] He then made a three-day trip to Israel, organised with Rabbi Marc Schneier of the Foundation for Ethnic Understanding and accompanied by Rabbi Shmuley Boteach; Schneier called it "a significant step in the strengthening of black-Jewish relations", and Boteach said: "We have to move forward. We cannot be trapped in the past."[126] The trip ended in controversy when Sharpton met Yasser Arafat in Gaza. Schneier, who had withdrawn as a chaperone, said: "If I were looking to reconcile with the Jewish community, my first overture would not be sitting down with Yasser Arafat."[127]
After antisemitic attacks in the New York area in December 2019, including the Monsey stabbing, Sharpton convened Black clergy with Schneier and said: "I am terribly disturbed by the recent anti-Semitic attacks on Jews, and particularly because they were perpetrated by members of the African-American community."[128] A 2013 NPR profile described him as having "gradually ... become the consummate insider", while the Brooklyn politician Dov Hikind complained that he had "been kosherized by a lot of people who I don't think would give many of us a second chance".[129]
In June 2020 the ADL's chief executive, Jonathan Greenblatt, appeared on Sharpton's MSNBC programme to promote a Facebook advertising boycott. This drew criticism from Jewish groups: Hikind asked why it was "OK to align yourself with Al Sharpton, a race-baiter and inciter of violence in the Crown Heights riots", and Morton Klein of the Zionist Organization of America said the ADL "should not align itself with Sharpton".[130] After the Hamas attack of 7 October 2023, Greenblatt told the Washington Monthly that "the first person to call me was Reverend Sharpton", who had driven a joint civil-rights statement condemning "this terrorist attack on Israel in which civilians have been targeted, killed, and kidnapped".[124]
Pogrom or rebellion?
Goldschmidt sets out the two framings: "Black Crown Heights residents viewed this violence as a 'riot'—or a 'rebellion'—triggered by Black frustration at White privilege, while Jewish Crown Heights residents viewed it as a 'pogrom' triggered by baseless Gentile hostility toward Jews."[4] He argues that each side reinterprets the other's terms: "to define Blacks as Gentiles, criminals as Cossacks, and a riot as a pogrom", and, on the other side, "to define Jews as Whites, insularity as insult, and a pogrom as a riot".[131] Rabbi Shmuel Butman, quoted by Goldschmidt, spoke of "a pogrom that we thought was only going to exist in books. Unfortunately we saw it right here, on the streets of Crown Heights", and Goldschmidt notes that "nearly all Lubavitchers in Crown Heights echo Rabbi Butman's assessment of a 'one side confrontation'".[132]
Jewish and conservative readings
For Gourevitch, "it was a riot not by victims of racism but by racists, an attack on Jews because they were Jews", and "in this respect, the event was unprecedented in American history".[28] The ADL, an advocacy body, called it "the most dramatic, sustained and disturbing anti-Semitic outburst seen in the United States in many years".[133] Chabad.org describes "three days of unrestrained antisemitic violence".[7] Shapiro calls it "the only anti-Semitic riot in American history" and "the most lethal anti-Semitic event in American history".[30][38] For Spielman, 19 August 1991 was "the first pogrom here on America soil".[134][135] A full-page New York Times advertisement of 20 September 1991 declared: "This year Kristallnacht took place on August 19th right here in Crown Heights." On the tenth anniversary, the Jewish Press ran an editorial by Butman, dated 17 August 2001, titled "The Crown Heights Pogrom: Ten Years Later".[136][137] At a memorial in 1996, Butman cast the murder in terms of Jacob and Esau. Shapiro writes that "in 1991 Lubavitchers identified them with the blacks and West Indians of Crown Heights".[138][139] He also notes that Rosenbaum, often described as a "rabbinical student", "was, in fact, neither a Lubavitcher ... nor was he a yeshiva student".[140]
Black, activist and left readings
Daughtry, a participant, rejected the Jewish framing: "to refer to the riots in Crown Heights as Khristelnacht and pogroms" risked "diminishing the importance of those dreadful experiences in Jewish history", since the events were "a narrowly confined, spontaneous eruption for several days in reaction to a traffic accident by people who feel, right or wrong, that they have been victims of years of a double standard".[141] He wrote that "there was as much anger, if not more, directed toward the police as towards the Hasidim".[21] The Village Voice in 2002 described "the four-day disturbance—an uprising, a riot, or a pogrom, depending on whom you talk to".[25] A Black pastor quoted there asked: "They talk about the Black guys who started the riot, but they never talk about the Jewish driver who killed Gavin Cato."[25] Others read the riot as a struggle over turf. In 1981 Tim Robbins wrote in City Limits of "an ongoing tussle over turf and power between a large black and a West Indian population and an expanding community of Hasidic Jews"; the historian Richard Wade and the sociologist Jonathan Rieder took a similar view. Shapiro objects that this jostling "had been going on for years but without any large-scale violence and rioting".[142] The Village Voice reporter Peter Noel blamed Lubavitch lobbying for anti-poverty funds, the search for housing and "forceful demands for preferential treatment by city agencies, particularly the police".[143]
The City Sun, a Brooklyn Black weekly founded in 1984, was the most combative Black paper of the period; the journalist Wayne Dawkins notes that its founder's news service had won a 1979 award "for its multipart series on black-Jewish racial tension in Crown Heights, nearly 15 years before the Brooklyn neighborhood became nationally known".[144]
Fires in the Mirror
Anna Deavere Smith's one-woman play Fires in the Mirror: Crown Heights, Brooklyn and Other Identities (1992; published 1993) is built from her interviews with Black, Lubavitch and other New Yorkers, performed verbatim; the words below are interview testimony as edited and arranged by Smith. The published text opens with a background note from the PBS American Playhouse production, which gives weight to both communities' grievances. It records that "Black leaders have charged that the Lubavitchers have enjoyed 'preferential treatment' in the community from police and other city agencies, including permission to close off major city streets during Jewish holidays", and that "Hasidic crime patrols, Blacks say, have indiscriminately targeted members of the Black community". It also records that "Lubavitchers point to the August fighting that included calls to 'Kill the Jews,' 'Get the Jews out,' and chants of 'Heil Hitler'", and that remarks about "Hasidic 'diamond merchants' and Jews as the 'devil leaders' of White people evoked old stereotypes".[145] The note adds that "many young Blacks who took to the streets in August 1991 were less interested in targeting Jews than in fighting the police, whom many in New York City's Black community regard as an occupying army", that police "arrested between 150 and 300 young Blacks as a 'preventive measure' in what witnesses described as indiscriminate 'sweeps'", and that "Black media reports generally presented the conflict as an anti-racist struggle and dismissed or trivialized charges of anti-Semitism. Jewish newspapers often blamed 'black agitators' and spoke of 'pogroms'".[145]
The play's opening "identities" sequence sets everyday encounters beside the riot. In "Static", an anonymous Lubavitcher woman describes asking a Black neighbourhood boy to switch off a radio her baby had turned on during the Sabbath: "he says, 'You see this little button here / that says on and off? / Push that in / and that turns it off.' / ... and we laughed that he probably thought: / And people say Jewish people are really smart and they don't know / how to turn off their radios."[146] Sharpton appears in the same sequence talking not about Crown Heights but about his hair and his surrogate father, James Brown: "James Brown raised me. ... I always wanted a father / and he filled that void."[147] Goldschmidt draws on later parts of the play for Black testimony about the night of the accident, including the Rev. Heron Sam's remarks on the Hatzolah ambulance (Smith, p. 77).[47]
The word in politics
In the 1993 campaign Giuliani told a Bay Ridge audience: "One definition of pogrom is violence where the state doesn't do enough to prevent it." Ed Koch called it "an ugly term, but it applies".[148][149] The Black columnist Earl Caldwell called Giuliani's usage racially divisive, the City Sun alleged a "quiet deal" with the Crown Heights Jewish community, and Sharpton spoke of "race-baiting".[148] The historian Michael Stanislawski called the term "historically inaccurate", and Joyce Purnick wrote in the New York Times that the police "weren't Cossacks in blue".[150][151] Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan called the murder a "KKK-style lynching" and the riot a "race riot". Shapiro accepts that this placed the riot "within an American setting", but calls the comparison with the Detroit riot of 1943 "a stretch".[142] Shapiro's own judgement is that "the Crown Heights riot did not rise to the level of a pogrom, much less the Holocaust", but that "the rioters made no secret of their animus toward Jews".[152] Dinkins's "lynching" comparison with Yusuf Hawkins was attacked from the other side by the lawyer Colin Moore: "It's pandering to the votes of a certain people."[153]
Aftermath and the 1993 election
The riot opened a rift between Crown Heights Jews and the established Jewish defence organisations. Critics accused the agencies of having been absent; Lucette Lagnado wrote in the Village Voice in August 1993 that they had "failed horribly during the riot", and the ADL's Abraham Foxman spoke of "a strange sort of color-consciousness".[154][155] Shapiro disagrees in part: "The JCRC did, in fact, respond promptly", sending a representative within hours, calling for the National Guard if the police could not cope, offering a $10,000 reward and supplying a legal memorandum that helped bring in the Justice Department; he adds that the Lubavitch insistence that the riot was the work of "outside agitators" partly explains the agencies' slowness.[155][156] Beth Gilinsky's Jewish Action Alliance campaigned over both Rosenbaum and Graziosi and organised a boycott of the Black-owned radio station WLIB, part-owned by the Dinkins family, after which several advertisers withdrew.[157][158]
The Girgenti Report was published in July 1993, four months before the mayoral election. Kamber wrote that the riot "severely damaged the reputation of David Dinkins, the city's first African American mayor; sparked a white voter backlash; and was instrumental in Rudy Giuliani's defeat of Dinkins in the next election".[25] BlackPast states that Giuliani's campaign accused Dinkins of having "enabled an ethnic 'pogrom' by allowing rioters to roam in the street".[22] Dinkins, speaking at the Jewish Theological Seminary after the Nelson verdict, rejected the charge: "There is not a single shred of evidence that I held the NYPD back—and there never will be."[28] Three weeks after the riot he had called Rosenbaum's killing a "lynching".[28][153]
In July 1993 Dinkins made a four-day visit to the Zionist entity, where he was trailed by protesters led by Avi Weiss. A planned stop at Efrat, a settlement on occupied land, was dropped from his schedule.[87][159] During the campaign Fay Rosenbaum "claimed ... that her son would still be living if Giuliani had been mayor in August 1991", and the Patrolmen's Benevolent Association backed Giuliani.[160] Dinkins lost by 44,250 votes. Shapiro cites New York Times polls showing that his Jewish vote "only declined by 3 percent from 1989", and concludes that "It is likely that Dinkins would still have lost even if his support from Jews had remained at the level of 1989". Giuliani chose Rabbi Morris Sherer of Agudath Israel to give the invocation at his inauguration.[161] Dinkins's share of the Hispanic vote also fell, from 65 to 60 per cent. Daughtry, "a fervent adversary of the Lubavitch community", blamed a Black backlash against the mayor's efforts "to appease the Hasidim". Shapiro answers that "No evidence supports the claim", since the Black share of the vote for Dinkins rose from 91 to 95 per cent.[162][163] He concludes that the riot was not "the" issue: it "reinforced a growing sense within the city that the mayor was simply not up to the job", and "Dinkins might have lost even if the riot had never occurred". He adds that "Even Dinkins's harshest critics acknowledged that he was not an anti-Semite."[163]
The Rebbe's response
Shapiro counts "the failure of Rabbi Schneerson to express his personal condolences and to offer an apology to the Cato family" among "the more troubling and enigmatic aspects of the death of Gavin Cato". One week after the accident a New York Times headline read "As Racial Storm Rages, Hasidic Leader is Aloof". Although Lubavitch and other Jews visited the Cato family and expressed regret, "no official statements or calls for public prayer ever emanated from Lubavitch headquarters at 770 Eastern Parkway".[164] Instead, Shapiro writes, Schneerson "spoke cryptically to his followers", saying shortly after the riot began: "It's not in the nature of Jewish people to have war." On 25 August 1991 he spoke "on the need for every individual to make his surroundings a place of peace, tranquillity and holiness"; his followers took this as a reference to the events, but "its meaning to outsiders was obscure".[164]
Rabbi Yehuda Krinsky defended the Rebbe's reticence: "The Rebbe is an international figure. If there is an incident in Washington, D.C., should the President get involved with white and black leaders to settle the insurrection?"[164][165] Critics were unpersuaded. Kenneth S. Stern of the American Jewish Committee noted that the Rebbe spoke allegorically on every subject, but asked: "how could black residents of Crown Heights not believe the Rebbe was indifferent?" Albert Vorspan of the Reform movement's Union of American Hebrew Congregations said that Schneerson had "failed utterly to heal the rift", and Michael Lerner argued that a "morally sensitive leader" would long ago have taught his community to care for others, so that they would "immediately declare a day of mourning for the Black children that had been run over by the Rebbe's caravan".[165] For the Lubavitchers, Shapiro writes, the crash was "an accident, tragic but still an accident for which Lifsh apologized", and claims to the contrary were "redolent of the medieval 'blood libel'".[40]
The Rebbe's motorcade was at the centre of the events, and Goldschmidt notes that the violence "cast doubt on the promise of America—a country the Rebbe had always called a 'land of loving kindness' for its just treatment of Jews".[166] The Chabad.org retrospective of 2021 presents the riot as a test of the Rebbe's 1969 instruction not to leave: "The Jewish community still existed and was even growing, unlike the disappeared Jewish communities of Brooklyn's Brownsville, East New York, East Flatbush".[7]
Shapiro writes that "Schneerson's failure to speak directly about the riot fueled speculation that he believed it to be further confirmation of the impending arrival of the messiah". He describes Butman, who gave the keynote eulogy at Rosenbaum's funeral, as seeing the riot as both an attack on Jews and "a sure sign that the messianic era was approaching".[140] Days after the riot, a full-page advertisement paid for by the Australian Lubavitch supporter Joseph Gutnick linked it with other recent events: "The Era of Moshiach is upon us."[139][140] Shapiro also records that "Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson encouraged Lazerson to work with Green" on the joint projects described below.[167]
Memory and reconciliation
The earliest joint projects were led by Richard Green of the Crown Heights Youth Collective and the Lubavitcher David Lazerson. They included mixed basketball teams, seminars and joint Hanukkah–Kwanzaa events. A week after the riot Hatzolah helped refurbish an ambulance of the Black-owned Tri-Community Volunteer Ambulance Corps, partly to "dispel the rumor that it had refused to tend to the injured Cato children".[167] Mothers-to-Mothers brought together about twenty African American, Caribbean and Lubavitch mothers, meeting monthly from early 1992.[168] Not all Lubavitchers approved. Butman said: "Jewish children should be playing games with Jewish children. Black children should be playing games with black children. Just leave each other alone." Shapiro calls Butman's speech at a Jewish Community Relations Council event on 13 October 1991 "racist remarks"; the civil-rights campaigner Michael Meyers walked off the platform during it.[169][170]
On 20 August 2001, the tenth anniversary, Carmel Cato and Norman Rosenbaum met for the first time, at Cato's initiative. The next day Cato said he had accepted that no one would be indicted for his son's death; in Shapiro's words, "it was time to move on".[168][169] In April 1998 Cato had met representatives of national Jewish agencies, accompanied by Sharpton, a meeting the Rosenbaum family criticised.[171] In August 2003 Yankel's parents, Fay and Max Rosenbaum, met Cato in Manhattan. Cato said: "We are parents and we grieve."[172] Malcolm Hoenlein warned against equating the two deaths: "One was an accident, the other a murder."[169] Later accidents passed without unrest. In 2000 a Hatzolah ambulance killed Alberto Curtis and his son in Flatbush. In 2002, after a Hasidic driver hit a three-year-old Black girl, Tiamani Gittens, in Crown Heights, Black residents protected him from an angry crowd, and "In contrast to 1991, a Lubavitch leader immediately went to Kings County Hospital to offer condolences".[170][173] By Shapiro's estimate the Lubavitch population grew "by perhaps 20 to 25 percent" after the riot and spread north of Eastern Parkway; "In fact, the Crown Heights riot was not a watershed. The neighborhood did not fundamentally change and the Jews did not flee."[174] National efforts had mixed results. Art Spiegelman's Valentine cover for the New Yorker in February 1993 drew Spielman's response: "Rather than healing, this just makes everything ludicrous."[175][176] The American Jewish Committee and Howard University launched the magazine CommonQuest in 1996. It folded in 2000, when the AJC ended its $25,000 annual subsidy, having reached a circulation of only twenty thousand.[175][177]
By 2002 the Village Voice found "a neighborhood largely indifferent" to the reversal of Nelson's conviction, and community organisations such as "Mothers to Mothers, Project CARE, and the Crown Heights Youth Collective" running dialogue projects, although "there is still little voluntary interaction between Blacks and Jews".[25] Richard Green of the Crown Heights Youth Collective, an adviser to the Cato family, told Dasun Allah: "If the Hasidic community gets to buy a building, and we don't get together and buy that building, who's to be blamed for that?"[115] Carmel Cato told the Daily Challenge: "It's still not over ... I want Yosef Lifsh ... to face justice for killing my child."[115]
At the twentieth anniversary in 2011 the JTA reported Sharpton's partial admission of "mistakes".[178] Isaac Abraham, spokesman for the Rosenbaum family, had earlier objected to calls to move on: "Do you think the African American community would be silent if this happened in the African American community?"[25]
See also
- Menachem Mendel Schneerson
- Chabad-Lubavitch movement
- Crown Heights Jewish Community Council
- Hatzolah
- Al Sharpton
- Black–Jewish relations in the United States
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 Girgenti, vol. I (1993), Executive Summary, p. 4.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 Girgenti, vol. I (1993), p. 10.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. I (1993), p. 206.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 Goldschmidt (2006), ch. 1, "Collisions", p. 38.
- ↑ Henry Goldschmidt, Race and Religion among the Chosen Peoples of Crown Heights (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 2006), ISBN 978-0-8135-3897-6, p. 5.
- ↑ Goldschmidt (2006), p. 14.
- ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 Dovid Margolin, "Jews Don't Run: The Rebbe and Lessons From Crown Heights", Chabad.org, 19 August 2021, accessed 15 October 2026. Chabad-side primary source.
- ↑ 8.0 8.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 77.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 74.
- ↑ Goldschmidt (2006), p. 105.
- ↑ Shlomo M. Russ, "The 'Zionist Hooligans': The Jewish Defense League" (PhD thesis, City University of New York, 1981; UMI 8112371), pp. 214–16.
- ↑ Russ (1981), pp. 216–17.
- ↑ Russ (1981), pp. 235, 246.
- ↑ 14.0 14.1 14.2 Girgenti, vol. I (1993), ch. 2, p. 47.
- ↑ 15.0 15.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 84.
- ↑ 16.0 16.1 16.2 Shapiro (2006), p. 85.
- ↑ 17.0 17.1 Girgenti, vol. I (1993), ch. 2, p. 46.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 76.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 81.
- ↑ 20.0 20.1 Daughtry (1997), p. 206. First-hand account by a Black activist participant (primary source).
- ↑ 21.0 21.1 Herbert D. Daughtry Sr., No Monopoly on Suffering: Blacks and Jews in Crown Heights (and Elsewhere) (Trenton, NJ: Africa World Press, 1997), ISBN 0-86543-586-3, p. 173. First-hand account by a Black activist participant.
- ↑ 22.0 22.1 Marshall Greenlaw, "Crown Heights (Brooklyn) New York Riot, 1991", BlackPast.org, 27 November 2017, accessed 15 October 2026. Black-history reference site; student-written entry.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 83.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 87.
- ↑ 25.0 25.1 25.2 25.3 25.4 25.5 25.6 Michael Kamber, "Faded Rage", The Village Voice, 15 January 2002, accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ "Leonard Jeffries, Jr.", EBSCO Research Starters, accessed 15 October 2026. Tertiary reference.
- ↑ ADL (1992), p. 2.
- ↑ 28.0 28.1 28.2 28.3 28.4 28.5 28.6 28.7 28.8 Philip Gourevitch, "The Crown Heights Riot & Its Aftermath", Commentary, January 1993, accessed 15 October 2026. Neoconservative opinion journal.
- ↑ "City College Professor Assailed for Remarks on Jews", The New York Times, 7 August 1991, accessed 15 October 2026 (opening paragraphs).
- ↑ 30.0 30.1 Edward S. Shapiro, Crown Heights: Blacks, Jews, and the 1991 Brooklyn Riot (Waltham, MA: Brandeis University Press, 2006), ISBN 978-1-58465-561-9, p. 1.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 2.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 99, n. 48.
- ↑ Goldschmidt (2006), pp. 41–42.
- ↑ 34.0 34.1 34.2 34.3 34.4 "Fatal Brooklyn Traffic Accident Sparks Widespread Racial Violence", Jewish Telegraphic Agency, 22 August 1991, accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ Goldschmidt (2006), p. 47.
- ↑ 36.0 36.1 36.2 Goldschmidt (2006), p. 52.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 3.
- ↑ 38.0 38.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 4.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 5.
- ↑ 40.0 40.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 11.
- ↑ 41.0 41.1 41.2 Associated Press, "Grief, Anger at Funeral in Brooklyn: Dinkins Seeks Peace, Sharpton Asks Justice", The Washington Post, 27 August 1991, accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ Goldschmidt (2006), p. 48.
- ↑ Antonia Farzan, "Inside Brooklyn's Orthodox Jewish ambulance corps", EMS1 (from The Brooklyn Ink), 21 November 2015, accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ Reuven Fenton, Lia Eustachewich and Tamar Lapin, "All-women Hasidic EMT group denied bid for ambulance in Brooklyn", New York Post, 20 November 2019, accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. I (1993), p. 56.
- ↑ Goldschmidt (2006), p. 43.
- ↑ 47.0 47.1 47.2 Goldschmidt (2006), p. 49.
- ↑ 48.0 48.1 Goldschmidt (2006), p. 50, quoting Sharpton's eulogy as reprinted in The City Sun, 29 August–3 September 1991, p. 3 (Goldschmidt, n. 21).
- ↑ 49.0 49.1 William Saletan and Avi Zenilman, "The gaffes of Al Sharpton", Slate, 7 October 2003, accessed 15 October 2026. Critical journalism; gives no source for the eulogy text.
- ↑ Goldschmidt (2006), p. 53.
- ↑ Richard H. Girgenti, A Report to the Governor on the Disturbances in Crown Heights, vol. II: A Review of the Circumstances Surrounding the Death of Yankel Rosenbaum and the Resulting Prosecution (Albany: NYS DCJS, 1993), Executive Summary, p. 3. PDF. Official report.
- ↑ 52.0 52.1 Girgenti, vol. II (1993), p. 4.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 23.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 24.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 26.
- ↑ 56.0 56.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 193.
- ↑ Richard H. Girgenti, A Report to the Governor on the Disturbances in Crown Heights, vol. I: An Assessment of the City's Preparedness and Response to Civil Disorder (Albany: New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, July 1993), covering letter to Governor Mario Cuomo. PDF (New York State Library). Official report.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. I (1993), p. 33.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 37.
- ↑ 60.0 60.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 38.
- ↑ 61.0 61.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 39.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 63, n. 6.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 40.
- ↑ 64.0 64.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 41.
- ↑ 65.0 65.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 42.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 43.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. I (1993), p. 6.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. I (1993), p. 72.
- ↑ 69.0 69.1 Girgenti, vol. I (1993), p. 7.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. I (1993), p. 14.
- ↑ 71.0 71.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 53.
- ↑ 72.0 72.1 72.2 Shapiro (2006), p. 54.
- ↑ 73.0 73.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 55.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. I (1993), p. 67.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. I (1993), p. 207.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. I (1993), p. 213.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. I (1993), p. 25.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 48.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 50.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 51.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. I (1993), ch. 9, p. 246.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. I (1993), ch. 13, Finding 36, p. 363.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. II (1993), p. 5.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. II (1993), p. 8.
- ↑ 85.0 85.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 118.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 119.
- ↑ 87.0 87.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 120.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 122.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 124.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 123.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 125.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 173.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 174.
- ↑ 94.0 94.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 116.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 117.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 179.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 180.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 181.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 184.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 188.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 189.
- ↑ 102.0 102.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 190.
- ↑ 103.0 103.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 191.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 192.
- ↑ 105.0 105.1 Goldschmidt (2006), p. 58.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 185.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 186.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 187.
- ↑ Goldschmidt (2006), p. 57.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 17.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 18.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 19.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 21.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 22.
- ↑ 115.0 115.1 115.2 Dasun Allah, "The Crown Heights Quiets", The Village Voice, 15 January 2002, accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ Sam Manuel, "After third trial, Black man convicted in frame-up for 1991 Crown Heights killing", The Militant (Socialist Workers Party), vol. 67, no. 18, 2 June 2003, accessed via the Internet Archive 15 October 2026. Newspaper of the Socialist Workers Party (Trotskyist).
- ↑ 117.0 117.1 Al Sharpton, op-ed, New York Daily News, 21 August 2011, reprinted as "Op-Ed By Al Sharpton Twenty Years After Crown Heights Riots", The Yeshiva World, 21 August 2011, accessed 15 October 2026. Sharpton's own retrospective; self-interested primary source.
- ↑ Girgenti, vol. I (1993), p. 70.
- ↑ ADL (1992), p. 20.
- ↑ Gary Rosenberger, "Hundreds mourn boy whose death sparked riots", United Press International, 27 August 1991, accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ ADL (1992), p. 18.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 14.
- ↑ 123.0 123.1 123.2 Adam Dickter, "Sharpton Concedes Crown Heights Mistakes", New York Jewish Week (via JTA), 23 August 2011, accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ 124.0 124.1 Jamal Watson, "Al Sharpton Stands Up for Israel", Washington Monthly, 16 January 2024, accessed 15 October 2026. Commentary by Sharpton's biographer.
- ↑ Shlomo Shamir, "Al Sharpton Woos Israeli and Jewish Officials", Haaretz, 17 October 2001 (opening paragraph only; paywalled), accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ "Long Criticized by Jews, Sharpton Seeks Better Ties with Trip to Israel", JTA, October 2001, accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ "Sharpton under fire for meeting Arafat", JTA, late October 2001, accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ Marcy Oster, "Al Sharpton gathers black leaders for meeting with NY rabbi in wake of Monsey attack", JTA, 30 December 2019, accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ Corey Dade, "Sharpton 2.0: From Outsider To Insider", NPR (via KVPR), 12 March 2013, accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ Jackson Richman, "ADL CEO under fire for partnering with Sharpton in pushing for Facebook boycott", JNS, 2 July 2020, accessed 15 October 2026. Right-leaning Jewish news service.
- ↑ Goldschmidt (2006), p. 29.
- ↑ Goldschmidt (2006), p. 68.
- ↑ Anti-Defamation League, The Anti-Semitism of Black Demagogues and Extremists (New York: ADL, 1992), Introduction. Jewish advocacy organisation; advocacy report.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 143.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 167, n. 9.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 145.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 167, n. 14.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 140.
- ↑ 139.0 139.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 141.
- ↑ 140.0 140.1 140.2 Shapiro (2006), p. 142.
- ↑ Daughtry (1997), pp. 192–193. First-hand account by a Black activist participant (primary source).
- ↑ 142.0 142.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 150.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 151.
- ↑ Wayne Dawkins, "Why Did The City Sun [1984–1996 Matter?"], AALBC.com, accessed 15 October 2026.
- ↑ 145.0 145.1 "The Crown Heights Conflict: Background Information" (© 1993 WGBH Educational Foundation, from educational materials for American Playhouse), in Anna Deavere Smith, Fires in the Mirror: Crown Heights, Brooklyn and Other Identities (New York: Anchor Books, 1993), pp. xliii–xliv.
- ↑ Smith, Fires in the Mirror (1993), "Anonymous Lubavitcher Woman: Static", pp. 5–8. Interview testimony as edited by Smith.
- ↑ Smith, Fires in the Mirror (1993), "The Reverend Al Sharpton: Me and James's Thing", p. 19. Interview testimony as edited by Smith.
- ↑ 148.0 148.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 147.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 168, n. 18.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 148.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 168, n. 21.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 146.
- ↑ 153.0 153.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 149.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 59.
- ↑ 155.0 155.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 60.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 61.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 57.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 58.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 121.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 126.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 127.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 128.
- ↑ 163.0 163.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 129.
- ↑ 164.0 164.1 164.2 Shapiro (2006), p. 9.
- ↑ 165.0 165.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 10.
- ↑ Goldschmidt (2006), p. 70.
- ↑ 167.0 167.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 222.
- ↑ 168.0 168.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 223.
- ↑ 169.0 169.1 169.2 Shapiro (2006), p. 224.
- ↑ 170.0 170.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 225.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 235, n. 55.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 236, n. 56.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 226.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 230.
- ↑ 175.0 175.1 Shapiro (2006), p. 212.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 233, n. 25.
- ↑ Shapiro (2006), p. 213.
- ↑ Dan Klein, "Al Sharpton: I made 'mistakes' during Crown Heights riots", JTA, 22 August 2011, accessed 15 October 2026.
Further reading
- Edward S. Shapiro, Crown Heights: Blacks, Jews, and the 1991 Brooklyn Riot (Waltham, MA: Brandeis University Press, 2006).
- Anna Deavere Smith, Fires in the Mirror: Crown Heights, Brooklyn and Other Identities (New York: Anchor Books, 1993).
- Henry Goldschmidt, Race and Religion among the Chosen Peoples of Crown Heights (Rutgers University Press, 2006).
- Herbert Daughtry, No Monopoly on Suffering (Africa World Press, 1997).
- Brooklyn Historical Society, "Crown Heights Oral History – Bridging Eastern Parkway, 1993–1994", ArMs 1994.006.