Difference between revisions of "European Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism"

From Powerbase
Jump to: navigation, search
(→‎Advisory Board)
(→‎Patrons)
 
(20 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
===Board of Directors===
+
The [[European Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism]] was founded in 2007 as "as a think-tank to examine the growth and development of antisemitism in the world today and to explore new strategies for countering this age-old hatred in all its forms."<ref>[http://www.eisca.eu/ EUROPEAN INSTITUTE FOR THE STUDY OF CONTEMPORARY ANTISEMITISM], accessed 24 July 2009.</ref>
−
*[[Stephen Pollard]] - Chairman
 
−
*[[Jon Benjamin]]
 
−
*[[Jeremy Newmark]]
 
  
 +
It was publicly launched in July 2008 with a lecture in the House of Commons by Europe Minister [[Jim Murphy]].<ref>[http://www.eisca.eu/resources/countering-antisemitism.pdf Countering Anti-Semitism], European Institute for the Study of Contemporay Anti-Semitism, p.1, accessed 24 July 2009.</ref>
 +
 +
In July 2009, [[Shahid Malik]], Minister for Social Cohesion, launched a report commissioned from the Institute by the [[Department for Communities and Local Government]], entitled ''Understanding and Addressing the Nazi Card'', and pledged to refer the report’s recommendations to the Whitehall Cross-Departmental Task Force on Antisemitism.<ref> [http://www.eisca.eu/antisemitism/communities-minister-launches-new-eisca-research/ Communities Minister launches new EISCA research], 16 July 2009.</ref>
 +
 +
Anthony Lerman criticised the report on the ''Guardian'' website:
 +
::I also believe that there should be no place for Nazi analogies in public debate, but in my view, the argumentation and recommendations in this report are deeply flawed. And when you dig deeper into the reasoning, it seems confused, muddled and contradictory.
 +
 +
::While the principle that freedom of speech is not absolute is accepted in English law, not all offensive speech is criminalised. So, merely showing that comparing Israeli behaviour to the Nazis is offensive is no reason to outlaw such discourse. The authors try to get round this by arguing that such comparisons are especially offensive to Jews, because of their history. They say: "Most people would accept that it's completely unacceptable to call a Jewish person a Nazi." The implication here – that it may, therefore, be acceptable in some circumstances to call a non-Jew a Nazi – is unfortunate to say the least. If one is against the use of Nazi comparisons in public debate, it's unacceptable to call anyone a Nazi. In which case, the argument of exceptional offensiveness for Jews doesn't hold.<ref>Anthony Lerman, [http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2009/jul/24/israel-nazi-analogies-ban Should we ban 'Nazi analogies'?], guardian.co.uk, 24 July 2009.</ref>
 +
 +
Lerman went on to suggest that the reports failings reflected the Institute's ethos:
 +
::Had this report been commissioned by a university or a serious thinktank with proven expertise in this area, I'm a sure something more useful would have been produced. But the fact that the government can spend £20,000 in this way, backing a dubious body with no track record, is indicative of the sad politicising and devaluing of the entire field of contemporary antisemitism studies.<ref>Anthony Lerman, [http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2009/jul/24/israel-nazi-analogies-ban Should we ban 'Nazi analogies'?], guardian.co.uk, 24 July 2009.</ref>
 +
==Neocon connections==
 +
The Institute has a number of neoconservative and pro-war Left connections.  Its chair [[Stephen Pollard]] is a signatory to the British Neocon think tank the [[Henry Jackson Society]]. It advisory board includes some of the UK's leading Neocons, such as Tory MP [[Michael Gove]], [[Douglas Murray]] (author of ''Neoconservatism: Why We Need it''), [[Oliver Kamm]] ([[Henry Jackson Society]], [[Democratiya]] and author of ''Anti-Totalitarianism: The Left-wing Case for a Neoconservative Foreign Policy'') and former Tory Director of Research [[Daniel Finkelstein]].  Pro-war left figures include [[Martin Bright]] who has published a pamphlet with the [[Policy Exchange]] and [[Brian Brivati]] ([[Engage]], [[Euston Manifesto]], [[Democratiya]], [[Unite Against Terror]]), [[David Hirsh]] ([[Engage]], [[Euston Manifesto]], [[Democratiya]], [[Z-word]] contributor) and [[Adrian Cohen]] ([[Euston Manifesto]] | [[Engage]] | [[Unite Against Terror]]). The board also includes a number of hardline Zionists such as [[Emanuele Ottolenghi]] of the [[Transatlantic Institute]] (a front group for the [[American Jewish Committee]]). Among its patrons are other prominent Zionists such as [[George Weidenfeld]] who is active in a number of elite, right wing and Neocon connected lobby groups (such as the [[Club of Three]], the [[EastWest Institute]], [[Institute for Strategic Dialogue]] and the [[New Atlantic Initiative]])
 +
 +
==People==
 +
[[File:Screenshot 2024-03-08 at 10.59.03.png|right|thumb|500px|[[European Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism]] directors, advisors and staff circa 2009.  Screenshot from the inside front cover of Understanding and Addressing The ‘Nazi card’: Intervening Against Antisemitic Discourse, by [[Paul Iganski]] and [[Abe Sweiry]], July 2009]]
 +
===Directors===
 +
*[[Stephen Pollard]] - Chairman 6 March 2007 - 17 March 2009
 +
*[[Jon Benjamin]] - 6 March 2007 - 1 April 2013
 +
*[[Jeremy Newmark]] - 6 March 2007 - 7 July 2015
 +
*[[Denis MacShane]] - Chairman - 1 March 2009 - 1 April 2013
 +
*[[Philip Rosenberg]] 1 April 2013 - 7 July 2015
 +
*[[Winston Pickett]] - 6 March 2007 - 1 August 2009
 
===Patrons===
 
===Patrons===
 
*[[George Carey|Lord Carey]] | Chief Rabbi Dr Sir [[Jonathan Sacks]] | Sir [[Sigmund Sternberg]] | [[Lord Weidenfeld|George Weidenfeld]]
 
*[[George Carey|Lord Carey]] | Chief Rabbi Dr Sir [[Jonathan Sacks]] | Sir [[Sigmund Sternberg]] | [[Lord Weidenfeld|George Weidenfeld]]
  
−
===Advisory Board===
+
===Advisory Board - circa 2007===
 
Rabbi [[Sidney Brichto]] | Professor [[Vernon Bogdanor]] | [[Martin Bright]] | Professor [[Brian Brivati]] | [[Adrian Cohen]] | [[Janet Daley]] | [[Daniel Finkelstein]] | [[Mark Gardner]] | [[Michael Gove]] MP | [[John Gross]] | Dr [[David Hirsh]] | Dr [[Paul Iganski]] | [[Oliver Kamm]] | [[Dominic Lawson]] | [[Maureen Lipman]] | [[Douglas Murray]] | [[Fiyaz Mughal]] | Dr [[Emanuele Ottolenghi]] | [[Geoffrey Paul]] | [[Charles Small]] | [[Michael Whine]]
 
Rabbi [[Sidney Brichto]] | Professor [[Vernon Bogdanor]] | [[Martin Bright]] | Professor [[Brian Brivati]] | [[Adrian Cohen]] | [[Janet Daley]] | [[Daniel Finkelstein]] | [[Mark Gardner]] | [[Michael Gove]] MP | [[John Gross]] | Dr [[David Hirsh]] | Dr [[Paul Iganski]] | [[Oliver Kamm]] | [[Dominic Lawson]] | [[Maureen Lipman]] | [[Douglas Murray]] | [[Fiyaz Mughal]] | Dr [[Emanuele Ottolenghi]] | [[Geoffrey Paul]] | [[Charles Small]] | [[Michael Whine]]
  
 
===Staff===
 
===Staff===
−
 
 
*Dr [[Winston Pickett]] - Co-ordinator
 
*Dr [[Winston Pickett]] - Co-ordinator
 
*[[Abe Sweiry]] - Research Fellow
 
*[[Abe Sweiry]] - Research Fellow
 +
 +
===Circa 2009===
 +
====Patrons====
 +
*[[Lord Carey]] | Chief Rabbi Sir [[Jonathan Sacks]] | Sir [[Sigmund Sternberg]] | [[Lord Weidenfeld]]
 +
====Advisory Board====
 +
[[Jessica Asato]] | Professor [[Brian Brivati]] | Professor [[Vernon Bogdanor]] | [[Adrian Cohen]] | [[Janet Daley]] | [[Lord Dholakia]] | [[Daniel Finkelstein ]] | [[Rokhsana Fiaz ]] | [[Dean Godson]] | [[Michael Gove]] MP | [[Tom Gross ]] | Dr [[David Hirsh ]] | [[Anthony Julius ]] | [[Oliver Kamm ]] | [[Dominic Lawson]] | [[Maureen Lipman ]] | [[Charles Moore ]] | [[Fiyaz Mughal]] | Rt Hon [[Jim Murphy]] MP | [[Douglas Murray]] | Dr [[Peter Neumann]] | Dr [[Emanuele Ottolenghi]] | [[Geoffrey Paul ]] | [[Stephen Pollard]] | Baroness [[Margaret Prosser ]] | Baroness [[Meta Ramsay]] | Sir [[Tim Sainsbury ]] | Dr [[Charles Small]] | Rt Hon [[Iain Duncan Smith]] MP | [[Stephen Twigg ]] | [[Michael Whine]] |
 +
 +
====Staff====
 +
=====Consultant=====
 +
Dr Winston Pickett
 +
=====Research Fellow=====
 +
Abe Sweiry
 +
 +
 +
===Advisory board circa 2009===
 +
Secretary of State for Scotland [[Jim Murphy]] | [[Baroness Prosser]] | [[Lord Dholakia]] | Foreign Policy Centre director [[Stephen Twigg]] | Labour Party’s Progress magazine editor [[Jessica Asato]] | Sir [[Tim Sainsbury]] and [[Rokhsana Fiaz]],founding director of [[The Change Institute]] and a member of the government’s [[National Muslim Women’s Advisory Group]].<ref>Leon Symons, New chair for anti-racist think tank, 20 March 2009 The Jewish Chronicle.</ref>
 +
 +
==Publications==
 +
*[https://web.archive.org/web/20090731062555/http://www.eisca.eu/resources/countering-antisemitism.pdf Countering Anti-Semitism], The Minister for Europe [[Jim Murphy]] MP, With an introduction by [[Stephen Pollard]] and responses by: [[Iain Duncan Smith]] MP, [[Nick Cohen]], [[Karen Pollock]], [[Michael Whine]] and [[Winston Pickett]], July 2008.
 +
*[https://web.archive.org/web/20090806171125/http://www.eisca.eu/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/nazicard.pdf Understanding and Addressing The ‘Nazi card’Intervening Against Antisemitic Discourse], [[Paul Igansky]] and [[Abe Sweiry]], 14 July 2009.
 +
 +
==Contact==
 +
:Internet archive holdings: [https://web.archive.org/web/20140729163834/http://www.eisca.co.uk/ eisca.co.uk] Not updated after mid 2011.
 +
:Internet Archive holdings: [https://web.archive.org/web/20230000000000*/eisca.eu eisca.eu]
 +
:Internet Holdings of [https://web.archive.org/web/20240000000000*/eiscablog.eu eiscablog.eu]
 +
 +
==Resources==
 +
*https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/06140653/officers
 +
 
==Notes==
 
==Notes==
 
<references/>
 
<references/>

Latest revision as of 12:18, 8 March 2024

The European Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism was founded in 2007 as "as a think-tank to examine the growth and development of antisemitism in the world today and to explore new strategies for countering this age-old hatred in all its forms."[1]

It was publicly launched in July 2008 with a lecture in the House of Commons by Europe Minister Jim Murphy.[2]

In July 2009, Shahid Malik, Minister for Social Cohesion, launched a report commissioned from the Institute by the Department for Communities and Local Government, entitled Understanding and Addressing the Nazi Card, and pledged to refer the report’s recommendations to the Whitehall Cross-Departmental Task Force on Antisemitism.[3]

Anthony Lerman criticised the report on the Guardian website:

I also believe that there should be no place for Nazi analogies in public debate, but in my view, the argumentation and recommendations in this report are deeply flawed. And when you dig deeper into the reasoning, it seems confused, muddled and contradictory.
While the principle that freedom of speech is not absolute is accepted in English law, not all offensive speech is criminalised. So, merely showing that comparing Israeli behaviour to the Nazis is offensive is no reason to outlaw such discourse. The authors try to get round this by arguing that such comparisons are especially offensive to Jews, because of their history. They say: "Most people would accept that it's completely unacceptable to call a Jewish person a Nazi." The implication here – that it may, therefore, be acceptable in some circumstances to call a non-Jew a Nazi – is unfortunate to say the least. If one is against the use of Nazi comparisons in public debate, it's unacceptable to call anyone a Nazi. In which case, the argument of exceptional offensiveness for Jews doesn't hold.[4]

Lerman went on to suggest that the reports failings reflected the Institute's ethos:

Had this report been commissioned by a university or a serious thinktank with proven expertise in this area, I'm a sure something more useful would have been produced. But the fact that the government can spend £20,000 in this way, backing a dubious body with no track record, is indicative of the sad politicising and devaluing of the entire field of contemporary antisemitism studies.[5]

Neocon connections

The Institute has a number of neoconservative and pro-war Left connections. Its chair Stephen Pollard is a signatory to the British Neocon think tank the Henry Jackson Society. It advisory board includes some of the UK's leading Neocons, such as Tory MP Michael Gove, Douglas Murray (author of Neoconservatism: Why We Need it), Oliver Kamm (Henry Jackson Society, Democratiya and author of Anti-Totalitarianism: The Left-wing Case for a Neoconservative Foreign Policy) and former Tory Director of Research Daniel Finkelstein. Pro-war left figures include Martin Bright who has published a pamphlet with the Policy Exchange and Brian Brivati (Engage, Euston Manifesto, Democratiya, Unite Against Terror), David Hirsh (Engage, Euston Manifesto, Democratiya, Z-word contributor) and Adrian Cohen (Euston Manifesto | Engage | Unite Against Terror). The board also includes a number of hardline Zionists such as Emanuele Ottolenghi of the Transatlantic Institute (a front group for the American Jewish Committee). Among its patrons are other prominent Zionists such as George Weidenfeld who is active in a number of elite, right wing and Neocon connected lobby groups (such as the Club of Three, the EastWest Institute, Institute for Strategic Dialogue and the New Atlantic Initiative)

People

European Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism directors, advisors and staff circa 2009. Screenshot from the inside front cover of Understanding and Addressing The ‘Nazi card’: Intervening Against Antisemitic Discourse, by Paul Iganski and Abe Sweiry, July 2009

Directors

Patrons

Advisory Board - circa 2007

Rabbi Sidney Brichto | Professor Vernon Bogdanor | Martin Bright | Professor Brian Brivati | Adrian Cohen | Janet Daley | Daniel Finkelstein | Mark Gardner | Michael Gove MP | John Gross | Dr David Hirsh | Dr Paul Iganski | Oliver Kamm | Dominic Lawson | Maureen Lipman | Douglas Murray | Fiyaz Mughal | Dr Emanuele Ottolenghi | Geoffrey Paul | Charles Small | Michael Whine

Staff

Circa 2009

Patrons

Advisory Board

Jessica Asato | Professor Brian Brivati | Professor Vernon Bogdanor | Adrian Cohen | Janet Daley | Lord Dholakia | Daniel Finkelstein | Rokhsana Fiaz | Dean Godson | Michael Gove MP | Tom Gross | Dr David Hirsh | Anthony Julius | Oliver Kamm | Dominic Lawson | Maureen Lipman | Charles Moore | Fiyaz Mughal | Rt Hon Jim Murphy MP | Douglas Murray | Dr Peter Neumann | Dr Emanuele Ottolenghi | Geoffrey Paul | Stephen Pollard | Baroness Margaret Prosser | Baroness Meta Ramsay | Sir Tim Sainsbury | Dr Charles Small | Rt Hon Iain Duncan Smith MP | Stephen Twigg | Michael Whine |

Staff

Consultant

Dr Winston Pickett

Research Fellow

Abe Sweiry


Advisory board circa 2009

Secretary of State for Scotland Jim Murphy | Baroness Prosser | Lord Dholakia | Foreign Policy Centre director Stephen Twigg | Labour Party’s Progress magazine editor Jessica Asato | Sir Tim Sainsbury and Rokhsana Fiaz,founding director of The Change Institute and a member of the government’s National Muslim Women’s Advisory Group.[6]

Publications

Contact

Internet archive holdings: eisca.co.uk Not updated after mid 2011.
Internet Archive holdings: eisca.eu
Internet Holdings of eiscablog.eu

Resources

Notes

  1. ↑ EUROPEAN INSTITUTE FOR THE STUDY OF CONTEMPORARY ANTISEMITISM, accessed 24 July 2009.
  2. ↑ Countering Anti-Semitism, European Institute for the Study of Contemporay Anti-Semitism, p.1, accessed 24 July 2009.
  3. ↑ Communities Minister launches new EISCA research, 16 July 2009.
  4. ↑ Anthony Lerman, Should we ban 'Nazi analogies'?, guardian.co.uk, 24 July 2009.
  5. ↑ Anthony Lerman, Should we ban 'Nazi analogies'?, guardian.co.uk, 24 July 2009.
  6. ↑ Leon Symons, New chair for anti-racist think tank, 20 March 2009 The Jewish Chronicle.
Retrieved from "https://powerbase.info/index.php?title=European_Institute_for_the_Study_of_Contemporary_Antisemitism&oldid=262471"