Difference between revisions of "Caledonia Consulting"

From Powerbase
Jump to: navigation, search
(→‎Resources)
m
 
(14 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
[[Image:Caledoniateampic.jpg|right|thumb|400px|The Caledonia lobbyists who run the [[SPBE]] (from left to right)
+
[[Image:Caledoniateampic.jpg|right|thumb|400px|The Caledonia lobbyists who ran the [[SPBE]] (from left to right)
 
David Davidson, Mike Watson, Devin Scobie, Andrew Scobbie and Lynda Gauld]]
 
David Davidson, Mike Watson, Devin Scobie, Andrew Scobbie and Lynda Gauld]]
−
Caledonia Consulting is a lobbying firm in Edinburgh which is run by long time lobbyist [[Devin Scobie]].  Scobie used to work for the controversial lobby firm [[GPC International]] (involved in the [[Derek Draper]] affair). The firm is controversial because Scobie was simultaneously (until January 2008) the director of the [[Scottish Parliament Business Exchange]] a venture set up in the [[Scottish Parliament]] with the stated purpose of educating MSPs and business about each other.  It states that it is 'non-lobbying' and yet many of those associated with it (including Scobie) were/are professional lobbyists.<ref> Paul Hutcheon, [http://www.sundayherald.com/news/heraldnews/display.var.1443938.0.criticism_over_relaunched_holyrood_business_scheme.php Criticism over relaunched Holyrood business scheme] ''The Herald,'' 2nd June 2007, accessed 6th October 2011 </ref>  This apparent conflict in the operations of the Exchange led to an inquiry into its activities by the [[Standards Committee]] of the [[Scottish Parliament]].<ref>Standards Committee 9th Report 2002[http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/business/committees/historic/standards/reports-02/str02-09-01.htm  Report on The Scottish Parliament and Business Exchange] SP Paper 694 Session 1 (2002)</ref>
+
Caledonia Consulting is a lobbying firm in Edinburgh which is run by long time lobbyist [[Devin Scobie]].   
  
−
Also at Caledonia was another member of the SPBE, [[Lynda Gauld]] a former lobbyist for [[Pfizer]].<ref>[http://www.spinwatch.org/content/view/4523/29/ SPBE facilitates lobbying forum access to Scottish Parliament] Blogs - David Miller - Unspun Spinwatch, David Miller, 9 January 2008</ref>  This controversy is compounded by the fact that Caledonia has hired two former MSPs.  One [[David Davidson]] of the [[conservative Party]] was also connected with the SPBE while elected as an MSP.  The other [[Mike Watson]] is the disgraced former Labour minister imprisoned for 'fire raising' after he set alight the curtains at an Edinburgh hotel during a Scottish political awards event.<ref>[http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qn4156/is_20070805/ai_n19444216 Disgraced peer lands job with lobbying firm CONSULTANCY: NEW POST] Sunday Herald, The,  Aug 5, 2007  by Paul Hutcheon Scottish Political Editor</ref>
+
It employs two former [[Liberal Democrats]] MSPs (as of August 2015).
  
−
Caledonia are not members of the [[Association of Professional Political Consultants]] and thus do not divulge their clients.
+
==Controversy==
  
 +
===Conflict of interest===
 +
Caledonia's Devin Scobie used to work for the controversial lobby firm [[GPC International]] (involved in the [[Derek Draper]] affair). At the same time, Scobie was simultaneously (until January 2008) the director of the [[Scottish Parliament Business Exchange]] a venture set up in the [[Scottish Parliament]] with the stated purpose of educating MSPs and business about each other.  The body states that it is 'non-lobbying' and yet many of those associated with it, including Scobie, were/are professional lobbyists.<ref> Paul Hutcheon, [http://www.sundayherald.com/news/heraldnews/display.var.1443938.0.criticism_over_relaunched_holyrood_business_scheme.php Criticism over relaunched Holyrood business scheme] ''The Herald,'' 2nd June 2007, accessed 6th October 2011 </ref> 
  
−
==Caledonia Consulting and Scotch Whisky==
+
This apparent conflict in the operations of the Exchange led to an inquiry into its activities by the [[Standards Committee]] of the [[Scottish Parliament]].<ref>Standards Committee 9th Report 2002[http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/business/committees/historic/standards/reports-02/str02-09-01.htm  Report on The Scottish Parliament and Business Exchange] SP Paper 694 Session 1 (2002)</ref>
  
−
In 2009 The Herald reported that [[Diageo]] had hired [[Caledonia Consulting]] as part of their campaign against stricter alcohol regulation proposed by the SNP [[Scottish Government]].<ref> Tom Gordon and Paul Hutcheon,  [http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/politics/drunk-fire-raising-lord-s-links-to-firm-set-to-give-whisky-advice-to-holyrood-1.1125794?localLinksEnabled=false Drunk fire-raising Lord’s links to firm set to give whisky advice to Holyrood] ''The Herald'' 25th September 2011, accessed 6th October 2011 </ref> Furthermore, [[House of Lords]] cross-bencher, Baron Watson of Invergowrie, [[Mike Watson]], is an associate director of [[Caledonia Consulting]]. [[Mike Watson]] served a 16 month prison sentence for setting fire to a hotel after the Scottish Politician of the Year Event in 2004.  The event is sponsored by [[Diageo]] and The Herald.  Watson plead guilty to wilful fire raising, the Scottish legal establishment's term for arson, but claimed he had experienced an alcohol related 'blackout' <ref> Tom Gordon and Paul Hutcheon, [http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/politics/drunk-fire-raising-lord-s-links-to-firm-set-to-give-whisky-advice-to-holyrood-1.1125794?localLinksEnabled=false Drunk fire-raising Lord’s links to firm set to give whisky advice to Holyrood] ''The Herald'' 25th September 2011, accessed 6th October 2011 </ref> [[Evelyn Gillan]], then director of [[Scottish Health Action on Alcohol Problems]] (SHAAP), now chief executive of [[Alcohol Focus Scotland]] said: "It is ironic that someone who has been in prison for an alcohol-fuelled crime is working for a firm helping Diageo put a stop to innovative policies. [[Diageo]] is only interested in maintaining profits, and Caledonia Consulting are helping them do this." <ref> Paul Hutcheon and Tom Gordon, [http://www.heraldscotland.com/anger-over-spirits-giant-s-link-to-drunk-fire-raising-lord-1.827233 Anger over spirits giant's link to drunk, fire-raising lord] ''The Herald'' 8th February 2009, accessed 6th October 2011 </ref>
+
Also at Caledonia at the time was another member of the SPBE, [[Lynda Gauld]] a former lobbyist for [[Pfizer]].<ref>[http://www.spinwatch.org/content/view/4523/29/ SPBE facilitates lobbying forum access to Scottish Parliament] Blogs - David Miller - Unspun Spinwatch, David Miller, 9 January 2008</ref> 
 +
 
 +
The controversy was compounded by the fact that Caledonia also hired two former MSPs. One [[David Davidson]] of the [[conservative Party]] was also connected with the SPBE while elected as an MSP.  The other [[Mike Watson]] is the disgraced former Labour minister imprisoned for 'fire raising' after he set alight the curtains at an Edinburgh hotel during a Scottish political awards event.<ref>[http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qn4156/is_20070805/ai_n19444216 Disgraced peer lands job with lobbying firm CONSULTANCY: NEW POST] Sunday Herald, The,  Aug 5, 2007  by Paul Hutcheon Scottish Political Editor</ref>
 +
 
 +
===Caledonia Consulting and Scotch Whisky===
 +
In 2009 The Herald reported that [[Diageo]] had hired [[Caledonia Consulting]] as part of their campaign against stricter alcohol regulation proposed by the SNP [[Scottish Government]].<ref> Tom Gordon and Paul Hutcheon,  [http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/politics/drunk-fire-raising-lord-s-links-to-firm-set-to-give-whisky-advice-to-holyrood-1.1125794?localLinksEnabled=false Drunk fire-raising Lord’s links to firm set to give whisky advice to Holyrood] ''The Herald'' 25th September 2011, accessed 6th October 2011 </ref>  
 +
 
 +
At the time, [[House of Lords]] cross-bencher, Baron Watson of Invergowrie, [[Mike Watson]], was an associate director of [[Caledonia Consulting]].  
 +
 
 +
[[Mike Watson]] served a 16 month prison sentence for setting fire to a hotel after the Scottish Politician of the Year Event in 2004.  The event is sponsored by [[Diageo]] and The Herald.  Watson pleaded guilty to wilful fire raising, the Scottish legal establishment's term for arson, but claimed he had experienced an alcohol related 'blackout' <ref> Tom Gordon and Paul Hutcheon, [http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/politics/drunk-fire-raising-lord-s-links-to-firm-set-to-give-whisky-advice-to-holyrood-1.1125794?localLinksEnabled=false Drunk fire-raising Lord’s links to firm set to give whisky advice to Holyrood] ''The Herald'' 25th September 2011, accessed 6th October 2011 </ref>  
 +
 
 +
[[Evelyn Gillan]], then director of [[Scottish Health Action on Alcohol Problems]] (SHAAP), now chief executive of [[Alcohol Focus Scotland]] said: "It is ironic that someone who has been in prison for an alcohol-fuelled crime is working for a firm helping Diageo put a stop to innovative policies. [[Diageo]] is only interested in maintaining profits, and Caledonia Consulting are helping them do this." <ref> Paul Hutcheon and Tom Gordon, [http://www.heraldscotland.com/anger-over-spirits-giant-s-link-to-drunk-fire-raising-lord-1.827233 Anger over spirits giant's link to drunk, fire-raising lord] ''The Herald'' 8th February 2009, accessed 6th October 2011 </ref>
 
            
 
            
−
The consultancy has clients from the scotch whisky industry,  that both [[Devin Scobie]] and [[Andrew Scobie]] (no relation) both sit on the [[Cross-Party Group in the Scottish Parliament on Scotch Whisky]].<ref> Scottish Parliament, [http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/msp/crosspartygroups/documents/ScotchWhisky.pdf Cross-Party Groups in the Scottish Parliament- Registration Form], no date given, accessed 5th October 2011 </ref>
+
The consultancy had clients from the scotch whisky industry. Both [[Devin Scobie]] and [[Andrew Scobie]] (no relation) also sat on the [[Cross-Party Group in the Scottish Parliament on Scotch Whisky]].<ref> Scottish Parliament, [http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/msp/crosspartygroups/documents/ScotchWhisky.pdf Cross-Party Groups in the Scottish Parliament- Registration Form], no date given, accessed 5th October 2011 </ref>
  
 
==People==
 
==People==
−
[[Devin Scobie]] | [[David Davidson]] | [[Lynda Gauld]] | [[Andrew Scobbie]] | [[Mike Watson]]<ref>Caledonia Consulting, [http://www.caledoniaconsulting.co.uk/ourteam.html Our Team] accessed 6th October</ref> [[Darren McDermott]]<ref> Paul Hutcheon and Tom Gordon, [http://www.heraldscotland.com/anger-over-spirits-giant-s-link-to-drunk-fire-raising-lord-1.827233 Anger over spirits giant's link to drunk, fire-raising lord] ''The Herald'' 8th February 2009, accessed 6th October 2011 </ref>
+
*[[Devin Scobie]], ex journalist
−
==contact, resources, notes==
+
*[[Margaret Smith]], former [[Liberal Democrat]] MSP. Smith was for 12 years MSP for Edinburgh West until May 2011. Former City of Edinburgh councillor.
−
===contact===
+
*[[Euan Robson]], former [[Liberal Democrat]] MSP. Robson was for 8 years MSP for Roxburgh and Berwickshire until 2007. He was Deputy Minister for Parliamentary Business in the opening session of the Scottish Parliament and Deputy Minister for Education and Young People in the second. He was then CEO of [[Scottish Sustainable Energy Foundation]].<ref>[http://www.caledoniaconsulting.co.uk/team.html Team], Caledonia website, accessed August 2015</ref>
−
http://www.caledoniaconsulting.co.uk/
+
 
−
===Resources===
+
===Former employees===
−
+
*[[David Davidson]], Associate Director, 2008-2010; former MSP
 +
*[[Mike Watson]], members of the [[House of Lords]]. <ref>Caledonia Consulting, [http://www.caledoniaconsulting.co.uk/ourteam.html Our Team] accessed 6th October</ref>
 +
*[[Lynda Gauld]]
 +
*[[Andrew Scobie]]
 +
*[[Darren McDermott]]<ref> Paul Hutcheon and Tom Gordon, [http://www.heraldscotland.com/anger-over-spirits-giant-s-link-to-drunk-fire-raising-lord-1.827233 Anger over spirits giant's link to drunk, fire-raising lord] ''The Herald'' 8th February 2009, accessed 6th October 2011 </ref>
 +
 
 +
==Clients==
 +
Caledonia does not declare its clients on its website, nor is it signed up to the voluntary transparency registers operated by the lobbying industry.
 +
 
 +
However, Devin Scobie is registered on the [[CIPR]]'s voluntary register. As of August 2015, he lists his clients as:<ref>[http://www.lobbying-register.uk/individual/I-00273.html (voluntary) lobbying register], CIPR, accessed August 2015</ref>
 +
*[[FREPower]]
 +
*[[BHTA]], [[British Healthcare Trades Association]]
 +
*[[Air Products]]
 +
*[[Sustainability Plus]]
 +
*[[SELECT]], Scotland's Electrical Trade Association
 +
*[[Action for Children Scotland]]
 +
*[[Diageo]] GB
 +
*[[EMC]]
 +
*[[Kier]] MG
 +
*[[National Trust for Scotland]]
 +
*[[Law Society of Scotland]]
 +
 
 +
==Contacts==
 +
:Address: 50 Montrose Terrace, Edinburgh, EH7 5DL
 +
:Website:http://www.caledoniaconsulting.co.uk/
 +
 
 +
==Resources==
 
*David Miller [http://www.spinwatch.org/index.php/david-miller-unspun/item/4251-spbe-facilitates-lobbying-forum-access-to-scottish-parliament SPBE facilitates lobbying forum access to Scottish Parliament] Blogs - Unspun ''Spinwatch'', 9 January 2008
 
*David Miller [http://www.spinwatch.org/index.php/david-miller-unspun/item/4251-spbe-facilitates-lobbying-forum-access-to-scottish-parliament SPBE facilitates lobbying forum access to Scottish Parliament] Blogs - Unspun ''Spinwatch'', 9 January 2008
  

Latest revision as of 02:35, 13 October 2015

The Caledonia lobbyists who ran the SPBE (from left to right) David Davidson, Mike Watson, Devin Scobie, Andrew Scobbie and Lynda Gauld

Caledonia Consulting is a lobbying firm in Edinburgh which is run by long time lobbyist Devin Scobie.

It employs two former Liberal Democrats MSPs (as of August 2015).

Controversy

Conflict of interest

Caledonia's Devin Scobie used to work for the controversial lobby firm GPC International (involved in the Derek Draper affair). At the same time, Scobie was simultaneously (until January 2008) the director of the Scottish Parliament Business Exchange a venture set up in the Scottish Parliament with the stated purpose of educating MSPs and business about each other. The body states that it is 'non-lobbying' and yet many of those associated with it, including Scobie, were/are professional lobbyists.[1]

This apparent conflict in the operations of the Exchange led to an inquiry into its activities by the Standards Committee of the Scottish Parliament.[2]

Also at Caledonia at the time was another member of the SPBE, Lynda Gauld a former lobbyist for Pfizer.[3]

The controversy was compounded by the fact that Caledonia also hired two former MSPs. One David Davidson of the conservative Party was also connected with the SPBE while elected as an MSP. The other Mike Watson is the disgraced former Labour minister imprisoned for 'fire raising' after he set alight the curtains at an Edinburgh hotel during a Scottish political awards event.[4]

Caledonia Consulting and Scotch Whisky

In 2009 The Herald reported that Diageo had hired Caledonia Consulting as part of their campaign against stricter alcohol regulation proposed by the SNP Scottish Government.[5]

At the time, House of Lords cross-bencher, Baron Watson of Invergowrie, Mike Watson, was an associate director of Caledonia Consulting.

Mike Watson served a 16 month prison sentence for setting fire to a hotel after the Scottish Politician of the Year Event in 2004. The event is sponsored by Diageo and The Herald. Watson pleaded guilty to wilful fire raising, the Scottish legal establishment's term for arson, but claimed he had experienced an alcohol related 'blackout' [6]

Evelyn Gillan, then director of Scottish Health Action on Alcohol Problems (SHAAP), now chief executive of Alcohol Focus Scotland said: "It is ironic that someone who has been in prison for an alcohol-fuelled crime is working for a firm helping Diageo put a stop to innovative policies. Diageo is only interested in maintaining profits, and Caledonia Consulting are helping them do this." [7]

The consultancy had clients from the scotch whisky industry. Both Devin Scobie and Andrew Scobie (no relation) also sat on the Cross-Party Group in the Scottish Parliament on Scotch Whisky.[8]

People

Former employees

Clients

Caledonia does not declare its clients on its website, nor is it signed up to the voluntary transparency registers operated by the lobbying industry.

However, Devin Scobie is registered on the CIPR's voluntary register. As of August 2015, he lists his clients as:[12]

Contacts

Address: 50 Montrose Terrace, Edinburgh, EH7 5DL
Website:http://www.caledoniaconsulting.co.uk/

Resources

References

  1. ↑ Paul Hutcheon, Criticism over relaunched Holyrood business scheme The Herald, 2nd June 2007, accessed 6th October 2011
  2. ↑ Standards Committee 9th Report 2002Report on The Scottish Parliament and Business Exchange SP Paper 694 Session 1 (2002)
  3. ↑ SPBE facilitates lobbying forum access to Scottish Parliament Blogs - David Miller - Unspun Spinwatch, David Miller, 9 January 2008
  4. ↑ Disgraced peer lands job with lobbying firm CONSULTANCY: NEW POST Sunday Herald, The, Aug 5, 2007 by Paul Hutcheon Scottish Political Editor
  5. ↑ Tom Gordon and Paul Hutcheon, Drunk fire-raising Lord’s links to firm set to give whisky advice to Holyrood The Herald 25th September 2011, accessed 6th October 2011
  6. ↑ Tom Gordon and Paul Hutcheon, Drunk fire-raising Lord’s links to firm set to give whisky advice to Holyrood The Herald 25th September 2011, accessed 6th October 2011
  7. ↑ Paul Hutcheon and Tom Gordon, Anger over spirits giant's link to drunk, fire-raising lord The Herald 8th February 2009, accessed 6th October 2011
  8. ↑ Scottish Parliament, Cross-Party Groups in the Scottish Parliament- Registration Form, no date given, accessed 5th October 2011
  9. ↑ Team, Caledonia website, accessed August 2015
  10. ↑ Caledonia Consulting, Our Team accessed 6th October
  11. ↑ Paul Hutcheon and Tom Gordon, Anger over spirits giant's link to drunk, fire-raising lord The Herald 8th February 2009, accessed 6th October 2011
  12. ↑ (voluntary) lobbying register, CIPR, accessed August 2015
Retrieved from "https://powerbase.info/index.php?title=Caledonia_Consulting&oldid=225431"