Difference between revisions of "Richard Chalk"

From Powerbase
Jump to: navigation, search
(fix)
 
(18 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
[[Richard Chalk]] has been the head of the [[Research Information and Communications Unit]] ([[RICU]]) since 2012.<ref name ="Guardian"> [http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/may/02/inside-ricu-the-shadowy-propaganda-unit-inspired-by-the-cold-war Inside Ricu, the shadowy propaganda unit inspired by the cold war], The ''Guardian'', 2 May 2016, accessed 10 May 2016</ref>
+
[[File:Screenshot 2020-02-28 at 22.07.35.png|thumb|right|400px|[[Richard Chalk]] in Estonia in March 2017]]
  
Prior to his current position, Chalk worked as an investment manager for [[British Aerospace]].<ref name ="Guardian"/>
+
[[Richard Chalk]] was head of the British [[Home Office]]'s [[Research Information and Communications Unit]] ([[RICU]]) between 2012 and around 2016.<ref name ="Guardian"> [http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/may/02/inside-ricu-the-shadowy-propaganda-unit-inspired-by-the-cold-war Inside Ricu, the shadowy propaganda unit inspired by the cold war], The ''Guardian'', 2 May 2016, accessed 10 May 2016</ref>
 +
[[File:Chalk.jpg|thumb|right|400px|[[Richard Chalk]] (on the left) with [[Michael Howard]] in 2005]]
  
Chalk has a long-standing association with the [[Conservative Party]]. In 1997, he stood as a parliamentary election candidate, reportedly describing himself as fuelled by 'religious conviction' and a 'passionate rejection of the dogma and dangerous idealism of a Socialist agenda'.<ref> [http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/the-cabinet-of-tomorrow-1277684.html The cabinet of tomorrow?] The ''Independent'', 9 February 1997, accessed 10 May 2016</ref> At this time he was also quoted as saying: 'I’m so dedicated to politics that I’m prepared to spend Valentine’s Day on the hustings'.<ref NAME ="Evening Standard"> IDS hopes to Chalk up success with spin wunderkind; Londoner’s Diary, The ''Evening Standard'', 11 April 2003, accessed 10 May 2016. Nexis Screengrab here </ref>  
+
==Spinning for the Conservative Party==
 +
Chalk has a long-standing association with the [[Conservative Party]]. In 1997, he stood as a parliamentary election candidate, reportedly describing himself as fuelled by 'religious conviction' and a 'passionate rejection of the dogma and dangerous idealism of a Socialist agenda'.<ref> [http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/the-cabinet-of-tomorrow-1277684.html The cabinet of tomorrow?] The ''Independent'', 9 February 1997, accessed 10 May 2016</ref> At this time Chalk worked as an investment manager for [[British Aerospace]].<ref name ="Guardian"/>
  
In 2001 Chalk reportedly masterminded [[Ken Clarke]]’s leadership bid against [[Iain Duncan Smith]].<ref name ="Evening Standard"/> Chalk was later appointed by Duncan Smith as director of planning in 2003, and acted also as deputy to the director of strategic communications, [[Paul Baverstock]].<ref name ="Evening Standard"/><ref> [http://www.prweek.com/article/505359/baverstock-handle-kenneth-clarkes-tory-leadership-bid Baverstock handles Kenneth Clarke's Tory leadership bid], ''PR Week'', 9 September 2005, accessed 10 May 2016</ref><ref> [http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1440203/Tory-media-chief-is-ousted-by-new-guard.html Tory media chief is ousted by new guard] The ''Telegraph'', 31 August 2003, accessed 10 May 2016</ref> [[The Sun]] credits Chalk for the 20 standing ovations Duncan Smith received for his Tory conference speech in the same year.<ref> Ken Clarke is banking on well-choreographed media appearances, The ''Sun'', 8 September, 2005, accessed 10 May 2006. Nexis Screengrab here </ref> Chalk subsequently worked as a spin doctor under former party leader [[Michael Howard]] in 2004,<ref> Hickey, The Express, 12 August 2005, accessed 10 May 2016. Nexis Screengrab here  </ref> before overseeing press relations for Ken Clarke’s unsuccessful leadership campaign in 2005.<ref> [http://www.walesonline.co.uk/news/wales-news/conservatives-refuse-confirm-role-london-1898046 Conservatives refuse to confirm role of London official in racism storm] ''Wales Online'', 17 September 2010, accessed 10 May 2016</ref>
+
In 2003 he was also quoted as saying: 'I’m so dedicated to politics that I’m prepared to spend Valentine’s Day on the hustings'.<ref NAME ="Evening Standard"> IDS hopes to Chalk up success with spin wunderkind; Londoner’s Diary, The ''Evening Standard'', 11 April 2003, accessed 10 May 2016. Nexis Screengrab [http://powerbase.info/index.php/File:Richard_Chalk_The_Evening_Standard_Nexis_Screengrab.jpg here] </ref>  
  
In 2005-2006 Chalk worked in Baghdad for British public relations firm [[Bell Pottinger Communications]], where he was commissioned to deliver multi-channelled communications campaigns.<ref name="Zoominfo"> [http://www.zoominfo.com/p/Richard-Chalk/1235200107 Zoominfo, Richard Chalk], accessed 12 May 2016</ref> In a $5.8m (£3.2m) deal, Bell Pottinger had been appointed by the [[Coalition Provisional Authority]] to promote democracy in Iraq preceding the handover of power to the [[Iraqi Interim Government]] on 30 June 2005.<ref> [http://www.prweek.com/article/204668/bell-pottinger-iraq-democracy-pr-drive Bell Pottinger in Iraq democracy PR drive], ''PR Week'', 11 March 2004, accessed 10 May 2016</ref> Chalk’s work, some of which is confidential, included 'information operations' aimed at undermining the insurgency. Scott Brown, who in 2016 is a director of [[Breakthrough Media Network]], which currently works for RICU also worked for both the Conservatives and Bell Pottinger’s information operations team in Baghdad.<ref name= "Guardian"/>
+
In 2001 Chalk reportedly masterminded [[Ken Clarke]]’s leadership bid against [[Iain Duncan Smith]].<ref name ="Evening Standard"/> Chalk was later appointed by Duncan Smith as director of planning in 2003, and acted also as deputy to the director of strategic communications, [[Paul Baverstock]].<ref name ="Evening Standard"/><ref> [http://www.prweek.com/article/505359/baverstock-handle-kenneth-clarkes-tory-leadership-bid Baverstock handles Kenneth Clarke's Tory leadership bid], ''PR Week'', 9 September 2005, accessed 10 May 2016</ref><ref> [http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1440203/Tory-media-chief-is-ousted-by-new-guard.html Tory media chief is ousted by new guard] The ''Telegraph'', 31 August 2003, accessed 10 May 2016</ref> [[The Sun]] credits Chalk for the 20 standing ovations Duncan Smith received for his Tory conference speech in the same year.<ref> Ken Clarke is banking on well-choreographed media appearances, The ''Sun'', 8 September, 2005, accessed 10 May 2006. Nexis Screengrab [http://powerbase.info/index.php/File:Richard_Chalk_The_Sun_Nexis_Screengrab.png here]</ref> Chalk subsequently worked as a spin doctor under former party leader [[Michael Howard]] in 2004,<ref> Hickey, The Express, 12 August 2005, accessed 10 May 2016. Nexis Screengrab [http://powerbase.info/index.php/File:Richard_Chalk_The_Express_Nexis_Screengrab.jpg here]</ref> before overseeing press relations for Ken Clarke’s unsuccessful leadership campaign in 2005.<ref> [http://www.walesonline.co.uk/news/wales-news/conservatives-refuse-confirm-role-london-1898046 Conservatives refuse to confirm role of London official in racism storm] ''Wales Online'', 17 September 2010, accessed 10 May 2016</ref>
 +
==Spinning democracy in Iraq==
 +
In 2005-2006 Chalk worked in Baghdad for British public relations firm [[Bell Pottinger Communications]], where he was commissioned to deliver multi-channelled communications campaigns.<ref name="Zoominfo"> [http://www.zoominfo.com/p/Richard-Chalk/1235200107 Zoominfo, Richard Chalk], accessed 12 May 2016</ref> In a $5.8m (£3.2m) deal, Bell Pottinger had been appointed by the [[Coalition Provisional Authority]] to promote democracy in Iraq preceding the handover of power to the [[Iraqi Interim Government]] on 30 June 2005.<ref> [http://www.prweek.com/article/204668/bell-pottinger-iraq-democracy-pr-drive Bell Pottinger in Iraq democracy PR drive], ''PR Week'', 11 March 2004, accessed 10 May 2016</ref> Chalk’s work, some of which is confidential, included 'information operations' aimed at undermining the insurgency. Scott Brown, who in 2016 is a director of [[Breakthrough Media Network]] - which currently works for RICU - also worked for both the Conservatives and Bell Pottinger’s information operations team in Baghdad.<ref name= "Guardian"/>
  
Chalk returned to the UK in 2006 to fulfil an 18 month contract as Chief of Staff under the then Conservative Party co-chair [[Sayeeda Warsi]].<ref name= "Guardian"/><ref name="Zoominfo"/>. In 2008 he became the CEO of [[M&C Saatchi]]’s Middle East operation<ref name="Zoominfo"/><ref>[http://www.kippreport.com/article/testy-creatives-hit-back-at-saatchi-jibes/ Testy creatives hit back at Saatchi jibes] ''Kip Report'', 6 June 2008, accessed 10 May 2016</ref>
+
Chalk returned to the UK in 2006 to fulfil an 18-month contract as chief of staff under the then Conservative Party co-chair [[Sayeeda Warsi]].<ref name= "Guardian"/><ref name="Zoominfo"/>. In 2008 he became the chief executive of [[M&C Saatchi]]’s Middle East operation.<ref name="Zoominfo"/><ref>[http://www.kippreport.com/article/testy-creatives-hit-back-at-saatchi-jibes/ Testy creatives hit back at Saatchi jibes] ''Kip Report'', 6 June 2008, accessed 10 May 2016</ref>
  
 
==Head of RICU==
 
==Head of RICU==
Line 25: Line 29:
 
A report by [[CAGE]] stated that under Chalk’s guidance, RICU has played a central role in delivering campaigns to secretly steer the conversation within Muslim communities on issues such as ‘extremism’ and ‘radicalisation’, and to garner support for the Government’s counter-terrorism policies.<ref> [http://www.cageuk.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/CAGE_WACI.pdf "We are completely independent": The Home Office, Breakthrough Media and the PREVENT Counter Narrative Industry] Ben Hayes and Asim Qureshi, ''CAGE'', 2016, accessed 10 May 2016</ref>
 
A report by [[CAGE]] stated that under Chalk’s guidance, RICU has played a central role in delivering campaigns to secretly steer the conversation within Muslim communities on issues such as ‘extremism’ and ‘radicalisation’, and to garner support for the Government’s counter-terrorism policies.<ref> [http://www.cageuk.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/CAGE_WACI.pdf "We are completely independent": The Home Office, Breakthrough Media and the PREVENT Counter Narrative Industry] Ben Hayes and Asim Qureshi, ''CAGE'', 2016, accessed 10 May 2016</ref>
  
==Conference Speeches==
+
==European Strategic Communications Network==
  
In June 2013 Chalk co-chaired [[The Global Counterterrorism Forum]]’s organised UN Conference on 'Best Practice in Communications' in London. The talk concluded that 'practitioners must take a strategic approach to countering violent extremism communications work and articulate the totality of a government’s engagement on a given issue', and that 'policies must be aligned with messages in order to be credible.'<ref>[https://www.opendemocracy.net/ben-hayes-asim-qureshi/going-global-uk-government-s-propaganda-and-censorship-silicon-valley-and-cve Going global: the UK government’s ‘CVE’ agenda, counter-radicalisation and covert propaganda] Ben Hayes and Asim Qureshi, ''Open Democracy UK'' 4 May 2016, accessed 10 May 2016</ref>
+
In March 2017 Chalk appeared at a number of conferences representing the [[European Strategic Communications Network]].
  
Chalk was invited to speak at the Security and Counter Terror Expo on 19 April 2016. His talk was to cover the efficacy of the Government’s [[PREVENT]] Strategy in dealing with radicalisation.<ref>[http://www.counterterrorexpo.com/seminar/BREAK Session 2: Radicalisation, de-radicalisaiton] Security and Counter terror expo, accessed 10 May 2016</ref>
+
*On 17 March spoke on 'Communication  strategies:  Governments  and  institutions  and other key players responding to terrorism, migration information challenges, disinformation and declining trust' at a meeting of the Club of Venice titled, Seminar on 'Strategic communications challenges for Europe'.<ref name="Venice">Club of Venice  [http://www.politicheeuropee.gov.it/media/3221/programma-del-seminario.pdf Seminar on strategic communications challenges for Europe], 16 and 17 March 2017.</ref>
 +
*On 30 March he spoke at “European response to terrorism” at the conference centre of the Radisson Blu Sky Hotel in Tallinn, Estonia. He was listed as 'Head' of the ESCN.<ref>Hea Kodanik [https://heakodanik.ee/uudised/mis-euroopa-vastus-terrorismile-tule-konverentsile-30-martsil/ Mis on Euroopa vastus terrorismile? Tule konverentsile] 30. märtsil
 +
laine uudised-laine] 27. märts 2017.</ref> and 'Head of advisory team'. <ref name="Delfi">Delfi [https://www.delfi.ee/news/paevauudised/eesti/blogi-terrorismikonverentsilt-tallinnas-kuidas-vastab-euroopa-terrorismile?id=77729236 BLOGI terrorismikonverentsilt Tallinnas: kuidas vastab Euroopa terrorismile?], 30 March 2017.</ref>
 +
 
 +
In Estonia Chalk was reported as saying the following (Translated from Estonian by Google translate):
 +
 
 +
:1:26 pm
 +
:Chalk: The arrival of the Islamic State (Daesh) meant a major change in the world of terrorism. Military defeats have led to a change in their propaganda, now calling for local ultra-violent attacks. Such are the terrorist attacks in Nice, Berlin and London.
 +
:1:29 pm
 +
:Chalk: Both Daesh, al-Qaeda and right-wing extremists are creating aggressive messages that we are against.
 +
:1:31 pm
 +
:Chalk: Not only a counter narrative is needed, but also alternative narratives. There is a need to show young people alternatives to terrorism.
 +
:1:57 pm
 +
:Chalk: The Islamic State is a brand that has certain features that are advertised. It is sold like other brands. A brand relies on emotional attraction, it can be undermined if you show that the brand does not really deliver what it promises. It has been done. If the advertised item is not as advertised, it will soon become known.<ref name="Delfi"/>
 +
 
 +
==Conference speeches==
 +
 
 +
In June 2013 Chalk co-chaired the [[Global Counterterrorism Forum]]’s organised [[UN Conference on 'Best Practice in Communications']] in London. The talk concluded that 'practitioners must take a strategic approach to countering violent extremism communications work and articulate the totality of a government’s engagement on a given issue', and that 'policies must be aligned with messages in order to be credible'.<ref>[https://www.opendemocracy.net/ben-hayes-asim-qureshi/going-global-uk-government-s-propaganda-and-censorship-silicon-valley-and-cve Going global: the UK government’s ‘CVE’ agenda, counter-radicalisation and covert propaganda] Ben Hayes and Asim Qureshi, ''Open Democracy UK'' 4 May 2016, accessed 10 May 2016</ref>
 +
 
 +
Chalk was invited to speak at the [[Security and Counter Terror Expo]] on 19 April 2016. His talk covered the efficacy of the Government’s [[PREVENT]] strategy in dealing with radicalisation.<ref>[http://www.counterterrorexpo.com/seminar/BREAK Session 2: Radicalisation, de-radicalisaiton] Security and Counter terror expo, accessed 10 May 2016</ref>
 +
 
 +
==Affiliations==
 +
Chalk is the sole director of [[REOC Communications Limited]] which was registered in 2006.<ref>Companies House [https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/officers/C-P4piD-x3S0pxXrnxnl0oqjpGk/appointments Richard Edward Oliver CHALK]. Accessed 27 February 2020.</ref>  His former colleague at [[Breakthrough Media]], [[Tony McMahon]] lists a post as a consultant at REOC on his LinkedIn profile.[[File:Screenshot 2020-02-27 at 22.24.29.png|right|thumb|300px|[[Tony McMahon]], formerly of [[Breakthrough Media]]/[[Zinc]], now a consultant at [[REOC Communications]]]]
  
 
==Resources==
 
==Resources==
 +
 
==Notes==
 
==Notes==
 
<references/>
 
<references/>

Latest revision as of 09:50, 31 March 2020

Richard Chalk in Estonia in March 2017

Richard Chalk was head of the British Home Office's Research Information and Communications Unit (RICU) between 2012 and around 2016.[1]

Richard Chalk (on the left) with Michael Howard in 2005

Spinning for the Conservative Party

Chalk has a long-standing association with the Conservative Party. In 1997, he stood as a parliamentary election candidate, reportedly describing himself as fuelled by 'religious conviction' and a 'passionate rejection of the dogma and dangerous idealism of a Socialist agenda'.[2] At this time Chalk worked as an investment manager for British Aerospace.[1]

In 2003 he was also quoted as saying: 'I’m so dedicated to politics that I’m prepared to spend Valentine’s Day on the hustings'.[3]

In 2001 Chalk reportedly masterminded Ken Clarke’s leadership bid against Iain Duncan Smith.[3] Chalk was later appointed by Duncan Smith as director of planning in 2003, and acted also as deputy to the director of strategic communications, Paul Baverstock.[3][4][5] The Sun credits Chalk for the 20 standing ovations Duncan Smith received for his Tory conference speech in the same year.[6] Chalk subsequently worked as a spin doctor under former party leader Michael Howard in 2004,[7] before overseeing press relations for Ken Clarke’s unsuccessful leadership campaign in 2005.[8]

Spinning democracy in Iraq

In 2005-2006 Chalk worked in Baghdad for British public relations firm Bell Pottinger Communications, where he was commissioned to deliver multi-channelled communications campaigns.[9] In a $5.8m (£3.2m) deal, Bell Pottinger had been appointed by the Coalition Provisional Authority to promote democracy in Iraq preceding the handover of power to the Iraqi Interim Government on 30 June 2005.[10] Chalk’s work, some of which is confidential, included 'information operations' aimed at undermining the insurgency. Scott Brown, who in 2016 is a director of Breakthrough Media Network - which currently works for RICU - also worked for both the Conservatives and Bell Pottinger’s information operations team in Baghdad.[1]

Chalk returned to the UK in 2006 to fulfil an 18-month contract as chief of staff under the then Conservative Party co-chair Sayeeda Warsi.[1][9]. In 2008 he became the chief executive of M&C Saatchi’s Middle East operation.[9][11]

Head of RICU

Chalk was reportedly hired to head RICU in 2012 because of his expertise in counter-terrorism strategic communications. According to The Guardian:

Under Chalk’s leadership, Ricu began communicating with British Muslims in a manner more reminiscent of counter-insurgency operations than a traditional public information campaign: disseminating messages through the use of subterfuge.[1]

The Guardian also reported that Chalk supervises at least some of the work carried out by RICU’s contractor Breakthrough Media Network. Breakthrough produces films, Twitter feeds, Facebook profiles, YouTube clips and online radio content. One of its objectives is to 'influence online conversations by being embedded within target communities via a network of moderate organisations that are supportive of it’s [sic] goals.' It also seeks to help the British Government 'promote a reconciled British Muslim Identity.' The Guardian states:

Ricu and Breakthrough focus on 'Prevent priority areas' in the UK, using keywords and paid-for Google and Facebook adverts to target people whose browsing history suggests they are Muslims. Using so-called 'promotion and diversion techniques', Breakthrough promotes Ricu’s messages to browsers who are searching for terms such as Isis, Khalifa and “What does the Qur’an say about jihad?”[1]

Leaked papers acquired by The Guardian suggested that one of Breakthrough’s campaigns created under RICU’s instruction, Help for Syria, has been used secretly as a counter-radicalisation scheme for Britons wanting to assist fellow Muslims in Syria. The campaign funnels aid to Syrian refugees, but allegedly aims to divert British Muslims into UK-based charity aid as opposed to travelling to deliver aid or join the jihad in Syria. RICU’s involvement in Help for Syria is not openly advertised.[12]

A report by CAGE stated that under Chalk’s guidance, RICU has played a central role in delivering campaigns to secretly steer the conversation within Muslim communities on issues such as ‘extremism’ and ‘radicalisation’, and to garner support for the Government’s counter-terrorism policies.[13]

European Strategic Communications Network

In March 2017 Chalk appeared at a number of conferences representing the European Strategic Communications Network.

  • On 17 March spoke on 'Communication strategies: Governments and institutions and other key players responding to terrorism, migration information challenges, disinformation and declining trust' at a meeting of the Club of Venice titled, Seminar on 'Strategic communications challenges for Europe'.[14]
  • On 30 March he spoke at “European response to terrorism” at the conference centre of the Radisson Blu Sky Hotel in Tallinn, Estonia. He was listed as 'Head' of the ESCN.[15] and 'Head of advisory team'. [16]

In Estonia Chalk was reported as saying the following (Translated from Estonian by Google translate):

1:26 pm
Chalk: The arrival of the Islamic State (Daesh) meant a major change in the world of terrorism. Military defeats have led to a change in their propaganda, now calling for local ultra-violent attacks. Such are the terrorist attacks in Nice, Berlin and London.
1:29 pm
Chalk: Both Daesh, al-Qaeda and right-wing extremists are creating aggressive messages that we are against.
1:31 pm
Chalk: Not only a counter narrative is needed, but also alternative narratives. There is a need to show young people alternatives to terrorism.
1:57 pm
Chalk: The Islamic State is a brand that has certain features that are advertised. It is sold like other brands. A brand relies on emotional attraction, it can be undermined if you show that the brand does not really deliver what it promises. It has been done. If the advertised item is not as advertised, it will soon become known.[16]

Conference speeches

In June 2013 Chalk co-chaired the Global Counterterrorism Forum’s organised UN Conference on 'Best Practice in Communications' in London. The talk concluded that 'practitioners must take a strategic approach to countering violent extremism communications work and articulate the totality of a government’s engagement on a given issue', and that 'policies must be aligned with messages in order to be credible'.[17]

Chalk was invited to speak at the Security and Counter Terror Expo on 19 April 2016. His talk covered the efficacy of the Government’s PREVENT strategy in dealing with radicalisation.[18]

Affiliations

Chalk is the sole director of REOC Communications Limited which was registered in 2006.[19] His former colleague at Breakthrough Media, Tony McMahon lists a post as a consultant at REOC on his LinkedIn profile.

Tony McMahon, formerly of Breakthrough Media/Zinc, now a consultant at REOC Communications

Resources

Notes

  1. 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 Inside Ricu, the shadowy propaganda unit inspired by the cold war, The Guardian, 2 May 2016, accessed 10 May 2016
  2. The cabinet of tomorrow? The Independent, 9 February 1997, accessed 10 May 2016
  3. 3.0 3.1 3.2 IDS hopes to Chalk up success with spin wunderkind; Londoner’s Diary, The Evening Standard, 11 April 2003, accessed 10 May 2016. Nexis Screengrab here
  4. Baverstock handles Kenneth Clarke's Tory leadership bid, PR Week, 9 September 2005, accessed 10 May 2016
  5. Tory media chief is ousted by new guard The Telegraph, 31 August 2003, accessed 10 May 2016
  6. Ken Clarke is banking on well-choreographed media appearances, The Sun, 8 September, 2005, accessed 10 May 2006. Nexis Screengrab here
  7. Hickey, The Express, 12 August 2005, accessed 10 May 2016. Nexis Screengrab here
  8. Conservatives refuse to confirm role of London official in racism storm Wales Online, 17 September 2010, accessed 10 May 2016
  9. 9.0 9.1 9.2 Zoominfo, Richard Chalk, accessed 12 May 2016
  10. Bell Pottinger in Iraq democracy PR drive, PR Week, 11 March 2004, accessed 10 May 2016
  11. Testy creatives hit back at Saatchi jibes Kip Report, 6 June 2008, accessed 10 May 2016
  12. Help for Syria aid campaign secretly run by UK Government, The Guardian, 3 May 2016, accessed 10 May 2016
  13. "We are completely independent": The Home Office, Breakthrough Media and the PREVENT Counter Narrative Industry Ben Hayes and Asim Qureshi, CAGE, 2016, accessed 10 May 2016
  14. Club of Venice Seminar on strategic communications challenges for Europe, 16 and 17 March 2017.
  15. Hea Kodanik Mis on Euroopa vastus terrorismile? Tule konverentsile 30. märtsil laine uudised-laine] 27. märts 2017.
  16. 16.0 16.1 Delfi BLOGI terrorismikonverentsilt Tallinnas: kuidas vastab Euroopa terrorismile?, 30 March 2017.
  17. Going global: the UK government’s ‘CVE’ agenda, counter-radicalisation and covert propaganda Ben Hayes and Asim Qureshi, Open Democracy UK 4 May 2016, accessed 10 May 2016
  18. Session 2: Radicalisation, de-radicalisaiton Security and Counter terror expo, accessed 10 May 2016
  19. Companies House Richard Edward Oliver CHALK. Accessed 27 February 2020.