Confederation of Friends of Israel in Scotland

From Powerbase
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Glasgow-based charity that supports Friends of Israel groups in Scotland (OSCR SC050079)

Confederation of Friends of Israel in Scotland

Type Scottish Charitable Incorporated Organisation (SCIO)
Founded 17 April 2020
Registration ID SC050079 (Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator)
Status Active
Headquarters 222 Fenwick Road, Glasgow, G46 6UE[1]
Area served Scotland
Services Support and administration for regional Friends of Israel groups; website and social media about Israel
Registration Scotland (OSCR)
Website www.cofis.org

Confederation of Friends of Israel in Scotland (COFIS) is a Scottish charity that, in its own words, "is set up to support Friends of Israel groups in Scotland and to challenge antisemitism and misinformation about Israel". Its first stated purpose is "to advance education regarding Israel".[1] It registered with the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator (OSCR) as a SCIO on 17 April 2020. Its registered address is 222 Fenwick Road, Glasgow, G46 6UE,[1] the same building in Giffnock that appears on the register for the Jewish Council of Scotland, The KKL (Scotland) Charitable Trust (JNF KKL Scotland), Eastwood Jewish Community Centres and Giffnock Newton Mearns Synagogue.[2]

In the year to 30 April 2025 COFIS had income of £4,976, of which £4,396 was "Restricted donations received – GFOI" (Glasgow Friends of Israel). It spent £650 on "Restricted donations given – GFOI" and £3,746 on "Restricted donations - Conference cost".[3] The trustees' report says COFIS "was considerably involved in organising the Glasgow Friends of Israel Conference; the first since 2019; to be held on 11 May 2025".[3] Neither the accounts nor the OSCR register name its trustees.[3][1]

Confederation of Friends of Israel in Scotland (COFIS)

The Confederation of Friends of Israel in Scotland is a Scottish registered charity established 17 April 2020.

  • Regulatory Type: Standard
  • Objective: "The organisation’s purposes are: to advance education regarding Israel; to promote equality and diversity; to advance human rights, conflict resolution and reconciliation; to promote religious and racial harmony"

Formation

Richard Haley of Scotland Against Criminalising Communities wrote in February 2019:[4]

The launch of Edinburgh Friends of Israel in 2015 drew guests from all over Scotland. Around 95% of them were said to be non-Jewish, and most of these to have been Christian. Glasgow Friends of Israel was launched shortly afterwards. Co-founder Sammy Stein said: "The vast majority of our members are not Jewish." Similar groups have been set up around Scotland, including Aberdeen, Dundee, Dumfries and Galloway, Highland and Perth. The COFIS website currently lists thirteen groups as established or in the pipeline.
The groups were said to be "independently funded by members". But their rapid flowering was the outcome of an inititiative of the Britain Israel Communications and Research Centre (BICOM). BICOM is a privately funded lobby and action group for the benefit of Israel. It describes itself as "an independent research centre producing research and analysis about Israel and the Middle East" and says it supports "a close relationship between Britain and Israel, based on shared values and interests." It was set up in October 2000.

Creating a rash of Friends of Israel groups in Scotland

According to Zionist activist Judith Ornstein, the creation of the rash of pro Israel groups in Scotland from 2015 was spearheaded by Nigel Goodrich. In her account of her speech in Glasgow she states:

With the continuing support of StandWithUs, Judy Weleminsky and others he has set up Friends of Israel groups all over Scotland. They are also responsible for 2016’s and 2017’s Shalom Festivals at the Edinburgh Fringe where Israeli multicultural events were showcased. In 2016 audiences had to endure a barrage of abuse from the SPSC, but this year the Israeli presence was increased and the abuse reduced to almost nothing.[5]

Ornstein's husband Ged Ornstein was a trustee of StandWithUs UK between 15 November 2016 and 13 August 2020.

Members

In 2025 COFIS claims only three members as follows:

  • Glasgow Friends of Israel By far the largest of the Friends of Israel groups in Scotland, GFI operates an information stall in Buchanan Street every Saturday. as well as hosting interesting speakers via Zoom. Check out their website; their Facebook page and their Twitter account.
  • Edinburgh Friends of Israel Edinburgh is home to Scotland's second largest Jewish community but is, sadly, also home to considerable hostility towards Israel. Since the start of the current conflict, they have been busy organising vigils. Check out their Facebook page and get involved!
  • Highland Friends of Israel Based in Inverness, HFOI frequently operates an information stall in the city centre on Saturdays, as well as hosting visiting speakers. Check out their Facebook page and their Twitter account.

By October 2026 COFIS's website listed seven Scottish groups: Glasgow, Edinburgh, Ayrshire, Fife (founded 2026), Highland, North East Scotland and Tayside (founded 2026).[6]

​We Believe in Israel, by contrast, lists the following groups in Scotland. Most of these are no longer listed by COFIS: of the eight groups other than COFIS itself, only Edinburgh, Glasgow and Highland Friends of Israel appear among the Scottish groups on COFIS's website in October 2026, which also lists groups in Ayrshire, Fife, North East Scotland and Tayside.[6]

​

People

Patron

Trustees

COFIS does not disclose its Trustees or Patrons. Its subsidiary organisations such as Glasgow Friends of Israel do disclose officials, including Sammy Stein and Walter Hecht.

Details of charity's operations

2015: According to The Times of Israel, COFIS were operational in August 2015. The twitter account for COFIS was created in January 2016, however it did not become active until May 2018. One of COFIS earliest tweets was to advertise an event in Glasgow on 22 May 2018 with Luke Akehurst titled 'How did the Labour Party get into such a mess over Israel, Jews and antisemitism?' [17]


  • Charity Status: Active
  • Last Updated: 12 February 2025
  • Constitutional Form: SCIO (Scottish Charitable Incorporated Organisation)
  • Constitutional Form Date: 17 April 2020
  • Geographical Spread: Operations cover all or most of Scotland
  • Main Operating Location: Glasgow City
  • Puropses: "the advancement of education","the advancement of human rights, conflict resolution or reconciliation","the promotion of religious or racial harmony","the promotion of equality and diversity"
  • Beneficiaries: "No specific group, or for the benefit of the community"
  • Types of activity undertaken: "It carries out activities or services itself"

Income & Expenditure

Income and expenditure

Details

Registration and finances

  • Founded: Registered charity 17 April 2020[1]
  • Income and expenditure: Income £4,976; expenditure £5,104 (year ending 30 April 2025)[1]

COFIS is on the Scottish Charity Register as SC050079, known as "COFIS". It is a single-tier SCIO, so "the trustees are the members of the charitable organisation".[1][3] The register describes its work: "It does this through maintaining a website providing information about Israel and social media accounts, as well as providing administrative support to regional Friends of Israel groups including maintenance of social media accounts. Trustees also liaise with and support like-minded individuals and organisations throughout the rest of the UK." It records no staff and no volunteers.[1] Companies House lists it as a Scottish charitable incorporated organisation, CS004553, "registered externally as SC050079".[18]

Annual returns to OSCR[1]
Year ending Income (£) Expenditure (£) Annual return received
30 April 2022 0 0 30 January 2023
30 April 2023 1,681 1,326 30 January 2024
30 April 2024 1,216 997 29 January 2025
30 April 2025 4,976 5,104 25 February 2026
30 April 2026 Not yet received (October 2026)

The 2024-25 accounts give expenditure for the year to 30 April 2024 as £1,147 (in the financial review and the statement of financial activities), not the £997 shown on the register.[3][1]

Year to 30 April 2025

  • Income: £4,976, made up of donations of £580 and "Restricted donations received – GFOI" of £4,396 (2024: donations £440, GFOI £500, Gift Aid £276).[3]
  • Spending: £5,104, including "Restricted donations given – GFOI" £650, "Restricted donations - Conference cost" £3,746, computer costs £324, trustees' travel £132, subscriptions £187 and accountancy £50. The year ended with a deficit of £128, and reserves fell from £424 to £296.[3] The report says: "The great majority of the increased income and expenditure was in the form of restricted income which was then used to contribute to the Glasgow Friends of Israel Conference."[3]
  • Trustee support: "We were grateful once again for the donation by Trustees of ICT resources, including funding for the website."[3]
  • Independent examiner: Clapham Accounting Services, 38 Fruin Court, Newton Mearns, G77 6HJ.[3] The examiner's report refers to "the year ended 30 April 2024" and is addressed to the "Confederation of Friends of Israel of Scotland".[3]

Activities described in the 2024-25 report

The report states that after registration in 2020 "Covid lockdowns and other issues meant two years in which COFIS was largely dormant".[3] It lists these achievements:

  • "We supported the activities of Glasgow Friends of Israel and Highland Friends of Israel, including what we believe to be the most northerly pro-Israel advocacy stall in the UK ever, in sunny Dingwall!"
  • "Following the events of October 7, 2023 ... our Trustees have participated in dozens of vigils, marches, discussions, interviews and many hundreds of social media posts; keeping up our efforts until the final hostage was returned."[3]

It adds: "Trustees have been involved in organising and/or participating in vigils and other events for hostages in Glasgow, Edinburgh and London. Members of regional groups have done sterling work volunteering in Israel to support the country's efforts to sustain normal life".[3] A sentence beginning "Trustees and volunteers have supported the work of Israeli charities, including" breaks off without naming any charity.[3] For the future, COFIS aims to expand the regional groups, "Prime among these will be Edinburgh Friends of Israel, as that is a city with a great deal of anti-Israel sentiment and political activity."[3]

Trustees and governance

The OSCR register shows "Number of Charity Trustee: 0" and "No charity trustee information available".[1] In the redacted 2024-25 accounts the "Charity Trustees" heading, the list of trustees and the registered address are blank, and the report was signed on behalf of the trustees on 22 February 2026 without a legible name. The report says: "There were no new appointments to the Board during the year, and each of the office-bearers was unanimously re-elected."[3] OSCR says that supplying trustee information "will become mandatory as part of future annual submissions".[1]

In March 2019 Source News reported that Nigel Goodrich had been convener of COFIS until 9 October 2018, that Edward Sutherland was then acting convener, and that Sammy Stein spoke "on behalf of Cofis and affiliated organisation Glasgow Friends of Israel".[19] COFIS was registered as a charity on 17 April 2020.[1]

Controversies

Ben Wray reported in Source News on 15 March 2019:[19]

Former convenor of Cofis, Nigel Goodrich, is active participant in Facebook group which has as rule one: “This group is about ‘Palestine and Palestinians which doesn’t [sic] exist” Cofis activist Sammy Stein said they “have dissociated themselves from anything to do” with Goodrich, who stepped down as convenor last October However Cofis refused to offer their view on the ‘Jewish Defence Forces’ Facebook group, which also includes amongst its members a Britain First intelligence officer and a director of a anti-Islam conference addressed by Tommy Robinson in 2012
The leading pro-Israel campaigning group in Scotland has distanced itself from the man who was its convenor until just months ago, after it was revealed he was a member of a racist anti-Palestinian Facebook group. A representative of Confederation of Friends of Israel Scotland (Cofis) told CommonSpace it has “dissociated” itself from Nigel Goodrich, who is a major architect of pro-Israel networks in Scotland. CommonSpace can reveal that Goodrich was a member of the Facebook group ‘Jewish Defence Forces’ (JDF) whose description, pinned at the top of the page, engages in a series of racist smears against the Palestinian people, including that they do not exist and have no national claim.
Speaking to CommonSpace on behalf of Cofis and affiliated organisation Glasgow Friends of Israel (GFI), activist Sammy Stein said: “We have dissociated ourselves from anything to do with Nigel [Goodrich]. Full stop, everything and anything to do with Nigel.” Goodrich was convener of Cofis until 9 October 2018, according to the organisation. His history in rightwing pro-Israel circles in Scotland goes back several years, and he has represented the movement repeatedly in media interviews over that time. Cofis is the umbrella group coordinating a range of pro-Israel groups around the country, a key part of Goodrich’s efforts in recent years.
Cofis describes its role as to “resource and coordinate a growing number of groups around Scotland who are seeking to stand by the nation of Israel in the midst of pressures, boycotts and undeserved criticism.” The Jewish Defence Forces Facebook group’s first ‘rule’ for membership states: “‘This group is about “Palestine and Palestinians” which doesn’t [sic] exist. Israel is the name of our country.'” CommonSpace has seen evidence that Goodrich was an active member of the group, posting in support of the “honour” of the Israeli Defence Forces.
Stein was adamant that Goodrich no longer had anything to do with Cofis or GFI, and was not in contact. “He isn’t invited, he doesn’t attend, he isn’t in this country. He’s got nothing to do with those events,” he said. “I don’t believe he will be involved in anything we do.” When asked if it was worrying that the person who had led the organisation until so recently had joined a Facebook page who’s rules were based on such ideas, Stein said: “It sounds to me like he has changed, maybe that’s one of the reasons he has gone.” Stein insisted that the groups he was involved in were “anti-racist” and that “we believe in a two state solution”. He insisted that he “did not have a view” about whether the Facebook page was racist, as he had only just come across it through screenshots sent to him by CommonSpace. “I have to be very careful and check the things that you are pointing to. But that’s only partially something he said, he may have other views I don’t know.”
The current Cofis acting convener Edward Sutherland also commented, appearing to assert that Goodrich himself was not a racist. Sutherland said: “Nigel Goodrich resigned as Convenor of Cofis on 9 October 2018, due to relocating outside of the UK. He now has no involvement with Cofis. We are an organisation which advocates for peaceful coexistence between Israel and Palestinians and we reject all forms of racism, including antisemitism as defined in the IHRA definition. “Until yesterday, I was unaware of the existence of the Facebook group you refer to, but note from the screenshot that Nigel did not join until after he left Cofis. I have seen no evidence that Nigel has personally made any racist comment and would be astonished to do so [sic].” Other active members of the JDF Facebook group include Paul Besser, ’intelligence officer’ of the far-right group Britain First which has been banned from Facebook and Twitter, and Mordechai Kedar, an Israeli academic and director of Stop Islamisation of Nations, which infamous far-right figure Stephen Yaxley-Lennon (aka ‘Tommy Robinson’) addressed a conference of alongside Kedar in 2012.

Resources

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 1.11 1.12 Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator, Confederation of Friends of Israel in Scotland (SC050079) Scottish Charity Register, accessed 20 October 2026.
  2. ↑ Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator, Scottish Charity Register download (current register, 14 October 2026, and former charities, 20 October 2026), accessed 20 October 2026.
  3. ↑ 3.00 3.01 3.02 3.03 3.04 3.05 3.06 3.07 3.08 3.09 3.10 3.11 3.12 3.13 3.14 3.15 3.16 Confederation of Friends of Israel in Scotland, Trustees' Annual Report from 1 May 2024 to 30 April 2025 and Statement of Accounts (redacted copy), via Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator, accessed 20 October 2026.
  4. ↑ Richard Haley, Who are Friends of Israel? Scotland Against Criminalising Communities, 6 February 2019.
  5. ↑ Judith Ornstein, Antisemitism in the British Labour Party The Times of Israel (blogs), 10 December 2017, accessed 21 October 2026.
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 Confederation of Friends of Israel in Scotland, Scottish FOI groups cofis.org, accessed 28 October 2026.
  7. ↑ Aberdeen FOI aberdeenfoi.co.uk, archived 3 December 2023, accessed 21 October 2026.
  8. ↑ Dumfries and Galloway Friends of Israel, Dumfries and Galloway Friends of Israel - local people caring about international issues dagfoi.com, archived 4 September 2018, accessed 21 October 2026.
  9. ↑ https://web.archive.org/web/20191006162356/http://dagfoi.com/index.html
  10. ↑ Sandy Rashty, Friends groups will work to resist boycott efforts Jewish Chronicle, 2 April 2015, accessed 28 October 2026.
  11. ↑ The Edinburgh Star, No. 87, September 2019, "Edinburgh Jewish Community Contacts", accessed 28 October 2026.
  12. ↑ The Edinburgh Star, No. 88, September 2020, "Edinburgh Jewish Community Contacts", accessed 28 October 2026.
  13. ↑ Confederation of Friends of Israel in Scotland (COFIS), Edinburgh Friends of Israel cofis.org, archived 23 July 2021, accessed 21 October 2026.
  14. ↑ https://www.facebook.com/groups/178667772483257/user/100002318304869
  15. ↑ https://www.webelieveinisrael.org.uk/local_links
  16. ↑ Jenni Frazer. Ahead of summer fests, Scotland's new pro-Israel network stands guard. "Times of Israel". Retrieved via Archive.today on 21/10/21.
  17. ↑ Confederation of Friends of Israel in Scotland, @COFIScotland. Looking forward to hearing @lukeakehurst address Antisemitism issues in @UKLabour, @GnasherJew @antisemitism @BoardofDeputies #LabourFriendsOfIsrael #LabourAntisemitism. "Twitter". Retrieved via Archive today on 21/10/21.
  18. ↑ Companies House, CONFEDERATION OF FRIENDS OF ISRAEL IN SCOTLAND (CS004553), accessed 20 October 2026.
  19. ↑ 19.0 19.1 Ben Wray, Exclusive: Scottish pro-Israel group distances itself from former convener over racist Facebook page Source News, 15 March 2019.