Difference between revisions of "Melanie Phillips"

From Powerbase
Jump to: navigation, search
(Views)
m (=On Neoconservatism)
Line 42: Line 42:
 
==Views==
 
==Views==
 
===On Neoconservatism==
 
===On Neoconservatism==
In an article published shortly before the US-led invasion of Iraq Phillips told the ''[[Guradian|Guardian's]]'' Andy Beckett: 'I've been very influenced by what's called the neo-con movement. They're not conservatives. They define themselves famously as - and this is exactly how I would define myself - as liberals who have been mugged by reality.' <ref>Andy Beckett, '[http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2003/mar/07/dailymail.pressandpublishing The changing face of Melanie Phillips]', ''The Guardian'', 7 March 2003.</ref> Three years later she posted a review of [[Douglas Murray|Douglas Murray's]] book ''Neoconservatism: Why We Need It''. She praised the book and described neoconservatism as 'the only truly moral response to the times in which we live'. <ref>Melanie Phillips, '[http://www.melaniephillips.com/diary/archives/001617.html Why we need neoconservatism]', Melanie Phillips's Diary, 6 March 2006.</ref>
+
In an article published shortly before the US-led invasion of Iraq Phillips told the ''[[Guardian|Guardian's]]'' Andy Beckett: 'I've been very influenced by what's called the neo-con movement. They're not conservatives. They define themselves famously as - and this is exactly how I would define myself - as liberals who have been mugged by reality.' <ref>Andy Beckett, '[http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2003/mar/07/dailymail.pressandpublishing The changing face of Melanie Phillips]', ''The Guardian'', 7 March 2003.</ref> Three years later she posted a review of [[Douglas Murray|Douglas Murray's]] book ''Neoconservatism: Why We Need It''. She praised the book and described neoconservatism as 'the only truly moral response to the times in which we live'. <ref>Melanie Phillips, '[http://www.melaniephillips.com/diary/archives/001617.html Why we need neoconservatism]', Melanie Phillips's Diary, 6 March 2006.</ref>
  
 
===On Walt and Mearsheimer===
 
===On Walt and Mearsheimer===

Revision as of 14:58, 6 August 2010

Melanie Phillips. Picture by Flickr user Get Down

Melanie Phillips (b. 1951) is a British journalist and author.

Biography

According to her own website:

Born in 1951, Melanie read English at St Anne's College, Oxford before training as a journalist on the Evening Echo, Hemel Hempstead. After a short period on New Society magazine, she joined the Guardian in 1977 and soon became its social services correspondent and social policy leader writer. After a stint as the paper's news editor, she started writing her column in 1987, taking it to the Observer and then the Sunday Times before starting to write for the Daily Mail in December 2001.[1]

Phillips began blogging on her own website in October 2003. Four years later, she accepted an invitation to move the blog to the Spectator website. [2] On 6 June 2007, she appeared on the BBC's Question Time, and was introduced as 'one of the media's leading right-wing voices' [3] She is married to the Daily Telegraph's legal expert Joshua Rosenberg. [4]

Londonistan

Londonistan is Phillips's variation on the Eurabia theme. In 2006, Phillips published Londonistan: How Britain Has Created a Terror State Within. In a 2008 foreword, she wrote that "Britain is even now sleepwalking into Islamisation."

Some people will read that sentence and think this is mere hyperbole. That's the problem. Britain still doesn't grasp that it is facing a pincer attack from both terrorism and cultural infiltration and usurpation. The former is understood; the latter is generally not acknowledged or is even denied, and those who call attention to it are pilloried either as 'Islamophobes' or alarmists who have taken up residence on Planet Paranoia.[5]

Londonistan Conclusion

In Londonistan Phillips concludes that Islam "Has a responsibility to address those aspects of its culture that threaten the state"[6]. She argues that "Britain would first have to take robust steps to counter the specific threat posed by Islamist terrorism", a new threat which sits somewhere between war and terrorism"[7]. To deal with this new threat Phillips argues that:

  • Set up special courts to deal with "particularly sensitive cases in which intelligence could safely be brought forward as evidence"[8].
  • Repeal the human rights act and either derogate or withdraw from both the European convention on Human Rights and the UN Convention on Refugees, "To enable [Britain] to expel foreign radicals[9].
  • Stop the funding and recruitment of terrorism under the "umbrella of charitable work"[10].
  • "Shut down newspapers and television stations spreading incitement to terrorism in the war against the west[11].
  • Ban Hizb ut-Tahrir and the Muslim Association of Britain[12].
  • "Set about the remoralisation and reculturation of Britain by restating the primacy of British culture and citizenship" by recognising that "mass immigration, multiculturalism and the onslaught mounted by secular nihilists against the country’s Judeo-Christian values[13]."
  • Stop the practice of [Muslims] "marrying their young people to cousins from the Indian subcontinent"[14], because "that has got to stop because it is a threat to Social Cohesion""[15]
  • "Abolish the doctrine of Multiculturalism by reaffirming the primacy of British values"[16].
  • "Ensure that British political history is once again taught in schools, and that Christianity is restored to school assemblies"[17].
  • "Stop the drift towards the creation of a parallel Islamic jurisdiction under Sharia" and "no longer turn a blind eye to polygamy"[18].
  • End "the culture of entitlement ushered in by the application of secular human rights doctrine"[19].
  • "Finally, it [Britain] would undertake a major educational exercise for both Muslims and non-Muslims. It would teach Muslims what being a minority really means, and that certain ideas to which they may subscribe are simply unacceptable or demonstrably untrue. It would say loud and clear that the double standards from which Muslims think they suffer are actually a form of doublethink. Any administration that was really concerned to fight racism would educate the nation in the historical truths about Israel and the Arabs, and would tell Muslims that they have systematically been fed a diet of lies about Israel and the Jews"[20].

Views

=On Neoconservatism

In an article published shortly before the US-led invasion of Iraq Phillips told the Guardian's Andy Beckett: 'I've been very influenced by what's called the neo-con movement. They're not conservatives. They define themselves famously as - and this is exactly how I would define myself - as liberals who have been mugged by reality.' [21] Three years later she posted a review of Douglas Murray's book Neoconservatism: Why We Need It. She praised the book and described neoconservatism as 'the only truly moral response to the times in which we live'. [22]

On Walt and Mearsheimer

In March 2006, Phillips attacked the London Review of Books for publishing The Israel Lobby by John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt:

This LRB travesty is not a one-off. It is but the latest example of a poisonous pathology which has gripped the intelligentsia of the west, centred around a visceral loathing of America, Israel, the neocons and the Jews. Indeed, neo-conservatism seems to have induced a kind of madness, a total eclipse of reason among its political opponents; it is not surprising, therefore, that those within the intelligentsia who have developed such an obsessive loathing of the neo-cons have ended up in bed with white supremacists and clerical fascists.[23]

On Ed Husain

A one time champion of Ed Husain, Phillips went on to denounce him after he wrote an article critical of the Israeli assault on Gaza[24]. She called Husain's piece 'stupid and ignorant' and 'poisonous' which placed him on the wrong side 'in the great battle to defend civilisation against barbarism'.[25]

On Multiculturalism

The doctrines of multiculturalism and minority rights, themselves the outcome of a systematic onslaught by the British elite against the country’s own identity and values, have paralysed the establishment, which accordingly shies away from criticising any minority for fear of being labelled as bigoted...Britain effectively allowed itself to be taken hostage by militant gays, feminists or “anti-racists” who used weapons such as public vilification, moral blackmail and threats to people’s livelihoods to force the majority to give in to their demands.[26]

On the BNP

In November 2006, Phillips criticised the BNP's attempts to exploit hostility to Islam, while insisting that the party was tapping into a genuine issue:

Like all fascist parties, the BNP manipulate for their own ends genuine concerns that the political class has brushed aside. The concern today is radical Islamism. But the BNP’s platform against Muslims masks a racist hostility towards all immigrants, foreigners and Jews.
Despite the manifest absurdity of the BNP’s attempt to cosy up to the Jews, however, the left has seized on its manoeuvrings in order to smear Jews and Zionists as being the neo-fascists’ natural allies.[27]

In the Daily Mail a few days later, Phillips criticised the decision to put the BNP's Nick Griffin and Mark Collett on trial for inciting racial hatred.

There was never any chance of a conviction, for the simple reason that such statements were an attack on a religion rather than a race. It is perfectly legitimate, after all, to say that the enforcement of extreme Islamic precepts poses a threat to the lives of millions of Asians — including, in fact, many Muslims.
It didn’t take a genius to work out that this trial was a win-win situation for the BNP. If Griffin and Collett had been convicted, they would have posed as martyrs to free speech. Their acquittal, on the other hand, has provided a tremendous boost for their repellent platform.[28]

Resources

References

  1. Biography, melaniephillips.com, accessed 9 March 2009.
  2. Biography, melaniephillips.com, accessed 9 March 2009.
  3. This week's panel, BBC Question Time, 6 June 2007
  4. Matthew Norman, 'Matthew Norman's Media Diary: A challenge to Murdoch? Yes, really', Independent, 28 May 2007.
  5. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pvii.
  6. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.279
  7. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.279
  8. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.279
  9. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.279
  10. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.279
  11. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.279
  12. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.279
  13. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.279
  14. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.281
  15. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.281
  16. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.281
  17. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.281
  18. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.281
  19. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.281
  20. Melanie Phillips, Londonistan: How Britain Created A Terror State Within, Gibson Square, July 2008, pp.282
  21. Andy Beckett, 'The changing face of Melanie Phillips', The Guardian, 7 March 2003.
  22. Melanie Phillips, 'Why we need neoconservatism', Melanie Phillips's Diary, 6 March 2006.
  23. Melanie Phillips, The Graves of Academe, Melanie Phillips' Diary, 21 March 2006.
  24. Ed Husain, Britain has a duty to Arabs, The Guardian, 30 December 2009
  25. Melanie Phillips, On the other side from civilisation, The Spectator (Blog), 30 December 2008
  26. Melanie Phillips, Come to Londonistan, our refuge for poor misunderstood Islamist victims, The Times, 6 June 2006
  27. Melanie Phillips, The Troika of Bigotry, Jewish Chronicle, 10 November 2006, archived at melaniephillips.com 12 November 2006.
  28. Melanie Phillips, An Offensive Reaction, 13 November 2006, via melaniephillips.com.