Difference between revisions of "Steven Emerson"
m (terrorism spin category added) |
(→Jihad in America) |
||
| (40 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
[[image:Steve_Emerson.jpg|thumb|right|200px|Steven Emerson]] | [[image:Steve_Emerson.jpg|thumb|right|200px|Steven Emerson]] | ||
| + | *''Not to be confused with [[J. Steven Emerson]] of [[StandWithUs]]. | ||
| + | |||
'''Steven Abram Emerson''' is a former freelance journalist turned antiterrorism expert who began making a name for himself in the mid-1990s as one of the key promoters of the idea that Islamic terrorists were actively operating on American soil. | '''Steven Abram Emerson''' is a former freelance journalist turned antiterrorism expert who began making a name for himself in the mid-1990s as one of the key promoters of the idea that Islamic terrorists were actively operating on American soil. | ||
| − | + | In January 2015 Emerson earned international ridicule, including from UK prime minister [[David Cameron]], for claiming that Birmingham in the UK was a 'no-go zone' for non-Muslims. | |
| − | The ''American Spectator'' commented in a profile of Emerson that | + | Although Emerson has been repeatedly criticized for producing faulty analyses and having a distinctly anti-Islamic agenda, he has long been a frequent guest commentator on ''Fox News'', ''MSNBC,'' and other US national news programmes, and has often been invited to give testimony to Congress about purported threats from terrorists operating domestically. |
| + | |||
| + | The ''[[American Spectator]]'' commented in a profile of Emerson that 'Steve Emerson is to the media what [[Richard Clarke]] [a former US government advisor on terrorism turned media pundit and security consultant] was to the government'.<ref>William Tucker, [http://www.spectator.org/dsp_article.asp?art_id=6393 'He Saw It Coming'], ''American Spectator'', 7 April 2004</ref> | ||
==Message== | ==Message== | ||
| − | According to Jason Trahan, writing for the Dallas News Crime Blog: | + | According to Jason Trahan, writing for the ''Dallas News'' Crime Blog: |
:The terrorism expert's message... is that radical Islamists are feverishly working inside the U.S. to undermine the Constitution and replace it with Shariah, or Islamic law. | :The terrorism expert's message... is that radical Islamists are feverishly working inside the U.S. to undermine the Constitution and replace it with Shariah, or Islamic law. | ||
:According to Emerson, violent overthrow is not their aim. Instead, he says, their strategy is a type of "legal jihad," which includes groups such as the Council on American-Islamic Relations and the Islamic Society of North America... hiding behind free speech protections to spread their Islamist agenda.<ref>Jason Trahan, [http://crimeblog.dallasnews.com/archives/2008/09/controversial-terrorism-expert.html 'Controversial terrorism expert Steven Emerson warns against 'legal jihad' in Dallas speech'], Dallas News CRIME Blog, 5:00 PM Fri, Sep 26, 2008</ref> | :According to Emerson, violent overthrow is not their aim. Instead, he says, their strategy is a type of "legal jihad," which includes groups such as the Council on American-Islamic Relations and the Islamic Society of North America... hiding behind free speech protections to spread their Islamist agenda.<ref>Jason Trahan, [http://crimeblog.dallasnews.com/archives/2008/09/controversial-terrorism-expert.html 'Controversial terrorism expert Steven Emerson warns against 'legal jihad' in Dallas speech'], Dallas News CRIME Blog, 5:00 PM Fri, Sep 26, 2008</ref> | ||
| − | == | + | ==Controversies== |
| − | + | ===Operations of Fraud=== | |
| + | In October 2010 ''The Tennessean'' reported that in 2008, Emerson’s nonprofit [[Investigative Project on Terrorism]] 'paid $3,390,000 to [Emerson’s for-profit firm] [[SAE Productions]] for "management services" ' whilst 'Emerson is SAE’s sole officer.' It quoted [[Ken Berger]], president of [[Charity Navigator]], saying, 'basically, you have a nonprofit acting as a front organization, and all that money going to a for-profit [...] It’s wrong. This is off the charts.' <ref name=guide> [https://www.splcenter.org/20161025/field-guide-anti-muslim-extremists#executive%20summary Field Guide to Anti-Muslim Extremists],''Southern Poverty Law Center'', October 25, 2016. Accessed 07 November 2016. </ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | ===Claim that 'at least 30% of Muslims support jihad'=== | ||
| + | In a September 2011 radio interview on the ''Truth That Transforms with Jerry Newcome'' show, Emerson said that 'at least 30% to 40% [of Muslims] support cultural jihad. That is, at least, they support the notion that it’s okay to blow up a bus of Israelis, it’s okay to bomb the World Trade Center, it’s okay to impose the Shariah, the code of Islamic law, it’s okay to beat women or wives as part of Shariah.' Emerson was therefore essentially claiming that 480 million to 640 million Muslims 'support' Islamist terrorism; numbers that were, according to several serious polls, massively blown. <ref> Brian Tachman, [http://www.rightwingwatch.org/post/emerson-claims-at-least-thirty-to-forty-percent-of-all-muslims-support-terrorism/ Emerson Claims “At Least Thirty to Forty Percent” of All Muslims Support Terrorism], ''Right Wing Watch'', September 8, 2011. Accessed 07 November 2016. </ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==='Muslim-only' Birmingham=== | ||
| + | In January 2015, appearing on [[Fox News]] just after the [[Charlie Hebdo]] attacks, Emerson spread the idea of 'no-go zones', by saying: | ||
| + | |||
| + | :'Throughout Europe, Sean [Hannity, the presenter], you have no-go zones. … This goes on in Belgium, this goes on in Sweden, in France, it goes on it Italy, it goes on throughout Europe. So there are no-go zones. [..]These are semi-autonomous countries within countries, in which the federal governments there have basically surrendered their autonomy, surrendered their authority.' <ref name=guide> [https://www.splcenter.org/20161025/field-guide-anti-muslim-extremists#executive%20summary Field Guide to Anti-Muslim Extremists],''Southern Poverty Law Center'', October 25, 2016. Accessed 07 November 2016. </ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | Of Britain, he said: | ||
| + | :In Britain, it’s not just no-go zones, there are actual cities like Birmingham that are totally Muslim where non-Muslims just simply don’t go in. And, parts of London, there are actually Muslim religious police that actually beat and actually wound seriously anyone who doesn’t dress according to religious Muslim attire.<ref>Kevin Rawlinson, [http://www.theguardian.com/media/2015/jan/11/fox-news-steven-emerson-birmingham-muslims Birmingham is ‘totally Muslim’ city, claims Fox News pundit], The Guardian, 12 January 2015, accessed 13 January 2015</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | In the same interview, he asserted that [[Department of Homeland Security]] officers in overseas U.S. embassies have 'been told to look away' when foreign visa applicants had ties to 'Islamist terrorist' organisations ('even to ISIS'), and have essentially been forced to allow them entry into to the territory. 'I can tell you that personally,' Emerson said, even though he did not show any evidence. <ref name=guide> [https://www.splcenter.org/20161025/field-guide-anti-muslim-extremists#executive%20summary Field Guide to Anti-Muslim Extremists],''Southern Poverty Law Center'', October 25, 2016. Accessed 07 November 2016. </ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | As a result of these comments, Emerson and [[Fox News]] became the subject of ridicule on Twitter, with users posting sarcastic 'information' about Birmingham, the UK and Muslims under the hashtag #FoxNewsFacts<ref>Lydia Smith, [http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/foxnewsfacts-terrorism-expert-steve-emerson-ridiculed-saying-birmingham-no-go-zone-1482986 #FoxNewsFacts: 'Terrorism expert' Steve Emerson ridiculed for saying Birmingham is no-go zone for non-Muslims], IB Times, 12 January 2015, accessed 13 January 2015</ref>. The UK Prime Minister [[David Cameron]] also commented that Emerson was 'clearly a complete idiot'. Emerson apologised for the error<ref>Ned Simons, [http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2015/01/12/steve-emerson-an-idiot-says-david-cameron-fox-news_n_6455504.html Fox News' Steve Emerson Is 'Clearly An Idiot', Says David Cameron], Huffington Post, qw January 2015</ref>. | ||
| + | |||
| + | ===Other blunders... including claims that Islamic extremists carried out Oklahoma bombing=== | ||
| + | |||
| + | *In 1997, Emerson was accused of giving ''The Associated Press'' documents he claimed were from the [[FBI]] but were really written by him. <ref name=guide> [https://www.splcenter.org/20161025/field-guide-anti-muslim-extremists#executive%20summary Field Guide to Anti-Muslim Extremists],''Southern Poverty Law Center'', October 25, 2016. Accessed 07 November 2016. </ref> | ||
| − | + | *A story in the ''New Yorker'' noted that 'Emerson became widely known in the aftermath of the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing, when [he claimed that the Oklahoma bombing was carried out by Islamists], appearing as an expert on [[CBS News]]'. 'He theorized that the attack was the work of Islamic extremists. It turned out that [[Timothy McVeigh]] was responsible'.<ref>Benjamin Wallace-Wells, [http://www.newyorker.com/fact/content/articles/060529fa_fact PRIVATE JIHAD How Rita Katz got into the spying business], ''New Yorker'', 29 May 2006, Posted 2006-05-22</ref> He had also claimed that the attack had 'a Middle Eastern trait' and added that Oklahoma City was 'probably considered one of the largest centers of Islamic radical activity outside of the Middle East,' but was proven to be entirely wrong on both counts. <ref name=guide> [https://www.splcenter.org/20161025/field-guide-anti-muslim-extremists#executive%20summary Field Guide to Anti-Muslim Extremists],''Southern Poverty Law Center'', October 25, 2016. Accessed 07 November 2016. </ref> | |
| − | In addition, a report for FAIR (Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting) states: | + | *In addition, a report for FAIR (Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting) states: |
:Emerson was wrong when he initially pointed to Yugoslavians as suspects in the World Trade Center bombing (CNN, 3/2/93). He was wrong when he said on CNBC (8/23/96) that "it was a bomb that brought down TWA Flight 800." <ref>John F. Sugg, [http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=1443 'Steven Emerson's Crusade'], ''Extra!'', January/February 1999</ref> | :Emerson was wrong when he initially pointed to Yugoslavians as suspects in the World Trade Center bombing (CNN, 3/2/93). He was wrong when he said on CNBC (8/23/96) that "it was a bomb that brought down TWA Flight 800." <ref>John F. Sugg, [http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=1443 'Steven Emerson's Crusade'], ''Extra!'', January/February 1999</ref> | ||
| − | A review by Richard H. Curtiss for the Washington Report on Middle East Affairs notes: | + | *A review by Richard H. Curtiss for the Washington Report on Middle East Affairs notes: |
:Similarly, after Paris-bound TWA Flight 800 exploded off Long Island in July 1996, Emerson said in media statements he was “confident” and had “no doubt whatsoever” that the plane was brought down by a bomb and suggested to Reuters that it could be the work of “the permanent floating [Islamic] military international.” But after a painstaking investigation involving dredging up the aircraft, piece by piece by piece, from the sea floor, the FBI and FAA ascribed the explosion not to a bomb or a missile but to an accidental electrical spark that ignited fumes in an empty fuel tank.<ref>Richard H. Curtiss [http://www.washington-report.org/backissues/0999/9909138.html Foreword] to ''The Agent: The Truth Behind the Anti-Muslim Campaign in America'' By Dr. Ahmed Yousef and Caroline F. Keeble, USAR Publishing Group Inc., 1999, 120 pp. published in Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, SEPTEMBER 1999, pages 138-140</ref> | :Similarly, after Paris-bound TWA Flight 800 exploded off Long Island in July 1996, Emerson said in media statements he was “confident” and had “no doubt whatsoever” that the plane was brought down by a bomb and suggested to Reuters that it could be the work of “the permanent floating [Islamic] military international.” But after a painstaking investigation involving dredging up the aircraft, piece by piece by piece, from the sea floor, the FBI and FAA ascribed the explosion not to a bomb or a missile but to an accidental electrical spark that ignited fumes in an empty fuel tank.<ref>Richard H. Curtiss [http://www.washington-report.org/backissues/0999/9909138.html Foreword] to ''The Agent: The Truth Behind the Anti-Muslim Campaign in America'' By Dr. Ahmed Yousef and Caroline F. Keeble, USAR Publishing Group Inc., 1999, 120 pp. published in Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, SEPTEMBER 1999, pages 138-140</ref> | ||
| − | In a lesser known incident, Emerson had promoted the case of Iftikhar Chaudhry Khan, who had claimed he was a top Pakistani nuclear scientist, but turned out to be a "former low-level accountant at a company that makes bathroom fixtures." Khan was the source behind an article in ''The Observer'' that had claimed that "military commanders have discussed pre-emptive nuclear strikes against India."<ref>Peter Beaumont, Paul Beaver, Anwar Iqbal, 'Pakistan's plan for a nuclear hit Scientist defects with list of Indian targets', ''The Observer'', 28 June 1998</ref> According to Khan's lawyer, "Emerson was helpful in corroborating information and making scientific clarifications."<ref>John F. Sugg, [http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=1443 'Steven Emerson's Crusade'], ''Extra!'', January/February 1999</ref> | + | *In a lesser known incident, Emerson had promoted the case of [[Iftikhar Chaudhry Khan]], who had claimed he was a top Pakistani nuclear scientist, but turned out to be a "former low-level accountant at a company that makes bathroom fixtures." Khan was the source behind an article in ''The Observer'' that had claimed that "military commanders have discussed pre-emptive nuclear strikes against India."<ref>Peter Beaumont, Paul Beaver, Anwar Iqbal, 'Pakistan's plan for a nuclear hit Scientist defects with list of Indian targets', ''The Observer'', 28 June 1998</ref> According to Khan's lawyer, "Emerson was helpful in corroborating information and making scientific clarifications."<ref>John F. Sugg, [http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=1443 'Steven Emerson's Crusade'], ''Extra!'', January/February 1999</ref> |
| + | |||
| + | *In a March 2011 interview with [[Glenn Beck]], Emerson claimed without evidence that 'in Mexico today, they’re teaching Palestinian militants how to dig tunnels that will evade detection in Gaza.' <ref> [http://mediamatters.org/video/2011/03/17/steve-emerson-claims-palestinian-militants-are/177647 Steve Emerson Claims Palestinian Militants Are In Mexico Learning "How To Dig Tunnels That Will Evade Detection In Gaza"], ''Media Matters'', March 17, 2011 Accessed 07 November 2016. </ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==The Bat Cave== | ||
| + | In an extended profile in the ''Washington Post'', John Mintz reported: | ||
| + | |||
| + | :People invited to the Washington-area office of terrorism expert Steven Emerson say he sets one condition: They must swear never to reveal its location. Some visitors have been blindfolded as they're driven to his headquarters, where the masks are removed to reveal a warren of rooms piled high with dossiers, transcripts and videotapes, they say. The people who work there call it "the bat cave." <ref>John Mintz, "The Man Who Gives Terrorism A Name; Expert's Finger-Pointing Troubles Muslim Groups", ''Washington Post'', 14 November 2001</ref> | ||
==Israel link== | ==Israel link== | ||
| − | During the 1990s the former Israeli intelligence commander [[Yigal Carmon]] stayed at Emerson's Washington apartment on trips to lobby Congress against Middle East peace initiatives. An Associated Press reporter who has dealt with Emerson and Carmon says: "I have no doubt these guys are working together."<ref>John F. Sugg, [http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=1443 'Steven Emerson's Crusade'], ''Extra!'', January/February 1999</ref> | + | During the 1990s the former Israeli intelligence commander [[Yigal Carmon]] stayed at Emerson's Washington apartment on trips to lobby Congress against Middle East peace initiatives. An ''Associated Press'' reporter who has dealt with Emerson and Carmon says: "I have no doubt these guys are working together."<ref>John F. Sugg, [http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=1443 'Steven Emerson's Crusade'], ''Extra!'', January/February 1999</ref> |
| + | |||
| + | While Emerson maintains close ties to the Israeli intelligence and Jewish organizations in the US, he has been curiously sensitive about revealing what religion he is (his associates told the ''Washington Post'' he is Jewish).<ref>John Mintz, "The Man Who Gives Terrorism A Name; Expert's Finger-Pointing Troubles Muslim Groups", ''Washington Post'', 14 November 2001</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==Jihad in America== | ||
| + | Emerson promoted his film 'Jihad in America: The Grand Deception' in a September 2012 [[Fox News]] interview, saying it 'show[ed] the extensive collaboration between the Obama administration and the Muslim Brotherhood in the United States. It’s pretty shocking.' He continued: 'I think Mr. Obama is not necessarily a Muslim, I don’t believe that; I think he’s pro-Islamist.' <ref name=guide> [https://www.splcenter.org/20161025/field-guide-anti-muslim-extremists#executive%20summary Field Guide to Anti-Muslim Extremists],''Southern Poverty Law Center'', October 25, 2016. Accessed 07 November 2016. </ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | According to Robert I. Friedman of ''The Nation'': | ||
| + | :Prior to its airing on PBS, Emerson screened Jihad in America for officials at the New York headquarters of a major national Jewish organization. He wanted their public endorsement of the film to increase pressure on Clinton for tougher laws to combat Arab terror. While the Jewish leaders weren't shy about using the film to press Clinton for laws to increase federal police powers, they didn't want to be publicly identified with the video, for fear of harming "intergroup relations," according to one official. "People were concerned then and now that it looked like all Arabs are blamed for a very small portion of Muslim fundamentalists who engage in terrorism, that it pointed the finger at the entire Arab community, that it made generalizations." | ||
| + | |||
| + | :The Israeli government was less concerned about stereotyping Arabs. Emerson gave a sneak preview for Israeli officials in Washington, who had long complained that Hamas was being run from bases in America. Emerson's film not only helped them press their case with the Administration--that Islam is our common enemy--but it also helped to rehabilitate Emerson with the Labor government. Labor was angry with Emerson for helping Likud undermine the peace process. [[Yossi Ben-Aharon]], [[Yoram Ettinger]] and [[Yigal Carmon]] are former high-ranking Likud government officials whom Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin dubbed the Gang of Three after the trio started lobbying Capitol Hill against the Israeli-P.L.O. accord and against sending U.S. peacekeepers to the Golan Heights "in order to undermine any chance for peace with Syria," says a prominent Israeli journalist. Carmon, who was Likud Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir's adviser on terrorism, and Ettinger, who was Likud leader Benjamin Netanyahu's man in the Israeli Embassy, stay in Emerson's apartment on their frequent visits to Washington. Carmon was credited as an adviser on Emerson's documentary.<ref>Robert I. Friedman, ‘One Man’s Jihad’, The Nation, 15 May 1995</ref> | ||
==Affiliations== | ==Affiliations== | ||
===Organisations=== | ===Organisations=== | ||
| + | *[[MEMRI]] - Board of Directors | ||
*[[Investigative Project on Terrorism]]: Founder | *[[Investigative Project on Terrorism]]: Founder | ||
| + | *[[SAE Productions]] - founder | ||
*[[Counterterrorism Blog]]: Contributor | *[[Counterterrorism Blog]]: Contributor | ||
*[[International Analyst Network]] | *[[International Analyst Network]] | ||
*[[Obsession]] Interviewee in this Islamophobic film | *[[Obsession]] Interviewee in this Islamophobic film | ||
| + | *[[Center for Security Policy]] - Contributor to CSP front group [[Family Security Matters]] | ||
| + | *[[B'nai B'rith International]] - 2010 Conference Participant<ref>BBI, [http://bnaibrith.org/pdf/BBIPC2010_AgendaProgram.pdf "Agenda"], B'nai B'rith International, accessed on 11 December 2010</ref> | ||
===Individuals=== | ===Individuals=== | ||
| Line 40: | Line 85: | ||
*[[Rita Katz]] | *[[Rita Katz]] | ||
| − | ==Government | + | ==Government service== |
U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee: Former Aide (Early 1980s) | U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee: Former Aide (Early 1980s) | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==Publications== | ||
| + | *''Jihad Incorporated: A Guide to Militant Islam in the U.S.'' | ||
| + | *''American Jihad: The Terrorists Living Among Us'' | ||
==Education== | ==Education== | ||
Brown University: BA, MA | Brown University: BA, MA | ||
| − | == | + | ==External resources== |
*Rightweb profile [http://rightweb.irc-online.org/profile/3770 Steve Emerson] | *Rightweb profile [http://rightweb.irc-online.org/profile/3770 Steve Emerson] | ||
| − | *John F. Sugg [http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=1443 Steven Emerson's Crusade] Why is a journalist pushing questionable stories from behind the scenes? Extra! January/February 1999 | + | *John F. Sugg [http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=1443 Steven Emerson's Crusade] Why is a journalist pushing questionable stories from behind the scenes? ''Extra!'' January/February 1999 |
| + | *[[Steven Emerson]], [http://youtube.com/watch?v=b3p2HnWt2bM Pentagon Islam Expert Fired for Telling the Truth], ''Fox News'', January 11 2008 [http://www.investigativeproject.org/article/584 Transcript] | ||
*[http://foreignaffairs.house.gov/110/eme073108.pdf Testimony] before the United States House of Representatives Committee on Foreign Affairs, Subcommittee on Terrorism, Nonproliferation, and Trade, 31 July 2008 | *[http://foreignaffairs.house.gov/110/eme073108.pdf Testimony] before the United States House of Representatives Committee on Foreign Affairs, Subcommittee on Terrorism, Nonproliferation, and Trade, 31 July 2008 | ||
*Richard H. Curtiss, Washington Report on Middle Eastern Affairs, September 1999, [http://www.washington-report.org/backissues/0999/9909138.html pp.138-140] | *Richard H. Curtiss, Washington Report on Middle Eastern Affairs, September 1999, [http://www.washington-report.org/backissues/0999/9909138.html pp.138-140] | ||
| − | + | *Robert Parry, [http://www.consortiumnews.com/2010/062410.html The CIA/Likud Sinking of Jimmy Carter (A Special Report)], Consortiumnews.com, 24 June 2010 | |
| − | + | *Nathan Guttman and Larry Cohler-Esses, [http://forward.com/articles/133244/ Terror Expert Emerson Feels His Own Heat Over Finances], ''Jewish Daily Forward'', 26 November 2010. | |
| − | + | *Peter Hart, [http://www.fair.org/blog/2013/04/17/steve-emerson-gets-it-wrong-again/ Steve Emerson Gets It Wrong–Again], ''Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting'', 17 April 2013. | |
| − | *[ | + | *Alex Seitz-Wald, [http://www.salon.com/2013/04/18/the_rights_new_boston_conspiracy_theory/ The right’s new Boston conspiracy theory], ''Salon.com'', 18 April 2013. |
| + | *Robert Parry, [https://consortiumnews.com/2015/01/12/the-sorry-record-of-a-muslim-basher/ The sorry record of a Muslim-basher], ''Consortium News'', 12 January 2015. | ||
| + | *[https://www.splcenter.org/20161025/field-guide-anti-muslim-extremists#executive%20summary Field Guide to Anti-Muslim Extremists ], ''Southern Poverty Law Center'', October 25, 2016. | ||
==Notes== | ==Notes== | ||
| Line 60: | Line 112: | ||
[[Category:Terrorologist|Emerson, Steven]] | [[Category:Terrorologist|Emerson, Steven]] | ||
[[Category:Terrorism Spin|Emerson, Steven]] | [[Category:Terrorism Spin|Emerson, Steven]] | ||
| + | [[Category:Counterjihad|Emerson, Steven]] | ||
| + | [[Category:Islam Critics|Emerson, Steven]] | ||
Latest revision as of 14:39, 7 November 2016
- Not to be confused with J. Steven Emerson of StandWithUs.
Steven Abram Emerson is a former freelance journalist turned antiterrorism expert who began making a name for himself in the mid-1990s as one of the key promoters of the idea that Islamic terrorists were actively operating on American soil.
In January 2015 Emerson earned international ridicule, including from UK prime minister David Cameron, for claiming that Birmingham in the UK was a 'no-go zone' for non-Muslims.
Although Emerson has been repeatedly criticized for producing faulty analyses and having a distinctly anti-Islamic agenda, he has long been a frequent guest commentator on Fox News, MSNBC, and other US national news programmes, and has often been invited to give testimony to Congress about purported threats from terrorists operating domestically.
The American Spectator commented in a profile of Emerson that 'Steve Emerson is to the media what Richard Clarke [a former US government advisor on terrorism turned media pundit and security consultant] was to the government'.[1]
Contents
Message
According to Jason Trahan, writing for the Dallas News Crime Blog:
- The terrorism expert's message... is that radical Islamists are feverishly working inside the U.S. to undermine the Constitution and replace it with Shariah, or Islamic law.
- According to Emerson, violent overthrow is not their aim. Instead, he says, their strategy is a type of "legal jihad," which includes groups such as the Council on American-Islamic Relations and the Islamic Society of North America... hiding behind free speech protections to spread their Islamist agenda.[2]
Controversies
Operations of Fraud
In October 2010 The Tennessean reported that in 2008, Emerson’s nonprofit Investigative Project on Terrorism 'paid $3,390,000 to [Emerson’s for-profit firm] SAE Productions for "management services" ' whilst 'Emerson is SAE’s sole officer.' It quoted Ken Berger, president of Charity Navigator, saying, 'basically, you have a nonprofit acting as a front organization, and all that money going to a for-profit [...] It’s wrong. This is off the charts.' [3]
Claim that 'at least 30% of Muslims support jihad'
In a September 2011 radio interview on the Truth That Transforms with Jerry Newcome show, Emerson said that 'at least 30% to 40% [of Muslims] support cultural jihad. That is, at least, they support the notion that it’s okay to blow up a bus of Israelis, it’s okay to bomb the World Trade Center, it’s okay to impose the Shariah, the code of Islamic law, it’s okay to beat women or wives as part of Shariah.' Emerson was therefore essentially claiming that 480 million to 640 million Muslims 'support' Islamist terrorism; numbers that were, according to several serious polls, massively blown. [4]
'Muslim-only' Birmingham
In January 2015, appearing on Fox News just after the Charlie Hebdo attacks, Emerson spread the idea of 'no-go zones', by saying:
- 'Throughout Europe, Sean [Hannity, the presenter], you have no-go zones. … This goes on in Belgium, this goes on in Sweden, in France, it goes on it Italy, it goes on throughout Europe. So there are no-go zones. [..]These are semi-autonomous countries within countries, in which the federal governments there have basically surrendered their autonomy, surrendered their authority.' [3]
Of Britain, he said:
- In Britain, it’s not just no-go zones, there are actual cities like Birmingham that are totally Muslim where non-Muslims just simply don’t go in. And, parts of London, there are actually Muslim religious police that actually beat and actually wound seriously anyone who doesn’t dress according to religious Muslim attire.[5]
In the same interview, he asserted that Department of Homeland Security officers in overseas U.S. embassies have 'been told to look away' when foreign visa applicants had ties to 'Islamist terrorist' organisations ('even to ISIS'), and have essentially been forced to allow them entry into to the territory. 'I can tell you that personally,' Emerson said, even though he did not show any evidence. [3]
As a result of these comments, Emerson and Fox News became the subject of ridicule on Twitter, with users posting sarcastic 'information' about Birmingham, the UK and Muslims under the hashtag #FoxNewsFacts[6]. The UK Prime Minister David Cameron also commented that Emerson was 'clearly a complete idiot'. Emerson apologised for the error[7].
Other blunders... including claims that Islamic extremists carried out Oklahoma bombing
- In 1997, Emerson was accused of giving The Associated Press documents he claimed were from the FBI but were really written by him. [3]
- A story in the New Yorker noted that 'Emerson became widely known in the aftermath of the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing, when [he claimed that the Oklahoma bombing was carried out by Islamists], appearing as an expert on CBS News'. 'He theorized that the attack was the work of Islamic extremists. It turned out that Timothy McVeigh was responsible'.[8] He had also claimed that the attack had 'a Middle Eastern trait' and added that Oklahoma City was 'probably considered one of the largest centers of Islamic radical activity outside of the Middle East,' but was proven to be entirely wrong on both counts. [3]
- In addition, a report for FAIR (Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting) states:
- Emerson was wrong when he initially pointed to Yugoslavians as suspects in the World Trade Center bombing (CNN, 3/2/93). He was wrong when he said on CNBC (8/23/96) that "it was a bomb that brought down TWA Flight 800." [9]
- A review by Richard H. Curtiss for the Washington Report on Middle East Affairs notes:
- Similarly, after Paris-bound TWA Flight 800 exploded off Long Island in July 1996, Emerson said in media statements he was “confident” and had “no doubt whatsoever” that the plane was brought down by a bomb and suggested to Reuters that it could be the work of “the permanent floating [Islamic] military international.” But after a painstaking investigation involving dredging up the aircraft, piece by piece by piece, from the sea floor, the FBI and FAA ascribed the explosion not to a bomb or a missile but to an accidental electrical spark that ignited fumes in an empty fuel tank.[10]
- In a lesser known incident, Emerson had promoted the case of Iftikhar Chaudhry Khan, who had claimed he was a top Pakistani nuclear scientist, but turned out to be a "former low-level accountant at a company that makes bathroom fixtures." Khan was the source behind an article in The Observer that had claimed that "military commanders have discussed pre-emptive nuclear strikes against India."[11] According to Khan's lawyer, "Emerson was helpful in corroborating information and making scientific clarifications."[12]
- In a March 2011 interview with Glenn Beck, Emerson claimed without evidence that 'in Mexico today, they’re teaching Palestinian militants how to dig tunnels that will evade detection in Gaza.' [13]
The Bat Cave
In an extended profile in the Washington Post, John Mintz reported:
- People invited to the Washington-area office of terrorism expert Steven Emerson say he sets one condition: They must swear never to reveal its location. Some visitors have been blindfolded as they're driven to his headquarters, where the masks are removed to reveal a warren of rooms piled high with dossiers, transcripts and videotapes, they say. The people who work there call it "the bat cave." [14]
Israel link
During the 1990s the former Israeli intelligence commander Yigal Carmon stayed at Emerson's Washington apartment on trips to lobby Congress against Middle East peace initiatives. An Associated Press reporter who has dealt with Emerson and Carmon says: "I have no doubt these guys are working together."[15]
While Emerson maintains close ties to the Israeli intelligence and Jewish organizations in the US, he has been curiously sensitive about revealing what religion he is (his associates told the Washington Post he is Jewish).[16]
Jihad in America
Emerson promoted his film 'Jihad in America: The Grand Deception' in a September 2012 Fox News interview, saying it 'show[ed] the extensive collaboration between the Obama administration and the Muslim Brotherhood in the United States. It’s pretty shocking.' He continued: 'I think Mr. Obama is not necessarily a Muslim, I don’t believe that; I think he’s pro-Islamist.' [3]
According to Robert I. Friedman of The Nation:
- Prior to its airing on PBS, Emerson screened Jihad in America for officials at the New York headquarters of a major national Jewish organization. He wanted their public endorsement of the film to increase pressure on Clinton for tougher laws to combat Arab terror. While the Jewish leaders weren't shy about using the film to press Clinton for laws to increase federal police powers, they didn't want to be publicly identified with the video, for fear of harming "intergroup relations," according to one official. "People were concerned then and now that it looked like all Arabs are blamed for a very small portion of Muslim fundamentalists who engage in terrorism, that it pointed the finger at the entire Arab community, that it made generalizations."
- The Israeli government was less concerned about stereotyping Arabs. Emerson gave a sneak preview for Israeli officials in Washington, who had long complained that Hamas was being run from bases in America. Emerson's film not only helped them press their case with the Administration--that Islam is our common enemy--but it also helped to rehabilitate Emerson with the Labor government. Labor was angry with Emerson for helping Likud undermine the peace process. Yossi Ben-Aharon, Yoram Ettinger and Yigal Carmon are former high-ranking Likud government officials whom Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin dubbed the Gang of Three after the trio started lobbying Capitol Hill against the Israeli-P.L.O. accord and against sending U.S. peacekeepers to the Golan Heights "in order to undermine any chance for peace with Syria," says a prominent Israeli journalist. Carmon, who was Likud Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir's adviser on terrorism, and Ettinger, who was Likud leader Benjamin Netanyahu's man in the Israeli Embassy, stay in Emerson's apartment on their frequent visits to Washington. Carmon was credited as an adviser on Emerson's documentary.[17]
Affiliations
Organisations
- MEMRI - Board of Directors
- Investigative Project on Terrorism: Founder
- SAE Productions - founder
- Counterterrorism Blog: Contributor
- International Analyst Network
- Obsession Interviewee in this Islamophobic film
- Center for Security Policy - Contributor to CSP front group Family Security Matters
- B'nai B'rith International - 2010 Conference Participant[18]
Individuals
Government service
U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee: Former Aide (Early 1980s)
Publications
- Jihad Incorporated: A Guide to Militant Islam in the U.S.
- American Jihad: The Terrorists Living Among Us
Education
Brown University: BA, MA
External resources
- Rightweb profile Steve Emerson
- John F. Sugg Steven Emerson's Crusade Why is a journalist pushing questionable stories from behind the scenes? Extra! January/February 1999
- Steven Emerson, Pentagon Islam Expert Fired for Telling the Truth, Fox News, January 11 2008 Transcript
- Testimony before the United States House of Representatives Committee on Foreign Affairs, Subcommittee on Terrorism, Nonproliferation, and Trade, 31 July 2008
- Richard H. Curtiss, Washington Report on Middle Eastern Affairs, September 1999, pp.138-140
- Robert Parry, The CIA/Likud Sinking of Jimmy Carter (A Special Report), Consortiumnews.com, 24 June 2010
- Nathan Guttman and Larry Cohler-Esses, Terror Expert Emerson Feels His Own Heat Over Finances, Jewish Daily Forward, 26 November 2010.
- Peter Hart, Steve Emerson Gets It Wrong–Again, Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting, 17 April 2013.
- Alex Seitz-Wald, The right’s new Boston conspiracy theory, Salon.com, 18 April 2013.
- Robert Parry, The sorry record of a Muslim-basher, Consortium News, 12 January 2015.
- Field Guide to Anti-Muslim Extremists , Southern Poverty Law Center, October 25, 2016.
Notes
- ↑ William Tucker, 'He Saw It Coming', American Spectator, 7 April 2004
- ↑ Jason Trahan, 'Controversial terrorism expert Steven Emerson warns against 'legal jihad' in Dallas speech', Dallas News CRIME Blog, 5:00 PM Fri, Sep 26, 2008
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 Field Guide to Anti-Muslim Extremists,Southern Poverty Law Center, October 25, 2016. Accessed 07 November 2016.
- ↑ Brian Tachman, Emerson Claims “At Least Thirty to Forty Percent” of All Muslims Support Terrorism, Right Wing Watch, September 8, 2011. Accessed 07 November 2016.
- ↑ Kevin Rawlinson, Birmingham is ‘totally Muslim’ city, claims Fox News pundit, The Guardian, 12 January 2015, accessed 13 January 2015
- ↑ Lydia Smith, #FoxNewsFacts: 'Terrorism expert' Steve Emerson ridiculed for saying Birmingham is no-go zone for non-Muslims, IB Times, 12 January 2015, accessed 13 January 2015
- ↑ Ned Simons, Fox News' Steve Emerson Is 'Clearly An Idiot', Says David Cameron, Huffington Post, qw January 2015
- ↑ Benjamin Wallace-Wells, PRIVATE JIHAD How Rita Katz got into the spying business, New Yorker, 29 May 2006, Posted 2006-05-22
- ↑ John F. Sugg, 'Steven Emerson's Crusade', Extra!, January/February 1999
- ↑ Richard H. Curtiss Foreword to The Agent: The Truth Behind the Anti-Muslim Campaign in America By Dr. Ahmed Yousef and Caroline F. Keeble, USAR Publishing Group Inc., 1999, 120 pp. published in Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, SEPTEMBER 1999, pages 138-140
- ↑ Peter Beaumont, Paul Beaver, Anwar Iqbal, 'Pakistan's plan for a nuclear hit Scientist defects with list of Indian targets', The Observer, 28 June 1998
- ↑ John F. Sugg, 'Steven Emerson's Crusade', Extra!, January/February 1999
- ↑ Steve Emerson Claims Palestinian Militants Are In Mexico Learning "How To Dig Tunnels That Will Evade Detection In Gaza", Media Matters, March 17, 2011 Accessed 07 November 2016.
- ↑ John Mintz, "The Man Who Gives Terrorism A Name; Expert's Finger-Pointing Troubles Muslim Groups", Washington Post, 14 November 2001
- ↑ John F. Sugg, 'Steven Emerson's Crusade', Extra!, January/February 1999
- ↑ John Mintz, "The Man Who Gives Terrorism A Name; Expert's Finger-Pointing Troubles Muslim Groups", Washington Post, 14 November 2001
- ↑ Robert I. Friedman, ‘One Man’s Jihad’, The Nation, 15 May 1995
- ↑ BBI, "Agenda", B'nai B'rith International, accessed on 11 December 2010
