Difference between revisions of "Publish it not... The Middle East Cover-Up"

From Powerbase
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Add JC items read 19 Nov 2026 (OCR text; marked in refs))
 
(4 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
[[File:Publish it not title page (Longman 1975).jpg|thumb|right|150px|Title page of Publish it not... The Middle East Cover-Up (Longman, 1975)]]
 +
'''''Publish it not... The Middle East Cover-Up''''' is a book by [[Christopher Mayhew]] and [[Michael Adams]], published by Longman in 1975. It argues that Western media coverage of the Middle East was biased in favour of Zionism.
  
  
 
From the personal statement by Mayhew at the beginning of the book:
 
From the personal statement by Mayhew at the beginning of the book:
  
−
:Ernest Bevin felt this injustice deeply too. I remember how, at the end of a particularly tense Question Time, when he had been mercilessly harried by Jewish MPs supporting Israel, he had finally burst out, “We must also remember the Arab side of the case—there are, after all, no Arabs in the House." This remark provoked an uproar, and I reproved him for it afterwards—mistakenly, I now think—on the grounds that by singling out the Jewish as against the non-Jewish supporters of Zionism he was making it easier for his enemies to suggest that he was anti- Semitic. But Bevin was unrepentant, protesting that the Zionists were “even now paralleling the Nazis in Palestine," and that they were creatures of violence and war—“What can you expect when people are brought up from the cradle on the Old Testament?"
+
:[[Ernest Bevin]] felt this injustice deeply too. I remember how, at the end of a particularly tense Question Time, when he had been mercilessly harried by Jewish MPs supporting Israel, he had finally burst out, “We must also remember the Arab side of the case—there are, after all, no Arabs in the House." This remark provoked an uproar, and I reproved him for it afterwards—mistakenly, I now think—on the grounds that by singling out the Jewish as against the non-Jewish supporters of Zionism he was making it easier for his enemies to suggest that he was anti- Semitic. But Bevin was unrepentant, protesting that the Zionists were “even now paralleling the Nazis in Palestine," and that they were creatures of violence and war—“What can you expect when people are brought up from the cradle on the Old Testament?"
−
:I did not then share Bevin's emotional commitment on Palestine, but I remember clearly his dislike of Zionist methods and tactics, and, indeed, of the Zionist philosophy itself. He was passionately and un- shakeably anti-Zionist. He held that Zionism was basically racialist, that it was inevitably wedded to violence and terror, that it demanded far more from the Arabs than they could or should be expected to accept peacefully, that its success would condemn the Middle East to decades of hatred and violence, and above all—this was his immediate concern— that by turning the Arabs against Britain and the Western countries, it would open a highroad for Stalin into the Middle East.
+
:I did not then share Bevin's emotional commitment on Palestine, but I remember clearly his dislike of Zionist methods and tactics, and, indeed, of the Zionist philosophy itself. He was passionately and un-shakeably anti-Zionist. He held that Zionism was basically racialist, that it was inevitably wedded to violence and terror, that it demanded far more from the Arabs than they could or should be expected to accept peacefully, that its success would condemn the Middle East to decades of hatred and violence, and above all—this was his immediate concern — that by turning the Arabs against Britain and the Western countries, it would open a highroad for Stalin into the Middle East.
 
:On all these points events proved him right; but in the immediate postwar years, so soon after the truth about the Nazis' treatment of the Jews had become widely known, his plain speaking struck many people as prejudiced and harsh, and enabled the Zionists to misrepresent him with some success as an anti-Semite, which he was not.
 
:On all these points events proved him right; but in the immediate postwar years, so soon after the truth about the Nazis' treatment of the Jews had become widely known, his plain speaking struck many people as prejudiced and harsh, and enabled the Zionists to misrepresent him with some success as an anti-Semite, which he was not.
−
:Then, as now, there was much confusion between anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism. Zionism—the idea that Jewish people everywhere should gather together in a state in Palestine—is a political concept which can and should be freely debated, one which has wide support but which many tolerant civilised people, including many Jews, strenuously oppose. But in the 1940s, and indeed until quite recently, many people con¬ fused Zionism with Judaism, the religion of the Jews, so that criticising Zionism sounded like criticising somebody's religion. :Others confused Zionism with the Jewish people itself, and so made the mistake of thinking that if one were anti-Zionist one must be anti-Jewish as well. Regrettably, this last confusion was deliberately fostered by some extreme Zionists,<ref>1. Such as Mr [[Sidney Goldberg]], quoted in Chapter 4, p. 58</ref> who discouraged potential opponents by making them afraid of being thought racialists.
+
:Then, as now, there was much confusion between anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism. Zionism—the idea that Jewish people everywhere should gather together in a state in Palestine—is a political concept which can and should be freely debated, one which has wide support but which many tolerant civilised people, including many Jews, strenuously oppose. But in the 1940s, and indeed until quite recently, many people con¬ fused Zionism with Judaism, the religion of the Jews, so that criticising Zionism sounded like criticising somebody's religion. :Others confused Zionism with the Jewish people itself, and so made the mistake of thinking that if one were anti-Zionist one must be anti-Jewish as well. Regrettably, this last confusion was deliberately fostered by some extreme Zionists,<ref>1. Such as Mr Sidney Goldberg, quoted in Chapter 4, p. 58</ref> who discouraged potential opponents by making them afraid of being thought racialists.
 
:Even today Zionism is a subject on which it is hard to speak frankly in Western countries without giving offence. Statements to the effect that communism or capitalism are wicked or inhuman may provoke disagreement, but they do not give offence. But if Zionism is similarly denounced, almost everyone is shocked, and the speaker's motives are widely suspected.
 
:Even today Zionism is a subject on which it is hard to speak frankly in Western countries without giving offence. Statements to the effect that communism or capitalism are wicked or inhuman may provoke disagreement, but they do not give offence. But if Zionism is similarly denounced, almost everyone is shocked, and the speaker's motives are widely suspected.
 
:In 1947 and 1948 it was the political pressure on the Labour Cabinet from American Zionists, exerted through the United States government, which angered Bevin most, and I shared his feelings about this to the full. At that time, Britain was dependent on American goodwill for her economic survival; and President Truman, as he later explained frankly in his memoirs, was equally dependent on Zionist goodwill for his presidential campaign funds. As a consequence, the British government was subjected to ruthless pressure from Washington to get the Arabs to accept the Zionists' demands. It was a disgraceful abuse of power. On one occasion I was exposed to the full brunt of it myself. In Bevin's absence, I had to receive the US Ambassador, Mr Lou Douglas, “with a message from the President about Palestine." Mr Douglas explained that he had been asked to repeat the President's urgent request to the British government to admit a hundred thousand Jewish refugees into Palestine immediately. In line with Bevin's views, and with the support of the Permanent Under-Secretary, Sir Orme Sargent, I objected that this was simply a prescription for war. The Ambassador then replied, carefully and deliberately, that the President wished it to be known that if we could help him over this it would enable our friends in Washington to get our Marshall Aid appropriation through Congress. In other words, we must do as the Zionists wished—or starve. Bevin surrendered—he had to—but he was understandably bitter and angry. He felt it out¬ rageous that the United States, which had no responsibility for law and order in Palestine (and no intention of permitting massive Jewish immigration into the United States), should, from very questionable motives, impose an impossibly burdensome and dangerous task on Britain.
 
:In 1947 and 1948 it was the political pressure on the Labour Cabinet from American Zionists, exerted through the United States government, which angered Bevin most, and I shared his feelings about this to the full. At that time, Britain was dependent on American goodwill for her economic survival; and President Truman, as he later explained frankly in his memoirs, was equally dependent on Zionist goodwill for his presidential campaign funds. As a consequence, the British government was subjected to ruthless pressure from Washington to get the Arabs to accept the Zionists' demands. It was a disgraceful abuse of power. On one occasion I was exposed to the full brunt of it myself. In Bevin's absence, I had to receive the US Ambassador, Mr Lou Douglas, “with a message from the President about Palestine." Mr Douglas explained that he had been asked to repeat the President's urgent request to the British government to admit a hundred thousand Jewish refugees into Palestine immediately. In line with Bevin's views, and with the support of the Permanent Under-Secretary, Sir Orme Sargent, I objected that this was simply a prescription for war. The Ambassador then replied, carefully and deliberately, that the President wished it to be known that if we could help him over this it would enable our friends in Washington to get our Marshall Aid appropriation through Congress. In other words, we must do as the Zionists wished—or starve. Bevin surrendered—he had to—but he was understandably bitter and angry. He felt it out¬ rageous that the United States, which had no responsibility for law and order in Palestine (and no intention of permitting massive Jewish immigration into the United States), should, from very questionable motives, impose an impossibly burdensome and dangerous task on Britain.
Line 17: Line 19:
 
::The L H I has passed sentence of death on the British pig Mayhew.
 
::The L H I has passed sentence of death on the British pig Mayhew.
 
::The execution will soon take place by silent and new means.
 
::The execution will soon take place by silent and new means.
−
::Signed Lahome Herut Israel.”<ref>1. However, the former Stern Gang leader, Mr [[Natan Yalin Mor]], was shown this letter recently, and denied its authenticity.</ref>
+
::Signed Lahome Herut Israel.”<ref>1. However, the former Stern Gang leader, Mr Natan Yalin Mor, was shown this letter recently, and denied its authenticity.</ref>
 
:I asked my secretary why he bothered me with such nonsense. He replied that the [[Home Office]] considered the assassination threat genuine and had already telephoned my home to warn my friends and relations against opening suspicious parcels. And sure enough, by coincidence or otherwise, explosive packets soon began arriving through the post for people supposed (sometimes quite wrongly) to be anti-Zionist. One arrived at Sir [[Anthony Eden]]’s home. I have been told that he actually stuffed it unopened into his pocket, and carried it around with him for some time before the security services relieved him of it. Another explosive packet was sent to Roy Farran, an avowed opponent of Zionism, and killed his brother, who opened it in error. To the best of my knowledge, however, no Jewish terrorist actually sent me an ex¬ plosive packet, or tried to assassinate me in any other way, though we had several false alarms.
 
:I asked my secretary why he bothered me with such nonsense. He replied that the [[Home Office]] considered the assassination threat genuine and had already telephoned my home to warn my friends and relations against opening suspicious parcels. And sure enough, by coincidence or otherwise, explosive packets soon began arriving through the post for people supposed (sometimes quite wrongly) to be anti-Zionist. One arrived at Sir [[Anthony Eden]]’s home. I have been told that he actually stuffed it unopened into his pocket, and carried it around with him for some time before the security services relieved him of it. Another explosive packet was sent to Roy Farran, an avowed opponent of Zionism, and killed his brother, who opened it in error. To the best of my knowledge, however, no Jewish terrorist actually sent me an ex¬ plosive packet, or tried to assassinate me in any other way, though we had several false alarms.
 
:I remember vividly several meetings with Zionist deputations at this time. Usually, they came to protest against harsh measures aimed at preventing illegal immigration into Palestine. On short-term human grounds, the case for unrestricted immigration was overwhelmingly strong. Scores of thousands of desperate Jewish people, fleeing from the scene of their wartime nightmare in Europe, were being channelled by Zionist organisations towards Palestine. Most of them were destitute and many were physically or mentally crippled. How could any civilised government, let alone a British Labour government, fail to admit them ? How could we use the Navy to board their ships and force them back towards Europe ? Never before or since have I known a more distressing task than that of defending the government's immigration policy to outraged deputations of Zionists. These deputations were almost always well-informed, articulate, demanding, passionate and ruthless. The most formidable of their spokesmen, without question, was Mr Sydney Silver- man; he would attack me personally in the most merciless fashion, placing on my own shoulders the responsibility for the deaths and suicides of immigrants whom we had turned back.
 
:I remember vividly several meetings with Zionist deputations at this time. Usually, they came to protest against harsh measures aimed at preventing illegal immigration into Palestine. On short-term human grounds, the case for unrestricted immigration was overwhelmingly strong. Scores of thousands of desperate Jewish people, fleeing from the scene of their wartime nightmare in Europe, were being channelled by Zionist organisations towards Palestine. Most of them were destitute and many were physically or mentally crippled. How could any civilised government, let alone a British Labour government, fail to admit them ? How could we use the Navy to board their ships and force them back towards Europe ? Never before or since have I known a more distressing task than that of defending the government's immigration policy to outraged deputations of Zionists. These deputations were almost always well-informed, articulate, demanding, passionate and ruthless. The most formidable of their spokesmen, without question, was Mr Sydney Silver- man; he would attack me personally in the most merciless fashion, placing on my own shoulders the responsibility for the deaths and suicides of immigrants whom we had turned back.
 
:But in spite of everything, were we wrong? Was Ernest Bevin mistaken in thinking, as he said so often, that the Jews were asking for more than the Arabs could ever accept peacefully—more than it was in the Jews’ own long-term interest to demand? I do not think so. I thought then, and I still think, that the scale of the Zionist demands and the ruthlessness with which they were pursuing them were bound to prove in the long term to be self-defeating.
 
:But in spite of everything, were we wrong? Was Ernest Bevin mistaken in thinking, as he said so often, that the Jews were asking for more than the Arabs could ever accept peacefully—more than it was in the Jews’ own long-term interest to demand? I do not think so. I thought then, and I still think, that the scale of the Zionist demands and the ruthlessness with which they were pursuing them were bound to prove in the long term to be self-defeating.
 
:But where, at Westminster or in Whitehall, was the counter-pressure from the Arabs whose land, homes and property these Jewish immigrants would soon be seizing? It did not exist: not because the Arabs did not feel strongly about what was going on in Palestine, but because they possessed at the time virtually no political influence at all. Very few Arab states had even achieved genuine independence before 1948, and there was no one who could command a hearing on their behalf. Con¬ sequently, the British government received virtually no support during these critical times from the people whose vital interests it was trying, however ineffectually, to protect.<ref>Publish it not..., p. 17-20.</ref>
 
:But where, at Westminster or in Whitehall, was the counter-pressure from the Arabs whose land, homes and property these Jewish immigrants would soon be seizing? It did not exist: not because the Arabs did not feel strongly about what was going on in Palestine, but because they possessed at the time virtually no political influence at all. Very few Arab states had even achieved genuine independence before 1948, and there was no one who could command a hearing on their behalf. Con¬ sequently, the British government received virtually no support during these critical times from the people whose vital interests it was trying, however ineffectually, to protect.<ref>Publish it not..., p. 17-20.</ref>
 +
 +
=="Personal Pressures"==
 +
In the chapter "Personal Pressures", [[Christopher Mayhew]] describes his attempts between 1969 and 1971 to establish how sterling remitted to Israel by the [[Jewish National Fund]] under exchange control was being used. According to Mayhew, Treasury ministers had given him assurances that turned out to refer not to the fund but to "another organisation with a similar name operating from the same address", the [[JNF Charitable Trust]]. In 1971 the Financial Secretary to the Treasury, [[Patrick Jenkin]], conceded that "it was of course a mistake that the Treasury failed to distinguish clearly between the JNF and the JNF Charitable Trust". The Prime Minister, [[Edward Heath]], refused an independent enquiry but called for a report from "the Head of the Treasury", which Mayhew wrote that Heath "will not allow to be published".<ref name="AdamsMayhew1975pp62-63">Michael Adams and Christopher Mayhew, ''Publish it not... The Middle East Cover-Up'' (London: Longman, 1975), chapter "Personal Pressures" by Christopher Mayhew, pp. 62–63.</ref>
 +
 +
The chapter then turns to Jewish critics of Zionism, for whom, Mayhew wrote, the Zionists reserved "their most bitter and relentless attacks". It quotes a memorandum of August 1974 from the journalist [[Marion Woolfson]], who described abuse and threats and a 1970 newspaper article on "Zionist activities in Britain" that "never appeared" after a "Zionist official" demanded its withdrawal. It names [[Elmer Berger]], [[Norton Mezvinsky]], [[Moshe Menuhin]], [[Mick Ashley]], [[Israel Shahak]] and [[Maxime Rodinson]] among the "small band of anti-Zionist Jewish people" who spoke out.<ref name="AdamsMayhew1975pp63-65">Michael Adams and Christopher Mayhew, ''Publish it not... The Middle East Cover-Up'' (London: Longman, 1975), chapter "Personal Pressures" by Christopher Mayhew, pp. 63–65.</ref>
 +
 +
==Reception==
 +
A Longman advertisement in the ''[[The Jewish Chronicle|Jewish Chronicle]]'' in October 1975 quoted reviews in ''[[Tribune]]'' ("powerfully argued and thoroughly documented"), ''[[The Sunday Times]]'' ("A serious indictment that cannot, I believe, be easily refuted") and ''[[The Economist]]'' ("This penetrating and honest book"), as well as the ''Liverpool Daily Post''. These quotations are given here as the publisher's advertisement quoted them.<ref name="JC751031">''The Jewish Chronicle'', 31 October 1975, p. 8, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/MjE2YjEzZmYtOWFiNy00 JC Archive] (subscription required; OCR text; publisher's advertisement), accessed 19 November 2026.</ref>
 +
 +
In the ''[[The Jewish Chronicle|Jewish Chronicle]]'', [[Tosco Fyvel|T. R. Fyvel]] called it "an anti-Zionist book with two separate theses", the first being "a spasmodic and incomplete attempt at a historical analysis of Zionism, with hostile quotations culled from here and there". He conceded that "Adams and Mayhew are right to stress the harm done to the Palestine Arab refugees", but objected to "the way Adams and Mayhew seek to smear the Jerusalem correspondents", naming [[Michael Elkins]] and [[Eric Silver]].<ref name="JC750801a">''The Jewish Chronicle'', 1 August 1975, p. 16, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/MDFlNmI0ZjUtMTc3OS00 JC Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref> Mayhew replied in a letter headed "Prejudice denied". He said the authors' objection to [[Michael Elkins]] and [[Eric Silver]] was to their being news correspondents in Israel, and that "we would object similarly to the appointment of Arabs as news correspondents in Egypt. It does not mean that we are racialists. It was partly to dispel such rubbishy suggestions that we wrote the book."<ref name="JC750808">"Prejudice denied", ''The Jewish Chronicle'', 8 August 1975, p. 15, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/ZDE0YzlmNDctYjFlNS00 JC Archive] (subscription required; OCR text; letter), accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> In the same issue [[Philip Kleinman]]'s column, "Stab in the back", criticised a favourable review in ''[[The Guardian]]'' by its leader-writer [[Anthony McDermott]], which had said that "The authors make a solid point in observing that nearly all correspondents in Israel ... are Jewish. This makes such correspondents suspect on sensitive internal issues". Kleinman wrote: "If The Guardian believes that the Jewishness of its correspondent makes his copy 'suspect', surely it should replace him".<ref name="JC750801b">"Stab in the back", ''The Jewish Chronicle'', 1 August 1975, p. 14, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/ZGMwYmUxMzMtMjQ1Yy00 JC Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref> A reviewer in the ''Liverpool Daily Post'' called it "a breathtaking book", writing that "THE WESTERN world has by a calculated and ruthlessly executed campaign been misled about the truth of the Middle East situation".<ref name="LDP750809">"Has Israel been wrong?", ''Liverpool Daily Post (Welsh edition)'', 9 August 1975, p. 6, [https://www.britishnewspaperarchive.com/image-viewer?issue=BL%2F0004986%2F19750809&page=0006&article=006 British Newspaper Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref>
 +
 +
In November 1975 the ''Jewish Chronicle'' reported that the [[British Broadcasting Corporation|BBC]]'s Director-General, Sir [[Charles Curran]], had upheld Elkins's impartiality against a campaign alleging that his Jewishness and "self-proclaimed Zionism" coloured his broadcasts, an allegation "earlier made in the book Publish It Not".<ref name="JC751107">''The Jewish Chronicle'', 7 November 1975, p. 9, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/NmEzNTkzNDMtOGQ2Yi00 JC Archive] (subscription required) (archive lists as 1 January 1975), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref>
 +
 +
In 1978 Mayhew and Adams sued the Israeli newspaper ''[[Maariv]]'' for libel in Jerusalem over a report that called the book "a propaganda document in the Nazi style". According to the ''Jewish Chronicle'', Mayhew conceded that he had tacitly compared [[Menachem Begin]] with [[Adolf Eichmann|Eichmann]] in the passage: "It must be hard for the Arabs to understand a country in which Germans who have massacred Jews are tried as war criminals, while Jews who have massacred Arabs are elected Prime Minister."<ref name="JC781117">"Mayhew and Adams sue Israeli newspaper", ''The Jewish Chronicle'', 17 November 1978, p. 3, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/YjA3MzZiZGItZDY5Mi00 JC Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref>
 +
 +
The plaintiffs, both members of the [[Council for the Advancement of Arab-British Understanding]], claimed I£500,000 in damages. The case was heard by Judge Jacob Bazak. In February 1979 witnesses for the plaintiffs included the Israeli reserve major-general [[Matityahu Peled]] of Tel Aviv University. He said the book was "definitely not antisemitic and not Nazi in style", though he agreed that comparisons of Israel with the Nazis were "unwise and irrelevant". [[Roger Owen]] of St Antony's College, Oxford, also said the book was not antisemitic. He called it "a limited and tendentious 'potted history'" whose facts were mostly accurate, but did not accept that "a pro-Zionist lobby controlling the media" explained the difficulty of putting the Arab case. Yigal Elam also gave evidence.<ref name="JC790202">"Book 'not antisemitic'", ''The Jewish Chronicle'', 2 February 1979, p. 2, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/NWU4ZTc2MDgtOWZiNS00 JC Archive] (subscription required; OCR text), accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> In March [[Dina Porat]] of Tel Aviv University, giving evidence for ''Maariv'', said there were "parallels between passages in the book ... and parts of the notorious anti-Jewish Tsarist forgery, 'The Protocols of the Elders of Zion,' and the writings of Josef Goebbels". She said the book was not antisemitic "in the aggressive, strident manner of classical antisemitic documents", but was "couched in a restrained, refined and subtle form".<ref name="JC790330">"Witness says Mayhew book is antisemitic", ''The Jewish Chronicle'', 30 March 1979, p. 5, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/ZTMxZTg3MzItNTk0Ny00 JC Archive] (subscription required; OCR text), accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> Summing up for ''Maariv'' in June, its counsel, Benny Levinburg, called it "an antisemitic book the central idea of which is the alleged Jewish conspiracy to dominate the press and the world".<ref name="JC790608">''The Jewish Chronicle'', 8 June 1979, p. 3, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/ZDBiNGU4YjctYzBhMi00 JC Archive] (subscription required; OCR text; headline partly missing; masthead not captured), accessed 19 November 2026.</ref>
 +
 +
In August 1979 the court rejected the libel action. According to the ''Jewish Chronicle'', Judge Bazak said: "To my regret I must agree with the author of the article, although I would not myself have phrased things quite so sharply or strongly." He called the book "definitely an anti-Israel, anti-Zionist propaganda work ... a one-sided, unbalanced work, based on preconceptions", and added: "It may well be that the plaintiffs themselves are not conscious of the fact that their arguments derive from antisemitic literature and Nazi propaganda." The paper reported that Porat's evidence had been "an important factor" in the judgment.<ref name="JC790810">''The Jewish Chronicle'', 10 August 1979, p. 3, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/MTI5ZTAyOGYtNTljZC00 JC Archive] (subscription required; OCR text; headline not captured), accessed 19 November 2026.</ref>
 +
 +
Reviewing the book in the ''Birmingham Daily Post'' in July 1975 under the headline "Is there a conspiracy in favour of Israel?", [[H. S. Ferns]] wrote that it contained "some extremely serious political charges against several Labour politicians and against the Labour Party". In his summary, the book alleged that [[Richard Crossman]] and [[John Strachey]] had "committed treason on behalf of Zionist lobbyists", and that [[Harold Wilson]] could not be trusted to express [[Labour Party]] policy on Israel. He noted that both authors were "leading figures in the [[Council for the Advancement of Arab-British Understanding]]". His verdict was: "It is pretty evident that the Zionist conspiracy has not closed down everything, and that the British public is not totally misinformed... For reasons best known to themselves Messrs. Mayhew and Adams are on the side of the Arabs. That is all there is to it."<ref name="BDP750726">"Is there a conspiracy in favour of Israel?", ''Birmingham Daily Post'', 26 July 1975, p. 14, [https://www.britishnewspaperarchive.com/image-viewer?issue=BL%2F0002135%2F19750726&page=14&article=388 British Newspaper Archive] (subscription required; OCR text, not checked against the page image), accessed 19 November 2026.</ref>
  
 
==Notes==
 
==Notes==
 +
<references/>

Latest revision as of 11:40, 19 November 2026

Title page of Publish it not... The Middle East Cover-Up (Longman, 1975)

Publish it not... The Middle East Cover-Up is a book by Christopher Mayhew and Michael Adams, published by Longman in 1975. It argues that Western media coverage of the Middle East was biased in favour of Zionism.


From the personal statement by Mayhew at the beginning of the book:

Ernest Bevin felt this injustice deeply too. I remember how, at the end of a particularly tense Question Time, when he had been mercilessly harried by Jewish MPs supporting Israel, he had finally burst out, “We must also remember the Arab side of the case—there are, after all, no Arabs in the House." This remark provoked an uproar, and I reproved him for it afterwards—mistakenly, I now think—on the grounds that by singling out the Jewish as against the non-Jewish supporters of Zionism he was making it easier for his enemies to suggest that he was anti- Semitic. But Bevin was unrepentant, protesting that the Zionists were “even now paralleling the Nazis in Palestine," and that they were creatures of violence and war—“What can you expect when people are brought up from the cradle on the Old Testament?"
I did not then share Bevin's emotional commitment on Palestine, but I remember clearly his dislike of Zionist methods and tactics, and, indeed, of the Zionist philosophy itself. He was passionately and un-shakeably anti-Zionist. He held that Zionism was basically racialist, that it was inevitably wedded to violence and terror, that it demanded far more from the Arabs than they could or should be expected to accept peacefully, that its success would condemn the Middle East to decades of hatred and violence, and above all—this was his immediate concern — that by turning the Arabs against Britain and the Western countries, it would open a highroad for Stalin into the Middle East.
On all these points events proved him right; but in the immediate postwar years, so soon after the truth about the Nazis' treatment of the Jews had become widely known, his plain speaking struck many people as prejudiced and harsh, and enabled the Zionists to misrepresent him with some success as an anti-Semite, which he was not.
Then, as now, there was much confusion between anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism. Zionism—the idea that Jewish people everywhere should gather together in a state in Palestine—is a political concept which can and should be freely debated, one which has wide support but which many tolerant civilised people, including many Jews, strenuously oppose. But in the 1940s, and indeed until quite recently, many people con¬ fused Zionism with Judaism, the religion of the Jews, so that criticising Zionism sounded like criticising somebody's religion. :Others confused Zionism with the Jewish people itself, and so made the mistake of thinking that if one were anti-Zionist one must be anti-Jewish as well. Regrettably, this last confusion was deliberately fostered by some extreme Zionists,[1] who discouraged potential opponents by making them afraid of being thought racialists.
Even today Zionism is a subject on which it is hard to speak frankly in Western countries without giving offence. Statements to the effect that communism or capitalism are wicked or inhuman may provoke disagreement, but they do not give offence. But if Zionism is similarly denounced, almost everyone is shocked, and the speaker's motives are widely suspected.
In 1947 and 1948 it was the political pressure on the Labour Cabinet from American Zionists, exerted through the United States government, which angered Bevin most, and I shared his feelings about this to the full. At that time, Britain was dependent on American goodwill for her economic survival; and President Truman, as he later explained frankly in his memoirs, was equally dependent on Zionist goodwill for his presidential campaign funds. As a consequence, the British government was subjected to ruthless pressure from Washington to get the Arabs to accept the Zionists' demands. It was a disgraceful abuse of power. On one occasion I was exposed to the full brunt of it myself. In Bevin's absence, I had to receive the US Ambassador, Mr Lou Douglas, “with a message from the President about Palestine." Mr Douglas explained that he had been asked to repeat the President's urgent request to the British government to admit a hundred thousand Jewish refugees into Palestine immediately. In line with Bevin's views, and with the support of the Permanent Under-Secretary, Sir Orme Sargent, I objected that this was simply a prescription for war. The Ambassador then replied, carefully and deliberately, that the President wished it to be known that if we could help him over this it would enable our friends in Washington to get our Marshall Aid appropriation through Congress. In other words, we must do as the Zionists wished—or starve. Bevin surrendered—he had to—but he was understandably bitter and angry. He felt it out¬ rageous that the United States, which had no responsibility for law and order in Palestine (and no intention of permitting massive Jewish immigration into the United States), should, from very questionable motives, impose an impossibly burdensome and dangerous task on Britain.
I was myself comparatively slow to understand the Palestine problem and formulate my own views about it. For one thing—hard as it is to believe this now—the Foreign Office was struggling at that time with a number of world issues of even greater importance. India and Pakistan had to be given freedom. The Marshall Aid plan had to be pushed for¬ ward. Institutions had to be created for a divided Germany. NATO had to be formed. At that time, inevitably, Palestine seemed a sideshow.
My first personal brush with Zionism occurred in the strangest manner. I had been in the Foreign Office only a few weeks when the following absurd-sounding letter was placed on my desk, dated 5 December 1946, postmarked Lisbon:
“Mr Mayhew, Under Secretary, Foreign Affairs, London. Remember the very words of the great Stephen S. Wise ‘We are going to get a Jewish state soon in Palestine’ and we fighters from Lahome Herut Israel, add ‘Also against the decision of the British Foreign Office’.
Don’t forget that the Jewry defeated with your British assistance the bloody and damned Nazis i.e. the first Germanic nation, and don’t forget too that its now your turn as the second arrogant Germanic nation to kiss our feet.
We are determined this time to squash you British sons of a bitch and we declare war to the finish against the British.
For every Jew you stinking British pigs kill in Palestine you will pay a thousandfold in fetid English blood.
The L H I has passed sentence of death on the British pig Mayhew.
The execution will soon take place by silent and new means.
Signed Lahome Herut Israel.”[2]
I asked my secretary why he bothered me with such nonsense. He replied that the Home Office considered the assassination threat genuine and had already telephoned my home to warn my friends and relations against opening suspicious parcels. And sure enough, by coincidence or otherwise, explosive packets soon began arriving through the post for people supposed (sometimes quite wrongly) to be anti-Zionist. One arrived at Sir Anthony Eden’s home. I have been told that he actually stuffed it unopened into his pocket, and carried it around with him for some time before the security services relieved him of it. Another explosive packet was sent to Roy Farran, an avowed opponent of Zionism, and killed his brother, who opened it in error. To the best of my knowledge, however, no Jewish terrorist actually sent me an ex¬ plosive packet, or tried to assassinate me in any other way, though we had several false alarms.
I remember vividly several meetings with Zionist deputations at this time. Usually, they came to protest against harsh measures aimed at preventing illegal immigration into Palestine. On short-term human grounds, the case for unrestricted immigration was overwhelmingly strong. Scores of thousands of desperate Jewish people, fleeing from the scene of their wartime nightmare in Europe, were being channelled by Zionist organisations towards Palestine. Most of them were destitute and many were physically or mentally crippled. How could any civilised government, let alone a British Labour government, fail to admit them ? How could we use the Navy to board their ships and force them back towards Europe ? Never before or since have I known a more distressing task than that of defending the government's immigration policy to outraged deputations of Zionists. These deputations were almost always well-informed, articulate, demanding, passionate and ruthless. The most formidable of their spokesmen, without question, was Mr Sydney Silver- man; he would attack me personally in the most merciless fashion, placing on my own shoulders the responsibility for the deaths and suicides of immigrants whom we had turned back.
But in spite of everything, were we wrong? Was Ernest Bevin mistaken in thinking, as he said so often, that the Jews were asking for more than the Arabs could ever accept peacefully—more than it was in the Jews’ own long-term interest to demand? I do not think so. I thought then, and I still think, that the scale of the Zionist demands and the ruthlessness with which they were pursuing them were bound to prove in the long term to be self-defeating.
But where, at Westminster or in Whitehall, was the counter-pressure from the Arabs whose land, homes and property these Jewish immigrants would soon be seizing? It did not exist: not because the Arabs did not feel strongly about what was going on in Palestine, but because they possessed at the time virtually no political influence at all. Very few Arab states had even achieved genuine independence before 1948, and there was no one who could command a hearing on their behalf. Con¬ sequently, the British government received virtually no support during these critical times from the people whose vital interests it was trying, however ineffectually, to protect.[3]

"Personal Pressures"

In the chapter "Personal Pressures", Christopher Mayhew describes his attempts between 1969 and 1971 to establish how sterling remitted to Israel by the Jewish National Fund under exchange control was being used. According to Mayhew, Treasury ministers had given him assurances that turned out to refer not to the fund but to "another organisation with a similar name operating from the same address", the JNF Charitable Trust. In 1971 the Financial Secretary to the Treasury, Patrick Jenkin, conceded that "it was of course a mistake that the Treasury failed to distinguish clearly between the JNF and the JNF Charitable Trust". The Prime Minister, Edward Heath, refused an independent enquiry but called for a report from "the Head of the Treasury", which Mayhew wrote that Heath "will not allow to be published".[4]

The chapter then turns to Jewish critics of Zionism, for whom, Mayhew wrote, the Zionists reserved "their most bitter and relentless attacks". It quotes a memorandum of August 1974 from the journalist Marion Woolfson, who described abuse and threats and a 1970 newspaper article on "Zionist activities in Britain" that "never appeared" after a "Zionist official" demanded its withdrawal. It names Elmer Berger, Norton Mezvinsky, Moshe Menuhin, Mick Ashley, Israel Shahak and Maxime Rodinson among the "small band of anti-Zionist Jewish people" who spoke out.[5]

Reception

A Longman advertisement in the Jewish Chronicle in October 1975 quoted reviews in Tribune ("powerfully argued and thoroughly documented"), The Sunday Times ("A serious indictment that cannot, I believe, be easily refuted") and The Economist ("This penetrating and honest book"), as well as the Liverpool Daily Post. These quotations are given here as the publisher's advertisement quoted them.[6]

In the Jewish Chronicle, T. R. Fyvel called it "an anti-Zionist book with two separate theses", the first being "a spasmodic and incomplete attempt at a historical analysis of Zionism, with hostile quotations culled from here and there". He conceded that "Adams and Mayhew are right to stress the harm done to the Palestine Arab refugees", but objected to "the way Adams and Mayhew seek to smear the Jerusalem correspondents", naming Michael Elkins and Eric Silver.[7] Mayhew replied in a letter headed "Prejudice denied". He said the authors' objection to Michael Elkins and Eric Silver was to their being news correspondents in Israel, and that "we would object similarly to the appointment of Arabs as news correspondents in Egypt. It does not mean that we are racialists. It was partly to dispel such rubbishy suggestions that we wrote the book."[8] In the same issue Philip Kleinman's column, "Stab in the back", criticised a favourable review in The Guardian by its leader-writer Anthony McDermott, which had said that "The authors make a solid point in observing that nearly all correspondents in Israel ... are Jewish. This makes such correspondents suspect on sensitive internal issues". Kleinman wrote: "If The Guardian believes that the Jewishness of its correspondent makes his copy 'suspect', surely it should replace him".[9] A reviewer in the Liverpool Daily Post called it "a breathtaking book", writing that "THE WESTERN world has by a calculated and ruthlessly executed campaign been misled about the truth of the Middle East situation".[10]

In November 1975 the Jewish Chronicle reported that the BBC's Director-General, Sir Charles Curran, had upheld Elkins's impartiality against a campaign alleging that his Jewishness and "self-proclaimed Zionism" coloured his broadcasts, an allegation "earlier made in the book Publish It Not".[11]

In 1978 Mayhew and Adams sued the Israeli newspaper Maariv for libel in Jerusalem over a report that called the book "a propaganda document in the Nazi style". According to the Jewish Chronicle, Mayhew conceded that he had tacitly compared Menachem Begin with Eichmann in the passage: "It must be hard for the Arabs to understand a country in which Germans who have massacred Jews are tried as war criminals, while Jews who have massacred Arabs are elected Prime Minister."[12]

The plaintiffs, both members of the Council for the Advancement of Arab-British Understanding, claimed I£500,000 in damages. The case was heard by Judge Jacob Bazak. In February 1979 witnesses for the plaintiffs included the Israeli reserve major-general Matityahu Peled of Tel Aviv University. He said the book was "definitely not antisemitic and not Nazi in style", though he agreed that comparisons of Israel with the Nazis were "unwise and irrelevant". Roger Owen of St Antony's College, Oxford, also said the book was not antisemitic. He called it "a limited and tendentious 'potted history'" whose facts were mostly accurate, but did not accept that "a pro-Zionist lobby controlling the media" explained the difficulty of putting the Arab case. Yigal Elam also gave evidence.[13] In March Dina Porat of Tel Aviv University, giving evidence for Maariv, said there were "parallels between passages in the book ... and parts of the notorious anti-Jewish Tsarist forgery, 'The Protocols of the Elders of Zion,' and the writings of Josef Goebbels". She said the book was not antisemitic "in the aggressive, strident manner of classical antisemitic documents", but was "couched in a restrained, refined and subtle form".[14] Summing up for Maariv in June, its counsel, Benny Levinburg, called it "an antisemitic book the central idea of which is the alleged Jewish conspiracy to dominate the press and the world".[15]

In August 1979 the court rejected the libel action. According to the Jewish Chronicle, Judge Bazak said: "To my regret I must agree with the author of the article, although I would not myself have phrased things quite so sharply or strongly." He called the book "definitely an anti-Israel, anti-Zionist propaganda work ... a one-sided, unbalanced work, based on preconceptions", and added: "It may well be that the plaintiffs themselves are not conscious of the fact that their arguments derive from antisemitic literature and Nazi propaganda." The paper reported that Porat's evidence had been "an important factor" in the judgment.[16]

Reviewing the book in the Birmingham Daily Post in July 1975 under the headline "Is there a conspiracy in favour of Israel?", H. S. Ferns wrote that it contained "some extremely serious political charges against several Labour politicians and against the Labour Party". In his summary, the book alleged that Richard Crossman and John Strachey had "committed treason on behalf of Zionist lobbyists", and that Harold Wilson could not be trusted to express Labour Party policy on Israel. He noted that both authors were "leading figures in the Council for the Advancement of Arab-British Understanding". His verdict was: "It is pretty evident that the Zionist conspiracy has not closed down everything, and that the British public is not totally misinformed... For reasons best known to themselves Messrs. Mayhew and Adams are on the side of the Arabs. That is all there is to it."[17]

Notes

  1. ↑ 1. Such as Mr Sidney Goldberg, quoted in Chapter 4, p. 58
  2. ↑ 1. However, the former Stern Gang leader, Mr Natan Yalin Mor, was shown this letter recently, and denied its authenticity.
  3. ↑ Publish it not..., p. 17-20.
  4. ↑ Michael Adams and Christopher Mayhew, Publish it not... The Middle East Cover-Up (London: Longman, 1975), chapter "Personal Pressures" by Christopher Mayhew, pp. 62–63.
  5. ↑ Michael Adams and Christopher Mayhew, Publish it not... The Middle East Cover-Up (London: Longman, 1975), chapter "Personal Pressures" by Christopher Mayhew, pp. 63–65.
  6. ↑ The Jewish Chronicle, 31 October 1975, p. 8, JC Archive (subscription required; OCR text; publisher's advertisement), accessed 19 November 2026.
  7. ↑ The Jewish Chronicle, 1 August 1975, p. 16, JC Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  8. ↑ "Prejudice denied", The Jewish Chronicle, 8 August 1975, p. 15, JC Archive (subscription required; OCR text; letter), accessed 19 November 2026.
  9. ↑ "Stab in the back", The Jewish Chronicle, 1 August 1975, p. 14, JC Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  10. ↑ "Has Israel been wrong?", Liverpool Daily Post (Welsh edition), 9 August 1975, p. 6, British Newspaper Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  11. ↑ The Jewish Chronicle, 7 November 1975, p. 9, JC Archive (subscription required) (archive lists as 1 January 1975), accessed 18 November 2026.
  12. ↑ "Mayhew and Adams sue Israeli newspaper", The Jewish Chronicle, 17 November 1978, p. 3, JC Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  13. ↑ "Book 'not antisemitic'", The Jewish Chronicle, 2 February 1979, p. 2, JC Archive (subscription required; OCR text), accessed 19 November 2026.
  14. ↑ "Witness says Mayhew book is antisemitic", The Jewish Chronicle, 30 March 1979, p. 5, JC Archive (subscription required; OCR text), accessed 19 November 2026.
  15. ↑ The Jewish Chronicle, 8 June 1979, p. 3, JC Archive (subscription required; OCR text; headline partly missing; masthead not captured), accessed 19 November 2026.
  16. ↑ The Jewish Chronicle, 10 August 1979, p. 3, JC Archive (subscription required; OCR text; headline not captured), accessed 19 November 2026.
  17. ↑ "Is there a conspiracy in favour of Israel?", Birmingham Daily Post, 26 July 1975, p. 14, British Newspaper Archive (subscription required; OCR text, not checked against the page image), accessed 19 November 2026.