Difference between revisions of "Scottish Council Foundation"

From Powerbase
Jump to: navigation, search
(→‎Notes)
 
(41 intermediate revisions by 8 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
'''Scottish Council Foundation''' (SCF) is a [[Sourcewatch:Think tanks|Think tank]] that proclaims that it  "develops leading edge thinking and world class practice to address the strategic challenges facing Scotland and other modern economies and societies in an age of complexity and rapid change." It was established  by the [[Scottish Council for Development and Industry]] (SCDI) in 1999 [http://www.psa.ac.uk/2005/pps/Pautz.pdf].
+
{{Template:Foodspin badge}}
  
−
According to [http://www.psa.ac.uk/2005/pps/Pautz.pdf Hartwig Pautz] 'Three of the SCF’s five trustees are highranking members of the SCDI executive and its board and all of them are
+
The [[Scottish Council Foundation]] (SCF) is a neoliberal [[Sourcewatch:Think tanks|think tank]] that proclaims that: "Politically independent, our work bridges thinking and practice to provide innovative and practical solutions to many of the pressing social, economic and environmental challenges facing Scotland" <ref>[http://www.scottishcouncilfoundation.org/ Scottish Council Foundation Website, Home Page], accessed Nov. 2008</ref>.
−
important members of Scotland’s business community. The SCF employs seven full-time and one part-time staff; of whom five are involved in research and securing research income. The present director, [[James McCormick]], was appointed in 2002. Previously he worked for the [[Institute for Public Policy Research]]’s (IPPR) Social Justice Commission Report, published in 1994.'
 
  
−
The following account draws on Hartwig Pautz 'Think-Tanks in Scotland' Paper for the 55th Political Studies Association Annual conference, 4-7 April 2005, University of Leeds,  [http://www.psa.ac.uk/2005/pps/Pautz.pdf]
+
It was established  by the [[Scottish Council for Development and Industry]] (SCDI) in 1999, which  remains strongly involved as three of the SCF&#39;s five trustees are high-ranking members of the SCDI executive and its board and all of them are important members of Scotland&#39;s business community.  
  
−
:'Officially non-aligned to any political party, the SCF’s language resembles (New) Labour-speech: the institute’s core aims are ‘tackle[ing] inequalities in the marketplace’, in public health and in the distribution of wealth[http://www.scottishcouncilfoundation.org/news.php?id=4]. It demands action led by the Scottish Executive to ‘promote cost-cutting partnerships between local shops and major retailers, and offer incentives for new businesses to set up in low-income neighbourhoods’ in order to allow poor households to get more value for their money. In order to ‘enjoy the benefits of competition’ more commitment from government and a clearer challenge to private service providers is demanded [http://www.scottishcouncilfoundation.org/news2.php#inscf]]. Equality is not an aim in itself; at best marked disparities are seen as economically undesirable for all members of society – ‘a pronounced set of inequalities is bad for everyone, for the economy, for the people in the middle, for the people at the bottom’(interview with James McCormick, 2004).'
+
In 2004, the SCF employed five full-time research staff. Its present director, James McCormick, was appointed in 2002. Previously he had worked for the Institute for Public Policy Research&#39;s (IPPR) Social Justice Commission Report (1994), which was important for the Labour Party&#39;s Third Way concepts of the welfare state.  
  
−
:The SCF, which employs an in-house research team, carries out more original research and
+
The SCF is one of the only Scottish-based and Scotland-focussed think-tanks that carries out original research and only occasionally draws from external expertise. Unlike the [[David Hume Institute]] and [[Policy Institute]], the SCF also cooperates with various organisations, including the Washington D.C [[Centre for Excellence in Government]], the [[IPPR]], the [[Public Health Institute of Scotland]] and the [[Scottish Development Centre for Mental Health]]. The SCF emphasises that it "brings the experience of its international networks ... to bear in everything it does." <ref>[http://www.scottishcouncilfoundation.org/page.php?id=9 Scottish Council Foundation Website, About Us], accessed Nov. 2008</ref>.  
−
only occasionally draws from external expertise in the form of cooperation
 
−
between the SCF and an individual researcher on an original project.
 
−
Unlike the [[David Hume Institute]] and [[Policy Institute]], the SCF has cooperated on research with various groups, including the Washington D.C [[Centre for Excellence in Government]],
 
−
the [[IPPR]], the [[Public Health Institute of Scotland]] and the [[Scottish
 
−
Development Centre for Mental Health]]([http://www.scottishcouncilfoundation.org
 
−
/comm.php.] Accessed 1 June 2004). The SCF emphasises the international
 
−
and national relevance of its projects and therefore the ‘exportability’ of its products. The in-house research competence allows it considerably more freedom to do research.  
 
  
 +
Non-aligned to any political party, the SCF&#39;s language resembles (New) Labour-speech: the institute&#39;s calls for action to "tackle inequalities in the marketplace as well as to redistribute income to poor households". It demands action led by the Scottish Executive to "promote cost-cutting partnerships between local shops and major retailers, and offer incentives for new businesses to set up in low-income neighbourhoods" in order to allow poor households to get more value for their money. In order to "enjoy the benefits of competition" more commitment from government to functioning markets and a clearer challenge to private service providers is demanded <ref>[http://www.scottishcouncilfoundation.org/news.php?id=4 Scottish Council Foundation Website, Press Release, 20 February 2004], accessed Nov. 2008</ref>.
 +
 +
In the SCF's policy research work, equality does not feature very highly on the agenda as an aim in itself; at best marked disparities are seen as economically undesirable for all members of society: "a pronounced set of inequalities is bad for everyone, for the economy, for the people in the middle, for the people at the bottom", said its director James McCormick in January 2004. <ref>[http://www.psa.ac.uk/journals/pdf/5/2005/Pautz.pdf  H. Pautz pdf] Think-Tanks in Scotland, 55th Political Studies Association Annual  Conference  4-7 April 2005 - University of Leeds]</ref> 
 +
 +
In January 2006 it published a report with the [[Fraser of Allander Institute]] proposing that Scottish Water be privatised.<ref>[http://www.scottishcouncilfoundation.org/pubs_more.php?p=53 Scottish Council Foundation Website, Raising the Return - Scotland's Public Assets], accessed Nov. 2008</ref> In the same month it organised a conference with pharma giant [[Pfizer]], one of the most active pharma lobbyists in Scotland on binge drinking.  [[Andrew Harris]], from the Foundation, said: "Education, improved housing, employment and environmental changes can all address problems such as binge-drinking far more effectively than trying to tackle the problem in isolation" <ref>Richard Gray [http://scotlandonsunday.scotsman.com/opinion/Message-in-a-bottle.2746330.jp Message in a bottle] Scotland on Sunday, 29 January 2006.</ref>
 +
 +
The SCF, though its director says he sees it in a "social-democratic" epistemic community, pushes market friendly policies. It rejects what its director called the &#39;Scottish consensus&#39;. What this means is the following: "to say that you&#39;re a left think-tank would not really say anything, it would say you&#39;re part of the consensus, because Scotland is so heavily centre-left, and you want to challenge the consensus [...] so we&#39;re not really interested in being aligned in a partisan sense". <ref>[http://www.psa.ac.uk/journals/pdf/5/2005/Pautz.pdf  H. Pautz pdf] Think-Tanks in Scotland, 55th Political Studies Association Annual  Conference  4-7 April 2005 - University of Leeds]</ref> Challenging the consensus here means introducing pro-market ideas into the public sphere and advising decision-makers into that direction.
  
 
==Funding==
 
==Funding==
−
The SCF states that its "principal supporters: include:
+
The SCF is funded by big business . 
 +
The SCF states that its "principal supporters" include  
 
*[[Associated Newspapers]]
 
*[[Associated Newspapers]]
 
*[[Boots]]
 
*[[Boots]]
Line 35: Line 35:
  
 
==Personnel==
 
==Personnel==
 +
===Trustees===
 
SCF's Trustees are:  
 
SCF's Trustees are:  
−
*[[Shonaig MacPherson]], Chairperson
+
====2001====
−
*[[Donal Dowds]]
 
−
*[[Crawford Gillies]]
 
−
*[[Mike Hambly]]
 
−
*[[Alan Wilson]]
 
  
 +
*[[Shonaig Macpherson]], Chairperson
 +
*[[Mike Hambly]] CEO Digital Animations Group plc
 +
*[[Donald I Turner]] Chairman, [[Scottish Council for Development and Industry]]
 +
*[[Alan Wilson]], CEO [[Scottish Council for Development and Industry]]
 +
*[[Crawford Gillies]]
 +
 +
*[[Donal Dowds]] BAA Scottish Airports - Past Chairman of [[SCDI]]
 +
 +
==2006==
 +
Source: [http://www.scottishcouncilfoundation.org/page.php?id=2]
 +
*[[Shonaig Macpherson]], Chairperson
 +
*[[Alan Wilson]], CEO [[Scottish Council for Development and Industry]]
 +
*[[Crawford Gillies]]
 +
*[[Mike Hambly]] CEO Digital Animations Group plc, Executive of [[Scottish Council for Development and Industry]]
 +
*[[David Wilson]]
 +
*[[Jim Martin]] [[LogicaCMG]] and Executive of [[Scottish Council for Development and Industry]]
 
All serve in a personal capacity.
 
All serve in a personal capacity.
  
 +
===Advisors===
 +
All members serve in a personal capacity.
 +
 +
*[[Andrew Adonis]] No 10 Policy Unit
 +
*[[Jonathan Cape]] [[East of Scotland Water]]
 +
Johnston Clark Blackadders Solicitors
 +
[[Brendan Dick]] BT Scotland
 +
[[Roland Diggens]] [[Scottish Council for Development and Industry]]
 +
[[Andrew Gibb]] Glasgow 1999
 +
[[Robina Goodlad]] Glasgow University
 +
Jon Harris COSLA
 +
Alison Hook
 +
Jill Kent British Energy plc
 +
[[Thomas Lange]] Robert Gordon University, Aberdeen
 +
[[Carolyn McAdam]] [[Scottish and Southern Energy]] plc
 +
[[Joyce McMillan]] journalist and critic
 +
Anne Meikle Fair Play Scotland
 +
[[Jeremy Peat]] The Royal Bank of Scotland plc
 +
[[Seona Reid]] Glasgow School of Art
 +
[[Nicholas Rengger]] St Andrews University
 +
Tracey White Scottish Trades Union Congress
  
 +
Source [http://www.scottishpolicynet.org.uk/scf/about/content2.shtml]
 +
===Staff 2001===
 +
source[http://www.scottishpolicynet.org.uk/scf/about/content2.shtml]
 +
*[[Graham Leicester]] Director
 +
*[[James McCormick]] Research Director
 +
*[[Richard Maconachie]] Development Director
 +
*[[Linda Boyes]] Policy Manager
 +
*[[Mike Davies]] Policy Manager
 +
*[[Deirdre Elrick]] Policy Manager
 +
*[[Andrew Lyon]] [[International Futures Forum]]
 +
*[[Gillian Menzies]] Administration
 +
*[[Sandra Robertson]] Administration
  
−
===Staff===
+
===Staff 2006===
−
*Linda Boyes  Policy Manager 
+
Source: [http://www.scottishcouncilfoundation.org/page.php?id=4]
−
*Deirdre Elrick Policy Manager
+
*[[Linda Boyes]] Policy Manager 
−
*Jim McCormick Director
+
*[[Deirdre Elrick]] Policy Manager
−
*Gillian Menzies Finance Officer
+
*[[James McCormick]] Director
−
*Sandra Robertson Events Co-ordinator
+
*[[Gillian Menzies]] Finance Officer
−
*Janet Smith Office Manager
+
*[[Sandra Robertson]] Events Co-ordinator
−
*Mark Langan Research Fellow
+
*[[Janet Smith]] Office Manager
−
*Andrew Harris Programme Director
+
*[[Mark Langan]] Research Fellow
 +
*[[Andrew Harris]] Programme Director
  
 
==Contact details==
 
==Contact details==
Line 66: Line 113:
  
 
==External links==
 
==External links==
−
Hartwig Pautz 'Think-Tanks in Scotland' Paper for the 55th Political Studies Association Annual conference, 4-7 April 2005, University of Leeds,  [http://www.psa.ac.uk/2005/pps/Pautz.pdf www.psa.ac.uk/2005/pps/Pautz.pdf]
+
 
−
[[Category: Think tanks]]
+
*Alf Young [http://www.theherald.co.uk/business/54799.html The horse is at the water, but who&#39;s nagging it to drink?] the Herald, 24 January 2006.
 +
 
 +
==Notes==
 +
<references/>
 +
[[Category: Think Tanks]]
 +
[[Category:Food Industry lobby groups]][[Category:Water: Advocates for Privatisation of Scottish water]]
 +
[[Category: Water]][[Category: Scotland]][[Category:Scottish Think Tanks]]

Latest revision as of 14:46, 7 September 2009

Foodspin badge.png This article is part of the Foodspin project of Spinwatch.

The Scottish Council Foundation (SCF) is a neoliberal think tank that proclaims that: "Politically independent, our work bridges thinking and practice to provide innovative and practical solutions to many of the pressing social, economic and environmental challenges facing Scotland" [1].

It was established by the Scottish Council for Development and Industry (SCDI) in 1999, which remains strongly involved as three of the SCF's five trustees are high-ranking members of the SCDI executive and its board and all of them are important members of Scotland's business community.

In 2004, the SCF employed five full-time research staff. Its present director, James McCormick, was appointed in 2002. Previously he had worked for the Institute for Public Policy Research's (IPPR) Social Justice Commission Report (1994), which was important for the Labour Party's Third Way concepts of the welfare state.

The SCF is one of the only Scottish-based and Scotland-focussed think-tanks that carries out original research and only occasionally draws from external expertise. Unlike the David Hume Institute and Policy Institute, the SCF also cooperates with various organisations, including the Washington D.C Centre for Excellence in Government, the IPPR, the Public Health Institute of Scotland and the Scottish Development Centre for Mental Health. The SCF emphasises that it "brings the experience of its international networks ... to bear in everything it does." [2].

Non-aligned to any political party, the SCF's language resembles (New) Labour-speech: the institute's calls for action to "tackle inequalities in the marketplace as well as to redistribute income to poor households". It demands action led by the Scottish Executive to "promote cost-cutting partnerships between local shops and major retailers, and offer incentives for new businesses to set up in low-income neighbourhoods" in order to allow poor households to get more value for their money. In order to "enjoy the benefits of competition" more commitment from government to functioning markets and a clearer challenge to private service providers is demanded [3].

In the SCF's policy research work, equality does not feature very highly on the agenda as an aim in itself; at best marked disparities are seen as economically undesirable for all members of society: "a pronounced set of inequalities is bad for everyone, for the economy, for the people in the middle, for the people at the bottom", said its director James McCormick in January 2004. [4]

In January 2006 it published a report with the Fraser of Allander Institute proposing that Scottish Water be privatised.[5] In the same month it organised a conference with pharma giant Pfizer, one of the most active pharma lobbyists in Scotland on binge drinking. Andrew Harris, from the Foundation, said: "Education, improved housing, employment and environmental changes can all address problems such as binge-drinking far more effectively than trying to tackle the problem in isolation" [6]

The SCF, though its director says he sees it in a "social-democratic" epistemic community, pushes market friendly policies. It rejects what its director called the 'Scottish consensus'. What this means is the following: "to say that you're a left think-tank would not really say anything, it would say you're part of the consensus, because Scotland is so heavily centre-left, and you want to challenge the consensus [...] so we're not really interested in being aligned in a partisan sense". [7] Challenging the consensus here means introducing pro-market ideas into the public sphere and advising decision-makers into that direction.

Funding

The SCF is funded by big business . The SCF states that its "principal supporters" include

Personnel

Trustees

SCF's Trustees are:

2001

2006

Source: [1]

All serve in a personal capacity.

Advisors

All members serve in a personal capacity.

Johnston Clark Blackadders Solicitors Brendan Dick BT Scotland Roland Diggens Scottish Council for Development and Industry Andrew Gibb Glasgow 1999 Robina Goodlad Glasgow University Jon Harris COSLA Alison Hook Jill Kent British Energy plc Thomas Lange Robert Gordon University, Aberdeen Carolyn McAdam Scottish and Southern Energy plc Joyce McMillan journalist and critic Anne Meikle Fair Play Scotland Jeremy Peat The Royal Bank of Scotland plc Seona Reid Glasgow School of Art Nicholas Rengger St Andrews University Tracey White Scottish Trades Union Congress

Source [2]

Staff 2001

source[3]

Staff 2006

Source: [4]

Contact details

Scottish Council Foundation,
23 Chester Street,
Edinburgh, Scotland, EH3 7ET
Phone: 0131 225 4709
Fax: 0131 220 2116
Email: scf AT @scottishcouncilfoundation.org
Web: http://www.scottishcouncilfoundation.org/index.php

External links

Notes

  1. ↑ Scottish Council Foundation Website, Home Page, accessed Nov. 2008
  2. ↑ Scottish Council Foundation Website, About Us, accessed Nov. 2008
  3. ↑ Scottish Council Foundation Website, Press Release, 20 February 2004, accessed Nov. 2008
  4. ↑ H. Pautz pdf Think-Tanks in Scotland, 55th Political Studies Association Annual Conference 4-7 April 2005 - University of Leeds]
  5. ↑ Scottish Council Foundation Website, Raising the Return - Scotland's Public Assets, accessed Nov. 2008
  6. ↑ Richard Gray Message in a bottle Scotland on Sunday, 29 January 2006.
  7. ↑ H. Pautz pdf Think-Tanks in Scotland, 55th Political Studies Association Annual Conference 4-7 April 2005 - University of Leeds]
Retrieved from "https://powerbase.info/index.php?title=Scottish_Council_Foundation&oldid=95531"