Michael Adams
| Michael Adams
| |
|---|---|
| Born | 31 May 1920 Addis Ababa, Ethiopia |
| Died | 6 February 2005 Exeter, Devon |
| Nationality | British |
| Occupation | Journalist, broadcaster, author, campaigner |
| Known for | Manchester Guardian Middle East correspondent (from 1956); co-founder and director of the Council for the Advancement of Arab-British Understanding; first editor of Middle East International (1971) |
| Spouse(s) | Celia Pridham (m. 1957) |
| Education | Sedbergh School; Christ Church, Oxford |
Michael Evelyn Adams (31 May 1920 – 6 February 2005) was a British journalist and campaigner. From 1956 he was Middle East correspondent of the Manchester Guardian, and his reporting on the Palestinians after the 1967 war led to a break with the editor, Alastair Hetherington. He co-founded the Council for the Advancement of Arab-British Understanding (CAABU) in 1967 and in 1971 became the first editor of Middle East International.[1][2]
In Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (2004), Daphna Baram lists Adams among the paper's "Key Players". She writes that he "reported movingly on the plight of the Palestinians" and that his disagreement with Hetherington "ultimately brought about Adams's resignation".[3]
Early life and war service
Adams was born in Addis Ababa, where his father worked for the National Bank of Egypt. He was educated at Sedbergh School and read history at Christ Church, Oxford.[2][1] When the Second World War began he joined the Royal Air Force. He was shot down over the North Sea, picked up by the Germans after six days in a dinghy, and spent the rest of the war as a prisoner, mostly in the camp at Luckenwalde, south of Berlin.[1][2] He returned to Oxford and took his MA in 1948. He then worked as a scriptwriter for the BBC European Service.[4][3]
Manchester Guardian
In 1956 the Manchester Guardian sent Adams to Cairo as its Middle East correspondent. According to his obituary in the Guardian, he told Alastair Hetherington, who became editor later that year, that he knew little of the region. Hetherington replied that the paper needed someone with an open mind.[2] Adams opposed Anthony Eden's policy over Suez, and the paper's leaders took the same line. When British correspondents were expelled from Cairo he moved to Beirut. His first book, Suez and After: Year of Crisis, appeared in 1958.[2][3] In 1961 he covered Italy as well as the Middle East from Rome, until a financial crisis at the paper ended the post. He then spent a year in Umbria writing Umbria (1964) and worked for Voluntary Service Overseas.[2]
The Independent says that his reporting "angered many of Israel's friends both in Israel and Britain", among them Hetherington himself.[1]
The 1967 war and the break with Hetherington
After the Six-Day War the BBC sent Adams to the Middle East to make radio programmes on Arab opinion. These became Chaos or Rebirth: The Arab Outlook (1968).[2][4] On the same trip he visited Gaza, Jerusalem and the West Bank. The Guardian obituary says he was "appalled by the brutality of the occupation" and that he became "the first journalist to question the myth of Israel's 'benign occupation'".[2]
He wrote freelance articles for the Guardian that ended with an account of the Israeli demolition of three villages near Jerusalem, among them Imwas (Emmaus). Hetherington rejected the piece, arguing that the story must be exaggerated because Jerusalem-based correspondents had not reported it. When Adams protested, Hetherington threatened never to publish his work again. The paper later ran another piece confirming the destruction of the villages.[2] According to Exeter University's archive, the article appeared instead in The Sunday Times.[4] The Independent says that "Adams left" after this refusal.[1] Baram puts the cause in his view that the Israelis would either have to give the Palestinians "equal partnership in the state" or drive "every last Arab out", a view that "did not find favour with Alastair Hetherington".[3]
Baram's account of the break with the Guardian
1964–1967
Daphna Baram writes that Adams was a staff correspondent of the Guardian from 1956 to 1962 and covered the Suez crisis from Cairo. When he came back from the Middle East in 1964 he applied for the post of diplomatic editor. He found that it had gone to Terence Prittie, and left the staff, though his relations with the paper stayed cordial and he went on contributing articles.[5]
On 15 June 1967, three days after a leader by Alastair Hetherington that marked a change in the paper's line, the Guardian printed an article by Adams headed "The foundations of peace". It warned that Israeli talk of absorbing Gaza, the old city of Jerusalem, the West Bank and the Syrian heights would "destroy any chance of creating in the Middle East an environment in which Israel will be able to live at peace". Adams argued for "a settlement, rather than a 'solution'". Baram calls the article "chillingly prophetic" when read after 9/11.[6] He also sent an angry letter in reply to Martha Gellhorn's articles on the refugees.[5] During the 1967 war, Baram writes, Adams wrote for the paper on the Arab response to defeat, while Prittie used his Israeli sources to outline how Israel would deal with victory.[7] The paper's correspondent in Cairo, Michael Wall, was kept by Egyptian censorship from filing until the fighting was over, as Adams had been in 1956.[8]
The 1968 features
In 1968, while travelling in the region to make documentary films for the BBC and already active in CAABU, Adams suggested a series of four features on the occupied territories, and the Guardian commissioned them. The first, from Gaza, described punitive curfews, house demolitions and shooting in civilian areas in defiance of the Geneva Convention. It ended with a personal note: as a prisoner of war in Germany for four years, he wrote, "the Germans never treated me as harshly as the Israelis are treating the Arabs of Gaza Strip". Baram says the outcry led Hetherington to tell Adams that he regretted publishing it.[9] The second feature, from the West Bank, concluded that the result of the occupation's measures, "and it is difficult to believe that it is not the result intended", was "to terrorise the local population" and encourage them to leave across the Jordan.[10]
Adams sent his third report, on house demolitions in the old city of Jerusalem, with a private letter to the foreign editor, Geoffrey Taylor. He listed neutral witnesses, among them diplomats, UN staff and medical workers, and wrote: "I cannot overemphasise the seriousness of the situation of the Arab inhabitants under Israeli occupation." Hetherington's reply referred to an article in the Jewish Observer and to a conversation with Lord Sieff, and told Adams that "the bulk of Jewish readers here believe that the Israelis have behaved with astonishing restraint". Adams answered that even the mayor of Jerusalem, Teddy Kollek, had complained to him that the government failed to compensate evicted families.[11]
Latrun, 1968
The fourth story, in May 1968, concerned three villages in the Latrun area west of Jerusalem, Imwas, Yalo and Beit Nuba, which had been demolished and their inhabitants expelled weeks after the war. Baram writes that Taylor, who usually acted as a buffer between editor and reporter, was away in eastern Europe, and that Hetherington dealt with the story himself. After "a noisy row over the telephone" he told Adams that he no longer fully trusted what he wrote. He did not dispute the facts, but accused Adams of leaving out that the villages had been used as bases for attacks on Israel. He refused to print the story or to take any more work from him.[12] This account differs from the Guardian obituary cited above. Adams sold the story to The Sunday Times, but Harold Jackson reported the villages independently for the Guardian, which published his piece on 5 June 1968, a week before Adams's feature appeared. Adams told Baram that Hetherington rang him before Jackson's story ran: "It was as apologetic as he could get."[13]
Adams told Baram that he did not believe economic pressure was the main reason for Hetherington's doubts. In his view the editor was surrounded in London by important people, among them Sieff, Marks and members of parliament, who told him that Adams was wrong. Both Adams and Jackson told Baram that they had seen a letter from Lord Marks to Hetherington threatening an organised boycott of the paper by businesses. Baram found no such letter in the Guardian or Marks and Spencer archives.[14] Baram attributes the different treatment of Jackson's report largely to style: Hetherington, "as well as his Zionist critics, couldn't stomach Adams's biblical indignation".[15]
The Ingrams libel case, 1972
In October 1971 Richard Ingrams, editor of Private Eye, said on the BBC programme A Chance to Meet that the Guardian had dropped articles about Israel after advertisers threatened to withdraw. The paper sued the BBC and Ingrams for libel, and in 1972 Adams gave evidence for the defendants: "It is impossible for anyone except the editor to say with certainty what impelled him to stop me writing for the paper. What is certain is that there was pressure and that he did stop me." He also told the court that Hetherington had spoken of the paper's "specially difficult position" because of its readership in the north-west of England. The defendants withdrew, apologised publicly and paid the paper's costs.[16][17]
Later relations and Baram's assessment
According to Baram, after Adams became editor of Middle East International he wrote for the Guardian again in the 1980s, especially during the Lebanon war, but desk editors were told to use him for opinion pieces rather than reporting. His relationship with the paper stayed "sour".[16] In the issue after the Sabra and Shatila massacre in September 1982 the paper ran his article "Why Israel's moral blackmail has backfired", mainly a translation of an article by the Israeli columnist Boaz Evron on "the use made of the Holocaust as a means of propaganda".[18]
Baram writes that the conflict became almost central to life for some correspondents: "Terence Prittie became a propagandist for Israel, Adams for the Palestinian issue." She puts the definition of objectivity at the centre of the dispute. Hetherington held that someone who believed Israel should not have been created as a separate Jewish state could not claim to be an objective journalist. Adams answered: "If you believe, rightly, that the Arabs have no right to drive the Israelis into the sea [...] you must agree that the Israelis have no right to drive the Arabs into the desert."[19]
CAABU and Middle East International
In 1967 Adams co-founded the Council for the Advancement of Arab-British Understanding with a group that included several MPs. According to the Guardian obituary, the group's aim was to counter "the pro-Israeli bias prevailing at the time". He was CAABU's director, and later concentrated on its information work.[2][4] Baram describes him as CAABU's chairman.[3]
In 1971 he became the first editor of Middle East International. According to the Independent, the magazine was founded "quite independently of CAABU" by a group that included the MPs Christopher Mayhew, Ian Gilmour and Dennis Walters and the retired ambassador Harold Beeley.[1] Baram says that he edited it until he retired in 1981.[3]
During the "Black September" crisis in Jordan in September 1970, Adams flew to Amman on behalf of CAABU to help with negotiations over the hostages held by the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine after the Dawson's Field hijackings. His 52-page diary of the episode is in his papers at Exeter.[4]
With Christopher Mayhew he wrote Publish It Not: The Middle East Cover-Up (Longman, 1975). Exeter's archive describes the book as presenting "evidence of systematic media bias in western coverage of matters relating to Israel and Palestine".[4][3] His campaigning brought accusations of anti-Semitism from supporters of Israel. The Exeter archive says he "became embroiled in an unpleasant lawsuit trying to defend himself".[1][4]
Later life
In 1984 Adams retired to Devon with a research fellowship at the University of Exeter. He published a memoir, The Untravelled World (1984), but did not write a planned second volume.[2][1] From 1967 he made documentaries for the BBC series Chronicle on BBC2.[2] His papers, catalogued as EUL MS 241, are held by the University of Exeter.[4]
Books
- Suez and After: Year of Crisis (1958)
- Umbria (1964)
- Chaos or Rebirth: The Arab Outlook (BBC, 1968)
- Publish It Not: The Middle East Cover-Up, with Christopher Mayhew (Longman, 1975)
- The Untravelled World (1984)
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 James Craig, "Michael Adams", The Independent, 14 February 2005, accessed 21 November 2026.
- ↑ 2.00 2.01 2.02 2.03 2.04 2.05 2.06 2.07 2.08 2.09 2.10 2.11 2.12 David Gilmour, "Michael Adams", The Guardian, 8 February 2005, accessed 21 November 2026.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), "Key Players", p. 259.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8 University of Exeter Special Collections, "The Road to Emmaus: the papers of Michael Adams (1920–2005) – EUL MS 241", 14 December 2018, accessed 21 November 2026.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", p. 113.
- ↑ Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", pp. 113–114.
- ↑ Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", p. 107.
- ↑ Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", p. 106.
- ↑ Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", p. 114.
- ↑ Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", pp. 114–115.
- ↑ Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", pp. 115–116.
- ↑ Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", p. 117.
- ↑ Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", pp. 117–118.
- ↑ Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", pp. 116–117.
- ↑ Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", p. 120.
- ↑ 16.0 16.1 Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", p. 118.
- ↑ Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", pp. 118–119.
- ↑ Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 8, "Sour Grapes", p. 160.
- ↑ Daphna Baram, Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel (London: Guardian Books, 2004; paperback 2008), ch. 6, "Watershed", p. 119.