Integrity Initiative

From Powerbase
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Institute for Statecraft project on disinformation, funded by the UK Foreign Office from 2017

Integrity Initiative

Logo Integrity Initiative logo.png
Integrity Initiative logo. Source: integrityinitiative.net (archived). Fair use.
Type Counter-disinformation project
Founded 2015
Founder(s) Institute for Statecraft
Location United Kingdom
Area served Europe; proposed North American expansion
Services Expert networks; research; policy and media engagement
Key people Chris Donnelly; Dan Lafayeedney
Remarks The Institute ended its involvement in 2019. FCO grant funding included £296,500 in 2017/18 and £1,961,000 in 2018/19.[1]

The Integrity Initiative was created in 2015. It was run by the Institute for Statecraft until 2019.[1]


Activities

Affiliations

Partners

Beacon Project | CEPA | CIBOD | European Values | Kremlin Watch | Political Capital | The Institute for Statecraft | UoM Research Institute | RES[2]


People

British Embassy/High Commission Contacts for the Integrity Initiative

Embassy liaison

The leaked Phase II application, published by Anonymous in 2018, claimed engagement with government departments in France, the Netherlands, Spain, Norway and Lithuania to encourage the development of centres studying disinformation. This was the Institute's account of institutional engagement, not independent confirmation by the departments concerned.[3]

History and funding

The Foreign and Commonwealth Office began funding the project in 2017. In December 2018 Alan Duncan described it as bringing together experts to analyse Russian disinformation overseas; he said its grant agreement prohibited attempts to influence the UK Parliament, government or political parties.[4] A written answer specified that the funding came from the Counter Disinformation and Media Development Programme, into which the former Russian Language Programme had been amalgamated.[5]

Grants and proposals (different measures, not additive)
Period Amount Status and source
2017–18 £296,500 FCO grant reported from parliamentary answers.[1]
2017–18 £480,635 Amount sought in the leaked Phase I application and budget, not the confirmed grant paid.[6]
2018–19 £1,961,000 Announced FCO funding; same total appears in the leaked Phase II budget.[1][3]
2018–19 £196,500 Administration subtotal within the Phase II budget, not additional funding.[3]
2018–19 £1,764,500 Activity subtotal within the same budget.[3]

A leaked Foreign and Commonwealth Office grant agreement, issued by the Eastern Europe and Central Asia Directorate, provides grant funding to the Institute for Statecraft for the project entitled “INTEGRITY INITIATIVE Phase 2”. The grant funding period is 1 April 2018 to 31 March 2019. The authority undertakes to provide up to a maximum of £1,961,000 (“one million, nine hundred and sixty-one thousand pounds sterling”) towards the project, of which the same sum is to be paid in that financial year. The agreement names Chris Donnelly, as co-director of the Institute, as the grantee, at 2 Temple Place, London. It also states that the grant must not be used to support activity intended to influence or attempt to influence the UK Parliament, government or political parties, which is the prohibition later described by Alan Duncan in the Commons. Names of Foreign Office signatories on the scanned copy are not reproduced here.[7]

A leaked invoice dated April 2016 from the Hungarian institute Political Capital Kft billed the Institute for Statecraft Integrity Initiative £1,000 for “Study preparing” a paper titled Comrades for Peace, Equality and Neutrality: pro-Russian far-left parties in Europe. Bank-account, VAT and other personal or payment identifiers on the invoice are not reproduced here.[8]

The leaked Phase II proposal, published by Anonymous in 2018, claimed or anticipated contributions from the US Department of State (£250,000), Facebook (£100,000), Smith Richardson Foundation (£45,000), NATO public diplomacy (£168,000), partner institutions (£70,000), the Lithuanian Ministry of Defence (approximately £20,000 in support) and the German business community (£25,000). These are the applicant's co-funding claims, not independently verified receipts; some support was described as in kind.[3]

National projects and working methods

According to the proposal and progress report published by Anonymous in 2018, the Institute for Statecraft sought a “network of networks” comprising experts, journalists, academics and political actors. Its proposal listed nine established national clusters and a larger expansion plan. These are the Institute's descriptions, not verified membership or evidence of participation by everyone in a contact database.[3][9]

Examples in the leaked 2018 cluster progress report
Country/area Activity described
Spain Papers and newspaper articles, including material supplied anonymously to journalists; a study on the Catalan referendum was reportedly circulated to the prime minister’s office.[9]
Germany English- and German-language studies for different audiences, reportedly circulated in political circles.[9]
Greece Separate journalist and university-based groups coordinated from London; a media observatory studied reporting and attitudes.[9]
Netherlands The initial arrangement was described as having failed and a replacement cluster as being developed.[9]
Belgium The Institute for European Studies at the Vrije Universiteit Brussel was described as the academic base and de facto Brussels cluster.[9]
United States and Canada Proposed expansion beyond national capitals: plans, not a report of completed activity.[9]

The Spanish appointment controversy was raised in Parliament on 12 December 2018: Chris Williamson said the Initiative had taken credit for derailing the proposed appointment of Pedro Baños as Spain's national-security director. That is an allegation about the Initiative's claim of influence, not independent proof that its campaign determined the appointment.[4]

Leadership

Publicly documented parent-Institute leadership
Person Role
Chris Donnelly Co-director and trustee in the Institute’s published governance list; resigned as company director on 14 February 2020.[10][11]
Dan Lafayeedney Co-director and trustee in the published governance list; resigned as director and secretary on 14 February 2020.[10][11]

Controversies and responses

In December 2018 Emily Thornberry challenged the use of the Initiative's Twitter account to circulate attacks on Jeremy Corbyn and other politicians, pointing to social-media activity in the funding applications. Alan Duncan denied that FCO money financed the account's management or domestic political activity and said officials would seek a clearer division between domestic activity and overseas-funded work.[4][12]

In November 2019 The Ferret reported that the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator had found that the Institute for Statecraft's purposes were not entirely charitable, the Initiative did not provide public benefit in furtherance of its purposes, private benefit to trustees was not incidental, and trustees had breached duties of care and diligence, some seriously. The regulator also criticised oversight of the Twitter account. The Institute ended its involvement with the project and undertook governance changes. OSCR considered formal action unnecessary or disproportionate in light of those steps and said it would monitor the charity. The Institute acknowledged a need to improve governance and thanked OSCR for its conduct of the inquiry.[1]

The papers were published by people using the Anonymous name in 2018. The Institute and FCO described a hack and Russian amplification of stolen material. In Parliament Duncan said the attack could not be attributed with certainty to a specific source. Attribution of the release does not establish the authenticity of every document or the truth of every claim made by its publishers.[4][12]


Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 Billy Briggs, The Ferret, Scottish charity watchdog damns group that attacked integrity of politicians, 5 November 2019, accessed 8 November 2026.
  2. ↑ Integrity Initiative About, accessed 27 November 2018.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 Institute for Statecraft, Project Proposal Form: Integrity Initiative Phase II, 2018–19, co-funding and outputs sections; Integrity 2018/19 Quarterly Budget, summary totals; leaked document published by Anonymous in 2018. Bid values and targets are not proof of award, payment or implementation.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 UK Parliament, Institute for Statecraft: Integrity Initiative, 12 December 2018, accessed 8 November 2026.
  5. ↑ Alan Duncan, UK Parliament, Written answer 198811: Foreign and Commonwealth Office: Integrity Initiative, 10 December 2018, accessed 8 November 2026.
  6. ↑ Institute for Statecraft, Project Proposal Form: Integrity Initiative, 27 April 2017; Integrity budget FY2017–18; leaked document published by Anonymous in 2018. Bid values and targets are not proof of award, payment or implementation.
  7. ↑ Foreign and Commonwealth Office, Eastern Europe and Central Asia Directorate, Grant Agreement with the Institute for Statecraft for “INTEGRITY INITIATIVE Phase 2”, clauses 3–4 (grant funding period 1 April 2018 to 31 March 2019; maximum £1,961,000); leaked document published by Anonymous in 2018 (Integrity Initiative Part 4 scan). The figure matches the parliamentary answer already cited.
  8. ↑ Political Capital Kft, invoice DK/0000000006/2016 to “The Institute for Statecraft Integrity Initiative”, April 2016, for the study Comrades for Peace, Equality and Neutrality: pro-Russian far-left parties in Europe; leaked document published by Anonymous in 2018 (Integrity Initiative Part 4). A leaked invoice is not by itself proof that the study was published or used.
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 Institute for Statecraft, Progress report on establishing national clusters, 2018, country sections; leaked document published by Anonymous in 2018. Bid values and targets are not proof of award, payment or implementation.
  10. ↑ 10.0 10.1 Institute for Statecraft, Governance, archived 17 March 2016, accessed 8 November 2026.
  11. ↑ 11.0 11.1 Companies House, The Institute for Statecraft: officers, accessed 8 November 2026.
  12. ↑ 12.0 12.1 Damien Gayle, The Guardian, Foreign Office denies state funds went to Twitter account criticising Labour, 13 December 2018, accessed 8 November 2026.