The British Left and Zionism: History of a Divorce

From Powerbase
Revision as of 14:54, 19 November 2026 by Archive Research (talk | contribs) (New page: Paul Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism: History of a Divorce (Manchester University Press, 2012))
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

The British Left and Zionism: History of a Divorce is a 2012 book by Paul Kelemen, published by Manchester University Press. It is an archive-based history of how the British Labour Party, the communist movement and the new left shifted from support for Zionism and Israel to a more critical stance and, eventually, support for Palestinian national rights.[1]

Publication

The book was first published by Manchester University Press in Manchester and New York in 2012, distributed in the United States by Palgrave Macmillan. The paperback ISBN is 978 0 7190 8813 1; the hardcover ISBN is 978 0 7190 8812 4. The publisher describes the book as 240 pages; the printed text, bibliography and index run to page 225.[1][2]

An earlier version of Chapter 3 appeared as "British Communists and the Palestine Conflict, 1929–1948", Holy Land Studies, 5:2 (2006), pp. 131–153.[3]

Author

At the time of publication Kelemen was Lecturer in Sociology at the University of Manchester.[1] The university's sociology staff list records him as an Honorary Research Fellow.[4] He gave a talk on the book to the Modern History Group at the University of Sheffield on 28 February 2013.[5]

Argument

Kelemen's central question is not only why parts of the British left later broke with Zionism, but why there was a long alliance in the first place. He argues that after the Second World War the left, no less than the right, imagined a world of ethnically homogenous nation states, and that Israel was widely treated as atonement for the Holocaust, even though, in his account, the state was "borne through the expulsion of the Palestinians" and carried "a strand of the ideological legacy that the state's existence was meant to refute". In retrospect, he writes, "it is the left's previous and longstanding commitment to the Zionist project that stands out". That commitment, he argues, helped to popularise the Zionist cause and turned public support for Israel into a factor that successive British governments had to take into account.[6]

He treats Poale Zion as the main intermediary between the British and Israeli labour movements. The relationship, he says, "did not determine the British Labour Party's Middle East policy, whether in or out of power, but it gave that connection an ideological legitimacy and emotional charge among the party membership". Labour, in his view, supported Israel "both in the name of Britain's imperial policy and for its social democratic values" and became "the principal vector for popularising more widely an image of Israel as the beacon of progress in the Middle East".[7]

On the Labour side, the book traces a line from the party's August 1917 War Aims Memorandum — adopted two and a half months before the Balfour Declaration and committing Labour to a "Free State" in Palestine to which Jews might "return and work out their own salvation" — through conference statements in the 1920s and 1930s, the 1944 resolution that "the Arabs be encouraged to move out as the Jews move in", and the post-1948 defence of Israel as a social-democratic "beacon", to the erosion of that consensus after 1967 and a decisive conference shift in 1982 after Israel's invasion of Lebanon.[8] He presents Labour's early support as rooted in a "constructive" or "ethical" imperialism, a nonconformist Bible culture, and Poale Zion's claim that Jewish settlement was a socialist, not a colonial, project — a claim he argues was already contradicted by contemporary official reports on Histadrut exclusion of Arab labour and Jewish National Fund land policy.[9]

The Communist Party of Great Britain, in his account, was the main organised anti-Zionist force on the British left until 1947, when, following the Soviet Union, it rallied to partition and a Jewish state, "leaving the Palestinian cause with no effective protagonists in Britain".[1][10] A critical attitude to Israel and support for Palestinian nationalism, he argues, emerged on the new left after the 1967 war and Israel's occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, and only later moved into the Labour mainstream, especially around the 1982 Lebanon war. He does not carry the narrative in detail into the New Labour period, holding that by the late 1980s the political basis of the left's opposition to Israeli policy was already set.[11] A final chapter rejects the claim that post-1967 left criticism of Israel is explained by a "new anti-semitism".[12]

Contents

  • Introduction
  • 1. The Labour Party and the Zionist project
  • 2. Zionism and Anglo-Jewry
  • 3. British communists and Palestine
  • 4. Post-war social democracy and Israel
  • 5. The new left and the Palestinians
  • 6. A new anti-semitism?
  • Conclusion
  • Bibliography
  • Index[13]

Chapter 1 covers the 1917 War Aims Memorandum, Poale Zion "constructivism", Ramsay MacDonald's 1922 visit to Palestine, the Passfield White Paper and its retraction, Herbert Morrison's celebration of the kibbutz, Labour's response to the 1936–39 Arab revolt, and Hugh Dalton's 1944 "transfer" resolution. Chapter 2 treats Zionism's uneven hold on Anglo-Jewry and Poale Zion's post-war decline as a membership organisation, even as it continued to present itself as Labour's link to a "Jewish vote". Chapter 4 is the main post-1948 Labour chapter, including Ernest Bevin and Clement Attlee, Richard Crossman's Palestine Mission, Keep Left (Crossman, Michael Foot and Ian Mikardo), the 1948 war and the refugees, Sam Watson's 1949 Histadrut delegation, and a small pro-Arab group on the party's right that included Christopher Mayhew and George Brown. Chapter 5 covers 1967, the Labour Friends of Israel (nearly two-thirds of Labour MPs were members at the time, Kelemen writes), the Labour Middle East Council, Harold Wilson, the 1973 free vote described by David Watkins, and the 1982 conference resolutions after Sabra and Shatila, including Eric Heffer's resignation from LFI.[9][10][14]

Sources

The study draws on the Labour Party Archive at the People's History Museum, Manchester; the Levenberg Papers at the British Library of Political and Economic Science; The National Archives (especially FO 371 files on the 1948–50 refugee crisis, and earlier Colonial Office and MacDonald papers); the Andrew Faulds Papers at the London School of Economics; Mass Observation; conference reports (LPACR); The Jewish Chronicle; the Daily Herald; Tribune; and Hansard. Kelemen notes that only the first three of the 41 boxes of Levenberg Papers are listed.[15]

Reception

Ekaterina Kolpinskaya, reviewing the book in Political Studies Review, wrote that it "provides a historically accurate, informed overview of how the British Left shifted from support to criticism of Zionism in opposition to Israel's 'blood and soil' nationalism and the expansion of Israeli settlements in the Occupied Territories."[16] The same publisher's page also quotes her describing it as a "revelatory and investigative book".[1]

John McIlroy reviewed the book in Capital and Class under the title "British Labour and the challenge of Israel-Palestine".[17]

Miriam Scharf, reviewing Kelemen alongside Philip Mendes's Jews and the Left in International Socialism, wrote that Kelemen "aims to explain ... not so much the divorce of the left from Zionism but why there was a marriage in the first place", and called the book "meticulously well researched and well written". She noted that Mendes is "pro-Zionist and Kelemen is not", and that this difference shapes their post-1948 accounts.[18]

Tony Greenstein, in Weekly Worker, called it "the first comprehensive account of the history of the British left and Zionism" and "indispensable" for understanding Labour's adoption of Zionism from August 1917, while stating that the book "is written from an avowedly anti-Zionist perspective".[19]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 Manchester University Press, "The British left and Zionism", publisher's page for the paperback (ISBN 978 0 7190 8813 1), accessed 19 November 2026.
  2. ↑ Paul Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism: History of a Divorce (Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press, 2012), title page and copyright page (the title page uses the form The British left and Zionism: History of a divorce).
  3. ↑ Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism, p. vii.
  4. ↑ University of Manchester, Faculty of Humanities, "Sociology staff", accessed 19 November 2026.
  5. ↑ Matthew Kerry and Abdel Razzaq Takriti, "The Left and Zionism", History Matters, University of Sheffield, 18 March 2013, historymatters.sites.sheffield.ac.uk, accessed 19 November 2026.
  6. ↑ Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism, pp. 1–2.
  7. ↑ Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism, p. 9.
  8. ↑ Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism, pp. 11, 36, 133–139, 150–151, 171–174.
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism, pp. 11–37.
  10. ↑ 10.0 10.1 Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism, p. 111.
  11. ↑ Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism, pp. 2–3, 150–179, 203.
  12. ↑ Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism, pp. 3, 185–199.
  13. ↑ Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism, contents page.
  14. ↑ Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism, pp. 44–71, 111–143, 150–174.
  15. ↑ Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism, pp. vii, 10, and endnotes to chapters 1, 4 and 5.
  16. ↑ Ekaterina Kolpinskaya, review of Paul Kelemen, The British Left and Zionism: History of a Divorce, Political Studies Review, vol. 12, no. 3 (September 2014), p. 450, as quoted on the Manchester University Press paperback page, manchesteruniversitypress.co.uk/9780719088131, accessed 19 November 2026.
  17. ↑ John McIlroy, "British Labour and the challenge of Israel-Palestine", Capital and Class, vol. 37, no. 3 (October 2013), pp. 491–496, doi:10.1177/0309816813505282b. An accepted manuscript is listed in the Middlesex University research repository, repository.mdx.ac.uk/item/84vq6, accessed 19 November 2026. The full text of the review was not obtained for this page.
  18. ↑ Miriam Scharf, "The contested history of the left and Zionism", International Socialism, 10 October 2014, isj.org.uk/the-contested-history-of-the-left-and-zionism, accessed 19 November 2026.
  19. ↑ Tony Greenstein, "Israel and the 'new anti-Semitism'", Weekly Worker, 24 March 2019 (issue 1248), weeklyworker.co.uk/worker/1248/israel-and-the-new-anti-semitism, accessed 19 November 2026. A version also appeared on Greenstein's blog, 30 April 2019.