Secret Service Committee
British committee of ministers and, later, senior officials, set up by the War Cabinet in January 1919 to review and reorganise the intelligence services, which shaped the post-war structure of MI5, SIS, Special Branch and the Government Code and Cypher School
| Secret Service Committee
| |
|---|---|
| Logo | Lord Curzon, chairman of the Secret Service Committee from 1919. Source: George Grantham Bain Collection, Library of Congress, via Wikimedia Commons (public domain) |
| Type | Interdepartmental committee of the British government |
| Founded | January 1919[1] |
| Founder(s) | War Cabinet[1] |
| Location | London |
| Key people | Lord Curzon (chairman, 1919); Walter Long; Winston Churchill; John Anderson; Robert Vansittart; Maurice Hankey; Warren Fisher (chairman by 1939)[1][2][3] |
| Remarks | Reconstituted under officials in 1921; reconvened in 1925 and April 1931[2][4] |
The Secret Service Committee was a British government committee set up by the War Cabinet in January 1919 "to review the performance of the intelligence agencies and how best to co-ordinate their work". Chaired by Lord Curzon, it oversaw the reorganisation of the wartime intelligence services on a peacetime footing, recommended the creation of the Directorate of Intelligence under Basil Thomson and of a unified codebreaking agency, the Government Code and Cypher School, and, reconstituted as a committee of senior officials, was reconvened in 1921, 1925 and 1931 to cut costs and settle disputes between MI5, the Secret Intelligence Service (SIS) and Special Branch.[1][5][2] In the 1930s it consisted of three senior officials, the heads of the Foreign Office, Cabinet Office and Treasury, and had "at least the notional responsibility for overseeing the intelligence services".[2]
1919: post-war reorganisation
According to Christopher Andrew's authorised history of MI5, Curzon, then in charge of the Foreign Office while Arthur Balfour was at the Paris peace conference, chaired the committee; Walter Long and Winston Churchill also served on it, and all three "attached great importance to intelligence reports on the advance of the Red Menace". The committee met intermittently for two years. It rejected Thomson's proposal for a single civilian head of the whole intelligence community but approved Long's earlier proposal for a "Civil Secret Service" to monitor subversion, and its first report, in February 1919, recommended Thomson's appointment as head of a new Directorate of Intelligence under the Home Office, which he took up on 1 May 1919.[1]
The committee also recommended a unified peacetime codebreaking agency, merging the Army and Royal Navy codebreakers. Alastair Denniston of the Admiralty's Room 40 became its head, and the Government Code and Cypher School was formed on 1 November 1919.[5] John Ferris, the official historian of GCHQ, writes that agent and communications intelligence services were reorganised into MI6 and GC&CS under the control of the Permanent Under-Secretary of the Foreign Office, and that the Secret Service Committee, which included the Permanent Under-Secretary, the Cabinet Secretary and the permanent secretaries of the Home Office and the Treasury, "made major decisions about the structure of intelligence agencies".[6]
In 1921 a Secret Service Committee of senior officials chaired by Warren Fisher, Permanent Secretary to the Treasury, was instructed to make recommendations "for reducing expenditure and avoiding over-lapping". Its report, issued in July, concentrated on Thomson's Directorate of Intelligence, which it criticised for overspending, duplicating the work of other agencies and producing misleading reports. Thomson was dismissed and the Directorate of Intelligence disappeared. The committee was at first sceptical of the need to keep MI5 at all, but concluded that because of increasing espionage by several powers and the threat of Bolshevik subversion in the armed forces, MI5 should continue on a reduced scale with responsibility for counter-espionage and for counter-subversion in the army and navy.[2]
1925 and 1931
The committee was reconvened in 1925 and heard evidence from the heads of SIS and MI5. Hugh Sinclair, who had succeeded Mansfield Cumming as head of SIS, argued that the intelligence services should be under one head and responsible to the Foreign Office, and that it was "impossible to draw the line" between espionage and counter-espionage. Vernon Kell told the committee on 10 March 1925 that, because of his reduced resources, MI5 had no "agents" in the accepted sense but only informants; Sinclair said that this obliged SIS to run agents inside the United Kingdom as well as abroad.[2] In its report of 1 December 1925 the committee acknowledged the "organizational confusion" created by dividing responsibility for civil and military subversion between different agencies.[4]
The committee was revived in April 1931 to "discuss the difficulties that had arisen in the inter-relation between C's organisation and Scotland Yard", after Special Branch discovered that SIS was running Maxwell Knight and his agents against domestic communist targets. At its meeting on 22 June 1931 the Permanent Under-Secretary at the Home Office, Sir John Anderson, proposed that Special Branch's SS1 section and its responsibilities be transferred to Kell, leaving "only two organisations dealing with secret service work, C covering foreign countries, and MI5 the Empire". The proposal was accepted, and SIS was to confine its operations to at least three miles from British territory.[2]
1930s
In the 1930s the committee was composed of Robert Vansittart, Permanent Under-Secretary at the Foreign Office, Maurice Hankey, Cabinet Secretary from 1916 to 1938, and Warren Fisher, Permanent Secretary to the Treasury and head of the civil service from 1919 to 1939.[2] By 1939 Fisher chaired the committee; in January 1939 he agreed that Kell should eventually be succeeded by Jasper Harker, head of MI5's B Branch, as Kell had recommended.[3][7]
See also
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 Christopher Andrew, The Defence of the Realm: The Authorized History of MI5, London: Allen Lane, 2009, section A, chapter 3, "The First World War: Part 2 – The Rise of Counter-Subversion", citing the Report of the Secret Service Committee, February 1919, TNA CAB 127/356.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 Christopher Andrew, The Defence of the Realm: The Authorized History of MI5, London: Allen Lane, 2009, section B, introduction, "MI5 and its Staff – Survival and Revival".
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 Christopher Andrew, The Defence of the Realm: The Authorized History of MI5, London: Allen Lane, 2009, notes to section C, introduction, notes 85–86.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 Christopher Andrew, The Defence of the Realm: The Authorized History of MI5, London: Allen Lane, 2009, section B, chapter 1, "The Red Menace in the 1920s", citing the Report of the Secret Service Committee, 1 December 1925.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 Richard J. Aldrich, GCHQ: The Uncensored Story of Britain's Most Secret Intelligence Agency, London: William Collins, 2019 edition (first published 2010), chapter 1, "Schooldays", p. 15.
- ↑ John Ferris, Behind the Enigma: The Authorised History of GCHQ, Britain's Secret Cyber-Intelligence Agency, London: Bloomsbury, 2020, ISBN 9781526605467, chapter 3, "Whitehall's Black Chamber: British Cryptology and the Government Code & Cypher School, 1919–39".
- ↑ Christopher Andrew, The Defence of the Realm: The Authorized History of MI5, London: Allen Lane, 2009, section C, introduction, "The Security Service and its Wartime Staff: 'From Prison to Palace'".