Bus 300 Affair

From Powerbase
Revision as of 15:52, 18 November 2026 by Surveillance research (talk | contribs) (Create page: Bus 300 Affair, 1984 Shin Bet killings and cover-up (New York Times, JTA, Supreme Court of Israel))
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Israeli scandal over the killing in custody of two captured Palestinian hijackers of the No. 300 Tel Aviv–Ashkelon bus in April 1984 by members of the Shin Bet security service, the subsequent cover-up, and the 1986 presidential pardons of the Shin Bet head Avraham Shalom and three officials

Bus 300 Affair

Logo Bus 300 hijacker 1984 Alex Levac - Powerbase.jpg
Alex Levac's photograph of a captured hijacker being led away alive by security men after the storming of the bus, April 1984. The military censor initially banned publication of such photographs. Photograph: Alex Levac, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Type Political and security scandal ("the Shin Bet affair")[1]
Founded Night of 12–13 April 1984 (hijacking and killings)[2][3]
Location Gaza Strip; Israel
Key people Avraham Shalom (head of the Shin Bet); Meir Zorea (head of the 1984 inquiry); Moshe Arens (Defence Minister); Yitzhak Shamir (Prime Minister in 1984); Chaim Herzog (President, granted pardons); Yosef Harish (Attorney General); Reuven Hazak, Ehud Yatom[3][4][1]
Remarks Two of the four hijackers, Majdi and Subhi Abu Jumaa, were captured alive and later beaten to death; the other two, Jamal Kablan and Mohammed Barakeh, were killed in the assault on the bus. In 1986 the High Court upheld the presidential pardons of Shalom and three Shin Bet officials (Barzilai v. Government of Israel, HCJ 428/86).[3][4][2]

The Bus 300 Affair, also called the Shin Bet affair, was an Israeli political and security scandal arising from the killing of two captured Palestinian hijackers of a bus, the No. 300 from Tel Aviv to Ashkelon, in April 1984, and from the subsequent cover-up by officials of the Shin Bet (General Security Service).[3][1][2] A Defence Ministry inquiry found in May 1984 that two of the hijackers had been captured alive and then beaten to death by security personnel. In 1986 President Chaim Herzog pardoned the head of the Shin Bet, Avraham Shalom, and three officials before any trial, and the High Court of Justice upheld the pardons.[3][4]

The hijacking

According to The New York Times, the hijacking began on the evening of 12 April 1984, when four Palestinians seized the bus on a regular run from Tel Aviv to Ashkelon and forced the driver into the Gaza Strip, where they threatened to blow it up with its 35 passengers unless 500 Palestinian prisoners were released.[3] After an all-night stand-off, Israeli troops stormed the bus just before dawn on 13 April, killing an Israeli woman passenger and wounding seven others.[3] The army's public statements, that two of the hijackers had "died on the way to the hospital", implied that all four had been killed in the assault.[3]

Censorship and the Zorea inquiry

The authorities initially tried to suppress the story by having the military censor ban publication of news photographs showing two of the hijackers being led away from the bus, and by barring news articles on the subject.[3] After The New York Times published details despite the censorship, the Defence Minister, Moshe Arens, appointed a commission of inquiry headed by the reserve general Meir Zorea.[3]

On 28 May 1984 the Defence Ministry announced that the commission had found that only two of the hijackers, Jamal Kablan and Mohammed Barakeh, died "at an early stage of the strike force's assault on the bus, as a result of the attacking force's gunfire", while the other two, the cousins Majdi and Subhi Abu Jumaa, were captured alive and later beaten, their skulls fractured with blunt objects. The commission found that no order had been given by superiors to kill them, and could not determine who had delivered the fatal blows; a criminal investigation was ordered.[3] Arens said he condemned "most forcefully" behaviour "in clear contradistinction to the basic rules and norms incumbent on all and especially on the security forces".[3] The following day the censor lifted the ban on the photographs; the newspaper Hadashot published a picture of Majdi Abu Jumaa being led away by two security men, "the first piece of evidence that not all four hijackers had been killed during an assault on the bus".[5] A Jewish Telegraphic Agency summary of the report recorded that the two captured men "were beaten to death by security personnel while undergoing interrogation".[6]

Pardons and the High Court

In 1986 President Chaim Herzog pardoned Avraham Shalom and three Shin Bet officials in respect of all offences connected with the incident, although none had been tried.[4][2] Petitioners, including private lawyers and the Citizens' Rights Movement, asked the High Court of Justice to invalidate the pardons. In August 1986 the court upheld them; Justices Meir Shamgar and Miriam Ben-Porat ruled that the President could grant a pardon at any stage of a case, even before trial, while Justice Aharon Barak dissented, holding that such authority conflicted with democratic principles. The court accepted the Attorney General's statement that the police would investigate the affair.[4] The judgment, Barzilai v. Government of Israel (HCJ 428/86), concerned pardons for offences connected with "the incident known as 'bus no. 300'", occurring "on the night between 12 April and 13 April 1984", whether committed on the day or subsequently in connection with it.[2]

The Harish report and political responsibility

In December 1986 a Justice Ministry panel of lawyers headed by the Attorney General, Yosef Harish, found that Yitzhak Shamir, Prime Minister at the time of the incident, had not ordered the killings and was not implicated in attempts to cover them up. The report castigated Shalom, who had claimed to have acted on orders from a higher authority.[1] Zorea criticised the report for failing to place any blame on the political establishment, saying: "Everyone was happy, though something disgusting had been done". He said his own committee had been misled by Shalom's testimony, and that "in the end nobody was found guilty or punished because of the Presidential pardon". The JTA reported that Shalom resigned only after the scandal broke in 1986.[1]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 Jewish Telegraphic Agency, "Shamir Absolved of Any Wrongdoing in 1984 Arab Bus Hijackers' Killings", JTA Daily News Bulletin, 30 December 1986, accessed 18 November 2026.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 Supreme Court of Israel sitting as the High Court of Justice, "Barzilai v. Government of Israel", HCJ 428/86, English translation, Versa: Opinions of the Supreme Court of Israel, Cardozo Law School, 1986, accessed 18 November 2026.
  3. ↑ 3.00 3.01 3.02 3.03 3.04 3.05 3.06 3.07 3.08 3.09 3.10 3.11 David K. Shipler, "Arabs Were Slain by Israeli Guards, Inquiry Concludes", The New York Times, 29 May 1984, pp. A1, A8; transcription in the Covering Palestine archive, CP-1984-054, accessed 18 November 2026.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 Jewish Telegraphic Agency, "High Court Upholds Presidential Pardons of Shin Bet Officials", JTA Daily News Bulletin, 7 August 1986, accessed 18 November 2026.
  5. ↑ The New York Times, "Israeli Censor Ends the Ban On Pictures of 2 Slain Arabs", 30 May 1984; transcription in the Covering Palestine archive, CP-1984-045, accessed 18 November 2026.
  6. ↑ Jewish Telegraphic Agency, "News Brief", JTA Daily News Bulletin, 27 September 1984, accessed 18 November 2026.