Difference between revisions of "Quintin Hogg (born 1907)"
(New page: Quintin Hogg, Lord Hailsham (1907–2001), Lord Chancellor; includes his February 1980 minute to Margaret Thatcher on the Arab/Israel initiative) |
(Added image of page 2 of Lord Hailsham's minute of 14 February 1980 (PREM 19/295)) |
||
| Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
As Lord Chancellor in [[Margaret Thatcher]]'s first government he was a member of the Cabinet's Defence and Overseas Policy Committee. In a minute to Thatcher dated 14 February 1980 he opposed a proposal by the Foreign Secretary, [[Peter Carrington|Lord Carrington]], for a British and European initiative on Palestinian rights. He warned that British "Jewish opinion" was "fanatically involved in the fate of Israel" and would affect seats in Manchester, Leeds and North London. Thatcher wrote on the file: "I agree with the Lord Chancellor."<ref name="HailshamMinute1980">Lord Hailsham, minute to the Prime Minister, "Arab/Israel", 14 February 1980, with covering note and Margaret Thatcher's annotation, The National Archives, PREM 19/295 f89, [https://www.margaretthatcher.org/document/120544 reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation], accessed 17 November 2026.</ref> In 1975 he had told Thatcher that he tended "to take the Israel point of view in the Middle East Affairs".<ref name="Hailsham1975">Lord Hailsham, letter to Margaret Thatcher, 17 February 1975, with Thatcher's handwritten reply, [https://www.margaretthatcher.org/document/854CB7F0EDC247B799CEC18C5A986210.pdf facsimile] reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.</ref> | As Lord Chancellor in [[Margaret Thatcher]]'s first government he was a member of the Cabinet's Defence and Overseas Policy Committee. In a minute to Thatcher dated 14 February 1980 he opposed a proposal by the Foreign Secretary, [[Peter Carrington|Lord Carrington]], for a British and European initiative on Palestinian rights. He warned that British "Jewish opinion" was "fanatically involved in the fate of Israel" and would affect seats in Manchester, Leeds and North London. Thatcher wrote on the file: "I agree with the Lord Chancellor."<ref name="HailshamMinute1980">Lord Hailsham, minute to the Prime Minister, "Arab/Israel", 14 February 1980, with covering note and Margaret Thatcher's annotation, The National Archives, PREM 19/295 f89, [https://www.margaretthatcher.org/document/120544 reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation], accessed 17 November 2026.</ref> In 1975 he had told Thatcher that he tended "to take the Israel point of view in the Middle East Affairs".<ref name="Hailsham1975">Lord Hailsham, letter to Margaret Thatcher, 17 February 1975, with Thatcher's handwritten reply, [https://www.margaretthatcher.org/document/854CB7F0EDC247B799CEC18C5A986210.pdf facsimile] reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[File:Hailsham minute to Thatcher 14 February 1980 p2 (PREM 19-295).jpg|thumb|right|250px|Second page of Lord Hailsham's minute of 14 February 1980 to Margaret Thatcher, including the paragraph on "Jewish opinion" (The National Archives, PREM 19/295)]] | ||
== Early life and career == | == Early life and career == | ||
Revision as of 10:49, 17 November 2026
British Conservative politician and Lord Chancellor (1907–2001)
| Quintin Hogg, Lord Hailsham
| |
|---|---|
| Image | Lord Hailsham in 1986 |
| Born | 9 October 1907 |
| Died | 12 October 2001 |
| Nationality | British |
| Occupation | Barrister; Conservative Party politician |
| Known for | Lord Chancellor, 1970–74 and 1979–87 |
| Parents | Douglas Hogg, 1st Viscount Hailsham; Elizabeth Marjoribanks (née Brown) |
| Spouse(s) | Mary Martin (m. 1944; died 1978); Deirdre Shannon (m. 1986; died 1998) |
| Children | Two sons and three daughters, including Douglas Hogg |
| Education | Eton College; Christ Church, Oxford |
Quintin McGarel Hogg (9 October 1907 – 12 October 2001), known from 1950 to 1963 as the 2nd Viscount Hailsham and from 1970 as Lord Hailsham of St Marylebone, was a British barrister and Conservative Party politician who served twice as Lord Chancellor, from 1970 to 1974 and from 1979 to 1987.[1][2] He sat in the House of Commons for Oxford (1938–50) and St Marylebone (1963–70), held a series of Cabinet posts under Anthony Eden and Harold Macmillan, and was a contender to succeed Macmillan as party leader in 1963.[1][2]
As Lord Chancellor in Margaret Thatcher's first government he was a member of the Cabinet's Defence and Overseas Policy Committee. In a minute to Thatcher dated 14 February 1980 he opposed a proposal by the Foreign Secretary, Lord Carrington, for a British and European initiative on Palestinian rights. He warned that British "Jewish opinion" was "fanatically involved in the fate of Israel" and would affect seats in Manchester, Leeds and North London. Thatcher wrote on the file: "I agree with the Lord Chancellor."[3] In 1975 he had told Thatcher that he tended "to take the Israel point of view in the Middle East Affairs".[4]
Early life and career
Hogg was the eldest son of Sir Douglas Hogg, later the 1st Viscount Hailsham and himself a Lord Chancellor, and Elizabeth Marjoribanks (née Brown), whom The Guardian's obituary describes as the daughter of a judge from Nashville, Tennessee.[1][2] He was educated at Eton College and Christ Church, Oxford, where he was president of the Oxford Union. He was a fellow of All Souls College, Oxford from 1931 to 1938 and again after 1961, was called to the bar in 1932 and became a QC in 1953.[2]
He entered the Commons at the Oxford by-election of 27 October 1938.[1] According to The Guardian, he stood as a supporter of Neville Chamberlain against A. D. Lindsay, the Master of Balliol, who ran as an all-party candidate opposed to the Munich Agreement; Hogg later called Munich "an absolutely legitimate step in the circumstances of 1938".[2] Commissioned into the Rifle Brigade in September 1939, he was wounded in the Western Desert in 1941 and served in Egypt, Palestine and Syria. Back in the Commons he was a leading figure in the Tory Reform Group, was briefly a junior minister in the 1945 caretaker government, and in 1947 published The Case for Conservatism.[2]
His first spell in the Commons ended on 16 August 1950, when he succeeded his father in the peerage as the 2nd Viscount Hailsham.[1]
Ministerial career
Hailsham held the following offices, as listed by the History of Parliament Trust:[1]
| Office | Dates |
|---|---|
| First Lord of the Admiralty | 1956–1957 |
| Minister of Education | 1957 |
| Lord President of the Council | 1957–1960 |
| Lord Privy Seal | 1959–1960 |
| Minister for Science | 1960–1964 |
| Lord Chancellor | 1970–1974 |
| Lord Chancellor | 1979–1987 |
The sources differ on his time as Lord President: the History of Parliament Trust gives 1957–1960, while The Guardian's obituary says he held the post, "with a short break, from 1957–1964".[1][2]
According to The Guardian, Anthony Eden made him First Lord of the Admiralty in 1956, and he defended Eden's Suez policy. As chairman of the Conservative Party from 1957 to 1959 he was "a central figure" in the party's third successive election victory, and in 1963 he oversaw the final negotiations on the nuclear test ban treaty in Moscow.[2]
Harold Macmillan privately favoured Hailsham as his successor in 1963, and Hailsham announced that he would renounce his peerage in order to return to the Commons. He became the first Conservative to do so, but Sir Alec Douglas-Home became leader instead.[2] Hogg disclaimed the viscountcy in November 1963 and won St Marylebone at a by-election on 5 December 1963. He held the seat until the 1970 general election, when he was made a life peer as Baron Hailsham of St Marylebone.[1]
Edward Heath appointed him Lord Chancellor in 1970, and Margaret Thatcher reappointed him in 1979. His two terms as Lord Chancellor, from June 1970 to March 1974 and from May 1979 to June 1987, made him, according to The Guardian, the longest-serving Lord Chancellor of the 20th century.[2] In The Dilemma of Democracy (1978) he set out his doctrine of "elective dictatorship".[2]
Conservative Friends of Israel, 1975
On 17 February 1975 Hailsham sent Margaret Thatcher a letter he had received from Michael Fidler inviting him to join Conservative Friends of Israel. He wrote:[4]
- "As you know, I tend to take the Israel point of view in the Middle East Affairs but I would not wish to join anything which would embarrass you or our spokesman on Foreign Affairs. Could you kindly give me guidance?"
Thatcher's handwritten reply on the letter, received on Friday 21 February, said that she had joined "before I became leader" and that it was "causing me problems". She advised him to keep out, warning that if too many of them joined "we shall have 'Arab' problems".[4]
The "Arab/Israel" minute, February 1980
Background
On 22 January 1980 the Cabinet's Defence and Overseas Policy Committee (OD) asked the Foreign Secretary, Lord Carrington, for a paper on "possible British moves in relation to the Arab/Israel conflict". In a minute to Margaret Thatcher of 13 February, later circulated to the committee as OD(80) 13, Carrington argued that the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan had created "a unique opportunity" to work with the Islamic and non-aligned countries. The "main obstacle", he wrote, was their opposition to US policy on the conflict, and in particular "Israel's continuing presence in the territories occupied in 1967". He proposed that Britain and its European partners, subject to an understanding with the United States, bring forward a new UN Security Council resolution recognising the rights of the Palestinian people.[5][6]
The minute
Hailsham replied the next day in a minute headed "Arab/Israel", copied to the other members of OD and to Sir Robert Armstrong.[3] He said he "very largely" shared Carrington's views on using the Afghanistan situation to improve Arab–Western relations, but did "not altogether share his optimism on the prospects of his initiative, unless, of course we are prepared to sacrifice things which are too important morally, and too valuable in our interest to sacrifice." He based his view on "some knowledge of the physical characteristics of the country, and some knowledge of the mentality of Arab and Jew".[3]
The minute argued that Israel had defeated "a succession of Arab conspiracies in 1948, 1956, and 1967" "without assistance from the UN but with US aid and her own heroism". It said that before 1967 Israel's boundaries had been "virtually untenable militarily", while since then it had "enjoyed reasonably viable military frontiers consisting of the Judean hills (and the no less important frontier heights on the Syrian border)". Apart from Egypt, Hailsham wrote, none of the Arab states had shown "firm signs" of accepting Israel's right to exist, and he doubted that "world wide Jewish opinion" would accept a return of Jerusalem to "its former divided status".[3]
Paragraph 6 dealt with British politics:[3]
- "We should not underestimate the importance of Jewish opinion here. It is fanatically involved in the fate of Israel. Even non-observant or non Zionist Jews take this stance. I would not have cared even to fight St. Marylebone as a Conservative candidate in the face of Jewish hostility on this issue. Manchester, Leeds, and the whole of North London would be profoundly affected."
He ended: "If there be a reasonable chance of success without losing our honour yet again over the Balfour declaration; go ahead. But have we not enough on our plate just now not to consider leaving this hot potato alone?"[3]
Thatcher's response
The minute reached Downing Street on 15 February 1980. A handwritten covering note from a Downing Street official, dated 15 February, told Thatcher that the Lord Chancellor "makes some cogent points" but that a European initiative would aim to secure acknowledgement of Israel's right to exist from the Palestine Liberation Organisation and the Arab states. The note said it did not see that "losing our honour" arose, and added: "There may indeed be a hostile reaction in the Jewish community but that is a different kind of problem." Beneath it Thatcher wrote: "I agree with the Lord Chancellor. MT."[3]
In his briefing for the OD meeting, dated 20 February 1980, Sir Robert Armstrong noted that Hailsham doubted "whether the chances of success of the proposed initiative really justify the certain political difficulties it will arouse". He suggested that Thatcher ask Hailsham "to speak to his minute". Among the questions he proposed for discussion was "How will British and American Jewry regard the proposed new initiative?", to which his answer was "Almost certainly with the same lack of enthusiasm as the Israelis. The Lord Chancellor's minute stresses the importance and strength of British Jewish opinion."[7]
Outcome
The Security Council plan was dropped. By June 1980 Carrington was telling Thatcher that President Jimmy Carter and Edmund Muskie had made clear they would be "very unhappy about any recourse by their friends to the Security Council and, indeed, would be obliged to use the veto", and that the Foreign Office "had, in any case, been reaching the conclusion that this was not the path to follow". The initiative became instead a statement by the nine members of the European Economic Community, the Venice Declaration of 13 June 1980.[8]
Release
The minute was released at The National Archives on 30 December 2010.[9] The Jewish Chronicle quoted it the same day, noting that Thatcher was then MP for Finchley and Golders Green.[10] In Commentary, Rick Richman read the minute as an argument for defensible borders for Israel. He suggested that Thatcher might have been influenced by Hailsham's "immense stature", his reference to British honour, or "his point about Jewish opinion".[11]
Later life
After leaving office in 1987, Hailsham opposed his successor Lord Mackay's reforms in the Courts and Legal Services Bill. He sided with the judiciary in its 1996 dispute with the Home Secretary, Michael Howard, over sentencing powers. The Guardian records that "he also opposed the Conservative government's legislation to try war criminals 50 years after the events".[2] His autobiography, A Sparrow's Flight, appeared in 1990.[2]
His first marriage, in 1931, ended in divorce. In 1944 he married Mary Martin, who was killed in a riding accident in 1978; they had two sons and three daughters. In 1986 he married Deirdre Shannon, who died in 1998. His elder son, Douglas Hogg, became a QC and, in The Guardian's words, "a minister in the last Conservative government". Hailsham died on 12 October 2001, aged 94.[2][1]
See also
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 History of Parliament Trust, Hogg, Mr Quintin McGarel Members after 1832, accessed 17 November 2026.
- ↑ 2.00 2.01 2.02 2.03 2.04 2.05 2.06 2.07 2.08 2.09 2.10 2.11 2.12 2.13 Louis Blom-Cooper, Lord Hailsham of St Marylebone The Guardian, 15 October 2001, accessed 17 November 2026.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 Lord Hailsham, minute to the Prime Minister, "Arab/Israel", 14 February 1980, with covering note and Margaret Thatcher's annotation, The National Archives, PREM 19/295 f89, reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 Lord Hailsham, letter to Margaret Thatcher, 17 February 1975, with Thatcher's handwritten reply, facsimile reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
- ↑ Lord Carrington, minute to the Prime Minister, "Arab/Israel", PM/80/11, 13 February 1980, The National Archives, PREM 19/295 f94, reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
- ↑ Defence and Overseas Policy Committee, "The Arab/Israel Dispute: Memorandum by the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs", OD(80) 13, 15 February 1980, facsimile reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
- ↑ Sir Robert Armstrong, briefing for the Prime Minister, "Arab/Israel (OD(80) 13)", ref. A01478, 20 February 1980, The National Archives, PREM 19/295 f82, reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
- ↑ Lord Carrington, minute to the Prime Minister, "Arab/Israel", 6 June 1980, The National Archives, PREM 19/296 f174, reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
- ↑ Margaret Thatcher Foundation, PREM 19/295 Middle East (Situation in the Middle East) (Part 2), accessed 17 November 2026.
- ↑ Marcus Dysch, The clashes that divided Thatcher and Israel The Jewish Chronicle, 30 December 2010, accessed 17 November 2026.
- ↑ Rick Richman, Margaret Thatcher and Defensible Borders Commentary, 3 January 2011, accessed 17 November 2026.