Venice Declaration

From Powerbase
Jump to navigation Jump to search

1980 statement by the nine EEC states on the Arab–Israeli conflict

Venice Declaration

Venice European Council 1980 Carrington Thatcher (EC Audiovisual P-001979).jpg
Lord Carrington and Margaret Thatcher with other leaders at the Venice European Council, June 1980
Type Declaration of the European Council
Date 13 June 1980
Location Venice (San Giorgio Island), Italy
Participants Heads of government and foreign ministers of the nine member states of the European Economic Community
Outcome Called for Palestinian self-determination, for the PLO to be "associated with the negotiations", and for an end to Israel's occupation of the territories taken in 1967; declared Israeli settlements illegal under international law

The Venice Declaration was a statement on the Middle East issued on 13 June 1980 by the heads of government and foreign ministers of the nine member states of the European Economic Community (EEC), meeting as the European Council in Venice.[1] It recognised "the right to existence and to security of all the states in the region, including Israel", and said the Palestinian people must be placed in a position "to exercise fully its right to self-determination". It said the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO) "will have to be associated with the negotiations", and that Israeli settlements in "the occupied Arab territories" were "illegal under international law".[1]

Downing Street files released in December 2010 show that the declaration grew out of a proposal by the Foreign Secretary, Lord Carrington, for a new UN Security Council resolution. The Lord Chancellor, Lord Hailsham, opposed the proposal partly because of the strength of British "Jewish opinion", and Margaret Thatcher noted her agreement with him. The Security Council plan was dropped after the United States signalled that it would veto it.[2][3] The Israeli Cabinet said that any free person in Europe would see in the declaration "a Munich-like surrender".[4] Writing in the Jewish Chronicle in 2012, Azriel Bermant said that Israel's ambassador in London, Shlomo Argov, urged a public campaign against it that included "the mobilisation of the Jewish community".[5]

Background: the British initiative

Carrington's proposal

On 22 January 1980 the Cabinet's Defence and Overseas Policy Committee (OD) asked Lord Carrington for a paper on "possible British moves in relation to the Arab/Israel conflict". His minute of 13 February to Margaret Thatcher, circulated to the committee two days later as OD(80) 13, argued that the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan had created "a unique opportunity for the West to counter Soviet influence in alliance with the countries of the Third World". The "main obstacle", he wrote, was Islamic opposition to US policy and in particular "Israel's continuing presence in the territories occupied in 1967, with the exception of Sinai, coupled with her settlement of those territories and intervention in Lebanon, policies made possible by American military and financial support". He proposed that Britain and its partners in the Nine should, subject to an understanding with the United States, bring forward a new Security Council resolution recognising the rights of the Palestinian people, "including their right to a homeland".[6][7]

Hailsham's objection

On 14 February the Lord Chancellor, Lord Hailsham, replied that he did "not altogether share his optimism on the prospects of his initiative". He stressed the military value to Israel of "the Judean hills" and "the no less important frontier heights on the Syrian border". He also warned:[2]

"We should not underestimate the importance of Jewish opinion here. It is fanatically involved in the fate of Israel. Even non-observant or non Zionist Jews take this stance. I would not have cared even to fight St. Marylebone as a Conservative candidate in the face of Jewish hostility on this issue. Manchester, Leeds, and the whole of North London would be profoundly affected."

A covering note from a Downing Street official told Thatcher that "there may indeed be a hostile reaction in the Jewish community but that is a different kind of problem". Thatcher wrote beneath it: "I agree with the Lord Chancellor. MT."[2]

In his briefing for the OD discussion, dated 20 February 1980, Sir Robert Armstrong asked how "British and American Jewry" would regard the initiative. His answer was: "Almost certainly with the same lack of enthusiasm as the Israelis." He added that "in a Presidential election year Jewish-American opinion and support is going to be treated with great care by the United States Administration", although "President Carter made it clear to you in Washington that he was not opposed to a European rapprochement with the PLO".[8]

From resolution to declaration

By 6 June 1980 Carrington was telling Thatcher that President Jimmy Carter and Edmund Muskie had made it clear they would be "very unhappy about any recourse by their friends to the Security Council and, indeed, would be obliged to use the veto". He added: "We had, in any case, been reaching the conclusion that this was not the path to follow." Officials of the Nine had instead agreed that the European Council should issue a statement. Carrington saw two points in it that "might be construed as a move forward": "the endorsement of Palestinian self-determination, always within the framework of a negotiated settlement, and acknowledgement that the PLO among others, must be involved in negotiations".[3]

The draft statement attached to his minute contained bracketed alternative wordings still under negotiation. One bracketed passage said self-determination "involves the establishment of a homeland for the Palestinian people (organised by itself and, if it so desires, a Palestinian state on the territories which Israel should evacuate in Palestine)". This wording does not appear in the declaration as issued.[3][1]

On 10 June Carrington told the US ambassador, Kingman Brewster, that there was "no disposition to think in terms of a new Security Council resolution". All that was envisaged was "a statement dealing in an even-handed way with the right of Israel to exist within secure and recognised frontiers and the right of the Palestinians to self-determination", followed by soundings of all the parties "including the PLO". He did "not however envisage any British involvement, at any rate at ministerial level, in talks with the PLO". In Carrington's account, Brewster said that both Carter and Muskie had been obliged "to look partly towards the US domestic audience", and that "Mr Begin would like nothing better than to make support for Israel a major issue in the Presidential election campaign".[9]

Text

The declaration has eleven paragraphs.[1] The British delegation in Venice telegraphed the text to the Foreign Office on 13 June.[10] Its central passages read:[1]

  • Paragraph 4: "the time has come to promote the recognition and implementation of the two principles universally accepted by the international community: the right to existence and to security of all the states in the region, including Israel, and justice for all the peoples, which implies the recognition of the legitimate rights of the Palestinian people."
  • Paragraph 6: "A just solution must finally be found to the Palestinian problem, which is not simply one of refugees. The Palestinian people, which is conscious of existing as such, must be placed in a position, by an appropriate process defined within the framework of the comprehensive peace settlement, to exercise fully its right to self-determination."
  • Paragraph 7: the principles "apply to all the parties concerned, and thus to the Palestinian people, and to the PLO, which will have to be associated with the negotiations." The text telegraphed by the British delegation instead says the principles "are binding on all the parties concerned".[10]
  • Paragraph 8: the Nine "will not accept any unilateral initiative designed to change the status of Jerusalem".
  • Paragraph 9: "The nine stress the need for Israel to put an end to the territorial occupation which it has maintained since the conflict of 1967, as it has done for part of Sinai. They are deeply convinced that the Israeli settlements constitute a serious obstacle to the peace process in the Middle East. The nine consider that these settlements, as well as modifications in population and property in the occupied Arab territories, are illegal under international law."
  • Paragraph 11: the Nine would "make the necessary contacts with all the parties concerned" to determine "the form which such an initiative on their part could take".

Reactions

Israeli government

The Israeli Cabinet's statement, telegraphed to London by the British Embassy in Tel Aviv on 16 June, opened: "Nothing will remain from the Venice resolution but its bitter memory." It compared the PLO's aims to Mein Kampf and the European offer of guarantees to the guarantee given to Czechoslovakia in 1938. It said Jerusalem was "not subject to any division" and asserted a "right to settle and live in Eretz Yisrael". It concluded that "any free person in Europe" examining the document "would see in it a Munich-like surrender ... to tyrannic extortion".[4]

The Israeli Prime Minister, Menachem Begin, wrote to Thatcher on 17 June that "the Resolution hurt us deeply" and that "some aspects" of it were "impossible for us to accept". He cited the resolution of a congress of Fatah in Damascus on the eve of the meeting, and asked whether anyone "since the days of Hitler and Goebbels, Goering, Rosenberg and Streicher" had declared their aims more plainly.[11] According to Bermant, Thatcher decided she would "prefer not to write further to Mr Begin at present".[5]

House of Commons

Thatcher reported on the summit to the Commons on 16 June 1980. She said the declaration restated "the right of all the States in the region, including Israel, to existence and security; and justice for all the peoples". The Leader of the Opposition, James Callaghan, said that all the statement had done was "to encourage Mr. Begin in his unwise and illegal policy on the settlements, to give a boost to the PLO, which said that it would destroy Israel, and to embarrass the United States in its efforts". He called the reference to self-determination "a change of British policy" that risked "creating another powder keg in the Middle East". He also said that "Europe's motives are suspect as long as it is so concerned about oil".[12] Thatcher replied that the 1977 European Council declaration, which Callaghan had signed, already referred to "the need for a homeland for the Palestinian people", and that "if one people expects to exist behind secure boundaries it cannot deny that right to another people".[12]

Israeli embassy in London

Israel's ambassador in London, Shlomo Argov, also attacked the declaration in public, in the pages of the Jewish Chronicle. At a briefing for British journalists on the eve of the summit, he said that if the leaders of the EEC launched a campaign for general endorsement of self-determination for the Palestinians and for the participation of the Palestine Liberation Organisation in negotiations, "Israel would find such a diplomatic initiative totally unacceptable". Israel would "not be amenable to any European diplomatic effort which is based on support for the PLO and for the principle of Palestinian self-determination", and on this issue there was "the widest consensus of Israeli political opinion".[13]

A week after the summit, Argov told Joseph Finklestone of the Jewish Chronicle that the EEC had dealt a severe blow to the prospects of peace in the region. He said: "The European Economic Community is, perhaps, the least qualified to express itself in the manner in which it did on Middle East peace and on Israel's security, considering its record since 1973." Since then, he said, the policies of the Nine had been guided "first and foremost by the self-interest of the Nine", and "the need to placate and appease Arab oil suppliers and customers has been a paramount consideration". He called the endorsement of self-determination "nothing less than a code word for Palestinian statehood". He also said that, after the Fatah meeting in Damascus, the reference to the PLO's involvement in the peace process was "a travesty of the idea of peace and peace-making".[14]

In a speech at the Institute of Jewish Affairs, reported on 4 July, Argov summed up the European initiative as "Israel for oil". The Europeans, he said, had "made it clear that their one and only motivation was that of short-term self-interest". He added that the statement had been "appropriately proclaimed in Venice – a classic scene for the enactment of centuries-old European-Jewish tensions and the origin of the ghetto".[15]

On 11 July the Jewish Chronicle published a feature in which, in the paper's words, Argov "spells out the dangers to peace in the Middle East following the EEC summit in Venice". He wrote that there was "no better demonstration of Europe's deference to the Arab oil producers than in the present European attempt to establish a link between the situation in the Gulf area and the Arab-Israeli peace process". The "most telling evidence of Europe's increasingly unrealistic position on the Arab-Israel problem", he wrote, had been "its reaction to the Camp David agreements". He singled out Britain's former Prime Minister, James Callaghan, as foremost among those "who wisely gave Camp David their warm and generous support".[16]

Lobbying

Before the summit, on 9 June 1980, Greville Janner wrote to Thatcher in a letter "signed also by other officers of the Board of Deputies", raising the Fatah congress document. In her reply of 30 June, Thatcher called the declaration "a balanced statement" and said Britain was "absolutely committed" to Israel's security. She described the Fatah document's calls for "the liquidation of the 'Zionist entity'" as "quite unacceptable to us", while insisting that "the PLO has the support of many Palestinians" and "cannot be ignored if a settlement is to endure". There was "no question of Britain or the Nine giving any kind of official recognition to the PLO in present circumstances". She drew attention to "the need for Israel to put an end to the territorial occupation which it has maintained since 1967 ... and to halt the establishment of settlements".[17]

Writing in the Jewish Chronicle in 2012, Azriel Bermant said that "Israel's diplomats sought to mobilise the local Jewish community and Israel's supporters in a bid to neutralise the impact of the Venice Declaration". He quoted a cable from Ambassador Shlomo Argov to the Israeli Foreign Ministry:[5]

"We should not be afraid of making noise – it will embarrass the British more than it will embarrass us… It would be easier and more convenient to limit the campaign to the diplomatic sphere. It would be a lot more complicated and arduous to conduct a public campaign but this is the only sphere where we have room for manoeuvre and action, including the need for the mobilisation of the Jewish community."

Bermant does not give the cable's date or archival reference. He wrote that Argov "viewed Anglo-Jewry as an asset to be employed to counter policies that were detrimental to Israel". He also said that Argov accused Europe of betraying Israel in return for Arab oil, and was rebuked by Carrington for "objectionable emotive innuendo". According to Bermant, Carrington told Douglas Hurd of "being savaged by Israelis" and was heckled while addressing a Jewish audience in London, while Thatcher herself "was rarely criticised by the local community". Bermant also wrote that "British Jewry was far from united" in supporting the Begin government, and that the government heard "dissenting voices within Anglo-Jewry, including the Board of Deputies".[5]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 European Council, Venice Declaration, June 13, 1980 European External Action Service (archived documents), accessed 17 November 2026.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 Lord Hailsham, minute to the Prime Minister, "Arab/Israel", 14 February 1980, with covering note and Margaret Thatcher's annotation, The National Archives, PREM 19/295 f89, reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 Lord Carrington, minute to the Prime Minister, "Arab/Israel", 6 June 1980, with attached unofficial translation of a draft statement of the Nine, The National Archives, PREM 19/296 f174, reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 British Embassy Tel Aviv, telegram no. 238 to the Foreign and Commonwealth Office, "Middle East", 16 June 1980, text of Israeli Cabinet statement, The National Archives, PREM 19/296 f80, reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 Azriel Bermant, When Thatcher turned against Israel The Jewish Chronicle, 5 October 2012, p. 32 (The JC Essay), accessed 17 November 2026; also online, accessed 17 November 2026.
  6. ↑ Lord Carrington, minute to the Prime Minister, "Arab/Israel", PM/80/11, 13 February 1980, The National Archives, PREM 19/295 f94, reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
  7. ↑ Defence and Overseas Policy Committee, "The Arab/Israel Dispute: Memorandum by the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs", OD(80) 13, 15 February 1980, facsimile reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
  8. ↑ Sir Robert Armstrong, briefing for the Prime Minister, "Arab/Israel (OD(80) 13)", ref. A01478, 20 February 1980, The National Archives, PREM 19/295 f82, reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
  9. ↑ Foreign and Commonwealth Office, telegram no. 1095 to Washington, "Arab/Israel", 10 June 1980, The National Archives, PREM 19/296 f141, reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
  10. ↑ 10.0 10.1 UK delegation Venice, telegram no. 20 to the Foreign and Commonwealth Office, "European Council, Venice, 12/13 June: Middle East", 13 June 1980, The National Archives, PREM 19/296 f104, reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
  11. ↑ Menachem Begin, letter to Margaret Thatcher, 17 June 1980, transmitted by the Embassy of Israel, London, facsimile reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.
  12. ↑ 12.0 12.1 Hansard, European Council (Venice Meeting) HC Deb 16 June 1980 vol 986 cc1126–46, accessed 17 November 2026.
  13. ↑ Our Diplomatic Correspondent, Europe warned The Jewish Chronicle, 13 June 1980, p. 44, accessed 17 November 2026.
  14. ↑ Joseph Finklestone, Argov: EEC blow to peace The Jewish Chronicle, 20 June 1980, pp. 1, 44 (continuation), accessed 17 November 2026.
  15. ↑ Jewish Chronicle Reporter, EEC policy under fire The Jewish Chronicle, 4 July 1980, p. 48, accessed 17 November 2026.
  16. ↑ Shlomo Argov, FACING The Jewish Chronicle, 11 July 1980, p. 24, accessed 17 November 2026.
  17. ↑ Margaret Thatcher, letter to Greville Janner MP, 30 June 1980, The National Archives, PREM 19/296 f7, reproduced by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation, accessed 17 November 2026.