Marion Woolfson

From Powerbase
(Redirected from Miriam Woolfson)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Marion Woolfson

Image Marion Woolfson.jpg
Marion Woolfson (from Tony Greenstein's Blog, 2012; used with the agreement of the Powerbase editor)
Born 11 February 1923 Edinburgh
Died 29 September 2012 Western General Hospital, Edinburgh
Nationality British
Occupation Journalist; author; campaigner
Known for Jewish critic of Zionism; Prophets in Babylon (1980); Honorary President of the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign

Marion Woolfson (born Miriam Cohen; 11 February 1923 – 29 September 2012) was a prominent Scottish anti-Zionist, a journalist and author, and Honorary President of the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign.[1]

She was the daughter of Reuben Robert Cohen (1890?-11 April 1961, at 72) a company director in Edinburgh and Esther Golda Cohen (Death certificate says Esther Olga Pass, whereas death certificate of her husband says 'Golda'; nee Pass) (-1948 at 53).[2] Her parents were married in 1922 in George Square, Glasgow.[3]

In 2002 she wrote that she had been "born into a family of practising Jews", that her "late father was president of the Edinburgh synagogue for 23 years", and that Edinburgh was her birthplace.[4]

Marion Cohen as she was then, married Myer Henry Woolfson in 1942 in Newington, Edinburgh.[5] Myer Henry appeared in the 1911 Census at age 0 years in Newington, Midlothian (and died in Govan in 1962 at the age of 51[6]), along with his mother Rosie Woolfson (age 23, nee Oppenheim) and his father William Hillman Woolfson (27). William was born in Latvia in 1884.

Anti-Zionism

In August 1974 Woolfson sent Christopher Mayhew a memorandum describing the pressure she had faced as a Jewish critic of Zionism, and Mayhew published extracts from it in Publish it not... The Middle East Cover-Up (1975), the book he wrote with Michael Adams. According to Mayhew, her views developed after articles she wrote following a visit to Israel were rejected as "too critical" by the newspaper that had commissioned them. In the memorandum she wrote that in 1970 a national newspaper had agreed to publish a piece she had written "on Zionist activities in Britain", but that a "Zionist official" telephoned her "demanding that I withdraw the story"; when she said it would appear, he answered "We'll see about that". She wrote that "it never appeared", and that some time later "a member of the staff of the paper told me about the pressures to which the paper had been subjected". She did not name the newspaper or the official. She also described abusive letters and telephone calls, police advice to have her calls intercepted, a change to an ex-directory number, attacks in the Jewish Chronicle, a threat telephoned in the name of the Jewish Defence League, and a swastika painted on her gate.[7]

Marion Woolfson features in an extended passage in Publish it not... The Middle East Cover-Up by Michael Adams and Christopher Mayhew (London: Longman, 1975), in the chapter "Personal Pressures" written by Mayhew:

The Zionists reserve their most bitter and relentless attacks, not for people like Michael Adams and myself, but for critics of Israel who are themselves Jewish. These brave people play a role of particular value and importance in the Arab-Israeli conflict, not least because they serve as a striking reminder to the Arabs that their enemy is not the Jewish people but a political movement, Zionism, which many courageous and thoughtful Jews strenuously oppose.
Among the most distinguished Jewish critics of Zionism is Mrs Marion Woolfson, a professional journalist, who developed her convictions after some articles she had written after a visit to Israel were rejected as "too critical" by the newspaper which had commissioned them.
Mrs Woolfson subsequently explained her standpoint as follows:
"As no British newspaper would publish what I had written on Israel, I eventually began to write letters to the papers instead. These were published in The Times, The Guardian, The Sunday Times, The New Statesman, Tribune and The Spectator, among other publications. It became more and more difficult for me to get work in journalism.
"When I offered to write an article on an Arab country for a national British newspaper for which I had worked in the past, I was told that 'I was too well-known for my pro-Arab sympathies and nothing I wrote would be believed.'
"I was bombarded with highly emotional, illogical and often threatening or obscene letters and telephone calls (mostly anonymous) from Zionists. I was called a 'Jew-baiter', a 'Nazi' and an 'anti-Semite' as well as many unprintable epithets. After a particularly bad spate of hysterical telephone calls, usually in the early hours of the morning, I was advised by the police to have my calls intercepted by the GPO. Finally, my telephone number was changed and made ex-directory.
"When I receive an invitation to dinner from someone who is not involved in the Middle East, I ask who the other guests are to be because, in the past, at dinner parties where there happened to be one or two Jewish guests, I have been so violently berated and insulted that I have had to walk out. I have been attacked in Jewish shops and told to take my custom elsewhere. I have been attacked in both the editorial and readers' letters columns of the Jewish Chronicle. I was referred to in one article as 'a self-hater' and 'a self-proclaimed Jewish pro-Arabist'.
"Although, now, I still receive letters from the lunatic fringe, I no longer hear from Zionist officials as I used to when my views first became known. At the beginning, I received 'reasoned' letters and telephone calls suggesting that I was an unfortunate, misguided creature who was being 'used' by the wily Arabs for propaganda purposes 'because they find your Jewish surname useful.' In 1970, a national newspaper agreed to publish something I had written on Zionist activities in Britain. A Zionist official heard about this and telephoned me, demanding that I withdraw the story. I refused and he called me 'nothing but a publicity-seeker'. He also said I would be sorry for what I had done. When I said that, despite his veiled threats, the piece would appear, he answered: 'We'll see about that.' It never appeared and, although, at the time, I was unable to get a satisfactory explanation from the newspaper, some time afterwards a member of the staff of the paper told me about the pressures to which the paper had been subjected.
"Some letter-writers have suggested that I cannot possibly be Jewish and hold the views I do and, therefore, I must be a 'goy' who married a Jew. Just for the record, I should like to state that I was born of Jewish parents. I have frequently been called 'a traitor'. One man wrote to me and said it was his duty 'to stop a Jewess from damaging the cause of Israel.'
"I have been told that I am going to be pushed in front of a bus and, after my telephone number was changed, a friend received a telephone call purporting to be from the Jewish Defence League, announcing that I was about to be killed. Once, a swastika was painted on the gate of my house."[7]
In the battle for truth about the Middle East, the real heroes and heroines are the small band of anti-Zionist Jewish people who speak up for their beliefs in western countries and, most courageously, in Israel itself—colleagues of Mrs Woolfson like Dr Elmer Berger, Dr Norton Mezvinsky, Mr Moshe Menuhin, Mr Mick Ashley, Dr Israel Shahak, Professor Maxime Rodinson and many others. But everyone who criticises Israel publicly, whether Jew or Gentile, must expect to pay some penalty, even in the more relaxed climate of today. The debate about the Middle East is not like, say, the debate about the Common Market, which has been conducted in Britain in an atmosphere of comparative politeness and tranquillity; and as subsequent chapters will show, the path of truth about the Middle East has proved too narrow and stony for large numbers of people in British public life, especially in politics, the media and the churches.[8]


Jewish Chronicle coverage

The Jewish Chronicle was hostile to Woolfson. In September 1972 it called "Mr Erich Fried and Mrs Marion Woolfson" "the two self-proclaimed Jewish pro-Arabists whose letters receive automatic publication in the British press", and described her as "a China traveller and journalist".[9] In September 1974 a column criticising a Time Out article said that it was "written by the egregious Marion Woolfson, a nice Jewish girl gone wrong". In the article she had disputed Israeli accusations that Syria was preparing for war, and had written that "Israel is banging the propaganda drums in order to prepare Western opinion for further aggression against the Arabs".[10] In October 1982 the paper reported that she had signed an advertisement in The Guardian of 8 July about the Lebanon war, naming her among "well-known Jewish anti-Zionists such as Elfi Pallis ... and Mrs Marion Woolfson".[11]

Mick Napier writes[12]:

Marion Woolfson, Honorary President of Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign until her death two years ago today, was the author of several important books. Prophets in Babylon: Jews in the Arab World refuted the oft-asserted Zionist myth that the ancient Jewish communities in Arab countries were extinguished by anti-semitic ethnic cleansing and that this in turn justified the mass expulsion of Palestinians from Palestine to make way for the setting up of the Jewish State in 1948. Once labelled "the most dangerous anti-Zionist in Britain" by an Israeli daily, Marion publicly denounced Israeli barbarity towards the Palestinian people when doing so incurred a personal cost; national newspapers whose columns had previously been open to her, increasingly refused to answer her letters or return her calls. She was beaten at the door of her London home by an unknown asssailant, almost certainly an act of Zionist thuggery of a type becoming familiar. A number of her Palestinian friends were assassinated by the Israelis, including the novelist Ghassan Kanafani.
Once she became aware of the virulent racism visited upon the Palestinians under Israeli control, Marion was not someone to take half measures. She was a consistent supporter of human rights for all, including the Palestinian people, and was prepared to follow that commitment wherever it took her. She was shunned by most of her Jewish family solely on the grounds of her support for the rights of the Palestinian people and her opposition to the ethnic cleansing of a foreign state, Israel. I delivered a eulogy at her funeral in Edinburgh two years ago to a handful of mourners - one of her two daughters stayed away and only three family members attended. Many who had admired her work over the years had lost contact as she became increasingly frail and then housebound.
Marion rejected with contempt the all too frequent dishonest accusations of 'anti-semitism from Zionists: "Anyone who stands up for Palestinians is automatically accused of being 'anti-Semitic'. I am Jewish and proud to be Honorary President of the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign, an anti-racist group that opposes Israeli apartheid."

In 2012 Mick Napier, chair of the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign, wrote in an appreciation published on Tony Greenstein's blog:[1]

Marion's grandparents were penniless Jewish refugees who fled the massacres of Jews in Tsarist Russia, but Marion's father was wealthy and a pillar of Edinburgh society by the time she was born. Marion was very proud of her father, who was a member of the Board of Deputies of British Jews before it succumbed to Zionism, and a man who during the thirties insisted against others who wanted to help only Jewish refugees that a project he sponsored should help all those fleeing Nazi Germany.
Marion was a foreign correspondent for several major UK papers and the author of several works, including The Story of a Palestinian, a biography of Nablus Mayor, Bassam Shaka, and a 1980 work on Jews in the Arab countries, Prophets in Babylon. This work is again timely reading when Netanyahu is trying to exploit the emigration of Jews from Arab countries, which Zionism successfully worked to achieve, in order to deny the rights of Palestinian that Israeli militias drove from their homes and lands.
Her small pamphlet on the racism and criminality of the JNF-KKL, the Jewish National Fund, exposed the scandal of this body being granted tax-exempt charitable status in the UK to enable it to carry out its activities in the Israeli programme of ethic cleansing of the Palestinian people.
Many of her Palestinian friends were assassinated, including poet Ghassan Kanafani, and Marion's was one of relatively few Jewish voices in Britain for many years painstakingly telling stories of atrocious Israeli crimes at considerable personal and professional cost to herself. Marion described several times over the years her personal epiphany when she was a young woman on a visit to Israel and commented casually during a guided tour on the 'beautiful patterns' on the traditional Palestinian dress of a passing woman. The racist contempt and hatred this evoked from her Israeli guide set Marion on a political and personal journey that led one Israeli daily to call her 'the most dangerous anti-Zionist in Britain'.
That journey was filled with much sadness and loss, mixed with great courage and fortitude in the face of professional shunning, a violent beating in her home by a Zionist thug, and final vindication at the end of her life as Israeli crimes have aroused the anger of millions around the world, not excluding Britain and her native Scotland. Marion was happy to be told that there was now strong competition for her title of 'most dangerous anti-Zionist' but we are all in the debt of those, the living and the dead, who fought at great personal cost against the Zionist programme to ethnically cleanse Palestine.

Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign and later life

Palestinian-Jewish solidarity: Marion Woolfson (78) and Nasra Affara (82) on an SPSC publicity stall, Princes St, Edinburgh in 2001 (Tony Greenstein's Blog, 2012; used with the agreement of the Powerbase editor)

Woolfson was Honorary President of the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign (SPSC), which her obituary post also calls her its patron. In 2001, aged 78, she was photographed with Nasra Affara on an SPSC publicity stall in Princes Street, Edinburgh. When SPSC members were charged in 2008 with "racially aggravated conduct" over activities in support of the Palestinian call for a boycott of Israel, she defended them: "Anyone who stands up for Palestinians is automatically accused of being 'anti-Semitic'. I am Jewish and proud to be Honorary President of the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign, an anti-racist group that opposes Israeli apartheid.[1]

According to Mick Napier, the SPSC's chair, she became increasingly infirm in her last two years and died some months after a stroke from which she never fully recovered.[1] She died at the Western General Hospital, Edinburgh, on 29 September 2012, aged 89.[13] In the same obituary post Tony Greenstein wrote that she would be remembered for Prophets in Babylon, which in his view "debunked the Zionist myth that the Jews of the Arab lands were expelled and therefore form a counter-weight to the expulsion of the Palestinians in the Nakba".[1]

Newspaper articles

1983: the Church of Scotland

In May 1983 Woolfson wrote in The Scotsman, under the headline "Kirk victim of Israeli politics", warning the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland against "accepting official Israeli propaganda". She argued that a significant minority of Jews repudiated Zionism, citing Edwin Montagu's 1917 memorandum and Nahum Goldmann.[14]

2002: "I'm a Jew but Israel is wrong"

In April 2002 the Edinburgh Evening News published an article by Woolfson headed "I'm a Jew but Israel is wrong". In it she wrote that she had not been especially interested in Israel until her work as a journalist took her to London and she "began travelling extensively in Asia for several national newspapers". When she was commissioned to interview Indira Gandhi, after the 1967 war, her editor suggested she spend two weeks in Israel on the way. She wrote that what she then wrote brought "letters of support from fellow Jews", but also "abuse too and death threats from supporters of Israel". She had been in Lebanon during the civil war, and in Iraq during the war with Iran, when she interviewed Saddam Hussein. She was also "one of the first journalists to enter the Syrian town of Kuneitra" after the Israeli withdrawal of 1974. She wrote that since returning to Edinburgh she had met other Jews who supported the Palestinian struggle, and that she had joined the boycott of goods produced in Israeli settlements.[4] A reader, Gerry McGarvey, wrote to the paper three days later praising the article, in reply to a column by Brian Monteith.[15]

Letters to the press

2001

Referring to the attack on USS Liberty, you ask, "Why was no one ever told?" (The cover-up, G2, Au-gust 8). A full account of this atrocity, written by Anthony Pearson, a British journalist, who covered the 1967 war and worked for the Guardian, the Times and Paris Match, was published in Penthouse in May 1976. Attempts to have the material published in UK newspapers failed. Several editors admitted they were afraid of being accused of "anti-semitism" - a most potent form of blackmail then and now.
The full story, entitled 'The Liberty cover-up', also appeared, on June 15 1976, in Voice, a London-based journal on Middle Eastern affairs, owned by the late Claud Morris. He had been editor of a flourishing Welsh newspaper and owner of a printing company, but was forced out of business when, as a result of printing Free Palestine, his press was destroyed by arsonists. Mr Morris also published Middle East International, and the Jewish Chronicle reported on October 22, 1971 that Jewish advertisers had withdrawn their advertising from his newspaper and Mr Morris had "lost a number of his senior staff".
In 1972, the Sunday Times published a carefully researched report on the torture of Palestinians in Israeli prisons and the then editor, Harold Evans, was subjected to accusations of "anti-semitism". It is surely time for the media to resist the blackmail of Israel's supporters and print the truth as the Guardian has so courageously done.
Marion Woolfson, Edinburgh.[16]

Obituaries

On Saturday, September 29, 2012, at the Western General Hospital, Edinburgh, Miriam (Marion) (nee Cohen), aged 89, much loved mother of Rosalind and Esther, respected friend, journalist, traveller and redoubtable campaigner.[13]

Publications

Cover of Prophets in Babylon: Jews in the Arab World (Faber and Faber, 1980) (Tony Greenstein's Blog, 2012; used with the agreement of the Powerbase editor)
  • Prophets in Babylon: Jews in the Arab World (London and Boston: Faber and Faber, 1980), 292 pp., ISBN 057111458X.[17]
  • Bassam Shak'a: Portrait of a Palestinian (London: Third World Centre, 1981), 142 pp., ISBN 0861990099.[18] Napier calls it "The Story of a Palestinian, a biography of Nablus Mayor, Bassam Shaka".[1]
  • A pamphlet on the Jewish National Fund and its charitable status in the UK, according to Napier; its title is not given.[1]

Mick Napier on Prophets in Babylon

In a tribute on the second anniversary of her death, Mick Napier of the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign wrote that Prophets in Babylon "recognises the limitations and harshness of all medieval societies" and takes a nuanced approach to the status of Jews in the pre-modern Arab and Muslim world. In his view her refutation of Zionist claims of timeless Muslim–Jewish enmity had been "vindicated" by scholarship on the Cairo Geniza, the documents found in a medieval synagogue in Old Cairo, and he quoted the historian Marc Cohen on the Jews of medieval Muslim societies, who "suffered little of the discrimination" and "received fair treatment before Muslim judges".[12] He singled out a British Embassy report, quoted in the book, of the December 1942 deliberations of the American Jewish Committee, which "unanimously urged" a large post-war immigration of Central European Jews into Palestine "since it offers an alternative to…Jewish immigration in to the USA".[12]

Napier argued that the book remained relevant to debates on the exodus of Jews from Arab countries after 1948. He cited a Jewish Telegraph report that the Scottish minister Humza Yousaf had been told at a Glasgow meeting in May 2014 that Israel's war of independence "had created around 850,000 Jewish refugees from Arab countries", and he referred to what Ben-Gurion called "cruel Zionism", the efforts of the Zionist underground in Iraq and Egypt to force Jews to leave. He noted that Woolfson had not drawn on the testimony of the Iraqi Jew Naeim Giladi, which he said supported her case. He also linked her account of the racism Arab Jews met in Israel to the election of Mordechai Vanunu, whose family came from Morocco, as Rector of the University of Glasgow in 2004.[12] He concluded that she had "provided materials that contribute richly" to an understanding of this history, "grounded in a commitment to equal rights for all, the dismantling of Israeli apartheid, and an end to ethnic cleansing".[12]

Resources

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 Tony Greenstein, "Marion Woolfson RIP 11th February 1923 to 29th September 2012", Tony Greenstein's Blog, 10 October 2012, obituary post including an appreciation by Mick Napier, chair of the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign, accessed 18 November 2026.
  2. ↑ PASS ESTHER OLGA 53 F 1948 685 / 1 / 606 Haymarket
  3. ↑ PASS ESTHER GOLDA COHEN REUBEN ROBERT 1922 685 / 5 / 42 George Square
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 "I'm a Jew but Israel is wrong", Edinburgh Evening News, 27 April 2002, p. 10, British Newspaper Archive (subscription required; text checked against the page image), accessed 19 November 2026.
  5. ↑ WOOLFSON MYER HENRY COHEN MIRIAM 1942 685 / 6 / 48 Newington
  6. ↑ WOOLFSON MYER HENRY 51 M 1962 644 / 10 / 357 Govan
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 Michael Adams and Christopher Mayhew, Publish it not... The Middle East Cover-Up (London: Longman, 1975), chapter "Personal Pressures" by Christopher Mayhew, pp. 63–64, quoting a memorandum from Marion Woolfson to Mayhew, August 1974.
  8. ↑ Michael Adams and Christopher Mayhew, Publish it not... The Middle East Cover-Up (London: Longman, 1975), chapter "Personal Pressures" by Christopher Mayhew, pp. 64–65.
  9. ↑ The Jewish Chronicle, 22 September 1972, pp. 14–15, JC Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  10. ↑ The Jewish Chronicle, 6 September 1974, p. 24, JC Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  11. ↑ The Jewish Chronicle, 29 October 1982, p. 4, JC Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  12. ↑ 12.0 12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4 Mick Napier, "Marion Woolfson (11.02.1923 – 29.09.2012) RIP", Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign website, 29 September 2014, accessed 18 November 2026.
  13. ↑ 13.0 13.1 https://www.legacy.com/us/obituaries/legacyremembers/miriam-woolfson-obituary?id=42793881
  14. ↑ "Kirk victim of Israeli politics", The Scotsman, 26 May 1983, p. 13, British Newspaper Archive (subscription required; OCR text, not checked against the page image; OCR poor), accessed 19 November 2026.
  15. ↑ "Monteith proves to be misguided", Edinburgh Evening News, 30 April 2002, p. 12, British Newspaper Archive (subscription required; text checked against the page image; letter), accessed 19 November 2026.
  16. ↑ Letters: USS Liberty cover-up blown apart The Guardian (London) August 9, 2001, Pg. 17.
  17. ↑ Prophets in Babylon, Open Library catalogue record (Faber and Faber, 1980; LCCN 80670264), accessed 18 November 2026.
  18. ↑ Bassam Shakʼa, portrait of a Palestinian, Open Library catalogue record (Third World Centre, 1981), accessed 18 November 2026.