Lord Palmerston

From Powerbase
Jump to navigation Jump to search

British Foreign Secretary and Prime Minister who in 1840 urged the Ottoman Sultan to encourage Jewish settlement in Palestine

Henry John Temple, 3rd Viscount Palmerston

Image Henry John Temple, 3rd Viscount Palmerston.jpg
Lord Palmerston
Born 20 October 1784 Westminster, London
Died 18 October 1865 Brocket Hall, Hertfordshire
Nationality British
Occupation Politician
Known for Foreign Secretary; Prime Minister (1855–58, 1859–65)

Henry John Temple, 3rd Viscount Palmerston (1784–1865) was a British Whig and Liberal statesman. He was Foreign Secretary in 1830–34, 1835–41 and 1846–51, and Prime Minister in 1855–58 and 1859–65.[1][2] Urged on by the evangelical Lord Ashley (later Lord Shaftesbury), he set up a British vice-consulate in Jerusalem in 1838. In 1840 he instructed the British ambassador in Constantinople to press the Ottoman government to "hold out every just encouragement to the Jews of Europe to return to Palestine", partly so that Jewish settlers would act as a "check" on Mehemet Ali.[3] During the Damascus ritual-murder affair of 1840 he instructed British diplomats to demand redress for the accused Jews, and in 1841 he told consuls in the Ottoman empire to report cases of oppression of Jews.[4][5]

Career

Palmerston was born in Westminster on 20 October 1784 and died at Brocket Hall on 18 October 1865.[1] He sat for Newport (1807–11), Cambridge University (1811–31), Bletchingley (1831–32), South Hampshire (1832–35) and Tiverton (1835–65).[6] According to the official history, he "served in government for 46 years" and became "enormously popular thanks to his assertive and 'manly' foreign policy".[1] In 1839 he married Lady Cowper, the mother-in-law of Lord Ashley.[7]

Palestine and the Jews

Jerusalem vice-consulate, 1838

In September 1838 Ashley recorded the appointment of William Young as "her Majesty's Vice-Consul at Jerusalem". He saw it as a sign that "the ancient city of the people of God is about to resume a place among the nations", and he credited God with giving him "influence to prevail with Palmerston".[8]

The 1840 despatch

During the Eastern crisis of 1840 Ashley lobbied Palmerston directly. After dining with him on 1 August 1840, Ashley wrote that he had to "argue politically, financially, commercially; these considerations strike him home". On 24 August he noted that Palmerston had written to Ponsonby about "protection and encouragement to the Jews".[9] The historian Jonathan Frankel writes that "the foreign secretary was as good as his word", and that the opening paragraph of the despatch "could have been copied directly from almost any millennialist document".[10] The despatch itself, dated 11 August 1840, told Ponsonby that "there exists at present among the Jews dispersed over Europe a strong notion that the Time is approaching when their nation is to return to Palestine". It went on:

It is well known that the Jews of Europe possess great wealth; and it is manifest that any country in which a considerable number of them might choose to settle, would derive great benefit from the riches which they would bring to it. ... the Jewish people, if returning under the sanction and protection, and at the invitation of the Sultan, would be a check upon any future evil designs of Mehemet Ali or his Successor.[3]

Palmerston asked Ponsonby to put these considerations "confidentially" to the Turkish government. He added that even if few Jews actually settled, laws in their favour would "create useful friends in many countries by one single Edict".[3] In a memorandum of 25 September 1840, Ashley pressed him further for a guarantee of "equal laws and equal protection to Jew and Gentile" in Syria. He described Jewish settlement as "the cheapest and safest mode of supplying the wastes of those depopulated regions".[11] Palmerston did not send Ashley's memorandum on to Ponsonby until late November. His covering despatch of 24 November said the Sultan "would enlist in his favour the good opinion of numerous and powerful classes in the country" if he issued an edict granting Jews settling in the Ottoman lands, "but more especially in Syria, full security for their persons and property". It also proposed that Jews in Palestine "should be at liberty to transmit any complaints to the Turkish government through the British consular offices".[12]

Frankel stresses the limits of this policy: "at no time did the foreign secretary ever suggest that Palestine be detached from the Ottoman empire". On 17 August 1840 Palmerston told a correspondent who had proposed that the Jews be "established in Syria as an independent nation" that he considered "the plan you propose to be impracticable".[12] Frankel writes that Palmerston "bluntly rejected the requests reaching him from Christian millennialists that he adopt the cause of a Jewish state in Palestine". He also accepts, however, that "a diplomatic opportunity had been missed in 1840": had Montefiore and the Rothschilds backed the millennialists, Palmerston "would in all probability have acted with still greater urgency and persistence".[13] The Globe was "generally considered to be the vehicle most favored by Palmerston" for his unattributed views. On 27 July 1840 it predicted that "numbers would repair to Judea" and that "Now is the time for Britain to set about deserving" the blessing promised to those who were kind to "the children of Abraham". Frankel notes, however, that this article is not among the many surviving manuscript copies of his articles, and so "was probably not written by Palmerston himself".[14]

The Damascus affair, 1840

On 5 February 1840 a Capuchin monk, Father Thomas, and his servant, Ibrahim Amara, disappeared in Damascus, which was then ruled by Mehemet Ali. Jews of the city were accused of murdering them for ritual purposes.[15] On 30 April 1840 Palmerston received a deputation from the Board of Deputies whose members included David Salomons, I. L. Goldsmid, Moses Montefiore and Lionel Rothschild. At the time he was building a coalition to force Mehemet Ali out of Syria. Frankel argues, though, that he treated the charge "as an issue in its own right and not as a facet of, or pawn in, the conflict between the Sultan in Constantinople and the viceroy in Alexandria". He adds that Palmerston "for some years ... had been toying with the idea of granting the Eastern Jews, however informally, a modicum of British protection". France and Austria had Catholic clients in the region and Russia the Orthodox, "while England was left with no such constituency"; the "Protestant missionaries and the Jews could, perhaps, provide at least a partial substitute".[16] In January 1839 the Foreign Office had already told Young in Jerusalem that it "will be a part of your duty ... to afford protection to the Jews [in Palestine] generally".[17]

Palmerston told the deputation of his "surprise that the calumny which had been invented ... should have received the highest credence". He promised "that the influence of the British government should be exerted to put a stop to [the] atrocities" in Damascus and in a parallel case on Rhodes. In despatches sent out on 5 May he told Ponsonby to request "an immediate and strict inquiry" into the Rhodes case. He also instructed Colonel Hodges, the consul-general in Alexandria, to impress on Mehemet Ali "the extreme disgrace which the barbarous enormities perpetrated at [Damascus] reflect upon his administration".[4] The British consul in Damascus, N. W. Werry, had reported in March that he was confident of the Jews' guilt. Palmerston replied on 21 May that Werry's despatch "either proves you to be wholly uninformed of what passes in the city in which you are stationed or else evinces on your part an entire want of those principles and sentiments which ought to distinguish a British agent".[18] On 28 May the London Society for Promoting Christianity amongst the Jews sent a deputation that included Lord Ashley. Palmerston, "who was notoriously unpunctual", was not there to receive it. Even so, on 30 May he sent both capitals word that "a deep and general feeling of indignation has been excited throughout this country by the barbarity of treatment which the unfortunate Jews have experienced".[19] Frankel judges that British pressure "might go far at the Porte" but had "only a marginal, if not a downright negative effect in Egypt", where only France could end the affair.[20] The Rhodes Jews were acquitted by an Ottoman ministerial court in July 1840.[21]

Ashley later contrasted British silence over massacres of Eastern Christians with the fact that "Palmerston spoke for the Jews at Damascus". In an 1843 letter to Lord Aberdeen, he wrote that Palmerston "interposed in aid of the Jews at Damascus, and won golden opinions by such a becoming and manly policy".[22]

Consular protection and the Jerusalem bishopric, 1841

Once the Ottomans had won the war, they were unlikely to issue an edict encouraging Jewish settlement. Palmerston nevertheless wrote in February 1841 that "it would be highly advantageous to the Sultan that the Jews ... be induced to go and settle in Palestine". He also pressed for Jews to be allowed to send complaints through British consular channels. Reshid Pasha objected that this "amounts to placing them under English protection". "With characteristic willfulness", Frankel writes, Palmerston read the Porte's general assurances "in a most concrete manner".[23] His circular to consuls in the Ottoman empire of 21 April 1841 told them to report cases of oppression of Jews to the ambassador. It added: "You are not authorized to interfere officially with the local authorities", but they should make known "that the British government feels an interest in the welfare of the Jews".[5] The Anglo-Prussian plan for a Jerusalem bishopric "proved attractive to Palmerston".[24] In July 1841 the Prussian envoy Bunsen recorded that Palmerston had accepted the principle of the joint bishopric.[25]

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 Prime Minister's Office, "History of Henry John Temple, 3rd Viscount Palmerston", GOV.UK, accessed 18 November 2026.
  2. ↑ Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office, "Past Foreign Secretaries", GOV.UK, accessed 18 November 2026.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 Viscount Palmerston to Viscount Ponsonby, 11 August 1840, F.O. 78/390 (No. 134), in Albert H. Hyamson, The British Consulate in Jerusalem in relation to the Jews of Palestine 1838–1914, London: Edward Goldston for the Jewish Historical Society of England, 1939, pp. 33–34, reproduced by the Center for Online Judaic Studies, accessed 18 November 2026.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 Frankel, The Damascus Affair, pp. 128–129, citing Palmerston to Hodges, 5 May 1840, FO 78/403 (No. 9).
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 Frankel, The Damascus Affair, pp. 393–394, citing Palmerston to Ponsonby, 21 April 1841 (No. 95, enclosure), FO 195/181, in Hyamson, The British Consulate in Jerusalem, vol. 1, pp. 39–40.
  6. ↑ Hansard 1803–2005, "Viscount Palmerston", accessed 18 November 2026.
  7. ↑ Edwin Hodder, The Life and Work of the Seventh Earl of Shaftesbury, K.G., popular edition, London: Cassell, 1888, p. 122, accessed 18 November 2026.
  8. ↑ Hodder, Life and Work, p. 123.
  9. ↑ Hodder, Life and Work, p. 167.
  10. ↑ Jonathan Frankel, The Damascus Affair: "Ritual Murder", Politics, and the Jews in 1840, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997 (ISBN 0-521-48246-1), p. 307.
  11. ↑ Hodder, Life and Work, pp. 168–169.
  12. ↑ 12.0 12.1 Frankel, The Damascus Affair, p. 310, citing Palmerston to Ponsonby, 24 November 1840, FO 78/391 (No. 248), in Hyamson, The British Consulate in Jerusalem, vol. 1, p. 35.
  13. ↑ Frankel, The Damascus Affair, pp. 311–312.
  14. ↑ Frankel, The Damascus Affair, pp. 300–301.
  15. ↑ Jonathan Frankel, The Damascus Affair: "Ritual Murder", Politics, and the Jews in 1840, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997 (ISBN 0-521-48246-1), pp. 19–20, 128–130.
  16. ↑ Frankel, The Damascus Affair, p. 126.
  17. ↑ Frankel, The Damascus Affair, p. 127, citing Bidwell to Young, 31 January 1839, in Hyamson, The British Consulate in Jerusalem, vol. 1, p. 1.
  18. ↑ Frankel, The Damascus Affair, p. 130, citing Palmerston to Werry, 21 May 1840, in Hyamson, "The Damascus Affair", p. 53.
  19. ↑ Frankel, The Damascus Affair, p. 131, citing Palmerston to Ponsonby, 30 May 1840, FO 78/389, and Palmerston to Hodges, 30 May 1840, FO 78/403.
  20. ↑ Frankel, The Damascus Affair, pp. 131–132.
  21. ↑ Frankel, The Damascus Affair, p. 163.
  22. ↑ Hodder, Life and Work, pp. 279, 283.
  23. ↑ Frankel, The Damascus Affair, p. 393, citing Palmerston to Ponsonby, 17 February 1841, FO 78/427, in Hyamson, The British Consulate in Jerusalem, vol. 1, p. 38.
  24. ↑ Frankel, The Damascus Affair, p. 392.
  25. ↑ Hodder, Life and Work, pp. 199–200.