Herbert Samuel
British Liberal politician who proposed a Jewish Palestine under British rule in 1915 and was the first High Commissioner for Palestine (1920–25)
| Herbert Louis Samuel, 1st Viscount Samuel
| |
|---|---|
| Image | Herbert Samuel |
| Born | 1870 |
| Died | 5 February 1963 |
| Nationality | British |
| Occupation | Politician, colonial administrator |
| Known for | Memorandum "The Future of Palestine" (1915); first High Commissioner for Palestine |
Herbert Samuel (1870–1963), created Viscount Samuel in 1937, was a British Liberal Party politician. As a Cabinet minister in 1915 he circulated a memorandum, "The Future of Palestine", that called for British annexation of Palestine, Jewish settlement under British rule, and, in time, a Jewish majority with a measure of self-government. From 1920 to 1925 he was the first civilian High Commissioner for Palestine, charged with putting the Balfour Declaration into effect.[1][2]
Career
Samuel was Liberal MP for Cleveland from 1902 to 1918 and for Darwen from 1929 to 1935. His offices were:
- Parliamentary Under-Secretary at the Home Office (1905–09)
- Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster (1909–10 and 1915–16)
- Postmaster-General (1910–14 and 1915–16)
- President of the Local Government Board (1914–15)
- Home Secretary (1916 and 1931–32)
He was born in Liverpool on 6 November 1870 and was Parliamentary Under-Secretary at the Home Office from 1905 to 1909; in the Commons in 1907 he spoke as "THE UNDER-SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT".[3][4] He was made a viscount in 1937 and died on 5 February 1963.[5]
Zionism
Wartime advocacy
According to Balfour's biographer Blanche Dugdale, Samuel was in the early war years the one "active sympathiser of their own race" the Zionists had among British politicians.[6] David Lloyd George sent Chaim Weizmann and his colleagues on to Samuel late in 1914, and "in this English Jew they discovered a friend". It was through Samuel that the Zionists learned the Foreign Secretary Sir Edward Grey's private sympathy for their aims.[7]
In January 1915 Samuel wrote to Grey and circulated a Cabinet memorandum headed "The Future of Palestine", printed for the Cabinet and marked Secret.[1][8] The memorandum argued that "the time is not ripe for the establishment there of an independent, autonomous Jewish State". He warned: "If the attempt were made to place the 400,000 or 500,000 Mahommedans of Arab race under a Government which rested upon the support of 90,000 or 100,000 Jewish inhabitants, there can be no assurance that such a Government, even if established by the authority of the Powers, would be able to command obedience. The dream of a Jewish State, prosperous, progressive, and the home of a brilliant civilisation, might vanish in a series of squalid conflicts with the Arab population". The solution "which would be much the most welcome to the leaders and supporters of the Zionist movement throughout the world would be the annexation of the country to the British Empire". Under British rule he hoped that "facilities would be given to Jewish organisations to purchase land, to found colonies, to establish educational and religious institutions", and that "Jewish immigration, carefully regulated, would be given preference so that in course of time the Jewish people, grown into a majority and settled in the land, may be conceded such degree of self-government as the conditions of that day may justify".[1][9]
Among the arguments he advanced "from the standpoint of British interests" was the defence of Egypt: "The belt of desert to the east of the Suez Canal is an admirable strategic frontier for Egypt. But it would be an inadequate defence if a great European Power were established on the further side." A British Palestine, he wrote, would be "a far smaller risk to the vital interests of the British Empire than a common frontier at El Arish."[10] On the scale of settlement he wrote that "the gradual growth of a considerable Jewish community, under British suzerainty, in Palestine will not solve the Jewish question in Europe". "A country the size of Wales, much of it barren mountain and part of it waterless, cannot hold 9,000,000 people. But it could probably hold in time 3,000,000 or 4,000,000, and some relief would be given to the pressure in Russia and elsewhere."[11]
The Prime Minister, H. H. Asquith, summarised the memorandum in his diary on 28 January 1915. In Asquith's words, Samuel argued "in favour of the British annexation of Palestine", and "he thinks we might plant in this not very promising territory about three or four million European Jews, and that this would have a good effect upon those who are left behind". Asquith found it "almost like a new edition of 'Tancred' brought up to date", and was "not attracted by this proposed addition to our responsibilities".[12] On 13 March 1915 he called it a "dithyrambic memorandum" urging that Britain take Palestine, "into which the scattered Jews would in time swarm back from all the quarters of the globe, and in due course obtain Home Rule".[13] The "three or four million" phrase is often quoted as Samuel's own words, including in a 1978 United Nations study,[14] but those words are Asquith's paraphrase. Samuel's own wording was that Palestine "could probably hold in time 3,000,000 or 4,000,000".[11]
High Commissioner, 1920–25
After Britain was given the Mandate, the military administration was replaced by a civil one from 1 July 1920, with Samuel as High Commissioner. The first Immigration Ordinance was enacted in September 1920, and Samuel authorised a first year's quota of 16,500 Jewish immigrants.[2] In October 1920 he set up a nominated Advisory Council. In August 1922 he proposed a Legislative Council with a minority of elected Arab members, which the Palestine Arab Executive boycotted. Samuel then dropped it, and from 1923 legislation was made by the High Commissioner with an advisory council of officials only.[15] He held office until 1925.[16]
Later views
In 1934 Samuel wrote that "every one in Palestine agrees that the economic development is astonishing; no one thinks that the political situation shows any appreciable improvement".[17] In the House of Lords in July 1937 he opposed the Peel Commission's partition plan, warning that it would create "a Saar, a Polish Corridor, and half a dozen Danzigs and Memels in a country the size of Wales". As an alternative he proposed holding the Jewish population at no more than about 40 per cent for a period of years, together with an Arab confederation and the opening of Transjordan to Jewish as well as Arab settlement.[18]
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 The National Archives, CAB 37/123/43, Herbert Samuel, 'The future of Palestine', 21 January 1915, p. 1. Catalogue entry: CAB 37/123/43.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 Royal Institute of International Affairs, Great Britain and Palestine 1915–1945, Information Papers No. 20, London: RIIA, 1946, p. 39, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ Who's Who 1926, London: A. & C. Black, 1926, "Samuel, Rt. Hon. Sir Herbert Louis", accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ HC Deb 3 May 1907 vol 173 c1198, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ Hansard 1803–2005, "Mr Herbert Samuel", accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ Blanche E. C. Dugdale, Arthur James Balfour, vol. 2: 1906–1930, New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons, 1937, p. 156, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ Dugdale, Arthur James Balfour, vol. 2, pp. 163–164.
- ↑ The National Archives, FO 800/100/187, letter from Herbert Samuel to Sir Edward Grey concerning the future of Palestine, 22 January 1915, catalogue entry, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ The National Archives, CAB 37/123/43, Herbert Samuel, 'The future of Palestine', 21 January 1915, p. 2.
- ↑ The National Archives, CAB 37/123/43, Herbert Samuel, 'The future of Palestine', 21 January 1915, p. 3.
- ↑ 11.0 11.1 The National Archives, CAB 37/123/43, Herbert Samuel, 'The future of Palestine', 21 January 1915, p. 5.
- ↑ H. H. Asquith, Earl of Oxford and Asquith, Memories and Reflections 1852–1927, vol. 2, London: Cassell, 1928, p. 59, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ Asquith, Memories and Reflections, vol. 2, pp. 65–66.
- ↑ United Nations, The Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem, Part I: 1917–1947, 1978, section I and note 16, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ RIIA, Great Britain and Palestine 1915–1945, p. 41.
- ↑ RIIA, Great Britain and Palestine 1915–1945, p. 42 (list of High Commissioners).
- ↑ RIIA, Great Britain and Palestine 1915–1945, p. 84.
- ↑ RIIA, Great Britain and Palestine 1915–1945, p. 101, citing HL Deb 20 July 1937 col. 638.