Richard Meinertzhagen

From Powerbase
Revision as of 19:13, 18 November 2026 by Archive Research (talk | contribs) (Create page on Richard Meinertzhagen)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

British Army officer and self-described "ardent Zionist" who was Chief Political Officer in Palestine in 1919–20; later exposed as a fabricator

Richard Meinertzhagen

Born 3 March 1878
Died 17 June 1967
Nationality British
Occupation Army officer, ornithologist
Known for Chief Political Officer, Palestine and Syria (1919–20); Middle East Diary (1959)

Richard Meinertzhagen (3 March 1878 – 17 June 1967) was a British Army officer, intelligence officer and ornithologist.[1][2] In 1919–20 he was Chief Political Officer for Palestine and Syria on General Allenby's staff. In an official despatch of 1919 he described his views on Zionism as "those of an ardent Zionist".[3] His published Middle East Diary presents him as a lone champion of Zionism among hostile British officials. He also stole bird specimens from museum collections and falsified their data, and a reviewer of his 2007 biography concluded that "we cannot believe a word that Richard Meinertzhagen ever wrote or said about anything".[4] His own accounts therefore cannot be relied on without corroboration.

Career

Meinertzhagen was educated at Harrow and joined the army (Royal Fusiliers) in 1899. He served in India until 1902 and then with the King's African Rifles until 1905. During the First World War he served in East Africa, Palestine and France. He was afterwards a member of the British delegation to the Paris Peace Conference, Chief Political Officer in Palestine and Syria in 1919–20, and Military Adviser to the Middle East Department of the Colonial Office.[5] Who's Who 1954 dates the Colonial Office post to 1921–24 and adds that he graduated at the Staff College, went on to retired pay in 1925, sat on the Council of the Royal Geographical Society in 1927–30, and served at the War Office in 1939–40 and in the Home Guard in 1940–45. Its list of his publications includes Birds of Egypt (1930), Life of a Boy (1947), Review of the Alaudidae (1951) and Birds of Arabia (1953).[2] The historian David Omissi also dates the Colonial Office post to 1921–24 and lists his wartime role as "Field Intelligence, Allenby's Army, 1917–18".[6]

Garfield's biography adds detail from the official record. At the Paris Peace Conference Meinertzhagen worked on boundary maps; Garfield writes that the impression he later gave of having been "in Paris on the Intelligence Staff" was false: "He was not." Garfield also shows that his claim that Palestine's proposed northern frontier was to be called the "Meinertzhagen Line" rests on nothing more than a map on which the phrase "is entered in pencil".[7] Garfield credits Chaim Weizmann with Meinertzhagen's selection as Chief Political Officer in 1919. Weizmann wrote to Balfour on 17 August 1919: "Colonel Meinertzhagen has been appointed C.P.O. ... He is an honest, fair-minded and clever man." Garfield judges that the appointment "gradually proved to be a disaster, since he had minimal political skills". He adds that Meinertzhagen "supervised no spy network and committed no known acts of sabotage or violence": on his support for Zionism, "The overt support was real. The clandestine work was not."[8] After the Jerusalem riots of April 1920 Meinertzhagen sent a despatch to Lord Curzon, dated 14 April 1920, over Allenby's head. It charged that "The officers of the Administration are, almost without exception, anti-Zionist". Garfield writes: "Allenby's immediate and inevitable reaction was to sack Meinertzhagen." He calls the despatch "a brave and gallant act".[9]

In February 1921 Winston Churchill, the new Colonial Secretary, told the War Office: "I shall want Meinertzhagen for the Middle East department." Meinertzhagen reported for duty on 9 May 1921.[10] Garfield writes that "The actual record shows that RM spent most of his Colonial Office tour of duty in England, occupied with military budget matters and logistics rather than regional or ethnic politics". He adds that Meinertzhagen "was hardly the only voice for Zionism" in the department.[11] In a memorandum of 2 August 1921 to Sir John Shuckburgh he argued that British officials in Palestine who did not approve of Zionism should be removed and that Zionist immigration should be encouraged.[12] In 1922 the Colonial Office suspected that Middle East Department papers were being leaked to Weizmann. Garfield notes: "Whether in fact RM leaked information to Weizmann is a question to which no answer has come forward. He must be presumed innocent."[13] He rejoined his battalion, then training in Cologne, on 1 June 1924, and resigned from the army on 26 January 1925.[14]

His reputation as an ornithologist collapsed after his death. Pamela Rasmussen and Robert Prŷs-Jones of the Natural History Museum record that by 1919 he "had already been excluded from the NHM Bird Room for 18 months for unauthorised removal of specimens", and that museum documents over the next 30 years contain "numerous references to suspicions by staff that he was stealing both specimen and library material". The accusation of fraud was made public by Alan Knox in 1993, and they found "the scope of the problem is far greater" than had so far been published.[15][16]

Brian Garfield's 2007 biography extended the charges to his military and political record. Reviewing it, the Smithsonian ornithologist Storrs Olson wrote that Meinertzhagen "stole specimens of birds from museum collections, fabricated label data for them, and published deliberately falsified information about birds in scientific journals", and that much of Garfield's case "rests on the fact that no corroboration can be found for practically any of his alleged major deeds as a warrior and spy". On the diaries, Olson noted that "there seem to have been no original journals kept in the field, at least none that survived".[17]

Zionism

Apart from the two official despatches, which survive in the Foreign Office archives, the quotations in this section come from Meinertzhagen's own published diary. Given the findings above, they show how he chose to present himself, not necessarily what he wrote at the time.

In the preface to Middle East Diary he called "the ultimate establishment of Israel—bringing the Jews back to their old Home after nearly 2,000 years of dispersal and persecution" "the most constructive and important outcome of the First World War".[18] His published entry for 2 December 1917 contrasts Jewish settlers with the Arab, whom he describes as "an inhabitant of the east, nurturing stagnant ideas and seeing no further than the narrow doctrines of Mohammed".[19] In his entry for 7 February 1918 he recorded a conversation in which Balfour supposedly told him: "My personal hope is that the Jews will make good in Palestine and eventually found a Jewish State."[20] As with other conversations reported only in the diary, there is no independent record of this exchange. In an entry dated 30 July 1919 he recorded Balfour as defining government policy on the principle "that Zionists are the Most-favoured Nation in Palestine".[21]

His despatch to Lord Curzon of 26 September 1919, written as Chief Political Officer, survives in the Foreign Office records and was published in Documents on British Foreign Policy. In it he wrote:

My inclination towards Jews in general is governed by an anti-semitic instinct which is invariably modified by personal contact. My views on Zionism are those of an ardent Zionist.[3]

In the same despatch he said he was "insisting on official recognition of Zionism as the established policy of H.M.G.".[22] In a further despatch of 17 November 1919 he urged Curzon to draw Palestine's northern frontier well north of the Sykes–Picot line, along the Litani River. He argued that "The Sykes-Picot Line was fixed before His Majesty's Government was committed to Zionism, and cannot in any sense be said to satisfy the economic interests of Palestine".[23] In a diary entry dated 31 December 1919 he wrote: "I am not surprised that people think I must be a Jew, when I stand alone among Christians here as a friend to Zionism. And that is the irony of the whole situation, for I am also imbued with anti-semitic feelings, and would wish that Zionism could be divorced from Jewish Nationality."[24]

He blamed senior British officials for the anti-Zionist agitation of 1920. In an entry dated 27 April 1921 he claimed to have had "much documentary evidence against Storrs and Waters-Taylor" showing that Haj Amin al-Husseini had been encouraged by Ronald Storrs and Waters-Taylor, and he called Herbert Samuel's appointment of Haj Amin as Mufti of Jerusalem "sheer madness".[25] On 21 June 1921 he wrote that "The atmosphere in the Colonial Office is definitely hebraphobe".[26] In an entry dated 4 January 1948 he wrote that he had "implicit faith in the Jews being able to hold their own and a bit more in Palestine", and that British policy meant "I seldom felt so ashamed of my country".[27]

Garfield's assessment

Garfield accepts that Meinertzhagen's Zionism was genuine. He writes that during his first months in Cairo in 1917 "he became a Zionist", having arrived "a casual anti-Semite" by his own admission. Garfield calls the allegiance "a brave one", and says "he remained a steadfast supporter of the movement throughout his long life". He was, however, "issuing periodic anti-Semitic outbursts" and joined "a number of pro-Nazi business organizations in the early and mid-1930s".[28] On 29 September 1919, three days after Meinertzhagen called himself "an ardent Zionist" in his despatch to Curzon, Gertrude Bell recorded: "He used to be a strong Zionist; Gen. Clayton believes that he has considerably modified his views on this head." Garfield comments: "RM had not modified his Zionist views at all".[29] The Palin Commission's report on the 1920 riots, as quoted by the historian Sahar Huneidi, called him the "chief support of the Zionists" and "Dr. Weizmann's nominee".[30]

Garfield rejects the picture of Meinertzhagen as Zionism's lone defender. Meinertzhagen "felt—incorrectly—that everybody in the British administration was dead-set against him. This was not the case."[31] Garfield allows that he "was one of the very few British officers who were committed to carrying out the policy of the Balfour Declaration". But he finds that Meinertzhagen's diary claim to have brought about the civil administration under Herbert Samuel "exceeds reality", even if "he certainly played a part in it all".[32] His overall verdict is that "RM's obnoxious behavior on Zionism's behalf may have done more harm than was done by the anti-Semitic 'hebraphobia' he complained was rampant in Whitehall". He also concludes that Meinertzhagen "clearly misled the Zionist leadership" about having argued Zionism's case with Hitler in the 1930s.[33]

Garfield shows that the published diaries were not contemporary records. Readers of the "diary" books "took him at his word when he said the entries dated 1919 or 1921 were actually written at those times, rather than sometime during subsequent decades".[30] In the typescript diaries, the pages describing the 1922 leak inquiry, Churchill's questioning of him and his offer to resign are on a different paper. They are numbered "130" and "130a" and are, "equally clearly, ... pages added later". The same episode appears in Middle East Diary.[34]

The 1948 Haifa claim

In Middle East Diary, under 23 April 1948, Meinertzhagen described going ashore at Haifa from his ship in a borrowed soldier's uniform and fighting beside the Haganah against Arab snipers. "My first shot was a bull's-eye," he wrote, and he ended the entry: "Altogether I had had a glorious day. May Israel flourish!"[35] Garfield found that the ship, the Empress of Scotland, called at Haifa on 25 April 1948. A few days later, in a letter to his friend F. M. Bailey, Meinertzhagen described the fighting at Haifa as something he had witnessed, "not participated in", in Garfield's words, and did not mention going ashore. Neither the Secret Intelligence Service, which had a suspected arms dealer on the ship under surveillance, nor anyone else on board or on shore reported the episode, "Nor did any Haganah soldier mention having seen it."[36]

Richard Meinertzhagen in Nairobi, 1915. Scan of a printed plate captioned "R. M. in Nairobi 1915"; photographer unknown. Wikimedia Commons gives the source as the Kenya Diaries.
Richard Meinertzhagen, asserted date 1922. Photographer unknown. The image reached Wikimedia Commons from the parasitology website phthiraptera.org; the 1922 date has not been corroborated from a contemporary publication.

Notes

  1. ↑ Who Was Who, "Meinertzhagen, Col Richard, (3 March 1878–17 June 1967), late Duke of Cornwall's Light Inf.; ornithologist", Oxford University Press, online edition, 2007, entry heading, accessed 18 November 2026.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 Who's Who 1954, London: A. & C. Black, 1954, entry "MEINERTZHAGEN, Col. Richard".
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 Colonel Meinertzhagen (Cairo) to Earl Curzon, 26 September 1919, in E. L. Woodward and Rohan Butler (eds), Documents on British Foreign Policy 1919–1939, First Series, vol. IV: 1919, London: HMSO, 1952, no. 298, p. 424, accessed 18 November 2026.
  4. ↑ Storrs L. Olson, review of Brian Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery: The Life and Legend of a Colossal Fraud (Washington, DC: Potomac Books, 2007), The Wilson Journal of Ornithology, vol. 120, no. 4, December 2008, pp. 917–920, at pp. 917, 920, accessed 18 November 2026.
  5. ↑ Who's Who 1926, London: A. & C. Black, 1926, "Meinertzhagen, Col. Richard, D.S.O.", accessed 18 November 2026.
  6. ↑ David E. Omissi, "Biographical notes", in Air Power and Colonial Control: The Royal Air Force 1919–1939, Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1990 (online edition 2017), accessed 18 November 2026.
  7. ↑ Brian Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery: The Life and Legend of a Colossal Fraud, Washington, DC: Potomac Books, 2007 (ISBN 978-1-59797-041-9), pp. 134, 136.
  8. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, pp. 137–138.
  9. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, pp. 144–145, citing Meinertzhagen to Foreign Office, 14 April 1920, in Woodward and Butler (eds), Documents on British Foreign Policy 1919–1939.
  10. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, p. 148.
  11. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, p. 149.
  12. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, p. 154.
  13. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, pp. 155–156.
  14. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, pp. 157–158.
  15. ↑ Pamela C. Rasmussen and Robert P. Prŷs-Jones, "History vs mystery: the reliability of museum specimen data", Bulletin of the British Ornithologists' Club, vol. 123A, 2003, pp. 66–94, at pp. 84–85, accessed 18 November 2026.
  16. ↑ Alan G. Knox, "Richard Meinertzhagen—a case of fraud examined", Ibis, vol. 135, no. 3, 1993, pp. 320–325, doi:10.1111/j.1474-919X.1993.tb02851.x.
  17. ↑ Olson, review of Garfield, p. 917.
  18. ↑ Richard Meinertzhagen, Middle East Diary 1917–1956, New York: Thomas Yoseloff, 1960 (first published London: Cresset Press, 1959), p. ix.
  19. ↑ Meinertzhagen, Middle East Diary, p. 7.
  20. ↑ Meinertzhagen, Middle East Diary, p. 9.
  21. ↑ Meinertzhagen, Middle East Diary, pp. 24–25.
  22. ↑ Meinertzhagen to Curzon, 26 September 1919, Documents on British Foreign Policy, First Series, vol. IV, no. 298, p. 427; also printed in Meinertzhagen, Middle East Diary, pp. 49–53.
  23. ↑ Meinertzhagen (Cairo) to Curzon, 17 November 1919, Documents on British Foreign Policy, First Series, vol. IV, no. 366, pp. 532–533; also printed in Meinertzhagen, Middle East Diary, p. 61.
  24. ↑ Meinertzhagen, Middle East Diary, p. 67.
  25. ↑ Meinertzhagen, Middle East Diary, p. 97.
  26. ↑ Meinertzhagen, Middle East Diary, p. 99.
  27. ↑ Meinertzhagen, Middle East Diary, p. 221.
  28. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, pp. 120, 124.
  29. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, p. 139.
  30. ↑ 30.0 30.1 Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, p. 140, quoting Sahar Huneidi, "Was the Balfour Policy Reversible? The Colonial Office and Palestine, 1921–23", Journal of Palestine Studies, vol. 27, no. 2, 1998, p. 38 n. 6.
  31. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, p. 141.
  32. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, p. 142, discussing Meinertzhagen, Middle East Diary, p. 84.
  33. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, p. 242.
  34. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, p. 297 n. 69, discussing Meinertzhagen, Middle East Diary, p. 117.
  35. ↑ Meinertzhagen, Middle East Diary, pp. 222–223.
  36. ↑ Garfield, The Meinertzhagen Mystery, p. 235, citing Meinertzhagen to Bailey, India Office Library, and TNA FO 371/68418.