American Council for Judaism

From Powerbase
Revision as of 17:04, 13 November 2026 by Powerbase research (talk | contribs) (Create page (Moser Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History batch))
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

American Jewish organisation founded in 1942 by Reform rabbis to oppose Zionism and the creation of a Jewish state; relaunched in 2024

American Council for Judaism

Type Advocacy and educational organisation (Reform Judaism)
Founded 1942
Founder(s) Reform rabbis led by Louis Wolsey[1]
Location United States
Area served United States
Services Jewish education, religious guidance and community-building "beyond nationalism" (the Council's own description)[2]
Key people Lessing J. Rosenwald (first president); Elmer Berger (executive director to 1968); Rabbi Andrue Kahn (executive director since 2024)[1][2]
Website https://acjna.org

The American Council for Judaism (ACJ) is an American Jewish organisation founded in 1942 by a group of Reform rabbis to protest a resolution of the Central Conference of American Rabbis supporting a Jewish army in Palestine.[1] The Encyclopaedia Judaica calls it "the only American Jewish organization ever created to fight Zionism and the establishment of a Jewish state".[1] Thomas A. Kolsky, whose 1990 study is the only book-length history of the Council's first years, calls it "the only American Jewish organization ever formed for the specific purpose of fighting Zionism and opposing the establishment of a Jewish state in Palestine".[3] Benjamin Moser, in Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History, says it "led the charge against Zionism in the United States".[4]

After the 1967 war it lost several prominent supporters.[1] The organisation was reconstituted in 2024 with a new board and a rabbinic executive director, and now describes its work as "Judaism beyond nationalism".[2]

History

Founding, 1942–1948

According to the Council's own timeline, thirty-six Reform rabbis met in Atlantic City in 1942 to discuss opposing a Zionist resolution at the Central Conference of American Rabbis convention; the ACJ was founded with Rabbi Elmer Berger as executive director and Lessing J. Rosenwald as president.[2] The Encyclopaedia Judaica says the thirty-six dissident rabbis included some who wished to revitalise Reform Judaism and some who opposed Zionism, and that within a year leadership passed to laymen, led by Rosenwald, "an heir to the Sears Roebuck fortune", and Berger, so that the Council became "a secular anti-Zionist pressure group".[1]

The index to Kolsky's study records that the 1942 "Jewish army resolution" of the CCAR "sparked" the "rebellion of dissident Reform rabbis" (book pp. 42–55),[5] that the dissidents met at an Atlantic City conference (pp. 49–54) which James G. Heller, the CCAR's president elected in 1942, tried to prevent (pp. 47–48),[6] and that Louis Wolsey is indexed as the Council's founder (pp. 1, 3, 44–68), with Berger's selection as executive director at pp. 57–62.[7] The same index lists a "Baltimore meeting (January 1943), of ACJ and CCAR" (p. 63), Heller's "peacemaking attempt with ACJ" (pp. 63–65), the Council's "refusal to liquidate itself" (pp. 63–64, 190) and its "humiliation at 1943 CCAR convention" (pp. 72–74).[7][8] The book's chapters on these events are "The Rebellion of the Dissident Reform Rabbis" (p. 37) and "The Formation of the American Council for Judaism" (p. 57).[9]

The Encyclopaedia Judaica entry says the Council sought without success to form an alliance with the non-Zionist American Jewish Committee, "but non-Zionism was rather different from anti-Zionism", and that before 1948 it accepted the report of the Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry on the immigration of 100,000 Jews to Palestine "but not a Jewish state".[1] Berger published The Jewish Dilemma in 1945, which the Council describes as setting out its critique of Zionism.[2]

Moser describes the Council as "especially prominent in the South", where Jewish communities were more integrated, and says it brought the New York rabbi Hyman Judah Schachtel to the attention of Congregation Beth Israel in Houston.[4] Schachtel, one of the Council's "hawks", resigned from it at the end of 1948, after the establishment of Israel.[10]

After 1948

After the state of Israel was founded, the Encyclopaedia Judaica says, the Council "sought to limit Israel's influence on Diaspora Jewry, to promote integration of Jews, and to establish institutions that were resistant to Zionism".[1] It ran a quarterly journal, Issues (discontinued after November 1969), a religious education programme "devoid of 'Zionist' influence" and a separate philanthropic fund; by the end of 1955 it had established ten schools teaching classical Reform positions, and it claimed 20,000 members.[1] The historian Kyle Stanton reports that in Houston the Council's partisans left Beth Israel in the late 1950s and formed the Houston Congregation for Reform Judaism, whose religious school was affiliated with the ACJ.[11]

The Encyclopaedia Judaica records that the Council "has occupied an isolated position in Jewish life in America", that the 1967 war led several of its most prestigious lay supporters to leave, and that Berger was ousted in 1968.[1] It quotes the historian Thomas Kolsky: "In the end the Council failed … the organization became neither a focus for the revival of the classical version of Reform Judaism nor an effective force for fighting Zionism and preventing the establishment of a Jewish state."[1]

Renewal, 2007 onwards

The Council says it spun off the Society for Classical Reform Judaism, now Roots of Reform Judaism, in 2007, and that in 2024 it reconstituted its board with a new generation of leadership under Rabbi Andrue Kahn.[2] Its website describes its mission as offering "Jewish education, intercommunal connections, and religious guidance beyond nationalism—free from the Zionist idea of Judaism as a nationality".[2]

Anti-Zionism?

The Zionist state. Before 1948 the Council opposed the creation of a Jewish state; Kolsky describes its purpose as "opposing the establishment of a Jewish state in Palestine".[3] The Encyclopaedia Judaica says it "opposed the establishment of Israel and remained critical of what it calls 'the Israel-Zionist domination of American Jewish life'", and quotes its ideology: "Israel is the homeland of its own citizens only, and not of all Jews."[1] The same entry does not report a call by the Council after 1948 to dismantle the existing state. The renewed Council's website says the connection of Jews to the land "does not require the establishment or perpetuation of a state structured around Jewish privilege", and that the Council "advocates transforming Israel-Palestine into a genuinely pluralistic democracy".[2]

A replacement state. The Encyclopaedia Judaica entry reports no proposal by the 1942–1948 Council for a replacement state. The index to Kolsky's study, which gives topics and page numbers rather than the text, lists under the Council a "Palestine peace plan offered by (1947), 170–171", "trusteeship proposals of, 170, 181", "binational state rejected by, 114", "rejection of Morrison-Grady plan (1946) by, 145" and "rejection of UNSCOP partition plan (1947), 171", and, under "equal rights", "ACJ's advocacy of" at pp. 71, 90, 93, 102, 124, 132 and 170.[7][12] The index also lists the Council's "acceptance of partition as fait accompli" (pp. 172, 191), "dissociation from Jewish state" (pp. 164, 173, 177, 178, 189–191) and "acceptance of reality of" Israel (pp. 189–190).[7][13] Its statements of principles are indexed at pp. 51–52 (early statement), 69–70, 75–76 and 203–205 (1943) and 177–178 (1948).[7] The renewed Council's website states that it "advocates transforming Israel-Palestine into a genuinely pluralistic democracy where Jews, Palestinians, and all inhabitants are treated equally, with dignity and full civil rights", and calls for "truth-telling, tangible reparations such as the right of return and restitution".[2] The page does not say whether the "pluralistic democracy" would be one state or more than one, and does not use the terms "one state", "single state", "binational" or "two-state".[2]

The Zionist movement. The Council's target was Zionist influence on American Jewish institutions rather than the dissolution of the Zionist bodies: the Encyclopaedia Judaica says it sought to build "institutions that were resistant to Zionism".[1] Its website now says that "Jewish communal institutions which fall under Zionism's umbrella exclude anti-Zionist, and non-Zionist, Jews from community resources", and that the Council "opposes these totalizing claims of Jewish nationalism".[2] The Encyclopaedia Judaica reports that the Council was often accused of advocating "the Arab anti-Israel viewpoint".[1]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13 Frank N. Sundheim and Michael Berenbaum, American Council for Judaism Encyclopaedia Judaica (via Encyclopedia.com), accessed 13 November 2026.
  2. ↑ 2.00 2.01 2.02 2.03 2.04 2.05 2.06 2.07 2.08 2.09 2.10 American Council for Judaism, About Us acjna.org, accessed 13 November 2026.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 Thomas A. Kolsky, Jews Against Zionism: The American Council for Judaism, 1942–1948 (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1990), p. ix.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 Benjamin Moser, Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History (New York: Doubleday, 2026), p. 147.
  5. ↑ Kolsky, Jews Against Zionism, index, p. 263 ("Jewish army resolution (1942)").
  6. ↑ Kolsky, Jews Against Zionism, index, pp. 258–259 ("Atlantic City conference"), p. 262 ("Heller, James G.").
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 Kolsky, Jews Against Zionism, index, pp. 257–258 ("American Council for Judaism") and p. 259 ("Berger, Elmer").
  8. ↑ Kolsky, Jews Against Zionism, index, p. 259 ("Baltimore meeting"), p. 262 ("Heller, James G.").
  9. ↑ Kolsky, Jews Against Zionism, contents, p. vii.
  10. ↑ Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 162.
  11. ↑ Kyle Stanton, Hyman Judah Schachtel, Congregation Beth Israel, and the American Council for Judaism Southern Jewish History vol. 22 (2019), pp. 127–150, accessed 13 November 2026.
  12. ↑ Kolsky, Jews Against Zionism, index, p. 261 ("equal rights"), p. 267 ("trusteeship for Palestine").
  13. ↑ Kolsky, Jews Against Zionism, index, p. 263 ("Israel").