Congregation Beth Israel (Houston)
Reform congregation in Houston, Texas, whose 1943 "Basic Principles" rejecting Jewish nationalism split the congregation; the principles were repealed in 1968
| Congregation Beth Israel (Houston)
| |
|---|---|
| Type | Reform synagogue |
| Founded | 1844[1] |
| Location | Houston, Texas, United States |
| Key people | Henry Barnston (rabbi for forty-three years to 1943); Hyman Judah Schachtel (rabbi, 1943–1975); Leopold Meyer (president during the controversy)[1][2] |
Congregation Beth Israel is a Reform congregation in Houston, Texas. In 1943 its board adopted a set of "Basic Principles" that included a rejection of Jewish nationalism, which provoked a national controversy and split the congregation.[1] Benjamin Moser, in Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History, devotes a chapter, "The Houston Schism", to the affair; he calls Beth Israel "a flagship of American Judaism, its origins stretching back to 1844, when Texas was still an independent republic", and "the oldest temple in Texas and the largest congregation in the South".[1]
The Basic Principles, 1943
The congregation's rabbi, Henry Barnston, had served for forty-three years;[1] Moser says he was dismissed in 1943, and Stanton that the board forced him into retirement.[3][4] The board appointed Hyman Judah Schachtel, who had been active in the American Council for Judaism.[5] On 7 September 1943 the board of trustees approved a single page of seven "Basic Principles", of which the second read: "We are Jews by virtue of our acceptance of Judaism. We consider ourselves no longer a nation but we are a religious community and, therefore, we expect neither a return to Palestine nor a restoration of any of the laws concerning the Jewish State. We stand unequivocally for the separation of Church and State. We are neither a nation, a nationality nor a race. Our religion is Judaism. Our nation is the United States of America."[6] New members would have to accept the principles or become non-voting "associate members".[6]
Moser says the board explained the second principle by the history of the Reform movement, citing earlier statements including the 1885 Pittsburgh Platform, whose wording it echoes.[7] A congregational meeting on 23 November 1943, "the largest in the history of the congregation", with more than eight hundred present, approved the principles by 632 votes to 168.[8]
The principles were attacked in the Jewish and national press. Moser reports that the New York Congress Weekly called them "a set of 'Nuremberg laws'", that the rabbi Stephen S. Wise denounced the congregation in Opinion, and that Time magazine ran an article, "Storm over Zion", on 17 January 1944, quoting Schachtel: "Our congregation does not oppose Zionism. We simply do not participate in it."[9] The board maintained that Jews belonged "not among the League of Nations but among the League of Religions", while stating a duty to aid Jews everywhere, including in Palestine.[10]
The split
Zionist members held the first meeting of a new congregation, Emanu El, on 8 June 1944.[11] Kyle Stanton, writing in Southern Jewish History, says that more than 140 families out of a membership of about 800 left Beth Israel as a result of the Basic Principles and formed Emanu El, "a distinctly Zionist Reform congregation".[4] Stanton adds that in the late 1950s a further dispute over the influence of the American Council for Judaism led to the founding of another Reform congregation in Houston, the Houston Congregation for Reform Judaism.[4]
Later history
After the establishment of Israel, Moser says, Schachtel tried to bury the controversy and resigned from the American Council for Judaism at the end of 1948.[11] Stanton says that Beth Israel rescinded the Basic Principles in 1968, after the Six-Day War and the emergence of mass support for Israel in the United States, and that the differences between Beth Israel and Emanu El had by then greatly diminished.[4] Moser also gives 1968 for the repeal.[12]
Anti-Zionism?
The Zionist state. The Basic Principles rejected an expectation of "a return to Palestine" and "a restoration of any of the laws concerning the Jewish State".[6] In May 1944, Moser reports, the rabbi emeritus, Barnston, said of the attacks on the congregation: "This only shows how very far we Jews are from being able to govern ourselves as a distinct nation."[11] Schachtel's public position was that the congregation did not "oppose Zionism" but did "not participate in it".[9]
A replacement state. Moser does not attribute to the congregation a proposal for a Palestinian or other state in place of a Jewish one.
The Zionist movement. Moser reports no call by the congregation for the dissolution of Zionist organisations; the board's contention was that "rejection of nationalism was fundamental to their faith in a universal religion".[13] The congregation withdrew the principles in 1968.[4]
See also
- Hyman Judah Schachtel
- American Council for Judaism
- Pittsburgh Platform
- Central Conference of American Rabbis
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 Benjamin Moser, Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History (New York: Doubleday, 2026), pp. 141–142.
- ↑ Phyllis Harris, Schachtel, Hyman Judah Handbook of Texas Online, Texas State Historical Association, accessed 13 November 2026.
- ↑ Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 161.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 Kyle Stanton, Hyman Judah Schachtel, Congregation Beth Israel, and the American Council for Judaism Southern Jewish History vol. 22 (2019), pp. 127–150, accessed 13 November 2026.
- ↑ Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 147.
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 Moser, Anti-Zionism, pp. 142–143.
- ↑ Moser, Anti-Zionism, pp. 150–152.
- ↑ Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 154.
- ↑ 9.0 9.1 Moser, Anti-Zionism, pp. 153–157.
- ↑ Moser, Anti-Zionism, pp. 160–161.
- ↑ 11.0 11.1 11.2 Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 162.
- ↑ Moser, Anti-Zionism, pp. 163–164.
- ↑ Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 153.