Brit Shalom
Society founded in Jerusalem in 1925 to promote Jewish–Arab rapprochement through a binational state in Palestine; inactive by 1933
| Brit Shalom
| |
|---|---|
| Type | Society promoting Jewish–Arab rapprochement |
| Founded | 1925 |
| Founder(s) | Arthur Ruppin (initiator)[1] |
| Status | Virtually ceased to exist by 1933[1] |
| Location | Jerusalem, Mandatory Palestine |
| Key people | Arthur Ruppin (chairman to 1929); Joseph Lurie (chairman from 1929); Hugo Bergmann; Hans Kohn; Gershom Scholem; Ernst Simon; Robert Weltsch |
| Remarks | Never numbered more than 200 members; attacked by most Zionist parties[1] |
Brit Shalom (also transliterated Berit Shalom; Hebrew for "Covenant of Peace") was a society founded in Jerusalem in 1925 "to foster relations of rapprochement between Jews and Arabs in Palestine, on the basis of a bi-national solution to the conflict between them, with Jews and Arabs having an equal share in the administration regardless of the size of their respective populations", according to the Encyclopaedia Judaica.[1] It never numbered more than 200 members and had virtually ceased to exist by 1933.[1]
Benjamin Moser, in Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History, places Brit Shalom within "cultural" or "spiritual center" Zionism, and says that "many members of Brit Shalom opposed the partition of Palestine and advocated for a binational or one-state solution".[2]
History
The immediate trigger for the society's founding, the Encyclopaedia Judaica says, was a lecture at the opening of the Hebrew University by the Orientalist Joseph Horowitz of Frankfurt, and the initiative came from Arthur Ruppin.[1] It identifies three groups among the active members: East European immigrants who arrived before the First World War, were academically trained and "shared a practical political approach to Zionism" (including Ruppin, Jacob Thon, Joseph Lurie, Yitzhak Epstein, Haim Margolis-Kalvaryski and Rabbi Binyamin); from about 1929, a more ideological group of Central European intellectuals strongly influenced by Martin Buber (Hugo Bergmann, Hans Kohn, Gershom Scholem, Ernst Simon and Robert Weltsch); and a group of so-called "Anglo-Saxons", mostly men employed by the Palestine Administration, including Edwin Samuel, son of the first High Commissioner Herbert Samuel, and the attorney general Norman Bentwich.[1]
The entry says that from the start members differed over purpose: Ruppin wanted a research group that would present its findings to the Zionist leadership, while others wanted a political programme of their own. Ruppin chaired the society until 1929, and the more activist line was carried out by his successor, Joseph Lurie.[1] In 1930 senior members published four memoranda, the first of which, Memorandum by the Brit Shalom Society on an Arab Policy for the Jewish Agency, was submitted to the Zionist Executive in London in February; the last was a "Judeao-Arab Covenant" prepared by Kalvaryski and given to a member of the Arab Executive.[1] The monthly She'ifoteinu ("Our Aspirations") was its journal.[1]
The Encyclopaedia Judaica says that the society "was attacked by most of the Zionist parties, who viewed its members as defeatists at best and traitors and worst", and that many members deserted it and it ran out of funds.[1]
Judah Magnes
Moser lists Judah Magnes, with Martin Buber and Henrietta Szold, among Brit Shalom's "most prominent spokespeople".[2] The Encyclopaedia Judaica says Magnes, who also advocated bi-nationalism, "was never a member of the society, even though his name was frequently identified with it".[1]
Anti-Zionism?
The Zionist state. According to the Encyclopaedia Judaica, "bi-nationalism for Berit Shalom was not an ideal but a function of reality", and the first of its 1930 memoranda was addressed to the Zionist Executive as a proposal for an "Arab policy" for the Jewish Agency.[1] Moser says many of its members opposed the partition of Palestine into separate Jewish and Arab states.[2]
A replacement state. It proposed a binational arrangement in Palestine, with Jews and Arabs having an equal share in the administration irrespective of population size.[1] Moser describes the hope of its members as an "independent, democratic Palestine" in which "a new kind of Jewish culture could develop, including the Hebrew language".[2] Rabbi Binyamin, the first editor of its monthly, who demanded an agreement with the Arabs on the basis of unlimited Jewish immigration, was replaced when a majority of members declared themselves ready to accept a temporary limitation of immigration to facilitate an agreement.[1]
The Zionist movement. Neither source reports a call to dissolve the Zionist movement. The Encyclopaedia Judaica says that Ruppin wanted the society to be a research group that would present its results to the Zionist leadership.[1]