Difference between revisions of "Zinoviev Letter"
(Create page: Zinoviev Letter, 1924 forgery leaked before the general election (Gill Bennett/OUP, The Guardian, The Independent)) |
(Link Grigori Zinoviev (new page)) |
||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
| outcome = Published four days before the general election of 29 October 1924, which the Labour government lost<ref name="BennettZL"/> | | outcome = Published four days before the general election of 29 October 1924, which the Labour government lost<ref name="BennettZL"/> | ||
}} | }} | ||
| − | The [[Zinoviev Letter]] was a document, purportedly sent on 15 September 1924 by Grigori Zinoviev, head of the [[Comintern]], to the central committee of the [[Communist Party of Great Britain]] (CPGB), which was published by the ''[[The Daily Mail|Daily Mail]]'' on 25 October 1924, four days before a general election.<ref name="BennettZL"/> Its text reached London in a telegram from the Riga station of the [[Secret Intelligence Service]] (SIS); no original was ever found, the CPGB denied receiving it, and Zinoviev denied writing it.<ref name="BennettZL"/> A study by the Foreign Office's chief historian, Gill Bennett, published in 1999, concluded that the letter was almost certainly a forgery and that it had probably been leaked from SIS to the [[Conservative Party]].<ref name="GuardianZL99"/><ref name="IndependentZL99">Louise Jury, [https://www.independent.co.uk/news/official-zinoviev-letter-was-forged-1068600.html "Official: Zinoviev letter was forged"], ''The Independent'', 4 February 1999, accessed 18 November 2026.</ref> | + | The [[Zinoviev Letter]] was a document, purportedly sent on 15 September 1924 by [[Grigori Zinoviev]], head of the [[Comintern]], to the central committee of the [[Communist Party of Great Britain]] (CPGB), which was published by the ''[[The Daily Mail|Daily Mail]]'' on 25 October 1924, four days before a general election.<ref name="BennettZL"/> Its text reached London in a telegram from the Riga station of the [[Secret Intelligence Service]] (SIS); no original was ever found, the CPGB denied receiving it, and Zinoviev denied writing it.<ref name="BennettZL"/> A study by the Foreign Office's chief historian, Gill Bennett, published in 1999, concluded that the letter was almost certainly a forgery and that it had probably been leaked from SIS to the [[Conservative Party]].<ref name="GuardianZL99"/><ref name="IndependentZL99">Louise Jury, [https://www.independent.co.uk/news/official-zinoviev-letter-was-forged-1068600.html "Official: Zinoviev letter was forged"], ''The Independent'', 4 February 1999, accessed 18 November 2026.</ref> |
==Background and publication== | ==Background and publication== | ||
Latest revision as of 07:09, 19 November 2026
Purported 1924 instruction from the Comintern chief Grigori Zinoviev to the Communist Party of Great Britain, received through SIS's Riga station and published by the Daily Mail four days before the October 1924 general election; a 1999 Foreign Office study concluded it was almost certainly a forgery
| Zinoviev Letter
| |
|---|---|
First page of the circulated copy of the Zinoviev Letter, October 1924. Source: Wikimedia Commons (public domain) | |
| Type | Purported Comintern letter; political scandal |
| Date | Letter dated 15 September 1924; received by SIS 9 October 1924; published 25 October 1924[1] |
| Location | United Kingdom; Riga, Latvia (SIS station)[1] |
| Participants | Secret Intelligence Service; Foreign Office; Communist Party of Great Britain; Conservative Party; Daily Mail[1][2] |
| Inquiry status | Foreign Office history study by Gill Bennett, published February 1999[2] |
| Outcome | Published four days before the general election of 29 October 1924, which the Labour government lost[1] |
The Zinoviev Letter was a document, purportedly sent on 15 September 1924 by Grigori Zinoviev, head of the Comintern, to the central committee of the Communist Party of Great Britain (CPGB), which was published by the Daily Mail on 25 October 1924, four days before a general election.[1] Its text reached London in a telegram from the Riga station of the Secret Intelligence Service (SIS); no original was ever found, the CPGB denied receiving it, and Zinoviev denied writing it.[1] A study by the Foreign Office's chief historian, Gill Bennett, published in 1999, concluded that the letter was almost certainly a forgery and that it had probably been leaked from SIS to the Conservative Party.[2][3]
Background and publication
According to Bennett, the letter arrived at SIS head office on 9 October 1924, the day after Britain's first Labour government, under Ramsay MacDonald, was defeated in a Commons censure vote and MacDonald sought a dissolution.[1] The Guardian summarised it as calling on British communists to mobilise "sympathetic forces" in the Labour Party to support an Anglo-Soviet treaty, including a loan to the Bolshevik government, and to encourage "agitation-propaganda" in the armed forces.[2]
The Independent reported that the intelligence services made no effort to authenticate the document but distributed it to the Foreign Office, Scotland Yard and the War Office with the note: "The authenticity of the document is undoubted."[3] Within a fortnight of its arrival copies had reached Conservative Central Office and the Conservative-supporting press, and on 25 October the Daily Mail published it together with a Foreign Office note of protest which, according to MacDonald, had been issued without his authorisation.[1] The paper's front-page headlines read: "Civil War Plot by Socialists' Masters: Moscow Orders To Our Reds; Great Plot Disclosed".[2]
Election
At the election on 29 October 1924 Labour polled over a million more votes than in December 1923, but the Conservatives won 48.3 per cent of the vote against Labour's 33 per cent, while the Liberals fell to 17.6 per cent. Bennett writes that the letter "may, as all parties claimed, have damaged the Labour vote; it did not lose them the election".[1] In her 1999 report she concluded that "in electoral terms ... the impact of the Zinoviev letter on Labour was more psychological than measurable".[2]
Foreign Office study (1999)
Bennett's 128-page study was commissioned by the Foreign Secretary, Robin Cook, and drew on SIS and MI5 files and on Soviet archives in Moscow.[2][3] The Guardian reported that it pointed "the finger at Desmond Morton, an MI6 officer and close friend of Churchill", and at Major Joseph Ball, an MI5 officer who joined Conservative Central Office in 1926. Bennett said the letter "probably was leaked from SIS ... by somebody to the Conservative Party Central Office", and said of Morton: "I have my doubts as to whether he thought it was genuine but [Morton] treated it as if it was." Other possible conduits included Stewart Menzies, a future head of SIS, who according to SIS files admitted sending a copy to the Mail.[2]
Bennett found no evidence identifying the forger, attributing the letter to a campaign by White Russian émigrés opposed to the Anglo-Soviet treaty.[2][3] According to The Guardian, she found no evidence of a conspiracy in "the institutional sense", but described the intelligence community of the time as "a very, very incestuous circle, an elite network" whose allegiances "lay firmly in the Conservative camp"; the report also showed that SIS had misled the Foreign Office by claiming to know the source in order to insist that the letter was genuine.[2] The Independent reported that Bennett did not think the full answer was knowable: "The story remains incomplete ... the Zinoviev Letter remains, as before, a most extraordinary and mysterious business."[3]
In her 2018 book on the affair, Bennett restated that she had concluded the letter "was almost certainly a forgery" but could not say who forged it, and that a coordinated conspiracy among civil servants or intelligence officers seemed to her "very unlikely".[1]
See also
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 Gill Bennett, The Zinoviev Letter: The Conspiracy that Never Dies, Oxford University Press, 2018, Introduction, pp. 1, 4, 12 (publisher's preview), accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 Richard Norton-Taylor, "Zinoviev letter was dirty trick by MI6", The Guardian, 4 February 1999, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 Louise Jury, "Official: Zinoviev letter was forged", The Independent, 4 February 1999, accessed 18 November 2026.