R (E) v Governing Body of JFS

From Powerbase
Jump to navigation Jump to search

2009 UK Supreme Court judgment on the admissions policy of JFS

R (E) v Governing Body of JFS

250
The Supreme Court building (Middlesex Guildhall), London. Photograph by Dietmar Rabich, 10 October 2016 (CC BY-SA 4.0).
Type Court case
Date 16 December 2009
Location London
Participants E (claimant); the governing body of JFS; the admissions appeal panel of JFS; the United Synagogue
Charges Direct and indirect discrimination on grounds of ethnic origins, contrary to the Race Relations Act 1976
Court Supreme Court of the United Kingdom
Verdict Appeal of the governing body dismissed by a majority of five to four on the direct-discrimination issue; the United Synagogue's appeal on costs allowed in part
Outcome The school's admissions policy was held to be direct discrimination on grounds of ethnic origins
Website Judgment; press summary

R (E) v Governing Body of JFS and the Admissions Appeal Panel of JFS [2009] UKSC 15 is a judgment of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, given on 16 December 2009, on the admissions policy of JFS, a voluntary-aided Jewish secondary school in the London Borough of Brent. By a majority of five to four the court held that the school's oversubscription policy, which gave priority to children recognised as Jewish by the Office of the Chief Rabbi of the United Hebrew Congregations of the Commonwealth (the OCR), was direct discrimination on grounds of ethnic origins contrary to section 1(1)(a) of the Race Relations Act 1976.[1][2]

Facts

When oversubscribed, JFS used an admissions policy that gave priority to children recognised as Jewish by the OCR: either descent in the matrilineal line from a woman the OCR would recognise as Jewish, or a qualifying Orthodox conversion.[2]

In 2009 a father, anonymised in the proceedings as E, challenged the school's refusal to admit his son, M. E and M were practising Masorti Jews. The OCR recognised E as Jewish, but M's mother had converted under the auspices of a non-Orthodox synagogue, and that conversion was not recognised by the OCR, so the school rejected the application.[2] E argued that the policy was direct discrimination on grounds of ethnic origins, or alternatively indirect discrimination. The High Court of Justice rejected both claims. The Court of Appeal of England and Wales unanimously reversed that decision and held that the school had directly discriminated against M on the ground of his ethnic origins.[2]

Judgment

On 16 December 2009 the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom dismissed the governing body's appeal by a majority of five to four on the direct-discrimination issue (Lord Phillips, President, Lady Hale, Lord Mance, Lord Kerr and Lord Clarke; Lord Hope, Lord Rodger, Lord Walker and Lord Brown dissenting). The majority held that the school had directly discriminated against M on grounds of his ethnic origins. Lords Hope and Walker would have found that the policy was indirectly discriminatory and that the school had not shown it to be proportionate; Lords Rodger and Brown would have allowed the school's appeal in full.[1][2]

The court said the judgments should not be read as criticising the policy on moral grounds or as suggesting that any party was "racist" in the ordinary sense of the word; the legal question was whether M was disadvantaged on grounds of his ethnic origins.[1] The United Synagogue's appeal on costs was allowed in part.[2]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, R (E) v Governing Body of JFS and the Admissions Appeal Panel of JFS [2009 UKSC 15] Supreme Court, 16 December 2009, accessed 19 November 2026.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, Press summary: R (E) v Governing Body of JFS and the Admissions Appeal Panel of JFS [2009 UKSC 15] Supreme Court, 16 December 2009, accessed 19 November 2026.