McDonald Commission
Canadian federal commission of inquiry (1977–1981), chaired by Justice David McDonald, into illegal activities by the RCMP Security Service, whose recommendation of a separate civilian agency led to the creation of CSIS in 1984
| McDonald Commission
| |
|---|---|
| Logo | Shield of the arms of Canada. Source: Wikimedia Commons (public domain) |
| Type | Federal commission of inquiry (formally the Commission of Inquiry Concerning Certain Activities of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police)[1] |
| Founded | 6 July 1977 (appointment announced by Solicitor General Fox)[1] |
| Dissolved | 1981 (final report released 25 August 1981)[1] |
| Area served | Canada |
| Services | Inquiry into investigative practices of the RCMP Security Service "not authorized or provided for by law", and advice on national security policies and procedures[1] |
| Key people | Justice D. C. McDonald[1] (Chair) |
| Remarks | Recommended a civilian security intelligence agency separate from the RCMP, created in 1984 as the Canadian Security Intelligence Service[1][2] |
The McDonald Commission, formally the Commission of Inquiry Concerning Certain Activities of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, was a Canadian federal inquiry set up in 1977 after revelations of apparently illegal acts by the Security Service of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP). Its 1981 report recommended replacing the Security Service with a separate civilian agency, which was created in July 1984 as the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS).[1][2]
Background
According to a Library of Parliament paper, the Security Service had developed "gradually and incrementally" within the RCMP and had no distinct statutory basis.[1] On 6 July 1977 Solicitor General Fox announced the appointment of Justice D. C. McDonald to head an inquiry into allegations of RCMP wrongdoing.[1] The commission was to establish the extent of investigative practices "not authorized or provided for by law", report the facts, advise on how to deal with them, and advise generally on changes to "policies and procedures regarding national security".[1]
The Canadian Encyclopedia lists the matters referred to the commission as including a break-in at a data-processing company and the theft of a Parti Québécois membership list; some 400 warrantless break-ins, mainly in British Columbia; electronic surveillance of at least one member of Parliament; unauthorised mail opening; the burning of a barn in Quebec; widespread monitoring of election candidates; theft of dynamite; and the use of forged documents. The former RCMP Commissioner William Higgitt and the former Security Service Director General John Starnes testified that they knew subordinates occasionally broke the law, while Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau and other ministers testified that they had not been told of such activities.[2]
Findings and recommendations
The Library of Parliament paper says the commission "catalogued the many illegalities and improprieties" and found that the Security Service's political masters were, on the whole, ignorant of its misdeeds – an exoneration that was also a criticism of weak control and accountability. It found that the service lacked sophistication and analytical ability, showed "an inability to distinguish subversion from dissent and a concomitant anti-left wing bias", and lacked a precise mandate, effective political control and adequate review.[1]
Its principal recommendation was a separate civilian security agency, because "law enforcement and security work are incompatible". The new agency would have a statutory mandate covering espionage and sabotage, foreign interference, political violence and terrorism, and revolutionary subversion; it would be expressly forbidden from investigating lawful advocacy, protest or dissent; and intrusive techniques such as electronic surveillance, surreptitious entry and mail opening would be used only under judicial warrant.[1] The commission also recommended that the police comply strictly with the law.[2]
Outcome
After the final report was released on 25 August 1981, the government introduced legislation based on the commission's framework. A revised bill, C-9, was given first reading on 18 January 1984 and passed in June 1984; most of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act came into force on 16 July 1984, and the Security Intelligence Review Committee was established later that year.[1]
See also
- Canadian Security Intelligence Service
- Security Intelligence Review Committee
- National Security and Intelligence Review Agency
- Reg Whitaker
- Gregory S. Kealey
- Andrew Parnaby
- Ted Finn
Notes
- ↑ 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 1.11 1.12 Philip Rosen, The Canadian Security Intelligence Service, Library of Parliament, Parliamentary Research Branch, current issue review 84-27E, revised 24 January 2000, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 Jeffrey Sallot, "Royal Commission on Inquiry Into Certain Activities of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police", The Canadian Encyclopedia, Historica Canada, published 7 February 2006, last edited 16 December 2013, accessed 18 November 2026.