Is Labour Anti-Semitic?
2019 BBC Panorama documentary reported by John Ware on the handling of antisemitism complaints in the Labour Party under Jeremy Corbyn
| Is Labour Anti-Semitic?
| |
|---|---|
BBC image for the programme | |
| Type | Television documentary |
| Date | 10 July 2019 |
| Participants | John Ware (reporter); Leo Telling (producer); Neil Grant (executive producer); Rachel Jupp (editor) |
| Organisers | BBC One, Panorama |
| Accused | Labour Party leadership (subject of the programme) |
| Regulator | Ofcom; High Court (judicial review) |
| Outcome | BBC rejected Labour's complaint; Ofcom found the programme "duly impartial" (January 2020); judicial review refused (June 2020); Labour apologised to Ware and seven former staff in the High Court (July 2020) |
| Other | First broadcast Wednesday 10 July 2019, 21:00 (22:40 in Wales); 59 minutes. Sometimes cited as Is Labour Antisemitic? |
Is Labour Anti-Semitic? (sometimes written Is Labour Antisemitic?) is a Panorama documentary reported by John Ware and first broadcast on BBC One on Wednesday 10 July 2019 at 21:00. Its producer was Leo Telling, its executive producer Neil Grant and its editor Rachel Jupp.[1] It examined the handling of antisemitism complaints in the Labour Party under Jeremy Corbyn, drawing on former party staff and leaked emails. About two million people watched it.[2] The programme led to a series of complaints and legal actions, several of which ended in apologies and damages to Ware.
Content
The BBC said the programme went "inside the anti-Semitism crisis gripping Jeremy Corbyn's Labour Party", with "exclusive interviews from key insiders and access to confidential communications and documents".[1] BBC News reported that Panorama spoke to more than 20 former officials, eight of whom appeared, seven of them from the party's complaints and disputes department; four spoke despite having signed non-disclosure agreements.[3]
The main allegations were:[3]
- that Corbyn's communications director, Seumas Milne, had written in March 2018 that "we're muddling up political disputes with racism", which the former head of disputes, Sam Matthews, said he interpreted as "an instruction";
- that the general secretary, Jennie Formby, had tried to influence the panel for the disciplinary case of Jackie Walker, and had written that she had "deleted all trace of the email";
- that officials brought in by Formby had "overruled" disciplinary decisions and "downgraded" punishments;
- that Corbyn's office had on one occasion ordered batches of complaints to be brought to his Commons office for processing;
- that when Milne approached the former head of disputes, Mike Creighton, for advice in spring 2016, and Creighton suggested dealing with high-profile cases "much more swiftly and much more robustly", Milne had laughed at him.
Panorama also said there was a backlog of 1,000 antisemitism allegations in spring 2019, with only 15 expulsions. The former disputes officer Louise Withers Green said she would not "be able to live with myself unless I speak up".[3] The shadow communities secretary, Andrew Gwynne, was interviewed for the party.[4]
Responses
Labour said there had been no interference, and that the former staff were "disaffected former officials" including "those who have always opposed Jeremy Corbyn's leadership, worked to actively undermine it, and have both personal and political axes to grind". It called Creighton's account "false and malicious", described the batches of complaints as "a staff resourcing matter", and called the 1,000 figure "categorically untrue". The deputy leader, Tom Watson, said he was "shocked, chilled and appalled", and Ruth Smeeth called the testimony "heartbreaking".[3]
The party said the programme "was not a fair or balanced investigation. It was a seriously inaccurate, politically one-sided polemic, which breached basic journalistic standards, invented quotes and edited emails to change their meaning."[5] Corbyn accused it of "many, many, inaccuracies" and of adopting a "pre-determined position".[4]
The Media Reform Coalition said that the programme's "complete exclusion" of the voices of Jewish Labour members with a different perspective "amounts to a gross breach of the BBC's impartiality requirements", and criticised the BBC for "handing two editions to the same presenter with known (and hostile) political views on Corbyn".[5]
Complaints and rulings
Labour submitted a 28-page complaint to the BBC, which rejected it.[4][6] In January 2020 Ofcom confirmed that it had rejected 28 complaints that had gone through the BBC's process. An Ofcom spokesperson said: "In our view, the programme was duly impartial. As well as highly critical personal testimonies, it included the Labour Party's response prominently throughout, including in an interview with the Shadow Communities Secretary."[4] Campaign Against Antisemitism reported that Labour had apparently withdrawn its own Ofcom complaint.[6]
The academic Justin Schlosberg sought a judicial review of Ofcom's decision. On 10 June 2020 Mrs Justice Lang rejected the application, saying his case came "nowhere near reaching the high threshold" for an irrationality challenge.[7]
Legal actions
Labour Party settlement (2020)
On 22 July 2020 the Labour Party, then led by Keir Starmer, apologised "unreservedly" in the High Court to Ware and to seven former employees who had appeared in the programme. The Guardian reported that the settlement cost the party about £600,000, including about £180,000 in damages, and that Labour withdrew its accusation that Ware had made "deliberate and malicious misrepresentations designed to mislead the public". Corbyn called the settlement "a political decision".[8] The Jewish Chronicle reported that Labour had also accused Ware of having "invented quotes, flouted journalistic ethics" and "knowingly promoted falsehoods", and that it said it was "profoundly sorry".[9]
Ware v French (2022)
Ware sued the journalist Paddy French over an article published in French's Press Gang series. In 2021 Mr Justice Saini found that it meant Ware was "a rogue journalist who had engaged in dirty tricks aimed at harming the Labour Party's chances of winning the General Election" by presenting "a biased and knowingly false presentation of the extent and nature of antisemitism within the party". French withdrew his truth defence on 23 June 2022. On 30 November 2022 Mr Justice Julian Knowles awarded Ware £90,000 damages and granted a permanent injunction.[2]
Jewish Voice for Labour (2022)
Ware also sued Jewish Voice for Labour (JVL), its editor Richard Kuper and Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi over remarks she made on BBC Radio 2's Jeremy Vine show the day after the broadcast, and over a Facebook post reproduced on JVL's website. On 4 October 2022 a statement by Wimborne-Idrissi was read in open court accepting that her comments "were defamatory" and that "these allegations are untrue". The Jewish Chronicle estimated the damages and costs at £200,000.[10] On 21 October 2022 JVL said that "the apology issued in open court was not for what we had written or said about The Panorama Programme".[11]
Forde report and Al Jazeera
The 2022 report by Martin Forde for the Labour Party described the use of internal party emails by Panorama and other outlets as "entirely misleading". Al Jazeera's The Labour Files (2022) also criticised the programme. Ware replied in The Jewish Chronicle that Al Jazeera's central allegation was "wholly untrue".[12] In 2023 Middle East Eye reported that the Panorama editor, Karen Wightman, had asked Forde to amend his references to the programme, and that he had refused.[13]
See also
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 BBC One, Panorama: Is Labour Anti-Semitic?, programme page, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 High Court of Justice, King's Bench Division, Ware v French [2022 EWHC 3030 (KB)], judgment of Mr Justice Julian Knowles, 30 November 2022, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 BBC News, Top Labour figures 'interfered' in anti-Semitism disputes, 10 July 2019, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 Jack Mendel, Ofcom rejects all complaints about BBC Panorama on antisemitism whistle-blowers, Jewish News, 20 January 2020, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 Media Reform Coalition, BBC Panorama on anti-semitism: a catalogue of reporting failures, 29 July 2019, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 Campaign Against Antisemitism, Labour withdraws Ofcom complaint about Panorama expose of Party's antisemitism, 17 January 2020, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ Lee Harpin, Court rules against Panorama challenge, The Jewish Chronicle, 20 July 2020, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ Lisa O'Carroll and Jessica Elgot, Labour pays out six-figure sum and apologises in antisemitism row, The Guardian, 22 July 2020, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ Lee Harpin, Labour apologises to whistleblowers and Ware, The Jewish Chronicle, 22 July 2020, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ Nic North, JVL apologises to Panorama journalist John Ware for defaming him on radio and social media, The Jewish Chronicle, 6 October 2022, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi, Libel Settlement Clarification, Jewish Voice for Labour, 21 October 2022, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ John Ware, Al Jazeera's central allegation against my BBC programme can be easily debunked, The Jewish Chronicle, 13 October 2022, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ Richard Sanders, Forde speaks for the first time about his report investigating racism and factionalism in the Labour Party, Middle East Eye, 16 March 2023, accessed 18 November 2026.