Edwin Montagu

From Powerbase
Jump to navigation Jump to search

British Liberal politician (1879–1924) who opposed the Balfour Declaration in cabinet

Edwin Montagu

Born 6 February 1879 London, England
Died 15 November 1924 London, England
Nationality British
Occupation Politician
Known for Secretary of State for India (1917–1922); author of the 1917 memorandum "The Anti-Semitism of the Present Government"
Parents Samuel Montagu, 1st Baron Swaythling

Edwin Samuel Montagu (1879–1924) was a British Liberal politician who served as Secretary of State for India from 1917 to 1922 and helped introduce the Government of India Act 1919.[1] As the only Jewish member of the British cabinet in 1917, he wrote a memorandum opposing the Balfour Declaration.[2]

Career

Born in London on 6 February 1879, Montagu entered Parliament as a Liberal in 1906 and became secretary to the Prime Minister, H. H. Asquith.[1] He was parliamentary under-secretary at the India Office from 1910 to 1914, joined the cabinet in 1915 as Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, and as Financial Secretary to the Treasury helped promote the first war loans.[1] He became Secretary of State for India in 1917. With the viceroy, Lord Chelmsford, he prepared the Montagu–Chelmsford Report, whose recommendations were embodied in the Government of India Act 1919.[1] He resigned in 1922 after differences with the Prime Minister, David Lloyd George, over policy towards Turkey, and died in London on 15 November 1924.[1]

Moser describes the Montagu–Samuel family as the descendants of a Liverpool watchmaker who grew rich through the bank founded by Samuel Montagu, later Baron Swaythling, Edwin's father, and as part of the Anglo-Jewish "Cousinhood" allied with the Rothschilds and Montefiores.[3] His cousin was Herbert Samuel, later governor of Palestine.[3]

Anti-Zionism?

This section asks whether Montagu called for the Zionist state ("Israel") to be ended, or a Jewish state prevented, and replaced with a single democratic state, taken here as the minimum anti-Zionist position, and, separately, whether he called for the global Zionist movement to be dismantled. That second aim is treated as desirable but not required.

Moser devotes his second chapter, "A Fight in the Cousinhood", to Montagu and his cousin Herbert Samuel.[3]

The Zionist state. Montagu wrote that "Zionism has always seemed to me to be a mischievous political creed, untenable by any patriotic citizen of the United Kingdom", and set out four principles, the first being "that there is not a Jewish nation".[2] He wrote that he assumed the policy meant "that Mahommedans and Christians are to make way for the Jews", and that "Palestine will become the world's Ghetto".[2] Moser notes that his "main concern was the antisemitism that Zionism would fuel", but that he also "displayed basic human regard for Muslim and Christian Palestinian Arabs".[4]

A single democratic replacement. In the same memorandum he wrote that the government should secure "for Jews in Palestine complete liberty of settlement and life on an equality with the inhabitants of that country who profess other religious beliefs", and he added "I would ask that the Government should go no further".[2] He also wrote: "I would not deny to Jews in Palestine equal rights to colonisation with those who profess other religions."[2] Moser does not attribute to Montagu a proposal for a single democratic state in place of a Jewish national home.

The Zionist movement. In the memorandum Montagu wrote: "I would willingly disfranchise every Zionist. I would be almost tempted to proscribe the Zionist organisation as illegal and against the national interest."[2]

After 1917. Moser quotes a note Montagu sent to Herbert Samuel after Samuel's 1922 speech at Westminster. In it Montagu wrote that he still "would give anything that [the Balfour Declaration] should not have been made", but that "any view held as to its advisability is only of historic interest" and that Britain's promises "ought to be kept and honoured without hesitation"; "For these reasons I rejoice in your success".[5]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 Britannica Editors, Edwin Samuel Montagu Encyclopaedia Britannica, accessed 13 November 2026.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 Edwin Montagu, The Anti-Semitism of the Present Government (memorandum, 23 August 1917), reproduced at panarchy.org, accessed 13 November 2026.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 Benjamin Moser, Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History (New York: Doubleday, 2026), pp. 65–66.
  4. ↑ Moser, Anti-Zionism, pp. 80–81.
  5. ↑ Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 86.