Aaron Samuel Tamares

From Powerbase
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Polish Orthodox rabbi and essayist (1869–1931) who opposed political Zionism

Aaron Samuel Tamares

Born 1869 near Malech, Russian Empire (now Belarus)
Died 1931 Warsaw, Poland
Residence Milejczyce
Occupation Rabbi, essayist
Known for Orthodox Jewish criticism of political Zionism and Jewish nationalism; advocacy of nonviolence
Spouse(s) Rachel

Aaron Samuel Tamares (1869–1931) was a Polish Orthodox rabbi, essayist and advocate of nonviolence, who from 1893 was rabbi of the village of Milejczyce.[1] He was elected a delegate to the Fourth Zionist Congress in London in 1900 but returned disillusioned with political Zionism, and went on to write against it for the rest of his life.[1] Benjamin Moser's Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History (2026) begins with him.[2]

Early life

According to Moser, Tamares was born in 1869 near Malech, on what is now the Belarusian side of the forest, and married the daughter of the rabbi of Milejczyce, on the Polish side. He came from a poor but learned family and was regarded as a prodigy at school.[3] The YIVO Encyclopedia records that he studied at the Kolel ha-Perushim in Kovno and then for two years at the yeshiva of Volozhin.[1]

Rabbi and writer

In 1893 Tamares became rabbi of Milejczyce, succeeding his father-in-law.[1] He often signed his work with the pseudonym Ahad ha-Rabanim ha-Margishim ("one of the sensitive rabbis"), and Moser calls him "the Sensitive Rabbi".[1][3] He published in the Hebrew press (including Ha-Melits and Ha-Tsefirah) and in Yiddish periodicals, among them the Agudas Yisroel organ Der yud.[1]

His books included Sefer ha-yahadut veha-herut (1905), Sefer musar ha-Torah veha-yahadut (1912), Keneset Yisrael u-milhamot ha-goyim (1920), which advocated humanism and pacifism, Yad Aharon (1923), a book of Talmudic novellae, and Sheloshah zivugim bilti hagunim ("Three Unsuitable Unions", 1930), published partly in response to the 1929 Hebron riots.[1] In 1912 Hayim Tchernowitz invited him to head a yeshiva in Odessa, but he reportedly returned to Milejczyce after two days.[1]

Tamares died in Warsaw in 1931, aged 62.[4] Moser records that his wife, Rachel, and two of his daughters, Miriam and Zirka, who had remained in Milejczyce, were deported to Treblinka and murdered on 20 November 1942; his other four children had emigrated to Palestine before the war.[4]

Anti-Zionism?

This section asks whether Tamares called for the Zionist state ("Israel") to be ended, or a Jewish state prevented, and replaced with a single democratic state, taken here as the minimum anti-Zionist position, and, separately, whether he called for the global Zionist movement to be dismantled. That second aim is treated as desirable but not required.

According to the YIVO Encyclopedia, Tamares first joined the Zionist movement and defended it against traditionalist opposition in the Hebrew press.[1] Moser describes a cultural-Zionist phase in his youth, centred on the idea of a "spiritual center" in Palestine, and says that the Congress in London in 1900 was "a dividing line in his life".[5][6] Moser says that Tamares "would eventually enunciate nearly every objection that subsequent opponents of Zionism ... would discover".[2]

The Zionist state. The YIVO Encyclopedia says that in Sefer ha-yahadut veha-herut he criticised the Zionist aspiration for the Jewish people "to be like all the other nations" as a departure from Judaism's emphasis on justice, and that in 1913 he wrote that "the kingdom of the spirit is our state territory".[1] Moser quotes him writing that a modest Hebrew settlement in Palestine that "did not dream dreams of 'statehood' and 'sovereignty'" would not have alarmed the Arabs. Moser adds that Tamares "did not reject a Jewish community in Palestine—on the condition that this community not try to establish itself as a political and military state".[7][8]

A single democratic replacement. Moser quotes Tamares as writing that the Zionists entered Palestine "with that ostentatious pride of 'occupiers' who have conquered a land and come into it to impose their dominion on the original inhabitants", and that the land was "a place already inhabited by a people which was sure to feel the 'nationalist' and 'sovereign-political' aims as a needle in its living flesh".[8] Moser does not attribute to him a proposal for a single democratic state in its place.

The Zionist movement. Moser says that Tamares wrote about Zionism for thirty years, that his position "had, if anything, hardened" by the time of Three Unsuitable Unions, and that by 1930 he had abandoned the idea of a "spiritual center" and wrote that "If Judaism is truly Torah, then it cannot be reduced to the confines of any particular territory".[9] Moser reports his admiration for the young pioneers doing peaceful work in Palestine, whom he thought were being manipulated by "their masters" among the movement's propagandists.[9] Neither Moser nor the YIVO Encyclopedia reports a proposal from Tamares to dissolve the World Zionist Organization.

The Jewish Telegraphic Agency's report of his death, as quoted by Moser, was headed "Death of Polish Rabbi Who Was Champion of Zionism".[4]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 Gershon David Hundert, Tamares, Aharon Shemu'el YIVO Encyclopedia of Jews in Eastern Europe, accessed 13 November 2026.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 Benjamin Moser, Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History (New York: Doubleday, 2026), p. 40.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 36.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 57.
  5. ↑ Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 39.
  6. ↑ Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 44.
  7. ↑ Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 53.
  8. ↑ 8.0 8.1 Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 54.
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 Moser, Anti-Zionism, p. 58.