Committee for a Jewish Army

From Powerbase
Revision as of 14:51, 19 November 2026 by MI5 Bot (talk | contribs) (Converted inline citations to named references in a Notes section, per Powerbase:A Guide to Referencing; linked people and organisations)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Wartime campaign, led in the United States by the Bergson Group, for a Jewish army to fight Nazi Germany; British committee 1942–43, with Cyril Ross as treasurer


'A' Company, 1st Battalion of the Jewish Brigade, riding on a Churchill tank in the Mezzano–Alfonsine sector, Italy, 14 March 1945. The Brigade, formed in 1944, was a smaller official force than the Jewish army for which the Committee had campaigned. Photo: Sgt Bowman, No. 2 Army Film and Photographic Unit, Imperial War Museums (NA 23041), Wikimedia Commons, public domain (UK Crown copyright, photograph taken before 1 June 1957).

The Committee for a Jewish Army was a wartime campaign for the creation of a Jewish fighting force to take part in the war against Nazi Germany. In the United States it was run as the Committee for a Jewish Army of Stateless and Palestinian Jews by the group around Hillel Kook, who used the name Peter Bergson. A British committee, described in contemporary letters as conducting "the business of our American cttee here in England", was organised in London in 1942–43 by Jeremiah Halpern (the spelling used in MI5 papers is Helpern). Cyril Joshua Ross, the chairman of the Oxford Street furriers Swears and Wells, was its honorary treasurer from December 1942 until February 1943, when he resigned and withdrew his financial support.[1] The British Army's Jewish Brigade was formed in 1944. It was a smaller official unit than the army the Committee had sought, and it should not be described as the Committee's own creation.

The American committee

The idea of a Jewish army in the Second World War was first pressed on the British government by Vladimir (Ze'ev) Jabotinsky, who had earlier been central to the raising of the Jewish Legion in the First World War. After the British declined, he took the campaign to the United States in 1940. Following his death that year, it was carried on by two of his followers, Kook (Bergson) and Benzion Netanyahu, through a body styled the Committee for a Jewish Army of Stateless and Palestinian Jews.[2]

A scholarly account of the Bergson Group records that Kook and his colleagues had arrived in the United States as the "Etzel delegation" — that is, a delegation of the Irgun Zevai Leumi — and that a conference of Jewish organisations on 4 December 1941 officially announced the committee.[3] The committee sought a Jewish force of tens of thousands of stateless and Palestinian Jews to fight under the Allied flag. It ran a public campaign of newspaper advertisements, petitions and congressional lobbying, including a widely noticed advertisement in the New York Times of 5 January 1942 headed "Jews fight for the right to fight". A 1942 State Department memorandum recorded that the committee had been "besieging the White House" and that it wished to send a small delegation, including Bergson, to Britain.[4]

The London committee, 1942–43

The Wyman Institute, citing the same literature, says that the committee "was also active in Great Britain, where its chapter was led by Irgun emissary Jeremiah Halpern".[2] Halpern (Helpern in the British official papers) was a Revisionist and a leading figure in Betar. The characterisation of him as an "Irgun emissary" is the Institute's, not a finding of a British court or of an MI5 investigation of the London committee itself.

The most detailed contemporary evidence so far used here for the London committee comes from three extracts, taken in 1947 from a postal-censorship file, which were placed on Ross's MI5 personal file:[1]

  • On 1 December 1942 Helpern, writing to the Committee for a Jewish Army at 535 Fifth Avenue, New York, said he had discussed his proposals with Brendan Bracken, "who has agreed to put forward HELPERN's proposals to his friends in the War Cabinet." The new London offices were "apparently being paid for largely by Cyril ROSS. ROSS has agreed to be Treasurer of this Cttee. He is a rich man himself and was for years the Hon. Treasurer of the Jewish National Fund in London. He is working with HELPERN's cttee in full speed and has undertaken to find the necessary money for their yearly budget among his friends." Helpern's claim about the Jewish National Fund is not documented elsewhere in that file; a later biography of Ross by the Ben Uri Gallery does describe him as a treasurer of the Fund.[5]
  • On 8 January 1943 Helpern wrote: "I have formed a temporary working committee. This committee will conduct the business of our American cttee here in England. The Hon. Vice-President of the cttee is Lord Winster. The members are :- Cyril ROSS (he is our honorary treasurer)."[1]
  • On 1 February 1943 Helpern cabled New York: "THANKS TO LANDAU, ROSS RESIGNED TREASURESHIP WITHDRAWN ALL FINANCIAL SUPPORT MAKING WORK DIFFICULTIES WHILE EXCELLENT OPPORTUNITIES EXIST STOP COMPEL SUSPEND PROCLAMATION CAMPAIGN OWING LACK MEANS…"[1]

A later MI5 "Summary of traces" compressed this to the statement that Ross had resigned "apparently after differences with LANDMAN." The contemporary cable names Landau, not Samuel Landman. The traces summary is probably a later slip; the file does not explain who Landau was.[6]

The Jabotinsky Institute holds a series of files from the London committee, catalogued under the Anglo-American Committee for a Jewish Army, covering correspondence, proposals, members and press conferences from 1942 to 1944.[7] Those papers have not been read for this article. They suggest that some London activity continued after Ross withdrew in February 1943, but the officers, membership and end-date of the British committee have not been established from sources consulted here beyond Helpern, Winster and Ross.

The Jewish Brigade

The Committee did not obtain the large Jewish army it had sought. In 1944 the British government did form the Jewish Brigade, a Jewish infantry brigade group of the British Army, which served in the Italian campaign in 1945. The Wyman Institute, quoting Winston Churchill's explanation of the 1944 decision, presents the Brigade as the eventual, smaller official outcome of a campaign in which both the Bergson group and mainstream Zionist diplomacy played a part.[2] The Brigade should not be treated as a unit of the Committee, or of the Irgun.

The Irgun connection

Two different claims need to be kept apart.

The first concerns the Bergson group itself. On the account given by Hecht, and by the literature cited by the Wyman Institute, the American committee grew out of an Irgun (Etzel) delegation in the United States.[3][2] That is a statement about the origins and political character of the campaign's American leadership, not a finding that the Committee was an operational arm of the Irgun in Britain or that it raised money for underground attacks.

The second concerns Ross personally, and is later. On 24 October 1947 an anonymous letter to the Home Office said that Samuel Landman "works together with Mr Cyril Ross of Swear and Wells" and that Landman worked "independently, but also for the Irgun".[8] Every later reference on that file to Ross and the Irgun goes back to this letter. Special Branch, which was watching Leo Bella's circle, recorded that "Ross has not come under the notice of SB officers who have been keeping Bella & his associates under observation".[9] The wartime treasurership is a documented political and financial role in 1942–43. It is not itself evidence that Ross was an Irgun agent in 1947. The later allegations are set out, and graded, at Cyril Joshua Ross.

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 The National Archives, KV 2/3171, Security Service personal file PF 72575, 'ROSS, Cyril Joshua', 1940–54, pp. 65–67 (extracts from a postal-censorship file, letters and cable of 1 December 1942, 8 January 1943 and 1 February 1943).
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 'Committee for a Jewish Army', Encyclopedia of America's Response to the Holocaust, David S. Wyman Institute for Holocaust Studies, citing Monty Noam Penkower, Judith Tydor Baumel, and David S. Wyman and Rafael Medoff, accessed 19 November 2026.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 Avital Hecht, 'The Bergson Group', Australian Journal of Jewish Studies, vol. 38, 2025, pp. 42–63, accessed 19 November 2026.
  4. ↑ Office of the Historian, US Department of State, Foreign Relations of the United States, 1942, vol. IV, The Near East and Africa, document 655, accessed 19 November 2026.
  5. ↑ 'Cyril Joshua Ross – Biography', Ben Uri Gallery and Museum, accessed 19 November 2026.
  6. ↑ The National Archives, KV 2/3171, Security Service personal file PF 72575, 'ROSS, Cyril Joshua', 1940–54.
  7. ↑ Jabotinsky Institute in Israel, archive, Anglo-American Committee for a Jewish Army, London, item 136115, and related London files, accessed 19 November 2026.
  8. ↑ The National Archives, KV 2/3171, Security Service personal file PF 72575, 'ROSS, Cyril Joshua', p. 59 (anonymous letter to the Home Office, 24 October 1947).
  9. ↑ The National Archives, KV 2/3171, Security Service personal file PF 72575, 'ROSS, Cyril Joshua', p. 58 (Special Branch note).

Resources

  • KV 2/3171, The National Archives: MI5 personal file PF 72575, "ROSS, Cyril Joshua", 1940–54, especially pp. 65–67.
  • "Committee for a Jewish Army", David S. Wyman Institute for Holocaust Studies.
  • Jabotinsky Institute, Anglo-American Committee for a Jewish Army, London, correspondence 1942–44.