Security Intelligence Review Committee
Independent Canadian body, established under the CSIS Act of 1984, which reviewed the activities of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service and investigated complaints about it until it was replaced by the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency in July 2019
| Security Intelligence Review Committee
| |
|---|---|
| Logo | Shield of the arms of Canada. Source: Wikimedia Commons (public domain) |
| Type | Independent external review body reporting to Parliament[1] |
| Founded | 1984, under the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act[1] |
| Dissolved | 12 July 2019, replaced by the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency[2] |
| Status | Defunct |
| Location | Ottawa |
| Area served | Canada |
| Services | Review of the operations of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service; investigation of complaints about CSIS[3] |
| Key people | Gary Filmon (chair, 2008–2009); members Frances Lankin, Denis Losier, Arthur T. Porter and Raymond Speaker (2008–2009)[4] |
The Security Intelligence Review Committee (SIRC) was an independent Canadian review body which, from 1984 until 2019, reviewed the activities of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) and reported on them to Parliament.[1] It described itself as "the only independent review body with the mandate to comment on all aspects of the Service's operations".[3] On 12 July 2019 it was replaced by the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency (NSIRA), which was given a mandate to review all federal national security and intelligence activities.[2]
Mandate and powers
SIRC was part of "the scheme of accountability that was established in 1984 by Parliament" when CSIS was created.[1] Its 2008–2009 annual report stated that it provided assurances to Parliament "that CSIS investigates and reports on threats to national security in a manner that respects the rule of law and the rights of Canadians". The CSIS Act gave it full access to information under the control of the service, so that it could examine all CSIS files and activities "no matter how highly classified"; the sole exception was Cabinet confidences.[5] It could respond to complaints, review aspects of CSIS on its own initiative, and respond to requests from the Minister of Public Safety; each year it reviewed a selection of the service's operational activities to determine whether CSIS had acted "appropriately, effectively and in accordance with the law".[3]
All members of SIRC were Privy Councillors, appointed by the Governor-in-Council after consultation by the Prime Minister with the leaders of the opposition parties.[4]
Reviews
In its 2008–2009 annual report SIRC said that, although CSIS had made progress in developing policies on human rights, its review of the service's role in the case of Omar Khadr showed that "CSIS must consider the principles of national and international law in regards to the treatment of minors when interviewing a Canadian detainee abroad". The same report found that key elements of the service's strategy on domestic extremism needed to be "reviewed and reformulated", and called for more ministerial accountability over parts of its human source programme affected by the Anti-Terrorism Act of 2001.[3][6]
Replacement by NSIRA
NSIRA was created on 12 July 2019, when the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency Act came into force with other parts of Bill C-59. According to NSIRA, the change closed gaps in accountability "first identified by Justice O'Connor in the 2006 Arar report": previously only specific agencies had independent review bodies, which could not collaborate or share classified information. NSIRA replaced SIRC, "which was limited to the review of CSIS", and the Office of the CSE Commissioner, which had reviewed the Communications Security Establishment.[2] An NSIRA member, Pierre Blais, said: "For thirty five years, the Security Intelligence Review Committee helped protect the rights and freedoms of Canadians by ensuring the democratic accountability of CSIS."[2]
See also
- Canadian Security Intelligence Service
- Communications Security Establishment
- Ward Elcock
- Jim Judd
- Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security (New Zealand)
- Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security (Australia)
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 Security Intelligence Review Committee, Annual Report 2008–2009: Accountability in a new era of security intelligence, Ottawa, 2009, p. 3, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 National Security and Intelligence Review Agency, "All Government of Canada national security and intelligence activities now subject to independent expert review", public statement, 17 July 2019, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 Security Intelligence Review Committee, Annual Report 2008–2009, Ottawa, 2009, p. 6, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 Security Intelligence Review Committee, Annual Report 2008–2009, Ottawa, 2009, p. 26 and letter of transmittal, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ Security Intelligence Review Committee, Annual Report 2008–2009, Ottawa, 2009, p. 4, accessed 18 November 2026.
- ↑ Security Intelligence Review Committee, Annual Report 2008–2009, Ottawa, 2009, p. 7, accessed 18 November 2026.