Difference between revisions of "Edith Summerskill"

From Powerbase
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(New page: Labour politics and Israel, cited (Hansard, obituaries, Edmunds 1997))
 
(Add newspaper citations (British Newspaper Archive, Jewish Chronicle archive) from browser pass)
Line 13: Line 13:
  
 
== Nasser, Suez and the Palestinian refugees ==
 
== Nasser, Suez and the Palestinian refugees ==
−
This section draws on [[June Edmunds]]' 1997 doctoral thesis on the British left's views of Israel.
+
This section draws mainly on [[June Edmunds]]' 1997 doctoral thesis on the British left's views of Israel.
 +
 
 +
=== 1955 visit to Israel ===
 +
At the start of January 1955 Summerskill, then chairman of the Labour Party, left London Airport on what ''The Scotsman'' called a "one-woman mission" to Israel and the Arab countries, at the invitation of the Israeli government; [[James Griffiths]] also left for Israel the same day.<ref name="Scotsman550103">"Dr Summerskill going to Israel", ''The Scotsman'', 3 January 1955, p. 11, [https://www.britishnewspaperarchive.com/image-viewer?issue=BL%2F0000540%2F19550103&page=0011&article=284 British Newspaper Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref> Her local paper, the ''Fulham Chronicle'', reported later that month that she had "strongly denied a report" that she had shaken hands with a woman in a remote village during the tour.<ref name="Fulham550121">''Fulham Chronicle'', 21 January 1955, p. 2, [https://www.britishnewspaperarchive.com/image-viewer?issue=BL%2F0001984%2F19550121&page=0002&article=022 British Newspaper Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref> On 28 January the ''[[The Jewish Chronicle|Jewish Chronicle]]'' carried a report headed "Dr. Summerskill criticised – Labour M.P. on prejudiced views on Israel".<ref name="JC550128">"Dr. Summerskill criticised – Labour M.P. on prejudiced views on Israel", ''The Jewish Chronicle'', 28 January 1955, p. 9, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/ZjRlMzQ2ZmItZjk4NS00 JC Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref>
 +
 
 +
In March 1955, addressing the fifth annual conference of [[Pioneer Women]] of Great Britain, Summerskill appealed to her audience to help find a lasting peace between Jews and Arabs, saying that women might "succeed where, so far, the men had failed", and suggested that compensating the Arabs who had fled was one way of opening the door to peace.<ref name="JC550304">"Arab-Israeli relations: Dr. Summerskill's plea to women", ''The Jewish Chronicle'', 4 March 1955, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/ZDBjOTEwMWYtNTI4OC00 JC Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref>
  
 
=== Before the Suez war ===
 
=== Before the Suez war ===
Line 21: Line 26:
 
Edmunds describes Summerskill as "the only strongly pro-Arab member" of Labour's [[National Executive Committee of the Labour Party|National Executive Committee]] (NEC) and its International Sub-Committee in 1956, and writes that her views brought her into conflict with other NEC members.<ref name="Edmunds1997p68">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 68, citing ''The Diary of Hugh Gaitskell 1945–1956'', ed. Philip M. Williams (1983), p. 569.</ref> In Edmunds' tables of the 1956 NEC and International Sub-Committee she and [[Barbara Castle]] are the only members placed in the pro-Arab/Palestinian column.<ref name="Edmunds1997p69">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 69, tables 3.2 and 3.3.</ref>
 
Edmunds describes Summerskill as "the only strongly pro-Arab member" of Labour's [[National Executive Committee of the Labour Party|National Executive Committee]] (NEC) and its International Sub-Committee in 1956, and writes that her views brought her into conflict with other NEC members.<ref name="Edmunds1997p68">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 68, citing ''The Diary of Hugh Gaitskell 1945–1956'', ed. Philip M. Williams (1983), p. 569.</ref> In Edmunds' tables of the 1956 NEC and International Sub-Committee she and [[Barbara Castle]] are the only members placed in the pro-Arab/Palestinian column.<ref name="Edmunds1997p69">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 69, tables 3.2 and 3.3.</ref>
  
−
[[Hugh Gaitskell]] challenged Summerskill, with [[John Hynd]], [[William Warbey]] and [[Tony Benn]], over what he saw as their automatic defence of any eastern country and their failure to recognise that [[Gamal Abdel Nasser|Nasser]] was a dictator. According to Edmunds, Gaitskell believed that Summerskill's views stemmed from her being "a woman whose political views are almost entirely dependent on personal contacts".<ref name="Edmunds1997p71">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 71, citing Williams (ed.), ''The Diary of Hugh Gaitskell'', pp. 567–569.</ref> Summerskill knew Nasser personally. After the war she visited Egypt and returned saying that the Anglo-French attack had caused many more casualties than had been acknowledged.<ref name="Edmunds1997p84">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 84, citing Leon D. Epstein, ''British Politics and the Suez Crisis'' (1964), p. 76.</ref>
+
[[Hugh Gaitskell]] challenged Summerskill, with [[John Hynd]], [[William Warbey]] and [[Tony Benn]], over what he saw as their automatic defence of any eastern country and their failure to recognise that [[Gamal Abdel Nasser|Nasser]] was a dictator. According to Edmunds, Gaitskell believed that Summerskill's views stemmed from her being "a woman whose political views are almost entirely dependent on personal contacts".<ref name="Edmunds1997p71">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 71, citing Williams (ed.), ''The Diary of Hugh Gaitskell'', pp. 567–569.</ref> Summerskill knew Nasser personally. After the war she visited Egypt and returned saying that the Anglo-French attack had caused many more casualties than had been acknowledged.<ref name="Edmunds1997p84">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 84, citing Leon D. Epstein, ''British Politics and the Suez Crisis'' (1964), p. 76.</ref> In February 1957 the Conservative MP [[W. T. Aitken]] called her statements about British troops at Port Said "wicked and monstrous", and pointed out that a government White Paper had described the claims as "completely untrue".<ref name="BuryFP570215">''Bury Free Press'', 15 February 1957, p. 1, [https://www.britishnewspaperarchive.com/image-viewer?issue=BL%2F0000762%2F19570215&page=0001&article=010 British Newspaper Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref>
  
 
In the Commons debate of 31 October 1956, [[Lady Tweedsmuir]] quoted from a speech Summerskill had made at what she called "a Socialist Party gathering at East Ham": "It is as well for the British and French Governments to know now that the workers of this country will not fight a war designed solely to subject the people of the Middle East in the interests of French and British commercial interests."<ref name="Hansard561031">[https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1956/oct/31/middle-east-situation Middle East (Situation)], House of Commons debate, 31 October 1956, ''Hansard'', vol. 558, col. 1480, accessed 18 November 2026.</ref>
 
In the Commons debate of 31 October 1956, [[Lady Tweedsmuir]] quoted from a speech Summerskill had made at what she called "a Socialist Party gathering at East Ham": "It is as well for the British and French Governments to know now that the workers of this country will not fight a war designed solely to subject the people of the Middle East in the interests of French and British commercial interests."<ref name="Hansard561031">[https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1956/oct/31/middle-east-situation Middle East (Situation)], House of Commons debate, 31 October 1956, ''Hansard'', vol. 558, col. 1480, accessed 18 November 2026.</ref>

Revision as of 09:07, 18 November 2026

British Labour politician (1901–1980); MP for Fulham West and Warrington, and a member of Labour's National Executive Committee in the 1950s

Edith Summerskill

Image Edith Summerskill (1940).jpg
Edith Summerskill, 16 August 1940 (Bassano Ltd; public domain)
Born 19 April 1901
Died 4 February 1980
Nationality British
Occupation Politician
Known for Labour MP for Fulham West (1938–1955) and Warrington (1955–1961); member of the Labour National Executive Committee

Edith Summerskill (19 April 1901 – 4 February 1980), later Baroness Summerskill, was a British Labour Party politician. She sat for Fulham West from 1938 to 1955 and for Warrington from 1955 until 1961, when she was made a life peer as Baroness Summerskill of Kenwood.[1][2]

Nasser, Suez and the Palestinian refugees

This section draws mainly on June Edmunds' 1997 doctoral thesis on the British left's views of Israel.

1955 visit to Israel

At the start of January 1955 Summerskill, then chairman of the Labour Party, left London Airport on what The Scotsman called a "one-woman mission" to Israel and the Arab countries, at the invitation of the Israeli government; James Griffiths also left for Israel the same day.[3] Her local paper, the Fulham Chronicle, reported later that month that she had "strongly denied a report" that she had shaken hands with a woman in a remote village during the tour.[4] On 28 January the Jewish Chronicle carried a report headed "Dr. Summerskill criticised – Labour M.P. on prejudiced views on Israel".[5]

In March 1955, addressing the fifth annual conference of Pioneer Women of Great Britain, Summerskill appealed to her audience to help find a lasting peace between Jews and Arabs, saying that women might "succeed where, so far, the men had failed", and suggested that compensating the Arabs who had fled was one way of opening the door to peace.[6]

Before the Suez war

Before the 1956 war Anthony Greenwood reprimanded Summerskill for suggesting that some of the Palestinian refugees should return to Israel, on the grounds that her proposal gave the false impression that Labour held Israel responsible for resettling them.[7]

1956

Edmunds describes Summerskill as "the only strongly pro-Arab member" of Labour's National Executive Committee (NEC) and its International Sub-Committee in 1956, and writes that her views brought her into conflict with other NEC members.[8] In Edmunds' tables of the 1956 NEC and International Sub-Committee she and Barbara Castle are the only members placed in the pro-Arab/Palestinian column.[9]

Hugh Gaitskell challenged Summerskill, with John Hynd, William Warbey and Tony Benn, over what he saw as their automatic defence of any eastern country and their failure to recognise that Nasser was a dictator. According to Edmunds, Gaitskell believed that Summerskill's views stemmed from her being "a woman whose political views are almost entirely dependent on personal contacts".[10] Summerskill knew Nasser personally. After the war she visited Egypt and returned saying that the Anglo-French attack had caused many more casualties than had been acknowledged.[11] In February 1957 the Conservative MP W. T. Aitken called her statements about British troops at Port Said "wicked and monstrous", and pointed out that a government White Paper had described the claims as "completely untrue".[12]

In the Commons debate of 31 October 1956, Lady Tweedsmuir quoted from a speech Summerskill had made at what she called "a Socialist Party gathering at East Ham": "It is as well for the British and French Governments to know now that the workers of this country will not fight a war designed solely to subject the people of the Middle East in the interests of French and British commercial interests."[13]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ Dr Edith Summerskill, Hansard 1803–2005, UK Parliament, accessed 18 November 2026.
  2. ↑ Edith Clara Summerskill, Peerages, History of Parliament, accessed 18 November 2026.
  3. ↑ "Dr Summerskill going to Israel", The Scotsman, 3 January 1955, p. 11, British Newspaper Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  4. ↑ Fulham Chronicle, 21 January 1955, p. 2, British Newspaper Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  5. ↑ "Dr. Summerskill criticised – Labour M.P. on prejudiced views on Israel", The Jewish Chronicle, 28 January 1955, p. 9, JC Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  6. ↑ "Arab-Israeli relations: Dr. Summerskill's plea to women", The Jewish Chronicle, 4 March 1955, JC Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  7. ↑ June Edmunds, The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada, PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 73, citing a Poale Zion press release, 7 October 1955.
  8. ↑ June Edmunds, The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada, PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 68, citing The Diary of Hugh Gaitskell 1945–1956, ed. Philip M. Williams (1983), p. 569.
  9. ↑ June Edmunds, The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada, PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 69, tables 3.2 and 3.3.
  10. ↑ June Edmunds, The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada, PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 71, citing Williams (ed.), The Diary of Hugh Gaitskell, pp. 567–569.
  11. ↑ June Edmunds, The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada, PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 84, citing Leon D. Epstein, British Politics and the Suez Crisis (1964), p. 76.
  12. ↑ Bury Free Press, 15 February 1957, p. 1, British Newspaper Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  13. ↑ Middle East (Situation), House of Commons debate, 31 October 1956, Hansard, vol. 558, col. 1480, accessed 18 November 2026.