Difference between revisions of "Jeffrey Goldberg"

From Powerbase
Jump to: navigation, search
(Early History)
Line 1: Line 1:
[[Jeffrey Goldberg]] is an American-Israeli journalist and Zionist political pundit that writes for [[David G. Bradley]]'s ''The Atlantic''. Referred to as Netanyahu's "faithful stenographer" by Roger Cohen of ''The New York Times,''<ref>Roger Cohen, [http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/09/opinion/09iht-edcohen.html?_r=2&ref=global, 'Israel Cries Wolf'], ''The New York Times,'' 8 April 2009</ref> Goldberg focuses on matters related to Israel, particularly its relationship with the United States. He was influential in building American support for the 2003 invasion of Iraq and has been criticized for making alarmist claims and using unreliable sources during the run-up to the war.<ref>Ken Silverstein, [http://harpers.org/archive/2006/06/sb-goldbergs-war-1151687978 'Goldberg's War'], ''Harper's Magazine,'' 30 June 2006</ref> Goldberg is also known for launching attacks on those who criticize Israeli policy while constantly pushing the claim that Israel is a strategic asset rather than a liability for the US.<ref>Glenn Greenwald, [http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2010/06/27/goldberg 'The Jeffrey Goldberg Media'], ''Salon.com,'' 27 June 2010</ref> He has publicly attacked fellow staff members at ''The Atlantic'' (as well as the editors for their lack of "editorial standards") for allegedly making comments that are critical of Israel even though the publication itself and its writers are known to propagate a pro-Israel line.<ref>Jeffrey Goldberg, [http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2010/03/andrew-sullivan-revises-history-again/37401/ 'Andrew Sullivan Revises History (Again)'], ''The Atlantic,'' 12 March 2010</ref>
+
[[Jeffrey Goldberg]] is an American-Israeli journalist and Zionist political pundit that writes for [[David G. Bradley]]'s ''The Atlantic''. Referred to as Netanyahu's "faithful stenographer" by Roger Cohen of ''The New York Times,''<ref>Roger Cohen, [http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/09/opinion/09iht-edcohen.html?_r=2&ref=global, 'Israel Cries Wolf'], ''The New York Times,'' 8 April 2009</ref> Goldberg focuses on matters related to Israel and its relationship with the United States in particular. He was influential in building American support for the 2003 invasion of Iraq and has been criticized for making alarmist claims and using unreliable sources during the run-up to the war.<ref>Ken Silverstein, [http://harpers.org/archive/2006/06/sb-goldbergs-war-1151687978 'Goldberg's War'], ''Harper's Magazine,'' 30 June 2006</ref> Goldberg is also known for launching attacks on those who criticize Israeli policy while constantly pushing the claim that Israel is a strategic asset rather than a liability for the US.<ref>Glenn Greenwald, [http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2010/06/27/goldberg 'The Jeffrey Goldberg Media'], ''Salon.com,'' 27 June 2010</ref> He has publicly attacked fellow staff members at ''The Atlantic'' (as well as the editors for their lack of "editorial standards") for allegedly making comments that are critical of Israel even though the publication and its writers are known to propagate a pro-Israel line.<ref>Jeffrey Goldberg, [http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2010/03/andrew-sullivan-revises-history-again/37401/ 'Andrew Sullivan Revises History (Again)'], ''The Atlantic,'' 12 March 2010</ref>
  
 
==Early History==
 
==Early History==
  
Goldberg was born and raised in New York but his self-stated strong identification with Israel saw him joining a Zionist summer camp and Kibbutz during his youth. He relocated to Israel during his college years and joined the Israeli Defense Forces shortly after. His acclaimed book, ''Prisoners: A Story of Friendship and Terror,'' is a memoir which includes an account of his experience as a guard at Ketziot, an Israeli prison located in the Negev desert were thousands of Palestinians were detained during the first intifada. Still in operation today, Ketziot is known for its harsh living conditions and for detaining children and men without trial.<ref>Martin Asser, [http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/3130623.stm, 'Palestinians languish in Israeli jails'], ''BBC,'' 8 August 2003</ref>  
+
Goldberg was born and raised in New York but his self-stated strong identification with Israel saw him joining a Zionist summer camp and Kibbutz during his youth. He relocated to Israel during his college years and joined the Israeli Defense Forces shortly after. His acclaimed book, ''Prisoners: A Story of Friendship and Terror,'' is a memoir which includes an account of his experience as a guard at Ketziot, an Israeli prison located in the Negev desert were thousands of Palestinians were detained during the first intifada. Still in operation today, Ketziot is known for its harsh living conditions and for imprisoning boys and men without trial.<ref>Martin Asser, [http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/3130623.stm, 'Palestinians languish in Israeli jails'], ''BBC,'' 8 August 2003</ref>  
  
During his residency in Israel, Goldberg served as a journalist for the right-wing ''Jerusalem Post''. While working as Washington correspondent for ''The New Yorker'', Goldberg produced an 17,000+ word article entitled, "The Great Terror," which George W. Bush, Dick Cheney and others referenced as justification for the US invasion of Iraq. In it Goldberg described Saddam Hussein's gassing of the Kurds in long and vivid detail and strongly suggested that Hussein posed the same threat to the US and other nations. Goldberg also suggested that the Iraqi regime had ties with Al Qaeda. The article won the the Overseas Press Club award for "Best international reporting in a print medium dealing with human rights."<ref>[http://opcofamerica.org/awards/2003-opc-award-winners Overseas Press Club of America website], accessed 25 July 2010</ref>
+
During his residency in Israel, Goldberg served as a journalist for the right-wing ''Jerusalem Post''. While working as Washington correspondent for ''The New Yorker'', Goldberg produced an 17,000+ word article entitled "The Great Terror" which George W. Bush, Dick Cheney and others referenced as justification for the US invasion of Iraq. In it Goldberg described Saddam Hussein's gassing of the Kurds in long and vivid detail and strongly suggested that Hussein posed the same threat to the US and other nations. Goldberg also suggested that the Iraqi regime had ties with Al Qaeda. The article won the Overseas Press Club award for "Best international reporting in a print medium dealing with human rights."<ref>[http://opcofamerica.org/awards/2003-opc-award-winners Overseas Press Club of America website], accessed 25 July 2010</ref>
  
 
Goldberg has reported from various political hotspots in South Asia and the Middle East including Iraq, the occupied Palestinian territories, Afghanistan and Pakistan. He has received awards from various organizations including the Anti-Defamation League which provided him with their Daniel Pearl Prize in 2005.
 
Goldberg has reported from various political hotspots in South Asia and the Middle East including Iraq, the occupied Palestinian territories, Afghanistan and Pakistan. He has received awards from various organizations including the Anti-Defamation League which provided him with their Daniel Pearl Prize in 2005.
 
==Reaction to ''Prisoners: A Story of Friendship and Terror''==
 
  
 
==Analysis of "The Great Terror"==
 
==Analysis of "The Great Terror"==
  
Goldberg is best known for a series of articles he wrote during the run-up to the 2003 US-led invasion of Iraq which were used as reference by pro-war advocates. A 17,000+ word article in ''The New Yorker'' entitled "The Great Terror" was referenced by members of the Bush administration and has since been debunked by several analysts for its use of questionable sources (one of which was proven to be fabricated) and deeply alarmist claims.  
+
Goldberg is known for a series of articles he wrote during the run-up to the 2003 US-led invasion of Iraq which were used as reference by pro-war advocates. A 17,000+ word article in ''The New Yorker'' entitled "The Great Terror" was referenced by members of the Bush administration and has since been debunked by several analysts for its use of questionable sources and deeply alarmist claims.  
  
 
'''Goldberg on the alleged link between Iraq & Al Qaeda'''
 
'''Goldberg on the alleged link between Iraq & Al Qaeda'''
Line 24: Line 22:
  
 
:There is little doubt what Saddam might do with an atomic bomb or with his stocks of biological and chemical weapons. When I talked about Saddam’s past with the medical geneticist Christine Gosden, she said, 'Please understand, the Kurds were for practice.'"<ref name="JG"/>  
 
:There is little doubt what Saddam might do with an atomic bomb or with his stocks of biological and chemical weapons. When I talked about Saddam’s past with the medical geneticist Christine Gosden, she said, 'Please understand, the Kurds were for practice.'"<ref name="JG"/>  
 +
 +
According to Alexander Cockburn, Goldberg's "Great Terror" could not have come at a better time for pro-war members of the Bush Administration because it followed a joint FBI-CIA investigation which revealed that the alleged meeting between a 9/11 hijacker and an Iraqi intelligence agent prior to 9/11 (used as evidence that Al Qaeda was linked to Iraq) had not actually happened. Cockburn also notes that Jason Burke of the ''London Observer'' visited the Sulaimaniya prison where Goldberg met Mohammed Mansour Shahab, his main source for the "Great Terror," and established his lack of credibility. Burke's claim was also echoed by other journalists:
 +
 +
:"The piece was gratefully seized upon by the Administration as proof of The Link. The coup de grâce to Goldberg's credibility fell on February 9 of this year in the London Observer, administered by Jason Burke, its chief reporter. Burke visited the same prison in Sulaimaniya, talked to Shahab and established beyond doubt that Goldberg's great source is a clumsy liar, not even knowing the physical appearance of Kandahar, whither he had claimed to have journeyed to deal with bin Laden; and confecting his fantasies in the hope of a shorter prison sentence.
 +
:...
 +
:The European journalist, who doesn't want to be identified, said to me charitably that Golbberg's credulity about Shab 'could have been a matter of misjudgment but my even stronger criticism is that if you talked, as we did and as I gather Goldberg did, to anybody in the PUK [the Kurdish group controlling this area of northern Iraq] about this particular Islamic group all of them would tell you they are backed by Iran, as common sense would tell, you. Look where they are located. It's 200 meters across one river to Iran. That's what I find upsetting. Misjudging a source can happen to all of us, but Goldberg did talk to generals in the PUK. I think it's outrageous that New Yorker ran that story.'"<ref>Alexander Cockburn, [http://www.counterpunch.org/cockburn02282003.html 'Hacks and Heroes: Meet the New Yorker's Goldberg; Israeli Draft Resisters; Bulworth Screenwriter Lashes New York Times; Are Drunks' Dreams Corrupt?'], ''CounterPunch,'' 28 February 2003</ref>
 +
 +
==Reaction to ''Prisoners: A Story of Friendship and Terror''==
  
 
==Criticism==
 
==Criticism==

Revision as of 22:13, 25 July 2010

Jeffrey Goldberg is an American-Israeli journalist and Zionist political pundit that writes for David G. Bradley's The Atlantic. Referred to as Netanyahu's "faithful stenographer" by Roger Cohen of The New York Times,[1] Goldberg focuses on matters related to Israel and its relationship with the United States in particular. He was influential in building American support for the 2003 invasion of Iraq and has been criticized for making alarmist claims and using unreliable sources during the run-up to the war.[2] Goldberg is also known for launching attacks on those who criticize Israeli policy while constantly pushing the claim that Israel is a strategic asset rather than a liability for the US.[3] He has publicly attacked fellow staff members at The Atlantic (as well as the editors for their lack of "editorial standards") for allegedly making comments that are critical of Israel even though the publication and its writers are known to propagate a pro-Israel line.[4]

Early History

Goldberg was born and raised in New York but his self-stated strong identification with Israel saw him joining a Zionist summer camp and Kibbutz during his youth. He relocated to Israel during his college years and joined the Israeli Defense Forces shortly after. His acclaimed book, Prisoners: A Story of Friendship and Terror, is a memoir which includes an account of his experience as a guard at Ketziot, an Israeli prison located in the Negev desert were thousands of Palestinians were detained during the first intifada. Still in operation today, Ketziot is known for its harsh living conditions and for imprisoning boys and men without trial.[5]

During his residency in Israel, Goldberg served as a journalist for the right-wing Jerusalem Post. While working as Washington correspondent for The New Yorker, Goldberg produced an 17,000+ word article entitled "The Great Terror" which George W. Bush, Dick Cheney and others referenced as justification for the US invasion of Iraq. In it Goldberg described Saddam Hussein's gassing of the Kurds in long and vivid detail and strongly suggested that Hussein posed the same threat to the US and other nations. Goldberg also suggested that the Iraqi regime had ties with Al Qaeda. The article won the Overseas Press Club award for "Best international reporting in a print medium dealing with human rights."[6]

Goldberg has reported from various political hotspots in South Asia and the Middle East including Iraq, the occupied Palestinian territories, Afghanistan and Pakistan. He has received awards from various organizations including the Anti-Defamation League which provided him with their Daniel Pearl Prize in 2005.

Analysis of "The Great Terror"

Goldberg is known for a series of articles he wrote during the run-up to the 2003 US-led invasion of Iraq which were used as reference by pro-war advocates. A 17,000+ word article in The New Yorker entitled "The Great Terror" was referenced by members of the Bush administration and has since been debunked by several analysts for its use of questionable sources and deeply alarmist claims.

Goldberg on the alleged link between Iraq & Al Qaeda

"The allegations include charges that Ansar al-Islam has received funds directly from Al Qaeda; that the intelligence service of Saddam Hussein has joint control, with Al Qaeda operatives, over Ansar al-Islam; that Saddam Hussein hosted a senior leader of Al Qaeda in Baghdad in 1992; that a number of Al Qaeda members fleeing Afghanistan have been secretly brought into territory controlled by Ansar al-Islam; and that Iraqi intelligence agents smuggled conventional weapons, and possibly even chemical and biological weapons, into Afghanistan. If these charges are true, it would mean that the relationship between Saddam’s regime and Al Qaeda is far closer than previously thought."[7]

Goldberg on Iraq's alleged WMDs

There is some debate among arms-control experts about exactly when Saddam will have nuclear capabilities. But there is no disagreement that Iraq, if unchecked, will have them soon, and a nuclear-armed Iraq would alter forever the balance of power in the Middle East. “The first thing that occurs to any military planner is force protection,” Charles Duelfer told me. “If your assessment of the threat is chemical or biological, you can get individual protective equipment and warning systems. If you think he’s going to use a nuclear weapon, where are you going to concentrate your forces?”
There is little doubt what Saddam might do with an atomic bomb or with his stocks of biological and chemical weapons. When I talked about Saddam’s past with the medical geneticist Christine Gosden, she said, 'Please understand, the Kurds were for practice.'"[7]

According to Alexander Cockburn, Goldberg's "Great Terror" could not have come at a better time for pro-war members of the Bush Administration because it followed a joint FBI-CIA investigation which revealed that the alleged meeting between a 9/11 hijacker and an Iraqi intelligence agent prior to 9/11 (used as evidence that Al Qaeda was linked to Iraq) had not actually happened. Cockburn also notes that Jason Burke of the London Observer visited the Sulaimaniya prison where Goldberg met Mohammed Mansour Shahab, his main source for the "Great Terror," and established his lack of credibility. Burke's claim was also echoed by other journalists:

"The piece was gratefully seized upon by the Administration as proof of The Link. The coup de grâce to Goldberg's credibility fell on February 9 of this year in the London Observer, administered by Jason Burke, its chief reporter. Burke visited the same prison in Sulaimaniya, talked to Shahab and established beyond doubt that Goldberg's great source is a clumsy liar, not even knowing the physical appearance of Kandahar, whither he had claimed to have journeyed to deal with bin Laden; and confecting his fantasies in the hope of a shorter prison sentence.
...
The European journalist, who doesn't want to be identified, said to me charitably that Golbberg's credulity about Shab 'could have been a matter of misjudgment but my even stronger criticism is that if you talked, as we did and as I gather Goldberg did, to anybody in the PUK [the Kurdish group controlling this area of northern Iraq] about this particular Islamic group all of them would tell you they are backed by Iran, as common sense would tell, you. Look where they are located. It's 200 meters across one river to Iran. That's what I find upsetting. Misjudging a source can happen to all of us, but Goldberg did talk to generals in the PUK. I think it's outrageous that New Yorker ran that story.'"[8]

Reaction to Prisoners: A Story of Friendship and Terror

Criticism

War on Iran

According to M.J. Rosenberg of 'Talking Points Memo,' Goldberg is expected to produce reports similar to those which he produced during the run-up to the US-led invasion of Iraq, on Iran:

"For several days, the Atlantic's Jeff Goldberg has been calling Stephen Walt, John Mearsheimer and other critics of Bibi Netanyahu "anti-Semites." Nothing new about that. For Goldberg, a major AIPAC neocon, all critics of Israeli policies are anti-Semites by definition. (See this good piece on Goldberg).
But why is he obsessing about Walt so much now?
It is because, in August, Goldberg is coming out with his big Atlantic piece calling on the United States to bomb Iran so that Israel does not have to."[9]

Anti-Zionist Jews

Prominent Jewish-American journalist and blogger Philip Weiss has pointed out that Goldberg has refuted the Jewish identity of anti-Zionist Jews:

"Jeffrey Goldberg goes after the bloggers panel during the J Street conference and describes it as a group of "anti-Zionists with Jewish parents." Think about that. This is a statement of excommunication. He’s not saying anti-Zionist Jews. He’s saying we had Jewish parents. He’s not even calling us non-Jewish Jews, an insult that hurled by an old Israeli recently. This time we don’t get to be Jews. Thus he equates Jewishness with Zionism, entirely."[10]

References

  1. Roger Cohen, 'Israel Cries Wolf', The New York Times, 8 April 2009
  2. Ken Silverstein, 'Goldberg's War', Harper's Magazine, 30 June 2006
  3. Glenn Greenwald, 'The Jeffrey Goldberg Media', Salon.com, 27 June 2010
  4. Jeffrey Goldberg, 'Andrew Sullivan Revises History (Again)', The Atlantic, 12 March 2010
  5. Martin Asser, 'Palestinians languish in Israeli jails', BBC, 8 August 2003
  6. Overseas Press Club of America website, accessed 25 July 2010
  7. 7.0 7.1 Jeffrey Goldberg, 'The Great Terror', The New Yorker, 24 March 2002
  8. Alexander Cockburn, 'Hacks and Heroes: Meet the New Yorker's Goldberg; Israeli Draft Resisters; Bulworth Screenwriter Lashes New York Times; Are Drunks' Dreams Corrupt?', CounterPunch, 28 February 2003
  9. M.J. Rosenberg, 'Why Jeff Goldberg Is Losing It', 'Talking Points Memo Cafe,' 23 July 2010
  10. Philip Weiss, 'Jeffrey Goldberg suggests anti-Zionists aren’t Jews', Mondoweiss, 28 October 2009