Difference between revisions of "Emanuel Shinwell"

From Powerbase
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(New page: Labour politics and Israel, cited (Hansard, obituaries, Edmunds 1997))
 
(Fix duplicate ref name; merge Balfour rally detail with existing JC 27 Oct 1967 sentence)
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 15: Line 15:
 
=== 1940s ===
 
=== 1940s ===
 
The Jewish Telegraphic Agency's obituary states that in a speech to the Labour Party conference of 1933 Shinwell openly avowed that he was Jewish, that he voted in Parliament for the partition of Palestine and backed the United Nations resolution of November 1947, and that as Secretary of State for War from the end of 1947 he was in charge of the British withdrawal from Palestine. It also records that his relations with [[Ernest Bevin]] were bad, and that Bevin taunted him as an "Oriental".<ref name="JTA1986" />
 
The Jewish Telegraphic Agency's obituary states that in a speech to the Labour Party conference of 1933 Shinwell openly avowed that he was Jewish, that he voted in Parliament for the partition of Palestine and backed the United Nations resolution of November 1947, and that as Secretary of State for War from the end of 1947 he was in charge of the British withdrawal from Palestine. It also records that his relations with [[Ernest Bevin]] were bad, and that Bevin taunted him as an "Oriental".<ref name="JTA1986" />
 +
 +
In October 1943 the ''[[Jewish Echo]]'' reported, under the headline "Mr. Shinwell Denounces Palestine Arms Trials", his words: "I am a Jew and I never made a secret of this fact". He said he was "horrified at the despicable conduct of the court in Jerusalem which sentenced two civilians to long terms of imprisonment in gun-running trial, while a similar trial of an Arab resulted in a mild sentence", and that he was "proud of these two young men who tried to get arms to defend themselves".<ref name="JE431029">"Mr. Shinwell Denounces Palestine Arms Trials", ''Jewish Echo'' (Glasgow), 29 October 1943, p. 2, [https://www.britishnewspaperarchive.com/image-viewer?issue=BL%2F0006134%2F19431029&page=0002&article=002 British Newspaper Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref> A 1947 profile of him in the paper, "The Man Behind the Coal Crisis", said that he was "not unfavourable towards Zionism" and that "it is said" he had joined [[Aneurin Bevan]] in taking a stand against [[Clement Attlee]] and Bevin on Palestine. It reported his opinion that until a solution was found "Jewish immigration and land resettlement should continue", but also said that "he was never actively interested in the Jewish problem".<ref name="JE470314">"The Man Behind the Coal Crisis", ''Jewish Echo'' (Glasgow), 14 March 1947, p. 2, [https://www.britishnewspaperarchive.com/image-viewer?issue=BL%2F0006134%2F19470314&page=0002&article=004 British Newspaper Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref>
  
 
[[June Edmunds]], in her 1997 thesis on the British left and Israel, counts Shinwell among the pro-Zionists in the Attlee government who were "not sufficiently knowledgeable about foreign policy effectively to oppose the Palestine policy".<ref name="Edmunds1997p49">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 49, citing Kenneth O. Morgan, ''Labour in Power, 1945–1951'' (1989).</ref> She also records that Shinwell, with [[Hugh Dalton]] and Morgan Phillips, initiated the policy of purging the party of "fellow-travellers" in the late 1940s.<ref name="Edmunds1997p165">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 165.</ref>
 
[[June Edmunds]], in her 1997 thesis on the British left and Israel, counts Shinwell among the pro-Zionists in the Attlee government who were "not sufficiently knowledgeable about foreign policy effectively to oppose the Palestine policy".<ref name="Edmunds1997p49">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 49, citing Kenneth O. Morgan, ''Labour in Power, 1945–1951'' (1989).</ref> She also records that Shinwell, with [[Hugh Dalton]] and Morgan Phillips, initiated the policy of purging the party of "fellow-travellers" in the late 1940s.<ref name="Edmunds1997p165">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 165.</ref>
Line 22: Line 24:
  
 
=== 1967 and after ===
 
=== 1967 and after ===
−
During the June 1967 war Shinwell "forcefully attacked the leadership for failing to take positive action in favour of Israel".<ref name="Edmunds1997p105">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 105, citing ''The Times'', 8 June 1967, p. 7.</ref> The Jewish Telegraphic Agency wrote that he began appearing on Jewish public platforms as a defender of Israel only in his eighties. A week after the 1973 Yom Kippur War he addressed 18,000 people in Trafalgar Square and said that Israel was entitled to hold all the territory taken in 1967, and in 1981, on hearing of Israel's destruction of the Iraqi nuclear reactor, he exclaimed "Thank God for Begin".<ref name="JTA1986" />
+
During the June 1967 war Shinwell "forcefully attacked the leadership for failing to take positive action in favour of Israel".<ref name="Edmunds1997p105">June Edmunds, [https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/133840/ ''The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada''], PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 105, citing ''The Times'', 8 June 1967, p. 7.</ref> In the Commons during the war, according to the ''[[The Jewish Chronicle|Jewish Chronicle]]'', he urged the government to depart from its neutrality by congratulating Israel on having resisted "the threat of annihilation", saying: "I am not afraid of the Arabs or the Nassers. I am not afraid of anyone—I take sides".<ref name="JC670609">''The Jewish Chronicle'', 9 June 1967, p. 12, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/MTVkOWI0YTgtN2YwZi00 JC Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref> In October 1967, at a Balfour Day meeting in London, he made what the paper called "a blistering attack" on the Middle East policy of the Foreign Secretary, [[George Brown]].<ref name="JC671027p1">"Attack by Shinwell", ''The Jewish Chronicle'', 27 October 1967, p. 1, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/NGNkYzc5OWUtNTMyZi00 JC Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref> The meeting, held by the [[Board of Deputies of British Jews|Board of Deputies]] at Woburn House on 22 October 1967 to mark the 50th anniversary of the [[Balfour Declaration]], was chaired by the Board's president, [[Michael Fidler]]. According to the report, Shinwell blamed Brown for Egypt's sinking of the Israeli destroyer ''Elath'', calling it "a result of the cynical attitude taken by the Foreign Secretary and of his encouragement of Nasser". He praised Israel's "great and outstanding military victory" and said: "I deplore the stand of the Government which I support, which I helped into power and which I hope will continue in power." He went on: "our answer must be to bring every pressure we can mobilise on the United States, on the United Nations and on our own Government—and on our press". The Conservative MP [[John Biggs-Davison]] also spoke.<ref name="JC671027p17">"Brown accused at Balfour rally", ''The Jewish Chronicle'', 27 October 1967, p. 17, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/NWY3ZDQ4ZmYtM2E0MS00 JC Archive] (subscription required; OCR text), accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> In February 1969 it reported "a slanging match" in the Commons between Shinwell and [[Christopher Mayhew]] during a discussion on the Middle East.<ref name="JC690214">"Shinwell and Mayhew in Commons row", ''The Jewish Chronicle'', 14 February 1969, p. 18, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/M2FkNWE4ZDAtZmFjYy00 JC Archive] (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.</ref> The Jewish Telegraphic Agency wrote that he began appearing on Jewish public platforms as a defender of Israel only in his eighties. A week after the 1973 Yom Kippur War he addressed 18,000 people in Trafalgar Square and said that Israel was entitled to hold all the territory taken in 1967, and in 1981, on hearing of Israel's destruction of the Iraqi nuclear reactor, he exclaimed "Thank God for Begin".<ref name="JTA1986" />
  
 
== See also ==
 
== See also ==

Latest revision as of 11:42, 19 November 2026

British Labour politician (1884–1986); Minister of Fuel and Power, Secretary of State for War and Minister of Defence in the Attlee governments

Emanuel Shinwell

Image Emanuel Shinwell (IWM HU 59765).jpg
Emanuel Shinwell (Imperial War Museums HU 59765; public domain)
Born 18 October 1884
Died 8 May 1986
Nationality British
Occupation Trade unionist; politician
Known for Minister of Fuel and Power (1945–1947); Secretary of State for War (1947–1950); Minister of Defence (1950–1951)

Emanuel Shinwell (18 October 1884 – 8 May 1986), later Lord Shinwell, was a British Labour Party politician. He sat for Linlithgowshire in the 1920s, for Seaham from 1935 and for Easington from 1950 to 1970. In the Attlee governments he was Minister of Fuel and Power from 1945 to 1947, Secretary of State for War from 1947 to 1950 and Minister of Defence from 1950 to 1951. He was made a life peer in 1970.[1] He was born in Spitalfields, London.[2]

Palestine and Israel

1940s

The Jewish Telegraphic Agency's obituary states that in a speech to the Labour Party conference of 1933 Shinwell openly avowed that he was Jewish, that he voted in Parliament for the partition of Palestine and backed the United Nations resolution of November 1947, and that as Secretary of State for War from the end of 1947 he was in charge of the British withdrawal from Palestine. It also records that his relations with Ernest Bevin were bad, and that Bevin taunted him as an "Oriental".[2]

In October 1943 the Jewish Echo reported, under the headline "Mr. Shinwell Denounces Palestine Arms Trials", his words: "I am a Jew and I never made a secret of this fact". He said he was "horrified at the despicable conduct of the court in Jerusalem which sentenced two civilians to long terms of imprisonment in gun-running trial, while a similar trial of an Arab resulted in a mild sentence", and that he was "proud of these two young men who tried to get arms to defend themselves".[3] A 1947 profile of him in the paper, "The Man Behind the Coal Crisis", said that he was "not unfavourable towards Zionism" and that "it is said" he had joined Aneurin Bevan in taking a stand against Clement Attlee and Bevin on Palestine. It reported his opinion that until a solution was found "Jewish immigration and land resettlement should continue", but also said that "he was never actively interested in the Jewish problem".[4]

June Edmunds, in her 1997 thesis on the British left and Israel, counts Shinwell among the pro-Zionists in the Attlee government who were "not sufficiently knowledgeable about foreign policy effectively to oppose the Palestine policy".[5] She also records that Shinwell, with Hugh Dalton and Morgan Phillips, initiated the policy of purging the party of "fellow-travellers" in the late 1940s.[6]

Suez, 1956

Edmunds writes that Shinwell, who had "never forgiven Gaitskell for replacing him as Minister of Fuel and Power in 1947", publicly criticised Labour's policy during the Suez crisis. He "was not actively involved in Zionist or Jewish organisations" and "as a socialist he rejected zionist philosophy", but had "a strong emotional commitment to the Jewish state, rooted in his view of it as a refuge for the Jews and as an experiment in socialism". He mainly voted with the party but deliberately abstained on the vote condemning Israeli policy.[7] She quotes him in the Commons: "When, as a result of Hitler's dastardly acts, millions of people were destroyed in gas chambers, what could one expect? There must be a haven, a refuge for persecuted people, the victims of the pogroms and the rest, and there was the state of Israel".[8] He signed the pro-Israel early day motion of 1956.[9] The Jewish Telegraphic Agency obituary says that during Suez he "stoutly defended both Israel and the Conservative government of Anthony Eden".[2]

1967 and after

During the June 1967 war Shinwell "forcefully attacked the leadership for failing to take positive action in favour of Israel".[10] In the Commons during the war, according to the Jewish Chronicle, he urged the government to depart from its neutrality by congratulating Israel on having resisted "the threat of annihilation", saying: "I am not afraid of the Arabs or the Nassers. I am not afraid of anyone—I take sides".[11] In October 1967, at a Balfour Day meeting in London, he made what the paper called "a blistering attack" on the Middle East policy of the Foreign Secretary, George Brown.[12] The meeting, held by the Board of Deputies at Woburn House on 22 October 1967 to mark the 50th anniversary of the Balfour Declaration, was chaired by the Board's president, Michael Fidler. According to the report, Shinwell blamed Brown for Egypt's sinking of the Israeli destroyer Elath, calling it "a result of the cynical attitude taken by the Foreign Secretary and of his encouragement of Nasser". He praised Israel's "great and outstanding military victory" and said: "I deplore the stand of the Government which I support, which I helped into power and which I hope will continue in power." He went on: "our answer must be to bring every pressure we can mobilise on the United States, on the United Nations and on our own Government—and on our press". The Conservative MP John Biggs-Davison also spoke.[13] In February 1969 it reported "a slanging match" in the Commons between Shinwell and Christopher Mayhew during a discussion on the Middle East.[14] The Jewish Telegraphic Agency wrote that he began appearing on Jewish public platforms as a defender of Israel only in his eighties. A week after the 1973 Yom Kippur War he addressed 18,000 people in Trafalgar Square and said that Israel was entitled to hold all the territory taken in 1967, and in 1981, on hearing of Israel's destruction of the Iraqi nuclear reactor, he exclaimed "Thank God for Begin".[2]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ Mr Emanuel Shinwell, Hansard 1803–2005, UK Parliament, accessed 18 November 2026.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 Lord Shinwell Dead at 101, Jewish Telegraphic Agency, 9 May 1986, accessed 18 November 2026.
  3. ↑ "Mr. Shinwell Denounces Palestine Arms Trials", Jewish Echo (Glasgow), 29 October 1943, p. 2, British Newspaper Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  4. ↑ "The Man Behind the Coal Crisis", Jewish Echo (Glasgow), 14 March 1947, p. 2, British Newspaper Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  5. ↑ June Edmunds, The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada, PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 49, citing Kenneth O. Morgan, Labour in Power, 1945–1951 (1989).
  6. ↑ June Edmunds, The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada, PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 165.
  7. ↑ June Edmunds, The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada, PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 67, citing Kenneth O. Morgan, Labour People (1992), p. 222, and Parliamentary Debates, Commons, vol. 570, cols. 608–609.
  8. ↑ June Edmunds, The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada, PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 82, citing Parliamentary Debates, Commons, vol. 570, col. 609.
  9. ↑ June Edmunds, The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada, PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 233, appendix 3.1.
  10. ↑ June Edmunds, The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada, PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, p. 105, citing The Times, 8 June 1967, p. 7.
  11. ↑ The Jewish Chronicle, 9 June 1967, p. 12, JC Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  12. ↑ "Attack by Shinwell", The Jewish Chronicle, 27 October 1967, p. 1, JC Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.
  13. ↑ "Brown accused at Balfour rally", The Jewish Chronicle, 27 October 1967, p. 17, JC Archive (subscription required; OCR text), accessed 19 November 2026.
  14. ↑ "Shinwell and Mayhew in Commons row", The Jewish Chronicle, 14 February 1969, p. 18, JC Archive (subscription required), accessed 18 November 2026.