Difference between revisions of "John Hynd"
(New page (Labour batch 5): Labour record on Zionism, Israel and Palestine; sources Edmunds 1997, Kelemen 2012, Hansard and others) |
(Add section on Hynd as minister for Germany and Austria 1945–47: Jewish displaced persons in the British zone (Hansard; JC 28 Dec 1945), as approved by the editor) |
||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
}} | }} | ||
'''John Hynd''' was a British [[Labour Party (UK)|Labour Party]] politician. He was MP for Sheffield Attercliffe from a by-election in February 1944 until June 1970. In the [[Clement Attlee|Attlee]] government he was Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster from 1945 to 1947, and briefly Minister of Pensions in 1947.<ref name="HansardPeople">[https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/people/mr-john-hynd/index.html Mr John Hynd], ''Hansard 1803–2005'', UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> | '''John Hynd''' was a British [[Labour Party (UK)|Labour Party]] politician. He was MP for Sheffield Attercliffe from a by-election in February 1944 until June 1970. In the [[Clement Attlee|Attlee]] government he was Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster from 1945 to 1947, and briefly Minister of Pensions in 1947.<ref name="HansardPeople">[https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/people/mr-john-hynd/index.html Mr John Hynd], ''Hansard 1803–2005'', UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | == Minister for Germany and Austria, 1945–1947 == | ||
| + | As Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster in the [[Clement Attlee|Attlee]] government, Hynd answered in the Commons for the British zones of occupation in Germany and Austria, including the displaced persons' camps.<ref name="HansardPeople" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | On 20 December 1945, in reply to a private notice question from [[Eleanor Rathbone]] "concerning the treatment of Jewish displaced persons in the British Zone in Germany", Hynd said that the criticisms she referred to were "without foundation". He told the House that of about 550,000 displaced persons in the British zone who were not immediately repatriable, "only a relatively small proportion were Jews", and that "Jewish persons receive the same treatment and facilities as other displaced persons". He said the Belsen camp itself had been destroyed, and that about 9,500 Jews were among the displaced persons at the nearby Hoehne assembly centre, where "No restriction is placed on Zionist activities" and there had been no disturbance. He described the press criticisms abroad as "in this case deliberately fabricated", and said he was "already considering the appointment of Jewish advisers". When [[Barnett Janner]] asked whether he would consider "separate camps" for Jewish displaced persons, Hynd replied: "I am afraid the implication would be very detrimental."<ref name="HC451220">[https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1945/dec/20/displaced-personstreatment "Displaced Persons (Treatment)"], HC Deb 20 December 1945, vol. 417, cc. 1525–1529, ''Hansard'', UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> The parliamentary report in the ''Jewish Chronicle'', headed "Displaced Persons in Germany: Jewish Advisers May Be Appointed", said that Hynd "was ready with an important statement, which made an impression on the House".<ref name="JC451228">"Displaced Persons in Germany: Jewish Advisers May Be Appointed", ''The Jewish Chronicle'', 28 December 1945, p. 5, [https://www.thejc.com/archive/OTY5N2Q4NWItZWE5OS00 JC Archive] (subscription required), accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> Three days earlier he had told Rathbone that "Poles, including Jewish persons, in the British Zone in Germany are not repatriated against their wishes".<ref name="HC451217">[https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1945/dec/17/polish-displaced-persons "Polish Displaced Persons"], HC Deb 17 December 1945, vol. 417, cc. 921–922, ''Hansard'', UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | In March 1946, answering Janner and [[Maurice Orbach]], Hynd announced that "After consultation with the [[Board of Deputies of British Jews]]" he had appointed Lieutenant-Colonel R. B. Solomon as adviser on Jewish affairs to the British element of the Control Commission for Germany. No similar appointment was proposed for Austria.<ref name="HC460318">[https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1946/mar/18/adviser-on-jewish-affairs-appointment "Adviser on Jewish Affairs (Appointment)"], HC Deb 18 March 1946, vol. 420, c. 1526, ''Hansard'', UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> On 31 May 1946, answering a private notice question from [[Sydney Silverman]] about clashes at Belsen, he said that after "a very serious increase in crime" in the area the military commander had decided to close the camp while investigations were carried out. According to Hynd, Jews "staged demonstrations and processions", troops "exercised the utmost restraint", and there had been "no shooting whatsoever", although a police officer had briefly used a low-pressure fire hose. Janner told him that the camp's inmates were "almost in despair because they have no indication that they are to have access to Palestine". Hynd replied that the accommodation, food and amenities provided "are a burden upon ourselves", and that the "final disposal of the people in this camp, both Poles and Polish Jews, has not yet been finally decided".<ref name="HC460531">[https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1946/may/31/bergen-belsen-gamp-jewish-demonstrations "Bergen Belsen Gamp [sic] (Jewish Demonstrations)"], HC Deb 31 May 1946, vol. 423, cc. 1487–1489, ''Hansard'', UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> In October 1946, asked whether trawlers allocated to a Jewish committee in Hamburg were being used to move displaced persons out illegally, he said that a Jewish fishery school had used three river craft without Military Government authority and its activities had been suspended. He had been "unable to obtain evidence of any unauthorised emigration of displaced or persecuted persons by this means".<ref name="HC461017">[https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1946/oct/17/jewish-fishery-school "Jewish Fishery School"], HC Deb 17 October 1946, vol. 427, cc. 1058–1059, ''Hansard'', UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | In a debate on Germany in February 1947, Hynd answered complaints by Silverman about the position of the "infiltrees", a term Hynd said he was taking from Silverman. He said there was "a large number, I understand, of refugees from Poland and elsewhere, mainly Jews, so far as I can gather, who have come into our zone in defiance of the regulations". He said they would be fed, sheltered and clothed if they registered, but that "They have no proper rights as displaced persons", and that "we cannot really accept responsibility for everyone who cares to come into Germany and expects us to maintain him in these camps without obligation". He added: "Our purpose is to achieve dispersal of these persons as soon as possible."<ref name="HC470205">[https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1947/feb/05/germany-conditions "Germany (Conditions)"], HC Deb 5 February 1947, vol. 432, cc. 1911–1912, ''Hansard'', UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> In March 1947 he told the Commons that most Jewish displaced persons in the British zone were "accommodated at one large assembly centre, for convenience in meeting their religious needs and supplying them with Jewish foods", and had been exempted from being moved away from the camp for work.<ref name="HC470326">[https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1947/mar/26/displaced-persons "Displaced Persons"], HC Deb 26 March 1947, vol. 435, c. 1229, ''Hansard'', UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.</ref> | ||
== Suez, 1956 == | == Suez, 1956 == | ||
| Line 17: | Line 26: | ||
== See also == | == See also == | ||
| + | * [[Barnett Janner]] | ||
| + | * [[Sydney Silverman]] | ||
* [[William Warbey]] | * [[William Warbey]] | ||
* [[Edith Summerskill]] | * [[Edith Summerskill]] | ||
Latest revision as of 14:44, 19 November 2026
British Labour politician; MP for Sheffield Attercliffe 1944–1970
| John Hynd
| |
|---|---|
| Nationality | British |
| Occupation | Politician |
| Known for | Labour MP for Sheffield Attercliffe (1944–1970); Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster (1945–1947) |
John Hynd was a British Labour Party politician. He was MP for Sheffield Attercliffe from a by-election in February 1944 until June 1970. In the Attlee government he was Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster from 1945 to 1947, and briefly Minister of Pensions in 1947.[1]
Minister for Germany and Austria, 1945–1947
As Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster in the Attlee government, Hynd answered in the Commons for the British zones of occupation in Germany and Austria, including the displaced persons' camps.[1]
On 20 December 1945, in reply to a private notice question from Eleanor Rathbone "concerning the treatment of Jewish displaced persons in the British Zone in Germany", Hynd said that the criticisms she referred to were "without foundation". He told the House that of about 550,000 displaced persons in the British zone who were not immediately repatriable, "only a relatively small proportion were Jews", and that "Jewish persons receive the same treatment and facilities as other displaced persons". He said the Belsen camp itself had been destroyed, and that about 9,500 Jews were among the displaced persons at the nearby Hoehne assembly centre, where "No restriction is placed on Zionist activities" and there had been no disturbance. He described the press criticisms abroad as "in this case deliberately fabricated", and said he was "already considering the appointment of Jewish advisers". When Barnett Janner asked whether he would consider "separate camps" for Jewish displaced persons, Hynd replied: "I am afraid the implication would be very detrimental."[2] The parliamentary report in the Jewish Chronicle, headed "Displaced Persons in Germany: Jewish Advisers May Be Appointed", said that Hynd "was ready with an important statement, which made an impression on the House".[3] Three days earlier he had told Rathbone that "Poles, including Jewish persons, in the British Zone in Germany are not repatriated against their wishes".[4]
In March 1946, answering Janner and Maurice Orbach, Hynd announced that "After consultation with the Board of Deputies of British Jews" he had appointed Lieutenant-Colonel R. B. Solomon as adviser on Jewish affairs to the British element of the Control Commission for Germany. No similar appointment was proposed for Austria.[5] On 31 May 1946, answering a private notice question from Sydney Silverman about clashes at Belsen, he said that after "a very serious increase in crime" in the area the military commander had decided to close the camp while investigations were carried out. According to Hynd, Jews "staged demonstrations and processions", troops "exercised the utmost restraint", and there had been "no shooting whatsoever", although a police officer had briefly used a low-pressure fire hose. Janner told him that the camp's inmates were "almost in despair because they have no indication that they are to have access to Palestine". Hynd replied that the accommodation, food and amenities provided "are a burden upon ourselves", and that the "final disposal of the people in this camp, both Poles and Polish Jews, has not yet been finally decided".[6] In October 1946, asked whether trawlers allocated to a Jewish committee in Hamburg were being used to move displaced persons out illegally, he said that a Jewish fishery school had used three river craft without Military Government authority and its activities had been suspended. He had been "unable to obtain evidence of any unauthorised emigration of displaced or persecuted persons by this means".[7]
In a debate on Germany in February 1947, Hynd answered complaints by Silverman about the position of the "infiltrees", a term Hynd said he was taking from Silverman. He said there was "a large number, I understand, of refugees from Poland and elsewhere, mainly Jews, so far as I can gather, who have come into our zone in defiance of the regulations". He said they would be fed, sheltered and clothed if they registered, but that "They have no proper rights as displaced persons", and that "we cannot really accept responsibility for everyone who cares to come into Germany and expects us to maintain him in these camps without obligation". He added: "Our purpose is to achieve dispersal of these persons as soon as possible."[8] In March 1947 he told the Commons that most Jewish displaced persons in the British zone were "accommodated at one large assembly centre, for convenience in meeting their religious needs and supplying them with Jewish foods", and had been exempted from being moved away from the camp for work.[9]
Suez, 1956
In her 1997 doctoral thesis on the British left's views of Israel, June Edmunds writes that the Labour leader, Hugh Gaitskell, was "contemptuous of people who sympathised with" President Nasser of Egypt during the Suez crisis. She names Hynd with William Warbey, Tony Benn and Edith Summerskill. In her account, Gaitskell challenged "their automatic defence of any eastern country and their failure to recognise that Nasser was a dictator".[10]
On 24 October 1956, days before the Israeli attack on Egypt, Hynd asked how much the United Nations relief agencies had spent on Palestinian refugees since 1948 and what Britain had contributed, and whether the British contribution compared favourably with those of the United States and the Soviet Union.[11] On 30 October, after Israel invaded Egypt and Britain and France issued their ultimatum, he asked the Prime Minister, Anthony Eden, about the Tripartite Declaration and about Israel's assurance, given the night before, that it would not invade Jordan. He noted that "Those raids about which Israel has been complaining were from Jordan and not from Egypt", and said that many in the House and the country believed that "for a long time past the Prime Minister and the Government have been determined to find some excuse for landing British troops in the Canal area".[12]
Later
In February 1960 Hynd asked the Foreign Secretary whether, "in view of the deliberate defiance by Her Majesty's Government of the Tripartite Agreement in 1956", it would not be wise "to scrap this altogether, so that all know where they stand".[13]
See also
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 Mr John Hynd, Hansard 1803–2005, UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.
- ↑ "Displaced Persons (Treatment)", HC Deb 20 December 1945, vol. 417, cc. 1525–1529, Hansard, UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.
- ↑ "Displaced Persons in Germany: Jewish Advisers May Be Appointed", The Jewish Chronicle, 28 December 1945, p. 5, JC Archive (subscription required), accessed 19 November 2026.
- ↑ "Polish Displaced Persons", HC Deb 17 December 1945, vol. 417, cc. 921–922, Hansard, UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.
- ↑ "Adviser on Jewish Affairs (Appointment)", HC Deb 18 March 1946, vol. 420, c. 1526, Hansard, UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.
- ↑ "Bergen Belsen Gamp [sic (Jewish Demonstrations)"], HC Deb 31 May 1946, vol. 423, cc. 1487–1489, Hansard, UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.
- ↑ "Jewish Fishery School", HC Deb 17 October 1946, vol. 427, cc. 1058–1059, Hansard, UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.
- ↑ "Germany (Conditions)", HC Deb 5 February 1947, vol. 432, cc. 1911–1912, Hansard, UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.
- ↑ "Displaced Persons", HC Deb 26 March 1947, vol. 435, c. 1229, Hansard, UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.
- ↑ June Edmunds, The Left's Views on Israel: From the establishment of the Jewish state to the intifada, PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science, 1997, pp. 70–71, citing Hugh Gaitskell's diary in Philip Williams (ed.), The Diary of Hugh Gaitskell 1945–1956 (1983), pp. 567–569.
- ↑ "Palestine Refugees (Relief Disbursements)", HC Deb 24 October 1956, vol. 558, c. 616, Hansard, UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.
- ↑ "Egypt and Israel", HC Deb 30 October 1956, vol. 558, cc. 1292–1293, Hansard, UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.
- ↑ "United Arab Republic and Israel", HC Deb 17 February 1960, vol. 617, c. 1267, Hansard, UK Parliament, accessed 19 November 2026.