Difference between revisions of "ANBio"
m (→Role in dismissing Seralini's GM maize study) |
(→Funding) |
||
| (6 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
==Role in dismissing Seralini's GM maize study== | ==Role in dismissing Seralini's GM maize study== | ||
| − | [[File:ANBio_board_circa_2001_screengrab_taken_20Nov2012.png|277px|thumb|right|ANBio Executive Board circa 2001. Screengrab taken 26.11.12]] [[File:Anbio_Corporate_Institutional_members_2001_screengrab.png|200px|thumb|right|ANBio Corporate and institutional members circa 2001. Screengrab taken 26.11.12]]In November 2012 ANBio directors [[Lucia de Souza]] and [[Leila Macedo Oda]], who were | + | [[File:ANBio_board_circa_2001_screengrab_taken_20Nov2012.png|277px|thumb|right|ANBio Executive Board circa 2001. Screengrab taken 26.11.12]] [[File:Anbio_Corporate_Institutional_members_2001_screengrab.png|200px|thumb|right|ANBio Corporate and institutional members circa 2001. Screengrab taken 26.11.12]]In November 2012 ANBio directors [[Lucia de Souza]] and [[Leila Macedo Oda]], who were on ANBio's board in 2001 when it included GM companies among its "corporate members",<ref>Leila Macedo Oda was listed as 'Diretor Presidente [http://www.powerbase.info/images/4/4a/Book_anbio1.pdf ANBio website], downloaded 2001</ref> had a letter published in the scientific journal ''Food and Chemical Toxicology''. In it they expressed their "serious concerns" about the journal's earlier publication of a paper by Professor [[G.E. Seralini]] and colleagues at the [[University of Caen]], France, which they criticised as flawed.<ref>de Souza, L. and L. M. Oda (2012). [http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0278691512008022 Letter to the editor]. Food and Chemical Toxicology.</ref> Seralini's study had found that rats fed on [[Monsanto]]'s GM maize NK603 and tiny amounts of the crop's associated herbicide Roundup had increased tumour incidence, mortality, and serious liver and kidney damage.<ref>Séralini, G. E., E. Clair, et al. (2012). [http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0278691512005637 Long term toxicity of a Roundup herbicide and a Roundup-tolerant genetically modified maize]. Food and Chemical Toxicology 50(11): 4221-4231.</ref> |
| − | In their letter to Food and Chemical Toxicology De Souza and Oda listed their affiliation as ANBio, though no mention was made in their published letter of ANBio's funders, which in 2001 included GM seed developer and trading companies Monsanto, [[Bayer]], [[Cargill]], [[DuPont]], and [[Pioneer]].<ref>de Souza, L. and L. M. Oda (2012). [http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0278691512008022 Letter to the editor]. Food and Chemical Toxicology.</ref> | + | In their letter to ''Food and Chemical Toxicology'' De Souza and Oda listed their affiliation as ANBio, though no mention was made in their published letter of ANBio's funders, which in 2001 included GM seed developer and trading companies Monsanto, [[Bayer]], [[Cargill]], [[DuPont]], and [[Pioneer]].<ref>de Souza, L. and L. M. Oda (2012). [http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0278691512008022 Letter to the editor]. Food and Chemical Toxicology.</ref> |
Oda was the major source quoted in an ANBio press release disseminated two days after the release of Seralini's paper. The release said AnBio "warned about the dissemination of research developed without appropriate scientific methodology, without statistical significance and elaborated in a rather biased way". | Oda was the major source quoted in an ANBio press release disseminated two days after the release of Seralini's paper. The release said AnBio "warned about the dissemination of research developed without appropriate scientific methodology, without statistical significance and elaborated in a rather biased way". | ||
| Line 21: | Line 21: | ||
==Funding== | ==Funding== | ||
| − | 2001: According to ANBio web pages downloaded in 2001,<ref>[http://www.powerbase.info/images/4/4a/Book_anbio1.pdf AnBio website], downloaded 2001</ref> the organisation's corporate partners (funders) included the following | + | 2001: According to ANBio web pages downloaded in 2001,<ref>[http://www.powerbase.info/images/4/4a/Book_anbio1.pdf AnBio website], downloaded 2001</ref> the organisation's corporate partners (funders) included the following genetically modified organism development/trading/user companies: |
*[[Bayer]] | *[[Bayer]] | ||
*[[Cargill]] | *[[Cargill]] | ||
| Line 29: | Line 29: | ||
*[[Novozymes]] | *[[Novozymes]] | ||
*[[Pioneer]] | *[[Pioneer]] | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | Information on corporate funders as at November 2012 can no longer be found on AnBio's website but an English translated list of its "corporate and institutional members" circa 2001 along with its Executive Board, Scientific Committee and Audit Committee can be [http://www.anbio.org.br/english/book.htm found here], and also includes [[Syngenta]]. | + | Information on corporate funders as at November 2012 can no longer be found on AnBio's website but an English translated list of its "corporate and institutional members" circa 2001 along with its Executive Board, Scientific Committee and Audit Committee can be [http://www.anbio.org.br/english/book.htm found here], and also includes [[Monsanto]], [[Cargill]], [[Aventis]], and [[Syngenta]]. |
==People== | ==People== | ||
Latest revision as of 16:06, 26 November 2012
ANBio is the National Biosafety Association of Brazil, which was set up in March 1999 as a "non-profit scientific society" with "the purpose of promoting Biosafety as a scientific subject". [1]
According to ANBio's website in 2001 it was funded by the big genetically modified (GM) crop companies,[2][1] although it does not declare that on its website as of 2012.
Contents
Role in dismissing Seralini's GM maize study
In November 2012 ANBio directors Lucia de Souza and Leila Macedo Oda, who were on ANBio's board in 2001 when it included GM companies among its "corporate members",[3] had a letter published in the scientific journal Food and Chemical Toxicology. In it they expressed their "serious concerns" about the journal's earlier publication of a paper by Professor G.E. Seralini and colleagues at the University of Caen, France, which they criticised as flawed.[4] Seralini's study had found that rats fed on Monsanto's GM maize NK603 and tiny amounts of the crop's associated herbicide Roundup had increased tumour incidence, mortality, and serious liver and kidney damage.[5]
In their letter to Food and Chemical Toxicology De Souza and Oda listed their affiliation as ANBio, though no mention was made in their published letter of ANBio's funders, which in 2001 included GM seed developer and trading companies Monsanto, Bayer, Cargill, DuPont, and Pioneer.[6]
Oda was the major source quoted in an ANBio press release disseminated two days after the release of Seralini's paper. The release said AnBio "warned about the dissemination of research developed without appropriate scientific methodology, without statistical significance and elaborated in a rather biased way".
Oda was quoted in the ANBio release as saying that "ideological positions can influence quite negatively the understanding of reputable scientific information on GM food, vaccines and even biological medicines produced by modern biotechnology."
The ANBio release said, clearly referring to Seralini's study but without mentioning his name, "ANBio challenges the technical credibility of a questionable French study that casts doubts on the safety of one of the technologies of transgenic corn, which has been consumed by millions of people worldwide for nearly 10 years."[7]
Again, no mention was made in the published release about ANBio's funders. The organisation was described in neutral terms as if its primary focus were "biosafety" and "biosecurity":
- The National Biosafety Association (ANBio) was established in 1999 with the aim of disseminating information about advances in modern biotechnology and its control mechanisms. Promoting knowledge of biosecurity and its practices are in its scope of work, as a scientific discipline, as well as training and guidance of professionals who implement biosafety in research institutions and biomedical education.[8]
Oda was also quoted criticising Seralini's study in an article for the Russian news outlet Pravda, in which she was described as "president of National Biosafety, ANBio".[9]
Funding
2001: According to ANBio web pages downloaded in 2001,[10] the organisation's corporate partners (funders) included the following genetically modified organism development/trading/user companies:
Information on corporate funders as at November 2012 can no longer be found on AnBio's website but an English translated list of its "corporate and institutional members" circa 2001 along with its Executive Board, Scientific Committee and Audit Committee can be found here, and also includes Monsanto, Cargill, Aventis, and Syngenta.
People
- Leila dos Santos Macedo - Founder and President[11]
- Lúcia Helena Oliveira de Souza - vice president since 2005. She is also involved in the international Public Research and Regulation Initiative, which counts Monsanto among its funders as recently as 2009. [11]
Contact
- Address:
- ANBio - Associação Nacional de Biossegurança
- Av. Rio Branco, nº 37 Grupo 507, Centro - Rio de Janeiro CEP: 20090-003
- Tel: (0xx21) 2220-8327 / 2220-8678-
- Tel/Fax: (0xx21) 2215-8580
- Email:
- Website: http://www.anbio.org.br/site/
Resources
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 Science & Technology with Safety, circa 2001, acc 26 November 2012
- ↑ AnBio website, downloaded 2001
- ↑ Leila Macedo Oda was listed as 'Diretor Presidente ANBio website, downloaded 2001
- ↑ de Souza, L. and L. M. Oda (2012). Letter to the editor. Food and Chemical Toxicology.
- ↑ Séralini, G. E., E. Clair, et al. (2012). Long term toxicity of a Roundup herbicide and a Roundup-tolerant genetically modified maize. Food and Chemical Toxicology 50(11): 4221-4231.
- ↑ de Souza, L. and L. M. Oda (2012). Letter to the editor. Food and Chemical Toxicology.
- ↑ ANBio, Misinformation undermines understanding of scientific development, says ANBio, PRNewswire, Sept 21 2012, acc 23 No 2012
- ↑ ANBio, Misinformation undermines understanding of scientific development, says ANBio, PRNewswire, Sept 21 2012, acc 23 No 2012
- ↑ Lawrence, Amanda Transgenic grains again scare Europe, Pravda, 4 Oct 2012, acc 23 Nov 2012
- ↑ AnBio website, downloaded 2001
- ↑ 11.0 11.1 Quem Somos Nós - Quadro de Diretores da ANBio, Who we are - Directors at Anbio, Anbio website, undated, accessed 26 November 2012
