Difference between revisions of "Media Smart: International expansion of the Media Smart group"

From Powerbase
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 16: Line 16:
  
 
The average Canadian child sees 350,000 TV commercials before graduating from high school, spends nearly as much time watching TV as attending classes. In 1980 the Canadian province of Quebec banned advertising for children under age 13.<ref>[Consumer Protection Act, R.S.Q., c. P-40.1, ss. 248-9 (see also: ss. 87-91 of the Consumer Protection Regulations, R.R.Q., 1981, c. P-40.1; and Application Guide for Sections 248 and 249 of the Quebec Consumer Protection Act (Advertising Intended for Children Under 13 Years of Age). </ref>  
 
The average Canadian child sees 350,000 TV commercials before graduating from high school, spends nearly as much time watching TV as attending classes. In 1980 the Canadian province of Quebec banned advertising for children under age 13.<ref>[Consumer Protection Act, R.S.Q., c. P-40.1, ss. 248-9 (see also: ss. 87-91 of the Consumer Protection Regulations, R.R.Q., 1981, c. P-40.1; and Application Guide for Sections 248 and 249 of the Quebec Consumer Protection Act (Advertising Intended for Children Under 13 Years of Age). </ref>  
] “In upholding the consititutional validity of the Quebec Consumer Protection Act restrictions on advertising to children under age 13 (in the case of a challenge by a toy company) the Court held: ‘...advertising directed at young children is per se manipulative. Such advertising aims to promote products by convincing those who will always believe.’” Norway (ads directed at children under age 12), and Sweden (television ads aimed at children under age 12) also have legislated broad bans on advertising to children, during child programmes any kind of advertising is forbidden in Sweden, Denmark, Austria and Flemish Belgium. In Greece there is no advertising for kids products from 7 to 22 h. An attempt to restrict advertising directed at children in the US failed with reference to the First Amendment. In Spain bans are also considered undemocratic.<ref> [https://www.berlinonline.de/berliner-zeitung/archiv/.bin/dump.fcgi/2001/0203/none/0086/index.html Belgium News} Accessed 17/11/2010 </ref> <ref>[http://whqlibdoc.who.int/publications/2004/9241591579.pdf Spain] Accessed 17/11/2010 </ref>
+
] “In upholding the consititutional validity of the Quebec Consumer Protection Act restrictions on advertising to children under age 13 (in the case of a challenge by a toy company) the Court held: ‘...advertising directed at young children is per se manipulative. Such advertising aims to promote products by convincing those who will always believe.’” Norway (ads directed at children under age 12), and Sweden (television ads aimed at children under age 12) also have legislated broad bans on advertising to children, during child programmes any kind of advertising is forbidden in Sweden, Denmark, Austria and Flemish Belgium. In Greece there is no advertising for kids products from 7 to 22 h. An attempt to restrict advertising directed at children in the US failed with reference to the First Amendment. In Spain bans are also considered undemocratic.<ref> [https://www.berlinonline.de/berliner-zeitung/archiv/.bin/dump.fcgi/2001/0203/none/0086/index.html Belgium News] Accessed 17/11/2010 </ref> <ref>[http://whqlibdoc.who.int/publications/2004/9241591579.pdf Spain] Accessed 17/11/2010 </ref>
 
[[Image:Worldmap1.png|thumb|500px|right]]
 
[[Image:Worldmap1.png|thumb|500px|right]]
 +
 +
New Zealand's Willy Munchright is a version of Media Smart,although it only focuses on identifying snack food products with too much fat and suggested alternative everyday snack foods (i.e. oranges, crackers, and frozenyoghurt). It also suggested cutting fat from meat. But the advertisement still said that children can sometimes have the high fat snack foods after plenty of the everydayfoods. Another theme was “fat isn’t bad if you just have a tad”.The programme doe not give specific objectives provides traightforward information to young people in a cartoon form which will encourage healthyeating and actions It comprises a series of television advertisements, aired using donated television time, featuring an animated cartoon character promoting nutrition and healthy eating to children. <ref>[http://www.nzma.org.nz/journal/119-1233/1967/content.pdf New Zealand Medical Journal],accessed 17 November 2010</ref>
  
 
=The Media Smart website lists the following:=
 
=The Media Smart website lists the following:=

Revision as of 16:33, 17 November 2010

Across Europe over 73,000 primary schools are using the Media Smart material and 19,000 have requested the use of the material. .[1]

These programmes are supported by 36 monopolist companies all over the world including highly powerful global companies such as Microsoft, Nintendo, Hasbro to name just a few.

In Britain The official members of the Organization themselves raise suspicion with their involvement in other activities. For instance Marina Palomba who serves as the Director of Media Smart published a book titled “Ad Law- Breaking the Mould without Breaking the Rules".[2]She also specializes in Brand protection, advertising and marketing law and regulation, including intellectual property rights. She is also allegedly “establishing the first global compliance and advisory service with the aim to assist advertisers, agencies and technology companies’’.[3]Paul Jackson is the Director of European Marketing Director for the confectionary business and he serves as the Vise President of the World Federation of Advertising and the Responsible Advertising and Children program, they claim to be committed to responsible marketing communication on a local, regional and global scale. .[4]The programme is responsible for launching Media Smart in European Union. Coincidently he runs a Silver fin which is a brand doctoring consultancy company.[5]


The expert group are clearly using Media Smart programs as a platform for advertising products, to children in Europe and potentially in the world ,in which they have involvement. Issues and concerns have been raised by child psychologists about the vulnerability of children to advertising companies. In 2004 Minister of Media and Heritage Lord McIntosh noted that “advertising in all forms played an important role in informing people’s choices of products and services”. This view is channelled by Media Smart Groups to exploit young people by exposing them to all forms of advertising though Digital Ad wise and Media Smart programs.[6]


The creation of consumerism around the world has influenced children to think about a ‘must have’ toy and ‘I've got to have it’. This behavour is solicitated by pressures from the media and their peers. It is disappointingly a common marketing occurrence. It is not surprising that these organisations are mostly funded by private sector companies. In USA, the Media Smart Youth programme called "We can", is a national movement designed to teach 8 to 13 year olds to stay healthy. The programme has been implemented by many states. The programme was made available to the public in 2006[7] Since its launch, it has been adopted by all 50 states and community sites, and in several parts around the world including the Arab World [8]. In Canada 10 provinces have endorsed programmes aimed at advertising to young children [9]


The shift to neo-liberalism has increased the deregulation of companies to some extent, the reason being that regulation is now conducted to suit neo-liberal policies. The same policies are enacted in the public’s name but increasingly without the public’s consent,tghus they do not see the hidden messages attached in advertisements. In reality private interests supersedes children’s needs. This is done with the Government‘s protection of corporate companies rather than popular inference. Neo-liberal global capitalists market and the global commercial markets are closely linked. Thus they are a collective movement.


The average Canadian child sees 350,000 TV commercials before graduating from high school, spends nearly as much time watching TV as attending classes. In 1980 the Canadian province of Quebec banned advertising for children under age 13.[10] ] “In upholding the consititutional validity of the Quebec Consumer Protection Act restrictions on advertising to children under age 13 (in the case of a challenge by a toy company) the Court held: ‘...advertising directed at young children is per se manipulative. Such advertising aims to promote products by convincing those who will always believe.’” Norway (ads directed at children under age 12), and Sweden (television ads aimed at children under age 12) also have legislated broad bans on advertising to children, during child programmes any kind of advertising is forbidden in Sweden, Denmark, Austria and Flemish Belgium. In Greece there is no advertising for kids products from 7 to 22 h. An attempt to restrict advertising directed at children in the US failed with reference to the First Amendment. In Spain bans are also considered undemocratic.[11] [12]

Worldmap1.png

New Zealand's Willy Munchright is a version of Media Smart,although it only focuses on identifying snack food products with too much fat and suggested alternative everyday snack foods (i.e. oranges, crackers, and frozenyoghurt). It also suggested cutting fat from meat. But the advertisement still said that children can sometimes have the high fat snack foods after plenty of the everydayfoods. Another theme was “fat isn’t bad if you just have a tad”.The programme doe not give specific objectives provides traightforward information to young people in a cartoon form which will encourage healthyeating and actions It comprises a series of television advertisements, aired using donated television time, featuring an animated cartoon character promoting nutrition and healthy eating to children. [13]

The Media Smart website lists the following:

Germany [ http://www.mediasmart.de ]
Netherlands[ http://www.reklamerakkers.nl ]
Belgium [ http://www.mediasmart.be ]
Sweden [ http://www.mediasmart.se ]
Finland [ http://www.mediasmart.fi ]
Hungary [ http://www.mediatudor.hu ]
Portugal [ http://www.mediasmart.com ]

Netherlands

In the Netherlands Media Smart has sister companies which are named as: Media Rakkers which was launched in 2005 adopted by over 4,500 schools.Their other Company Recklame was launched in 2006 immediately afterwards. This initiative runs in 6,000 schools out of 8,500 primary schools. These statistics show that the company is very successful. [14]


Portugal

In Portugal Media Smart is already in 20,180 schools. The reception for the education community education divisions of Palmela and Almada also counted with the participation and training of Smart Media.

The Expert Group consists of:

  • Prof. Roberto Carneiro, Professor and Researcher at the Portuguese Catholic University
  • Dr. Paul Fonseca, General Directorate of Curriculum Innovation and Development (DGIDC)
  • Dr. Pedro Ribeiro da Silva, Directorate General of Health (DH)
  • Dr. Gisela Seraphim, Directorate General for Consumer (DGC)
  • Dr. Albino Almeida, Conf. National Parents Association (CONFAP)
  • Prof. Manuel Rangel, Professor and Specialist in Basic Education
  • Prof. Carlos Neto, Director of the School of Human Kinetics
  • Prof. Georg Dutschke, Marketing Specialist in Child
  • Ms. Cecilia Galvão, Child Psychologist at Hospital D. Estefania
  • Dr. Mónica Chaves, Communications Specialist Child
  • Dr. Alexandra Benedict, President of the Portuguese Association of Nutritionists (APN)
  • Dr. Maria Luiza Vaz Pinto (AC Media

Comments from teachers using the resources

  • "I really enjoyed using this program, is a groundbreaking work and is a challenge for us." - (Aveiro)
  • "Lets develop observation skills and develop the critical spirit in relation to advertising and then in relation to other issues." - (Lisbon)


  • "I really liked because it is essential to see this issue from small so they can make the right choices, for example at Christmas, and to teach them how to separate the useful from the harmful and help them learn to read between the lines." - ( Porto)


  • "I really liked because it meets the problems of day to day, and stirs the real and that is of interest to both students and for teachers." (Lisbon)


  • "The materials are easy to use, the exercises are well explained and linked." - (Aveiro)


  • "The students liked it a lot because we used the DVD and magazines that are of different materials that are used to and they get excited, and also because it could show that they have knowledge - knowledge that is not educated." - (Porto)

Sponsorship

  • Caixa Geral de Depósitos
  • DANONE PORTUGAL, SA
  • DIAGEO PORTUGAL, LDA.
  • FERRERO IBERICA, SA
  • Kellogg's ESPAÑA, SA
  • KRAFT FOODS PORTUGAL, LDA.
  • MARS PORTUGAL
  • Modelo Continente, SA
  • NESTLÉ PORTUGAL, SA
  • PORTUGAL TELECOM, SA
  • PROCTER & GAMBLE PORTUGAL, LDA.
  • MACDONALD'S SYSTEMS PORTUGAL, LDA.
  • UNICER - DRINK PORTUGAL, SA
  • Unilever Jerónimo Martins, Lda

Support

  • APAP - Portuguese Association of Advertising and Communication
  • APIMPRENSA, PORTUGUESE PRESS ASSOCIATION
  • BRANDKEY - MARKETING SERVICES, SA
  • BYCOM - ADVERTISING AND DESIGN SERVICES LTD.
  • Dfusion
  • EXPRESS
  • FILM BROKERS LTD
  • INITIATIVE MEDIA - ADVERTISING ACTIVITIES, SA
  • NEWSPAPER "THE FIRST IN JANUARY"
  • MEDIA MONITOR
  • AEIOU PORTAL
  • Porto Editora, Lda.
  • EN COMMUNICATIONS SA
  • RADIO AND TELEVISION IN PORTUGAL
  • Pip
  • SIC - Sociedade Independente de Comunicação
  • VISION

Contact Information

Avenida da República, 62F - 6th floor
1050 - 197 Lisbon

Tel. +351 21 796 67 31

Fax: +351 21 793 85 76
mediasmart@apan.pt www.mediasmart.com.pt [15]

Hungary

Media Smart was introduced in 2007-2008 [16] In Hungary 1195 of the country’ schools have participated in the program and a Media tutor website has been set up to encourage the success of Media Smart. Advertisers have donated cash and broadcasters have used pro bono airtime worth over £2million to help develop the project further. (There is currently an argument about the consultations which clearly is not deigned to benefit the public interest not sure if this is needed).

Expert Group:[17]

  • Ministry of Education and Culture
  • National Radio and Television Board
  • Dr. Eva Kosa, médiapszichológus, media scholars in the Expert Committee
  • Dr. Ildikó Sarkady, médiajogász
  • Dr. László Miklós, Sociologist, University
  • Keynote Dr., Sociologist, Moholy-Nagy University of Art
  • Disturbance in Dr. Bea, a psychiatrist, I no. Pediatrics
  • General Inspectorate of Consumer Protection
  • Economic Competition
  • European Commission Representation in Hungary
  • Valiant John Roman Catholic Teacher Training College
  • Parents Association for Children
  • Teachers' Association
  • Hungarian Advertising Association
  • Hungarian Section of the Advertising World
  • Advertising Self-Regulatory Body
  • Hungarian News Agency
  • Art Directors Club Hungary
  • dr.Gellén Clara University Assistant Professor, University of Szeged
  • Körös dr. Mikis Martin, National Institute of Public Education

Professional Cooperating Partners:[18]

A*DOC Semic Ltd.

  • E. ON Hungária
  • Confectionery Association
  • Ferrero Hungary Ltd.
  • Hasbro Hungary Ltd.
  • Hungarian Development Bank Ltd.
  • Magyar Posta
  • Magyar Telekom Plc Mobile Services
  • MARS Hungary
  • McDonald's Hungary Kft
  • Nestlé Hungária Kft
  • OTP Bank Plc
  • Mineral water and soft drink Capital Ltd.
  • Pappas Auto Hungary Kft
  • Gedeon Richter
  • Trigranit Development Corporation
  • Unilever Hungary Ltd.
  • Budapest College of Communication and Business
  • DDB Budapest
  • Kirowski
  • Edison Post
  • Touchstone Communications
  • AGB Nielsen
  • GFK Hungária
  • Ipsos
  • Tárki

Media resources which follow the organisations policies in Hungray

  • Axel Springer
  • Danubius Rádió
  • Duna TV
  • Egyszervolt.hu
  • Network TV
  • Inform Média Kft
  • Lapcom
  • Hungarian Radio
  • Hungarian Television
  • Metro Newsletter
  • Minimax
  • National Geographic Channel
  • Pannon Pages Association
  • RTL Klub
  • Sanoma Budapest
  • Slager Radio
  • TV2
  • Viasat3
  • MTV and VIVA TV

Contact Information: [19]

MediaSmart Hungary Oktatási Közhasznú Nonprofit Kft.
Budapest
Naphegy tér 8.
1016

E-mail: mediasmarthungary@mediasmarthungary.hu
telefon/fax: 06 1 212-5026

Sweden

Media Smart is not conducted in a commercially, but based on that support companies welcome the initiative to finance planning, production and launch of educational material that is free of charge for schools.

The following companies support Media Smart financially in Sweden[20]

• AMF
• Coop
• Ferrero Scandinavia
• ICA
• March Sweden
• Max Hamburger Restaurants
• McDonald's
• Mediaedge: cia
• Procter & Gamble
• Swedish Games
• Sweden Advertisers
• Swedish Association of Communication Agencies
• Unilever
• Waterfall

Contact us

Please contact us at the Media Smart Contact: Anna Lindstrom
Media Smart, Sweden Advertisers
Klara East Church Street 2C
Box 1327
111 83 Stockholm
Phone: +46 8545252 38
Mail: anna.lindstrom @ annons.se

Belgium

Media Smart ® "Pub-Be Evil!" Is a material, intended for children 8 to 12 years of primary education, to include advertising, awareness messages in the media. His goal is to make every child able to understand the situation he is when he is the recipient of messages.

Foreword by the Advertising Council: 'If we want children to understand the world they live in, it is essential to teach them to develop critical thinking over what they see and hear. Magazines, newspapers and radio, are excellent sources for learning, contain advertisements. On the way to school, children are confronted with many posters.When they go to the movies, the great film is preceded by commercials. At home, they discover the prospectus filed in the mailbox. On television, many commercials surround programs. And even on the Internet, advertising is increasingly present. Currently, most homes have a television that children watch an average of 2-3 hours per day. Almost half (44%) of Belgian households have a computer with an Internet connection.' [21]

In October 2005 the Council of Advertising, a tripartite organization representing the entire advertising industry, including advertisers, advertising agencies and media, has decided to follow this initiative and Media Smart Belgium " under the slogan "Be Pub-Malin! . This is the Belgian part of European material of awakening to the media advertising, aimed at children aged 8 to 12 years in primary education. [22]

Sponsors

•Association Belge des Banques (ABB)
• Danone
• Douwe Egberts
• Ferrero
• Hasbro
• Kellogg's
• National Lottery
• Masterfoods
• Mc Donald's
• Nestle
• Procter & Gamble
• Refinery Tirlemontoise
• Unilever

Conclusion

In Conclusion It can be seen that Media Smart has expanded around the globe on different continents, This Expansion could not have happened without the support of both the governments and Funders from each individual country. It has to be noted however that many funders either financially or through contributions are linked between said countries. This can be linked to the ideology that International corporations have many different aspects of power. Without their contributions Media Smart would not have expanded at the rate it has, evoking that the Funders must receive feedback for all their assistance.

Notes

  1. Media Smart UK Response to the European Commission Media Literacy QuestionnaireEuropean Commission Website, accessed 4 November 2010
  2. Marina Palomba Profile Linkedin Website, accessed 2 November 2010
  3. Marina Palomba Profile Linkedin Website, accessed 2 November 2010
  4. Frequently Asked Questions", Responsible Advertising for Children, accessed 16 November 2010
  5. Kids are getting Media Smart in the UK" Family kids and youth website],accessed 4 November 2010
  6. WFA members back digital media literacy lessons for UK children, World Federation of Advertisers website,accessed 4 November 2010
  7. Ways to enhance Children’s Activity and Nutrition, National Heart Lung and Blood Institute website, Accessed 17 November 2020
  8. "Helping Palestinian Children Become “Media Smart”!" Alliance of Civilisation website,accessed 17 November 2010
  9. "Media Education in Canada:An Overview" Media Awareness Network website,accessed 17 November 2010
  10. [Consumer Protection Act, R.S.Q., c. P-40.1, ss. 248-9 (see also: ss. 87-91 of the Consumer Protection Regulations, R.R.Q., 1981, c. P-40.1; and Application Guide for Sections 248 and 249 of the Quebec Consumer Protection Act (Advertising Intended for Children Under 13 Years of Age).
  11. Belgium News Accessed 17/11/2010
  12. Spain Accessed 17/11/2010
  13. New Zealand Medical Journal,accessed 17 November 2010
  14. Promoting Balanced Diets and Healthy Lifestyles Netherlands , CIAA Website, accessed 21 November 2010
  15. Portugal Media SmartPortugal Contact Info Accessed17/11/2010
  16. Hungary Accessed17/11/2010
  17. Hungary Media SmartHungary Expert Group Accessed17/11/2010
  18. Hungary Media SmartHungary Partners Accessed17/11/2010
  19. Hungary Media SmartHungary Contact Information Accessed17/11/2010
  20. Sweden's Supporters Accessed 17/1/2010
  21. Belgium Media Smart Accessed 17/11/2010
  22. Belgium Media SmartAccessed 17/11/2010

Back to Globalisation:Media Smart