Shlomo Sand - Revision history

David: /* Publications */

2026-05-17T14:13:28Z

Publications

David: /* Legacy and reception = */

2026-05-17T14:02:17Z

Legacy and reception =

David: /* Legacy and reception */

2026-05-17T14:02:04Z

Legacy and reception

David: /* Sand's edition of Ernest Renan – On the Nation and the Jewish People (2010) */

2026-05-17T13:57:19Z

Sand's edition of Ernest Renan – On the Nation and the Jewish People (2010)

David: /* The Invention of the Jewish People (2008) */

2026-05-17T13:57:00Z

The Invention of the Jewish People (2008)

David: /* The Invention of the Jewish People (2008) */

2026-05-17T13:56:45Z

The Invention of the Jewish People (2008)

David: /* External links */

2026-05-17T13:52:08Z

External links

David at 13:48, 17 May 2026

2026-05-17T13:48:06Z

David: Created page with " *https://yplus.ps/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Sand-Shlomo-The-Invention-of-the-Land-of-Israel.pdf ==Notes=="

2026-05-17T13:35:58Z

Created page with " *https://yplus.ps/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Sand-Shlomo-The-Invention-of-the-Land-of-Israel.pdf ==Notes=="

New page

*https://yplus.ps/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Sand-Shlomo-The-Invention-of-the-Land-of-Israel.pdf

==Notes==

@@ Line 104: / Line 104: @@
 * '''2004''': ''Historians, Time and Imagination'', Tel Aviv: Am Oved (in Hebrew).
 * '''2004''': ''Cinema and Memory'' (co-edited with Haim Bresheeth and Moshe Zimmerman), Jerusalem: Zalman Shazar Center (in Hebrew).
-* '''2008''': ''The Invention of the Jewish People'' (original Hebrew title: ''Matai ve'eich humtsa ha'am hayehudi?''; English translation Verso, 2009) – [https://archive.org/details/pdfy-tK1HC34yngmDtslV full PDF].
+* '''2008''': ''[[The Invention of the Jewish People]]' (original Hebrew title: ''Matai ve'eich humtsa ha'am hayehudi?''; English translation Verso, 2009) – [https://archive.org/details/pdfy-tK1HC34yngmDtslV full PDF].
 * '''2010''': ''Ernest Renan – On the Nation and the Jewish People'' (edited and introduced by Shlomo Sand), London: Verso (also in French and Hebrew).
 * '''2011''': ''The Words and the Land: Israeli Intellectuals and the Nationalist Myth'', Los Angeles: Semiotext(e) (also in French).

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:02, 17 May 2026
Line 91:		Line 91:


−	= Legacy and reception ==	+	== Legacy and reception ==

	Sand's work has been praised by some as a courageous deconstruction of nationalist myths and criticised by others as historically flawed or politically motivated. His books have sold widely and influenced debates on Israeli identity, the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, and the nature of Jewish peoplehood.		Sand's work has been praised by some as a courageous deconstruction of nationalist myths and criticised by others as historically flawed or politically motivated. His books have sold widely and influenced debates on Israeli identity, the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, and the nature of Jewish peoplehood.

@@ Line 80: / Line 80: @@
 In recent interviews, Sand dissects Zionism as a colonial-settler ideology that continues to shape Israeli policy. He traces its roots to 19th-century European nationalism and critiques its ongoing role in occupation, settlement expansion, and the denial of Palestinian rights. The book extends his earlier arguments, calling for a post-Zionist reimagining of Israel as a state for all its citizens.
-== Legacy and reception ==
+== Shlomo Sand on "anti-Semite"/"antisemite", "Jew hate" and "Judeophobia" ==
 ==Publications==

@@ Line 42: / Line 42: @@
 He rejects the notion of a shared secular Jewish culture or common origin, arguing that religion—not ethnicity—bound Jews historically. The book became a bestseller in Israel and provoked fierce controversy, with accusations of undermining Jewish identity and the legitimacy of Israel.
-== Sand's edition of ''Ernest Renan – On the Nation and the Jewish People'' (2010) ==
+=== Sand's edition of ''Ernest Renan – On the Nation and the Jewish People'' (2010) ===
 In 2010 '''[[Shlomo Sand]]''' edited and introduced the Verso edition of ''Ernest Renan – On the Nation and the Jewish People''. The volume contains Sand’s substantial essay “The Unclassifiable Renan” (also serving as preface) together with two classic lectures by [[Ernest Renan]]: the famous 1882 Sorbonne address “What Is a Nation?” and the 1883 lecture “Judaism as Race and Religion”.
 Sand presents Renan as a complex, contradictory thinker whose work cannot be reduced to simplistic labels. He situates Renan in the context of 19th-century French intellectual history and shows how his ideas on nationalism prefigure those of 20th-century theorists such as [[Raymond Aron]] and [[Ernest Gellner]]. Sand argues that Renan’s rejection of ethnic, racial, or religious definitions of the nation remains highly relevant to contemporary debates on identity, Zionism, and the Israeli–Palestinian conflict.

@@ Line 34: / Line 34: @@
 Sand writes:
-The Jews were never a foreign 'ethnos' of invaders from afar but rather an autochthonous population whose ancestors, for the most part, converted to Judaism before the arrival of Christianity or Islam.<ref>Shlomo Sand, [https://www.academia.edu/70367849/The_Invention_of_the_Jewish_People The Invention of the Jewish People] ''Academia.edu'', 2008 (English edition Verso, 2009).</ref>
+:The Jews were never a foreign 'ethnos' of invaders from afar but rather an autochthonous population whose ancestors, for the most part, converted to Judaism before the arrival of Christianity or Islam.<ref>Shlomo Sand, [https://www.academia.edu/70367849/The_Invention_of_the_Jewish_People The Invention of the Jewish People] ''Academia.edu'', 2008 (English edition Verso, 2009).</ref>
 In a 2009 interview, Sand explained his motivation:

← Older revision		Revision as of 13:56, 17 May 2026
Line 41:		Line 41:

	He rejects the notion of a shared secular Jewish culture or common origin, arguing that religion—not ethnicity—bound Jews historically. The book became a bestseller in Israel and provoked fierce controversy, with accusations of undermining Jewish identity and the legitimacy of Israel.		He rejects the notion of a shared secular Jewish culture or common origin, arguing that religion—not ethnicity—bound Jews historically. The book became a bestseller in Israel and provoked fierce controversy, with accusations of undermining Jewish identity and the legitimacy of Israel.
		+
		+	== Sand's edition of ''Ernest Renan – On the Nation and the Jewish People'' (2010) ==
		+	In 2010 '''[[Shlomo Sand]]''' edited and introduced the Verso edition of ''Ernest Renan – On the Nation and the Jewish People''. The volume contains Sand’s substantial essay “The Unclassifiable Renan” (also serving as preface) together with two classic lectures by [[Ernest Renan]]: the famous 1882 Sorbonne address “What Is a Nation?” and the 1883 lecture “Judaism as Race and Religion”.
		+	Sand presents Renan as a complex, contradictory thinker whose work cannot be reduced to simplistic labels. He situates Renan in the context of 19th-century French intellectual history and shows how his ideas on nationalism prefigure those of 20th-century theorists such as [[Raymond Aron]] and [[Ernest Gellner]]. Sand argues that Renan’s rejection of ethnic, racial, or religious definitions of the nation remains highly relevant to contemporary debates on identity, Zionism, and the Israeli–Palestinian conflict.
		+	Sand does not characterise Renan as either a “Judeophile” or an “anti-Semite”. Instead he stresses Renan’s nuanced position: Renan viewed the Jews historically as a religious community rather than a biological “race” or “pure ethnos”, while still employing the racial vocabulary common to his era. Sand uses Renan’s texts to undermine essentialist notions of Jewish peoplehood and to critique the ethnic-territorial claims of modern Zionism.
		+
		+	Key quotations from Sand’s introduction include:
		+	:Renan is unclassifiable… He cannot be fitted into the usual categories of progressive or reactionary, philo-Semite or anti-Semite.<ref>Shlomo Sand, “The Unclassifiable Renan”, in ''Ernest Renan – On the Nation and the Jewish People'', Verso, 2010.</ref>
		+	On Renan’s famous definition of the nation:
		+	:Renan’s nation is a “daily plebiscite”, a spiritual principle based on shared memory and the desire to live together, not on race, language, religion or geography.<ref name="SandRenan">Shlomo Sand (ed.), ''Ernest Renan – On the Nation and the Jewish People'', Verso, 2010.</ref>
		+	In the second lecture, Renan explicitly argues against viewing Jews as a racial group:
		+	:The Jews cannot be considered a “pure ethnos”… Judaism is a religion, not a race.<ref name="SandRenan" />
		+	No other authors contribute original essays to the volume; it consists solely of Sand’s introduction and Renan’s two lectures. There is no mention of “Steinschreiber” (or any similar name) anywhere in Sand’s text or the book’s contents.
		+	The edition thus serves Sand’s broader project of deconstructing nationalist myths by recovering Renan’s anti-essentialist conception of nationhood and applying it critically to Zionist historiography.

	=== ''The Invention of the Land of Israel'' (2012) ===		=== ''The Invention of the Land of Israel'' (2012) ===

@@ Line 71: / Line 71: @@
 == External links ==
@@ Line 77: / Line 97: @@
 * [https://www.historynewsnetwork.org/article/interview-with-shlomo-sand-the-new-history-of-the- Interview with Shlomo Sand (2009)]
 * [https://freethinker.co.uk/2025/12/the-anatomy-of-zionism-interview-with-shlomo-sand/ The Anatomy of Zionism: Interview with Shlomo Sand (2025)]
 ==Notes==
 [[Category:Israeli historians]]

← Older revision		Revision as of 13:48, 17 May 2026
Line 1:		Line 1:
		+	{{short description\|'''Israeli historian and professor emeritus at Tel Aviv University, known for critiquing Zionist historiography and the myths of Jewish ethnic continuity'''}}

		+	{{Infobox person
		+	\| name = Shlomo Sand
		+	\| birth_date = 10 September 1946
		+	\| birth_place = Linz, Austria
		+	\| occupation = Historian, author, professor emeritus
		+	\| known_for = Critique of Zionist historiography; ''The Invention of the Jewish People''
		+	\| alma_mater = Tel Aviv University; École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales
		+	\| institutions = Tel Aviv University (1988–2014)
		+	\| notable_works = ''The Invention of the Jewish People'' (2008); ''The Invention of the Land of Israel'' (2012); ''How I Stopped Being a Jew'' (2013); ''The Anatomy of Zionism'' (2025)
		+	}}

		+	'''[[Shlomo Sand]]''' (born 10 September 1946) is an Israeli historian and professor emeritus of contemporary history at [[Tel Aviv University]]. He is best known for his controversial books challenging traditional Zionist narratives of Jewish history, arguing that both the "Jewish people" and the concept of the "Land of Israel" as an ancestral national homeland are modern inventions shaped by 19th- and 20th-century nationalism rather than ancient ethnic or religious continuity. Sand's work has sparked intense debate in Israel and internationally, positioning him as a leading critic of ethno-nationalist historiography and the ideological foundations of Zionism.

		+	Born in a displaced persons camp in Linz, Austria, to Holocaust-survivor parents, Sand grew up in Israel and served in the [[Israel Defense Forces]]. He later pursued advanced studies in France before returning to teach at Tel Aviv University. His scholarship draws on post-nationalist historical methods to deconstruct myths of origin, exile, and return, emphasising conversion, cultural pluralism, and the constructed nature of modern national identities.

		+	== Early life and academic career ==

−	*https://yplus.~~ps/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Sand-Shlomo-~~The~~-Invention-of-~~the~~-Land-of-~~Israel.~~pdf~~	+	Sand was born on 10 September 1946 in a displaced persons camp in Linz, Austria, to Jewish parents who had survived the Holocaust. The family immigrated to Israel when he was a child. He served in the [[Israel Defense Forces]] during the 1967 and 1973 wars before pursuing higher education.

		+	Sand earned his doctorate at the [[École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales]] in Paris. He joined the faculty of [[Tel Aviv University]]in 1988, rising to full professor in 2002 and becoming professor emeritus in 2014. His early work focused on [[Georges Sorel]] and French intellectual history, but he later turned to Jewish and Israeli history, motivated by a desire to confront what he saw as Zionist distortions of the past.
		+
		+	== Political views and activism ==
		+
		+	Sand identifies as a non-Zionist or post-Zionist historian. He has argued that Zionism transformed a religious diaspora identity into an ethno-territorial nationalism, leading to the displacement of Palestinians and ongoing conflict. He supports a single democratic state in historic Palestine with equal rights for all inhabitants and has criticised Israel's occupation policies and the "ethnocratic" character of the Jewish state.
		+
		+	== Major works ==
		+
		+	=== ''The Invention of the Jewish People'' (2008) ===
		+
		+	In his best-known book, originally published in Hebrew as ''Matai ve'eich humtsa ha'am hayehudi?'' (''When and How Was the Jewish People Invented?''), Sand challenges the idea of Jews as a single, ancient ethnic nation exiled from Judea and later returning. He argues that Jewish identity was formed through widespread conversions across the ancient and medieval world, including the Khazars in the Caucasus, Berbers in North Africa, and other groups. There was no mass exile after the Roman destruction of the Second Temple; most Jews in the diaspora descended from local converts rather than a "wandering people."
		+
		+	Sand writes:
		+
		+	The Jews were never a foreign 'ethnos' of invaders from afar but rather an autochthonous population whose ancestors, for the most part, converted to Judaism before the arrival of Christianity or Islam.<ref>Shlomo Sand, [https://www.academia.edu/70367849/The_Invention_of_the_Jewish_People The Invention of the Jewish People] ''Academia.edu'', 2008 (English edition Verso, 2009).</ref>
		+
		+	In a 2009 interview, Sand explained his motivation:
		+
		+	:I remember being shocked the first time I heard that the Exile from Egypt was not true. Hearing that David and Solomon's kingdoms didn't exist. It shocked me so much that I decided… when I have time, I will need to focus on Jewish history.<ref>Shlomo Sand, [https://www.historynewsnetwork.org/article/interview-with-shlomo-sand-the-new-history-of-the- Interview with Shlomo Sand: The new history of the origins of the Jews] ''History News Network'', October 21, 2009.</ref>
		+
		+	He rejects the notion of a shared secular Jewish culture or common origin, arguing that religion—not ethnicity—bound Jews historically. The book became a bestseller in Israel and provoked fierce controversy, with accusations of undermining Jewish identity and the legitimacy of Israel.
		+
		+	=== ''The Invention of the Land of Israel'' (2012) ===
		+
		+	In this follow-up, Sand examines how the concept of ''Eretz Israel'' (the Land of Israel) as a national homeland was invented in the modern era. He shows that the Bible does not refer to a unified "Land of Israel" as collective Jewish property; the Promised Land was a conditional divine loan, not eternal territorial ownership. Traditional rabbinical Judaism viewed the land spiritually and rejected premature mass return or nationalism.
		+
		+	Sand argues that Zionism, influenced by European nationalism and Christian Zionism, transformed religious symbols into a secular nationalist ideology to justify colonisation. Biblical narratives were reinterpreted to support territorial claims, while the actual historical connection of most Jews to the land was minimal or symbolic.
		+
		+	Key quotes include:
		+
		+	:The 'Land of Israel' of Zionist and Israeli authors bears no resemblance to the Holy Land of my true forefathers… whose origins and lives were embedded within the Yiddish culture of Eastern Europe.<ref>Shlomo Sand, [https://yplus.ps/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Sand-Shlomo-The-Invention-of-the-Land-of-Israel.pdf The Invention of the Land of Israel: From Holy Land to Homeland] ''Yplus.ps'', 2012 (PDF).</ref>
		+
		+	:It is entirely illegitimate to identify the Jewish links with the ancestral land of Israel… with the desire to gather all Jews into a modern territorial state situated on the ancient Holy Land.<ref name="LandIsrael">Shlomo Sand, ''The Invention of the Land of Israel'', 2012.</ref>
		+
		+	:The Promised Land is neither a one-time grant nor an irrevocable gift. It remains a loan, never to be regarded as territorial property.<ref name="LandIsrael" />
		+
		+	Sand concludes that these invented myths have perpetuated conflict and that genuine peace requires dismantling ethno-territorial claims in favour of equal civic rights.
		+
		+	=== ''How I Stopped Being a Jew'' (2013) ===
		+
		+	In this autobiographical and polemical work, Sand reflects on his personal rejection of Jewish identity as defined by Zionism and the Israeli state. He argues that being Jewish today often means supporting an exclusionary ethno-state rather than a universalist or religious tradition. Sand declares himself a "non-Jew" in the Israeli context while affirming his cultural and historical ties to Jewish traditions.
		+
		+	=== ''The Anatomy of Zionism'' (2025) ===
		+
		+	In recent interviews, Sand dissects Zionism as a colonial-settler ideology that continues to shape Israeli policy. He traces its roots to 19th-century European nationalism and critiques its ongoing role in occupation, settlement expansion, and the denial of Palestinian rights. The book extends his earlier arguments, calling for a post-Zionist reimagining of Israel as a state for all its citizens.
		+
		+	== Legacy and reception ==
		+
		+	Sand's work has been praised by some as a courageous deconstruction of nationalist myths and criticised by others as historically flawed or politically motivated. His books have sold widely and influenced debates on Israeli identity, the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, and the nature of Jewish peoplehood.
		+
		+
		+
		+	== External links ==
		+	* [https://yplus.ps/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Sand-Shlomo-The-Invention-of-the-Land-of-Israel.pdf The Invention of the Land of Israel] (PDF)
		+	* [https://www.academia.edu/70367849/The_Invention_of_the_Jewish_People The Invention of the Jewish People]
		+	* [https://www.historynewsnetwork.org/article/interview-with-shlomo-sand-the-new-history-of-the- Interview with Shlomo Sand (2009)]
		+	* [https://freethinker.co.uk/2025/12/the-anatomy-of-zionism-interview-with-shlomo-sand/ The Anatomy of Zionism: Interview with Shlomo Sand (2025)]
	==Notes==		==Notes==
		+	[[Category:Israeli historians]]
		+	[[Category:Anti-Zionist activists]]
		+	[[Category:Tel Aviv University faculty]]
		+	[[Category:Jewish historians]]
		+	[[Category:Critics of Zionism]]
		+	[[Category:Israeli Jews]]